6 ms·
Do the same mechanisms that create complex life also create complex technology?
- alsobrsp 5y agoOne could argue that life is complex technology.
- hackernewds 5y agoOne could argue complex technology is indistinguishable from complex life.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoAre you arguing that an i9 is indistinguishable from a human?
- Zircom 5y agoHe clearly means sufficiently advanced technology.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoIn that case, we have never seen a sufficiently advanced technology, so "Objection your honor. Assumes facts not in evidence."
- teitoklien 5y agoLawyers are complex technology for sure too. Defenders of Complex Justice.
- clouddrover 5y agoAh, and therefore humans are indistinguishable from magic.
- Gravyness 5y agoCareful as some religions might take offense on that sarcasm.
- clouddrover 5y agoThen some religions will just have to lighten up.
- blamestross 5y agoI think an i9 is distinguishable from an i7 and a human. All our artifice isn't meaningfully different than termite mounds in this sort of sense. So, a more prudent/understandable question is: just how alien do you need to be to unsure where to draw the "organism/not-organism" line on a termite mound+termites or as a counterpoint: on a snail or clam vs thier shell. Does the fact that the shell of animal was chemically changed by it's body give it some specialness? Or would an animal that constructed limb extensions on demand from wood or stone include those bits? What about brain extensions from bits of metal and glass?
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoThich Nhat Hanh: “Imagine, for a moment, a beautiful flower. That flower might be an orchid or a rose, or even a simple little daisy growing beside a path. Looking into a flower, we can see that it is full of life. It contains soil, rain, and sunshine. It is also full of clouds, oceans, and minerals. It is even full of space and time. In fact, the whole cosmos is present in this one little flower. If we took out just one of these “non-flower” elements, the flower would not be there. Without the soil’s nutrients, the flower could not grow. Without rain and sunshine, the flower would die. And if we removed all the non-flower elements, there would be nothing substantive left that we could call a “flower.” So our observation tells us that the flower is full of the whole cosmos, while at the same time it is empty of a separate self-existence. The flower cannot exist by itself alone.“
- blamestross 5y agoPull any single petal or leaf from the flower, and yet it still grows and thrives. We can see each of the petals and leaves are of a kind with the others, so perhaps their removability doesn't imply that lack of membership in the flower. In persuit of this mystery, we looked closely at the flower, found all the petals, stamen, and roots were in fact made of little plants themselves. Often these "cells" are of different shape shape and function in the flower, but chemical stimulation seems all it takes to coerce most to take on a different role. The truth perhaps, is that there isn't a flower, only a civilization of these "cells" but thier behavior, cooperation, and the structures of sugars that build around themselves are what makes up the "flower" and that it's current form was borne of millions of years of iteration and experimentation in form and function made it what it is today. From the outside, the termite mound (and all the termites inside) are reasonably all the body of one organism. Just as reasonably they are not functionality different than a human body or a human civilization. The only difference between an i9 and your bones is the story you tell yourself about it.
- mccorrinall 5y agoAn i9 might not, but technology has successfully imitated humans before, see Google Duplex: https://youtu.be/D5VN56jQMWM https://youtu.be/D5VN56jQMWM
- taneq 5y agoClearly an i9 is insufficiently advanced. ;)
- mjan22640 5y agoLife is a very advanced nanotechnology. No human created technology is anywhere near that level.
- Razengan 5y agoIf that i9 (or more realistically a more efficient M1) was powering a robot, who went on to learn and create other robots, and they eventually go to another planet, mine it’s resources, make more of themselves and teach other, would they, in their effects upon the universe and their interactions with others, be any distinguishable from any other “life”?
- visarga 5y agoIt all started with self replicating genes, and later with ideas. A self replicator would quickly conquer the available resources and then have to face competition to continue to replicate. We're what happens after billions of years of copying and pasting information under adversarial conditions. Technology is also a self replicator in the space of ideas and artefacts, and it also has limited resources available.
- Razengan 5y ago> A self replicator would quickly conquer the available resources No it wouldn’t, if it didn’t want to. Have we conquered our own solar system yet? Or even our own planet? (You’d be surprised how much space is still unpopulated) Unless you meant a perfectly automated replicator, but even then, like viruses, they would have limitations and face resistance from natural forces and distance, logistics etc.
- Thiez 5y agoMost of our solar system is pretty difficult to get to for humans (the overwhelmingly vast majority of those living today will never be in space), so why do you consider it as an available resource? It's like criticizing bacteria in a petri dish for failing to use the ample resources of a nearby supermarket.
- Razengan 5y ago> so why do you consider it as an available resource? It's like criticizing bacteria in a petri dish for failing to use the ample resources of a nearby supermarket. Congratulations! You just realized why the Fermi Paradox is self-assuming tripe, or the concept of “Von Neumann probes”
- spiralx 5y agoI personally think it's the discovery of Proof of Work algorithms leading to dismantling of solar systems to build Dyson Spheres that capture a sun's energy to power miners. Possibly constructed by Von Neumann machines thinking about it :)
- boomlinde 5y agoHow would you define life and technology such that life can be considered technology?
