6 ms·
Atomic Habits: An Easy and Proven Way to Build Good Habits and Break Bad Ones
- black_13 5y ago
- bookreturn 5y agoI read the book and can't remember anything about it except the first chapter where James describes an accident he was in. Tiny Habits, from the man who created Behavioural Science, is much more concrete, doable and memorable: https://tinyhabits.com/ https://tinyhabits.com/
- feanaro 5y agoWhat exactly do you mean by "behavioural science" when you say that BJ Fogg created it? Behaviorism existed for some fifty years before he was even born (if we consider it started with John B. Watson).
- johnchristopher 5y agoMost likely refer to https://behaviordesign.stanford.edu/ https://behaviordesign.stanford.edu/
- cooltraction 5y agoI wonder what graduate course they teach this in.
- solarkraft 5y agoThe capitalization gives away that it's likely also a book.
- sheinsheish 5y agoOr the great free resource https://zenhabits.net/ https://zenhabits.net/
- triyambakam 5y agoI wouldn't say that's an analogous resource. Zen to Done is a simplified version of Getting Things Done, while Atomic Habits and the work of BJ Fogg is more about broad behavioral changes, through which a notetaking system could be implemented, or not.
- rjh29 5y agoMaybe my memory sucks but reading a book and relying on your brain to magically remember and recall it seems suboptimal to me. I read Atomic Habits and, while reading, wrote 150 lines of a .txt file summarising the best parts. I still find it useful today.
- zizee 5y agoCare to share your txt file?
- rjh29 5y agoI marked it up here: https://richardjharris.github.io/summary-of-atomic-habits-by-james-clear/ https://richardjharris.github.io/summary-of-atomic-habits-by...
- takyon12 5y agoSame question as the user above me - would you mind sharing the file? Thanks!
- rjh29 5y agoYep, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31173196 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31173196
- jwally 5y agoPost on github or something? 'Cause uh... me too!
- rjh29 5y agoYes, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31173196 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31173196
- magic_hamster 5y agoAbove all, this seems like an ad for a book with ideas that can be put into words in an easier way.
- Shugarl 5y agoI disagree with the other comments. Ever since I read this book years ago, I've been able to start reading daily, exercise regularly, clean my home almost daily, work on learning a new language daily (Japanese) among other things.
- deathofsocrates 5y agoI don't know how many times we need to see a post about this book. I read it. People read it. its in bookshelves of zoom meetings, its in blog posts, websites, there are summaries, audio versions, youtube videos... basically everywhere. enough is enough. Yes, its an okay book, its fine. Obvious facts put in words properly. if you can apply it, you obviously didn't need this book in the first place anyway.
- 2143 5y agoIt's an alright book. Nothing groundbreaking. Could have been condensed into a blog post. I assume most people intuitively know the ideas in it beforehand. Buy it only if you get it cheap. Or buy used. After reading a bunch of such books over the years, I have sworn never to read books about personal productivity.
- mikro2nd 5y ago"Could have been condensed into a blog post" Thanks for that! I've wasted far too many hours of my life on books like this that could easily have conveyed all their useful information in a couple of pages. I had the distinct feeling it might be that sort of book from the vapid, content-free nature of the linked blog post, but to have it confirmed by someone who's actually bothered to look at the source is valuable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway572 5y ago
- KSteffensen 5y ago"Could have been condensed into a blog post" Here you go: https://www.chrisbehan.ca/posts/atomic-habits https://www.chrisbehan.ca/posts/atomic-habits Related HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29774859 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29774859
- mdp2021 5y ago> Could have been condensed into a blog post Which would have drowned it in the ocean where drops are posts. _We do "need" (it would be a revolution in civilization) a system to review contributions - including posts - ranking them for value._ Something that would allow such «blog post» to have a recognition - closer to "best seller" class and farther to "found it randomly".
- stackbutterflow 5y ago
- jeffwass 5y agoI found this book a couple weeks ago. I’ve only read the first few chapters so far, but the one idea that really helped me is the importance of incorporating your habit into your identity. Eg, if you think “I am learning piano and will try to practice every day,” it doesn’t stick nearly as much as convincing yourself “I AM a piano player, and I practice every day”.
