8 ms·
Norway convinced Japan to love salmon sushi (2015)
- blisterpeanuts 5y agoI never knew this. Salmon is my favorite fish, and salmon sashimi is my favorite sashimi. It’s not the cheapest fish, either, so I guess demand caught up with supply.
- dang 5y agoRelated: How Norway Created Salmon Sushi - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10243823 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10243823 - Sept 2015 (88 comments)
- mfer 5y agoeating our way to extinction, which I’d on Amazon prime right now, talks about Norway and the farmed fish system there. Seeing what the farmed fish looked like (they are often not healthy) was kind of gross.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoNZ farmed salmon is supposedly safe, wonder if it has better status in Japan. Regardless I overeaten of it and now my go to is teriyaki snapper.
- philliphaydon 5y agoUnlike most places that farm salmon. Nz salmon starts out in the river. Grown to a certain size then moved to farms to finish growing. Farms are not overpopulated. The new born salmon are put back into rivers. In Norway the salmon farms spend the entire life in the farm. Are fed lots of antibiotics because they get sick. And are overpopulated. Nz. Is very strict because of 1 person messes up it ruins the reputation of the entire country.
- vintermann 5y agoThat wouldn't even work. You have to grow salmon in freshwater to a certain size before you can grow them in the sea, it's done in tanks on land here in Norway (the fishery directorate would certainly not let them use rivers). I worked at the University library when I studied, I remember there was a ton of outdated books from the early development of salmon aquaculture. Salmon farming didn't even succeed until the late 60s, it took a lot longer to make it profitable. They tried a lot of wild stuff, some of it was ecologically questionable to put it mildly (like "havbeite", the idea of forgoing enclosures entirely and just release the smolt to sea, hoping to catch it later). But regulation has caught up to the industry somewhat. Of course, now the Norwegian owned industry does a lot of the bad stuff it's no longer allowed to do in Norway in Chile instead.
- jandrewrogers 5y agoNew Zealand farmed salmon is the only farmed salmon I will eat, because it is legitimately much higher quality than farmed salmon I have eaten from anywhere else. No idea about safety per se. I have easy access to fresh wild Alaskan salmon and typically eat that from sources with known supply chains. Nonetheless, experience has convinced me that New Zealand produces the only farmed product that is remotely comparable in quality. New Zealand has a legit below-the-radar farmed salmon business, mostly because their salmon has quality unlike any other farmed salmon I've experienced.
- oneoff786 5y agoFarmed salmon tastes way better to me than wild. I think there’s some pollutant concerns with wild as well
- lr4444lr 5y agoIt tastes better likely because it is more fatty. The various toxins in farmed salmon probably accumulate in the fat tissues though, so not sure why you'd think wild is more toxic.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoYou have a source on farmed salmon being toxic? I'd think FDA (and other national equivalents) might have an issue with that...
- lr4444lr 5y agoI didn't specifically say farmed salmon was more toxic, just that the toxins we are concerned about in fish accumulate in the fat tissues. The FDA is very clear on this, even if they think the amounts are mostly of concern to pregnant and lactating women. https://www.fda.gov/food/consumers/questions-answers-fdaepa-advice-about-eating-fish-those-who-might-become-or-are-pregnant-or#V https://www.fda.gov/food/consumers/questions-answers-fdaepa-...
- oneoff786 5y agoLean salmon tastes too gamey for me. I find it very unpleasant.
- wumpus 5y agoYou're in luck! Most wild salmon is actually farmed these days. Many newspaper articles about that. On the flip side, farmed salmon doesn't have the health benefits of wild, because they don't eat things with a lot of omega-3's.
- rendang 5y ago
- TedShiller 5y agoNot really. Salmon sushi has been popular in Japan for ages.
- emsixteen 5y agoYes really.
- TedShiller 5y agoNope, at least not if you know Japan
- emsixteen 5y agoUh-huh, of course.
- tims33 5y agoMy experience in Japan is that salmon is still second class sushi even if it is more common now.
- bamboozled 5y agoThis is true, high grade salmon in a proper Sushi restaurant looks a lot different to the orange slop in cheaper places though. There is a wild / higher grade salmon available, even Japanese domestic salmon exists.