- rileyphone 5y agoI think so, at least in the broadest sense. Modern software has glaring flaws that make scaling it astoundingly complex, in a large part because of "Worse is Better". Coincidentally, I've been developing a screed on the bird website going deeper into this. It's a massive problem that must be solved, before we unintelligently create another intelligence to take care of it for us. https://twitter.com/riley_stews/status/1518389855864037382 https://twitter.com/riley_stews/status/1518389855864037382
- Flankk 5y ago> If technology x is replaced by a superior technology y, then technology x naturally goes “extinct.” That is a gross simplification. Monopolies have a perverse incentive to crush superior technology that might otherwise supplant them. The electric car is just one example. Superior technology does not automatically achieve widespread adoption. If it were that easy nobody would need advice or venture capital.
- visarga 5y agoIt's hard to see change as you're in the midst of it, but take a decade or two and it becomes apparent. Technological replacement is not instant but it does happen inevitably if there is competition or we face societal challenges.
- fedeb95 5y agoIn real life example fitting isn't as simple as "better at solving a problem". With cars you also have to deal with people psychology which forms an environment of its own
- dgb23 5y agoThere are typically many factors outside of just technical merit and even that can be quite subjective. But yes, there is also economic power, politics, fashion and all kinds of external pressures that are completely orthogonal to any quality metric.
- kuhewa 5y agoIt's a gross simplification of how it normally works in biological systems as well. Not that often that a totally dominant species that occupies the exact same niche appears. If it is a closely related species, if there aren't strict barriers to gene flow (i.e. they can reproduce) the species will just combine and those beneficial characters may or may not get swamped. If the second dominant species doesn't completely occupy the niche, the original is likely to just shift and specialise in a different part of niche - different food, shift in habitat, etc.
- Atlas667 5y agoI think so. That's why reality has fractal shapes. Circuit boards look like cities for electrons. Rivers look like arteries in a body. Lightning looks like offspring lineages. The universe has a few fundamental processes in it that repeat throughout all scales and the process of human development means technology also goes through an evolution.
- kuhewa 5y agoThose example motifs you mention are necessary for complex life but perhaps not sufficient. Maybe necessary isn't the right word, just emergent properties of low level phenomena
- mjburgess 5y agoIndeed, people begin by assuming that since programmable computers can approximate many classes of patterns and since computers are amazing therefore everything is just an instance of this class. Were this true, I cannot see why any system wouldn't be a model of any system; ie., alchemy would be possible. What people forget is that "programming" in the alchemical sense requires a star. Once you get specific about what properties and processes actually correspond to the allegdeged "complexities" you're talking about, its obvious that no programmable machine will implement them; as obvious as none will turn lead into gold.
- irrational 5y ago> no programmable machine will implement them; as obvious as none will turn lead into gold Unless we learned how to manipulate matter at an atomic level - construct and deconstruct atoms.
- Atlas667 5y agoI dont think that's where this conversation was going. I believe you got that impression from me mentioning fractals, but even so fractals are only self similar not identical. Maybe the fractal nature of computing is not in the "are we living in a simulation?" Kind, but is in the "we can imitate what we see at a different scale with fundamental units, logic/math, and visual field". In a sense it is a universe within a universe, but that doesn't imply everything is everything. It implies there are many things at different scales that are self similar. Scale still exists and is relevant.
- xyzrr 5y agoNatural selection is a good model not just for technology, but for ideas in general. Ideas have their own lifespans and virality coefficients, but they're like viruses in that they depend on their hosts, so their fitness is partially dependent on the fitness of their hosts. That's why our morals exist, because societies that had them were more fit than societies where everyone was totally selfish. We don't like to think of morality in terms of fitness though, because of our morals, ironically.
- amelius 5y ago> Natural selection is a good model not just for technology, but for ideas in general. Didn't social media show that not the best ideas win, but the most juicy ones? Technology might not be taking us where you think it takes us.
- keiferski 5y agoNatural selection doesn’t imply that the “best” organism wins.
- yetihehe 5y agoNope, social media only shows that juicy ideas spread more efficiently. Do they stay long with us? Not many of them do.
- JaimeThompson 5y agoQanon has been with us for years.
- Infernal 5y agoPrior to the 20th century, communicating ideas had a much higher cost. If we're talking about natural selection with respect to ideas, then we have to consider the last 100+ years as a massive environmental shift that we have not yet adapted to.
- kuhewa 5y ago> That's why our morals exist, because societies that had them were more fit than societies where everyone was totally selfish Or, our morals exist because they allowed us to steamroll other less selfish and more altruistic groups because we were able to frame them as outgroup 'others'.
- Geee 5y agoYes. Everything happens through trial and error. Intelligence is an illusion.
- HPsquared 5y agoIntelligence itself could be described as an (internal, simulated) process of trial and error.
- egman_ekki 5y agoOn the topic of complexity of life created structures, I found this Lex Fridman's interview with Lee Cronin fascinating and thought-provoking: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZecQ64l-gKM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZecQ64l-gKM
- bick_nyers 5y agoCame here looking for someone to mention this, great episode
- crgk 5y agoThe MathLabs competition reminds me a lot of speedrunning progressions in video games. The routes and techniques used to complete a video game as fast as possible evolve as the speedrunning community shares videos of their record-setting runs. It's a really cool environment for developing the "technology" behind each speedrunning category, and I'd be fascinated to read analysis similar to this article.