10 ms·
Howdy – Windows Hello style facial authentication for Linux
- als0 5y agoSome cameras have depth sensors to defend against the printed photo attack. Are they easily useable by Howdy? FWIW, Windows Hello refuses to work without one of these sensors.
- lhl 5y agoSadly, looks like no: https://github.com/boltgolt/howdy/issues/521 https://github.com/boltgolt/howdy/issues/521 "Windows Hello uses the two IR emitters to generate a 3D image of your face, and is much more secure. To do this Hello lights up your face with the left emitter on even frames, and uses the right emitter on odd frames. This lights up your face in slightly different angles, which is not possible to be faked by simply printing a 2D photo. Unfortunately Howdy does not have control over these IR emitters and can't use this process"
- als0 5y ago> Unfortunately Howdy does not have control over these IR emitters Wasn't sure if "does not" means can't, so I did a search and discovered this interesting development: https://github.com/boltgolt/howdy/pull/611 https://github.com/boltgolt/howdy/pull/611
- lhl 5y agoAh yeah, that's interesting. I was looking at the actual recognition code in howdy (basically leans on dlib's face detection), which doesn't seem to have any "3D" checker built in, but if it is just based on differential illumination, maybe it won't be so hard to simply make sure there are sufficient differences in the odd/even frames to distinguish a face as 3D. I suppose it could be weak to a "mask" attack, but you could add something like drishti to make sure you can real eyes in addition to a face. Note, even 3D sensors like Apple's FaceID can be broken with sufficient effort: https://www.wired.com/story/hackers-say-broke-face-id-security/ https://www.wired.com/story/hackers-say-broke-face-id-securi... Multi-spectral processing might help in that case, but honestly, if this sort of attack is a real security threat, then you probably shouldn't be running biometric logins in the first place (and you should probably actually be using MFA).
- als0 5y agoOf course, this is all about authentication convenience and keeping the attacker bar high. The mask attack is a lot more expensive/difficult than printing out a photo (too easy).
- jszymborski 5y ago> A note on security > This package is in no way as secure as a password and will never be. Although it's harder to fool than normal face recognition, a person who looks similar to you, or a well-printed photo of you could be enough to do it. Howdy is a more quick and convenient way of logging in, not a more secure one. Congrats to the author(s) for shipping a library, and having done so for some time now it seems (which is more than I've ever done). Can I ask if there's much of a point, though? Like why bother with the trouble of setting this up if I can just print a photo and have it unlock? At that point you're better off with a very weak and easy-to-remember password, no?
- spicybright 5y agoI wonder how it compares to windows Hello in terms of these attacks.
- Arainach 5y agoWindows Hello requires specific hardware that, among other things, uses IR imaging to make it much more difficult to spoof.
- dspillett 5y agoI'm still wary of biometrics for authentication no matter how difficult to spoof. They are also painful to revoke...
- lhl 5y agoMore difficult, but if you can capture an IR image of the user, it can be fed in directly if you have a device designed to spoof a USB webcam. A really interesting writeup from last year: https://www.cyberark.com/resources/threat-research-blog/bypassing-windows-hello-without-masks-or-plastic-surgery https://www.cyberark.com/resources/threat-research-blog/bypa...
- TYPE_FASTER 5y agoAt a first glance, it seems like a well done authentication system that handles video capture, integration with PAM, the workflow for managing faces/users, etc. As models evolve, they could be integrated without changing the other components. Also, I'd be curious to see how it compares to, say, Windows Hello. The nice thing about it being open source is you can change the confidence threshold for matching a face, and see the impact.
- spicybright 5y agoI personally hate the idea of face ID, but this project is exactly the kind of stuff we need if we want (and forgive the meme,) the year of the linux laptop. - Implements a popular feature other OS's have - A cute knock off name, making it self-explanatory (this is actually fairly important for adoption!) - Integrates well with cli junky workflows > Using the central authentication system (PAM), this works everywhere you would otherwise need your password: Login, lock screen, sudo, su, etc. - A nearly perfect readme in the repo. 2 sentence summary of the project, concise instructions for building/installation, where the error log lives, etc. without being too long. There are a lot of repos I've seen with horrible readmes that don't even have a sentence of what the purpose of it is. Which is reasonable if the repo is just for development, but most of the time a link to the repo is the main download link/project landing page. The added friction leads to less adoption and usage of something otherwise useful. If you're making a project simmilair to this, I recommend taking notes :^)
- Spivak 5y ago> I personally hate the idea of face ID I can kind of get why "Windows Hello" camera-based face id isn't exactly great but do you also think the same of Apple's "actually modeling your face" style? Because I was really apprehensive about it compared to a fingerprint reader but I've pretty much flipped 180.
- nicce 5y agoAs long as you think face or fingerprint as an username and not as password, they are kinda fine. You should be able to change your password, so there are not good. They are also public information. For now, they work as they are still hard to fake, but that might change over time in the future.
- spicybright 5y agoYup, just gotta model your threats. I use finger print scanners at home because it's less keystrokes. But not on my phone. Both because my (trusted) friends sometimes need to borrow a phone, and also for the very rare chance police detain me and try to break into my phone without a warrant. Legally, you don't have to tell a cop your password, but they can physically force you to use your finger/face to unlock your phone.