- persedes 5y agoyes, started reading the books 2 nights ago and tried that out yesterday to do some mundane tasks that I never find the motivation to do. It was amazingly effective and I love the simplicity of it. Not sure how long it'll keep its effect though hehe
- relativeadv 5y agoI like that. When I was a freshman in art school on my first day of painting class my professor said to us something like, "All of you are already artists, now you have to practice art." Changing it from "I must do my studio time so that when i graduate i can become an artist" to "I am already an artist and I am practicing right now" was a big deal for my young and insecure mentality. Also reminded me of this passage from War of Art... "What's hard is sitting down to write. Have you experienced a vision of the person you might become, the work you could accomplish, the realized being you were meant to be? Are you a writer who doesn't write, a painter who doesn't paint, an entrepreneur who never starts a venture? Then you know what “Resistance” is."
- IceDane 5y agoThis is just an ad.
- petargyurov 5y agoI read the book not too long ago. The only thing that truly stuck with me is: - Habit stacking: want to form a new habit? Stick it on the end of an existing one. Works really well. It's a decent book and worth the read IMO.
- mawadev 5y agoI've been forming and dropping habits for a while and what I've noticed is that you go into an "autopilot" mode - it is good for a while and you see results, but for some things you start stagnating. It is as if you are not conscious about the things you do anymore. Does anyone else have that experience?
- relativeadv 5y agoI recently experienced this in a surprising way. There is an app i use for dieting called MacroFactor, incredible app by the way, that really streamlines the process of checking in and making adjustments. The issue is it is actually SO good at streamlining everything that my previous rituals on checking on my trending weight and what my average calories and such served as an anchor to keep me "in" the goal. Without this, I will get a few weeks in and just go sort of "autopilot" as you say and become detached from the process and even the outcome.
- orzig 5y agoI also found the book unoriginal, but can’t ignore several people who report it helpful. So let’s move the conversation forward a step: does this book or any like it have (even slightly) rigorous evidence of positive impact? If the FDA wanted to approve a self-help book, would they be able to find a single study to reference?
- rchaud 5y agoReviewing books aren't part of the FDA's purview, but there are some that doctors frequently recommend. Dr. David Burns' "Feeling Good" is about as close as it gets to an English language bible for addressing early onset anxiety and depression via CBT methods. However, a doctor or therapist wouldn't just give you the book and ask you to follow its suggestions on your own. They'd work with you to set up homework (worksheets to identify negative thinking patterns for example), set deadlines and assess how you're doing after 2 weeks, 4 weeks, 6 weeks, etc. They act as an accountability partner. Judging the efficacy of productivity advice can also be properly assessed via a similar scientific method of observation and experimentation and measurement.
- kashunstva 5y agoAnything groundbreaking in Atomic Habits? Maybe not, but I found his focus on habits built around process goals helpful in my own practice. Whether an outcome-oriented goal is just aspirational or already well-defined quantitatively, building habits of process seem foundational. Again, nothing earth-shaking, but occasional reminders are good too.
- xunn0026 5y agoAtomic Habits is a book that should have been a long blog post. It's amazing how many self help book could be a pamphlet with 10 printed pages for more details.
- rchaud 5y agoThat's probably how self-help books started. Short and to the point. But it's hard for people to take the steps necessary to change, so I can imagine a lot of people simply stop doing the steps laid out in the original pamphlet, thinking there's a 'better way', that's less inconvenient. And so we get Self Help Book 2.0, now with a lengthy introduction describing all kinds of relatable issues that convinces you that this is the right book that seems to 'get' you as an individual. But beyond the motivational first chapter, the book still contains those hard-to-do-regularly steps and insists that you must change if your habits are to. So we end up dropping that as well, choosing instead to wait for the next book that makes all the right promises.
- jkmcf 5y agoWrite chapter that summarizes the findings and the following chapters focus on real-life examples. Sounds like a research paper written for normals. :). Self-help Book 3.0?
- xunn0026 5y agoIf it's any books that need a Reader's Digest, it's self help books. There's so much filler in Atomic Habits it's amazing. I think 10 pages would be too much for what was actually covered. I wonder if somebody actually did a good summary. It can't be too many pages, really.
- ahaferburg 5y agoI liked this video summary about the book: https://youtu.be/PZ7lDrwYdZc https://youtu.be/PZ7lDrwYdZc