- tims33 5y agoI completely agree. But even in the high end sushi places that only have quality sushi, it is still a second class citizen.
- nononononoaaa 5y agoThat is not a higher grade of salmon. You should not be eating that. Domestic Japanese Salmon has parasites in it. Just no.
- orangepurple 5y agoAll salmon, when consumed raw, potentially have parasites. The trick to killing them is storing the fish at far below zero for a week or cooking them
- enriquto 5y ago> storing the fish at -70C how do you do that? My expensive freezer only goes down to -30 when set to maximum cold (and then it becomes really loud!)
- orangepurple 5y agoMy apologies. It is not -70C, although it would work. Your expensive deep freezer is the correct tool for the job as long as the fish isn't huge. > Freezing and storing at an ambient temperature of -4°F (-20°C) or below for 7 days (total time), or freezing at an ambient temperature of -31°F (-35°C) or below until solid and storing at an ambient temperature of -31°F (-35°C) or below for 15 hours, or freezing at an ambient temperature of -31°F (-35°C) or below until solid and storing at an ambient temperature of -4°F (-20°C) or below for 24 hours are sufficient to kill parasites. Note that these conditions may not be suitable for freezing particularly large fish (e.g., thicker than 6 inches). > Brining and pickling may reduce the parasite hazard in a fish, but they do not eliminate it, nor do they minimize it to an acceptable level. Nematode larvae have been shown to survive 28 days in an 80° salinometer brine (21% salt by weight). Fish that contain parasites in their flesh may also contain parasites within their egg sacs (skeins), but generally not within the eggs themselves. For this reason, eggs that have been removed from the sac and rinsed are not likely to contain parasites. Trimming away the belly flaps of fish or candling and physically removing parasites are effective methods for reducing the numbers of parasites. However, they do not completely eliminate the hazard, nor do they minimize it to an acceptable level. Source: https://www.fda.gov/media/80777/download https://www.fda.gov/media/80777/download
- jbmny 5y agoAlways fascinated by salmon sushi's second class status. Salmon sushi to me is so much more flavorful than tuna. I thought maybe I just wasn't getting great tuna at sushi restaurants in the US, but I found the results to be the same in Tokyo.
- wintermutestwin 5y agoI love salmon and tuna sashimi, but rarely eat tuna due to high mercury content.
- trevorboaconstr 5y agoAre you for real? Any maguro you get in a serious Japanese sushi place is gunna melt in your mouth. But it’s gunna be 25-30 USD per plate (2 pieces).
- nawgz 5y agoI am relatively sure anytime you get 100g of meat for 30USD it will melt in your mouth.
- aaronblohowiak 5y agoNot everyone likes the same stuff! I also generally prefer salmon to tuna though I appreciate a chu-toro from time to time. For melt in mouth, uni takes the crown (otters again demonstrating they have life figured out better than people)
- tptacek 5y agoTaking Momotaro as a sort of baseline for high-end but not Omakase-only sushi in Chicago, akami is $7 ($14), chutoro is $11 ($22) and otoro $13 ($26). The otoro will melt, but the chutoro will have the same texture as the sake and the akami will be leaner and have more texture; all 3 are maguro, and all 3 are more expensive than sake. :) I prefer sake to akami and chutoro; it is hard to beat otoro. I can see how sake is a gateway fish! But the implication seems to be that instead of eating salmon, for the real deal we should be eating bluefin. That seems dumb; both salmon and bluefin are pretty boring, they all occupy sort of the same place in Japanese cooking as sesame chicken does in American Chinese food. Everything else is better!
- lvl102 5y agoSalmon is not loved in Japan. It’s mostly American sushi restaurants due to more fatty taste and familiarity. It is also largely due to Moonies and the fact that salmon was easy to source in the US.
- presentation 5y agoAs someone who lives in Japan happy to say that you’re wrong and sushi places both cheap and expensive serve salmon all the time, and Japanese people order them all the time.
- lvl102 5y agoAs a Japanese, I can say it was not loved. It’s there now and perhaps it’s enjoyed.