- guilhas 5y agoWindows Hello can be used as a 2fa for some websites, without a fido2 USB, is there anything like this for Linux?
- yoavm 5y agohttps://github.com/danstiner/rust-u2f/ https://github.com/danstiner/rust-u2f/ comes to mind
- CJefferson 5y agoI'm worried that "a well-printed photo of you" is enough to fool it. Both Windows Hello, and the Mac equivalent, can't be fooled by photos -- they require an IR camera, or camera which can measure depth. Claiming this is "Windows Hello style", if it can be fooled by a photo, is a bit misleading in my opinion.
- yoavm 5y agoI didn't try Howdy and so I'm not sure if and how it's enforced, but literally the second sentence in the README says it uses the IR camera too.
- cpuguy83 5y agoI don't have a lot of faith in Windows Hello either. My 6 year old daughter was able to log into my admin account. They weren't even trying to do that, just opened the laptop and it's all like "Hello, Brian!" and logged into my account.
- Boltgolt 5y agoHowdy is specifically made for IR cameras, normal cameras are not officially supported. Windows Hello works almost exactly the same way.
- krageon 5y ago> Both Windows Hello, and the Mac equivalent, can't be fooled by photos This is false, I've bypassed it on a very modern laptop using a phone picture.
- dimensionc132 5y ago
- nimbius 5y agofriendly reminder: do not use facial authentication (or biometrics), ever. in a US court of law, things like blood and biometrics are NOT protected by the fifth amendment. law enforcement can (and have) compelled submission of fingerprints and faces to unlock devices. this includes immigration and customs officers demanding credentials from foreign nationals. complex passphrases however are protected under the fifth amendment, and are much more secure overall.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- samatman 5y agoFor Apple biometric ID this is purely theatre, because devices can be compelled rapidly to require passwords. If the cops concerns you, I recommend practicing the lock sequence, and if they don't, perhaps we're not citizens of the same country.
- charcircuit 5y agoWhat's wrong with unlocking a device for them. Do you have something to hide? The convenience is valuable to the majority of people who will never be forced to unlock their device in their life.
- dTal 5y agoAdditionally, it provides zero security against any attack more earnest than peeking at your screen when your back is turned, unless combined with an elaborate chain of trust, including a TPM/Secure Enclave and full-disk encryption, which is only obtainable by running either Windows or Ubuntu with the officially signed-by-Microsoft Secure Boot kernel. Otherwise anyone can just boot the machine off a USB stick and take what they like.
- nerdjon 5y agoI will only use biometrics for authentication on a device that does 3 things: 1. if the device is turned off, I have to enter my passcode/password to enable biometrics authentication. 2. If after long enough of being on the biometrics are not used, it will require the passcode/password. 3. There is a quick shortcut to disable biometric authentication. To my knowledge iOS is the only one that does all 3. Mac does the first 2 for TouchID and annoyingly there is not a shortcut for the third available. Windows Hello seems like a half assed security measure since it is missing all 3. At quick glance this does the same.
- jeroenhd 5y agoMy Xiaomi does that too, although the quick shortcut is to just hold the power button down to force reboot it. I think it's just the PC space missing support for this. However, I think the emergency disable functionality in Windows Hello isn't really necessary. You can quickly disable biometrics on your phone from your pocket, but disabling it on a desktop or laptop is a lot harder to do inconspicuously. Because this is using PAM, you can configure it however you want. You can tell your system to allow user logins through biometrics but require a password for administrative tasks (doas/sudo) for example. You can also edit the source code and make it always fail if a certain file in a write-only directory is present and set up a keyboard shortcut that runs `touch /special/file/here`. You can even implement such a timer system by setting up a systemd timer that automatically creates such a file after a certain amount of time to make sure you need to reauthenticate. Setting up a reliable face recognition system that hooks into the right APIs is the hard part. That's what this project does. Customising it to serve your exact use case is relatively easy.
- NoGravitas 5y agoAndroid does all three, though there's no way to configure the timeout for (2), and the timeout seems inappropriately long (72 hours). At least, all these are the case on the Moto builds of Android 10. Could be different on other manufacturers.
- tempfs 5y agoLet's leave Microsoft's bad ideas on Windows mmmkay.
- Boltgolt 5y agoHey main developer of Howdy here, bizarre to see this on HN :) To emphasize: Howdy is about convenience for people that are okay with a less secure installation. It can also be used as a second factor. 3.0.0 has been in the works for 2 years now and will introduce a GTK UI, native PAM module and many other changes. Let me know if you have any questions!
- jotato 5y agoI've been using Howdy for a year now on an XPS 9500. It has been stable, fast, and super convenient. Thank you for making this available
- lazerl0rd 5y agoI never got round to PR'ing this (maybe I still will) but it would be great if Howdy had a feature where it could be "skipped" until the user is logged in. That would allow people using systemd-homed's encryption to unlock their home directories, which they otherwise cannot have done [as it requires the passphrase].
- jbm 5y agoInstalled but on my Regolith setup, it seems to result in this only working for sudo. I probably should remove it, but it is already saving me so much time..