6 ms·
Workers Are Winning the Return-to-Office War Because They’re Right
- gentleman11 5y agoThe news has said a lot of things like this recently and been inaccurate. The “great resignation” somehow is happening at the same time as record-low unemployment for example, where quitting rates go up by only 1%. I don’t trust them any more to report factually about employment trends
- zcdziura 5y agoThat's because people have been resigning from their old jobs and switching to different ones.
- fnordpiglet 5y agoAdditionally if you resign and are not looking for work you don’t count as unemployed. Unemployment rates are calculated only for people actively looking for employment.
- IshKebab 5y agoWikipedia has a graph of actual resignation rates for the US: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Resignation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Resignation They are... slightly higher than normal. "Great" is clearly an exaggeration. I agree with gentleman11. The news often clings on to and exaggerates ideas that sound interesting and reasonable but aren't actually happening to any notable degree.
- revlolz 5y agoI would argue it was a great migration over resignation. Vast majority of people aren't quitting the workforce, they are obtaining promotions and raises. People being told they weren't good enough for x, did not do enough to earn y, that the company has never supported remote work; all got to see their management's lie. They are more than qualified for x, they can earn 15% above y, and the entire company is doing just fine where leaders foretold jobloss and company destruction. Fwiw I am commenting on office jobs.
- WorldMaker 5y agoI think it was a massive migration at the "low end" too: fast food places complaining about lack of workers today are at least in part because the workers they laid off early in the pandemic [1] did exactly what you would expect them to do to survive and migrated en mass into "gig economy" jobs that relatively exploded at the same time like Postmates/DoorDash/etc. In some cases those were "raises" too. [1] The other "big lie" about calling it the "great resignation": there were plenty of layoffs that happened (and didn't need to) and burnt employee good will for short term stock concerns.
- elforce002 5y agoThese 2 years were the best test to validate remote working. No more commuting, etc...
- willcipriano 5y agoPaywall: https://archive.ph/qC6fv https://archive.ph/qC6fv
- 5350-uiop-1130 5y agoDon't want to follow the pointless, soul-crushing formalities and presenteeism of office life anymore.
- bobobob420 5y agoYes people do not want to return to office because of the darkening international situation and the growing disorder of American cities. What kind of journalist can seriously write that. Its like just adding words to sentences to meet the word count.
- tonywastaken 5y agoI think there’s some truth to it. And the article is an opinion piece.
- bobobob420 5y agoYou think the war in Ukraine is stopping people in America from going in to office? I believe it has no impact whatsoever.
- sokoloff 5y ago> one thing is missing from this picture of returning normality: the rows of office workers bent over their desks. I suspect that was not inadvertent.
- jleyank 5y agoWhy is it so hard for businesses or people to understand why people aren't that interested in returning to open-offices or other "modern" ways of warehousing workers? If they all had 1-2 person offices w/door, where knowledge workers could have the quiet and uninterrupted time to work, then you'd probably get some return. If, however, you're asking people to return to mayhem, where they have to use blinders and noise-reducing headphones to think, you're crazy.
- philistine 5y agoI'm in an office with a door. My return to work was bittersweet, but manageable.
- dont__panic 5y agoMost people don't even have that at home! I suspect if everyone had an office at work for "deep work," the commute would be easier to swallow. I, for one, could save some money on rent by moving to a place with one fewer bedroom.
- jleyank 5y agoI think that's people's point - if you give me a better work environment than I have at home, you have an argument for me commuting. However, if it's worse or no batter...
- exabrial 5y ago> If they all had 1-2 person offices w/door, where knowledge workers could have the quiet and uninterrupted time to work, then you'd probably get some return. We've know this "secret" for long awhile, because literally everyone talks about it. We do some schedule office WFH days as well to balance things out.
- bberenberg 5y agoBecause managers are seeing this regularly https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31154119 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31154119
- hyperman1 5y agoMy company merged with a few others, so we are now multi-location. We reorganized, so the people in my room are not the people I work with anymore. Half of the IT workers are temps, externals, consultants, all over the world. So I spent my days in headphones, conducting meetings. Our main office is a drive a few hours away. Because of cost optimization, the building is in a less desirable part of town, and a few colleagues had to deal with crime on the way to work. On some days, predicted desk usage is above 100%, but management said that's OK because we'll spend our time in meeting rooms anyway, and we're supposed to empty our desk while we're in a meeting room. There's an endless amount of people shuffling back and forth, so if you're close to a door there is no way to have any concentration. Seeing all this, why should I go back to my company building? To annoy the people sitting next to me who are not my team members anymore, by having full time meetings over the computer? Thank god my managers are wise enough to say:this doesn't make sense, stay at home when necessary. But other teams are required to come back and they don't like it. Their bosses wonder why. I want to answer, they are hiding to try and get some work done, but you're not allowing them.
- justsomehnguy 5y ago> Why is it so hard for businesses or people to understand To have a proper answer you need a proper question. The proper one would be "what is the difference between an office and remote worker?". And the answer would be: 1. You have the easiest KPI to measure: butt-in-the-seat/hour. Because making some valid KPIs tied to the business performance is hard and requires to at least to think. 2. If something isn't right you can always come to the drone's desk and shout at him all you want. 3. If something isn't right you can always call a meeting and blame everyone for the fault until some without guts would accept it or just would be tired enough to want it end right now with any means. With all the points combined it becomes crystal clear what the need to "see and touch" your office drones is because the management is absolutely incompetent both in the business and a human interactions and this is the last option for them to have a sense of control.
- hyperman1 5y agoI wish any of these were true, so at least somebody had some use. Unfortunately, the latest reorg means that my manager has to go to another physical location than me. I have in fact never seen my current manager in real life, only by videochat.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]