- 3np 5y agoSome people love it, some don't. It is loved, just not universally. Aside, but like most other foods old or new it will have its fair share of TV airtime with celebrities making loud faces about how delicious it is ;) Or what distinction do you make between "it is enjoyed" and "it is loved"?
- prokopton 5y agoAnd if you go to 回転寿司 it's always topped with something else because nobody wants plain salmon.
- jeemusu 5y agoAs someone who lives in Japan, it may well be available but it is not LOVED by Japanese people. I'm always amazed how many of my Japanese friends don't eat Salmon sushi.
- JetAlone 5y agoI'm genuinely curious, what do the Moonies have to do with the history of salmon sushi? I presume you're talking about this group that was founded in Korea, right? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unification_Church https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unification_Church
- gruez 5y ago>How The Desperate Norwegian Salmon Industry Created A Sushi Staple This is slightly misleading. Salmon sushi in japan might not have been a thing prior to norway's marketing campaign, but there's plenty of evidence of salmon sushi being a thing outside of japan[1] and being at least somewhat popular. You could argue that if it weren't for acceptance in japan it wouldn't have been a "staple", but that seems a bit tenuous when it was already on magazine covers. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1k4x9FrD5k4&t=668s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1k4x9FrD5k4&t=668s
- tptacek 5y agoI've been curious for awhile about whether Seattle gets much better salmon sushi than the rest of the country (like: enough that it'd be a reason to seek out Japanese food in Seattle).
- mshron 5y agoI can't speak for the Japanese restaurants, but I had surprisingly delicious salmon nigiri just from a Seattle grocery store chain. Great flavor, and very inexpensive. I think it was a platter of 12 nigiri for what I'd expect to pay for a supermarket salmon maki in New York. This would have been at a QFC around 2015.
- buildbot 5y agoTotally biased but I think Seattle probably has the best sushi on the West Coast for any fish. This article was actually somewhat unexpected to me, as I was always told that one of the main people who made salmon sushi popular was Shiro at Niko/then Shiros. Last time I went to sushi Kashiba (his new place), Shiro served us salmon four ways as our first plate.
- jandrewrogers 5y agoHands down, as a salmon and sushi snob that has lived in Seattle for over a decade and eaten it globally countless times, the salmon available in Seattle is the best available anywhere. The proximity to some of the best and least damaged fisheries in the world helps. I have never eaten so much of it as since I lived in Seattle. It is the only place in the US you can get fresh top-tier salmon (and often many other fish) at the local markets. Everywhere else your options are farmed or frozen salmon of dubious provenance. And FWIW, Japanese expats I know, not necessarily living in Seattle, seem to confirm that the sushi quality here is exceptional. This is largely a product of geography, being relatively close to both Alaska and Japan.
- tptacek 5y agoSold; I need to get back out there.
- glandium 5y agoInterestingly (ironically?), Norway is not even close to the biggest provider of Salmon in Japan: https://www.maruha-nichiro.co.jp/salmon/data/images/index_ph03.gif https://www.maruha-nichiro.co.jp/salmon/data/images/index_ph... (pink in US, yellow is Canada, between yellow and green is Russia, green is Norway, blue is Chile and dark blue is Other)
- daniel-cussen 5y ago¡Vamos Chile! Yeah wow well there you go. You know Norwegians own most salmon farming in Chile, don't you? And let me say also, this validates government export offices. In fact I visited the Japanese Government export office in Santiago, they gave me really valuable information about exporting to Japan where the market for wasabi was at the time. What do you know, you pay taxes and you get back something for it?
- glandium 5y ago> You know Norwegians own most salmon farming in Chile, don't you? I must say, I didn't even know Chile "produced" salmon until I found that graph, so nothing would surprise me. However, wikipedia pointed me to https://www.terram.cl/2018/11/grupos-extranjeros-pasarian-a-controlar-37-de-los-envios-de-salmon-chileno/ https://www.terram.cl/2018/11/grupos-extranjeros-pasarian-a-... which doesn't seem to confirm what you're saying, but my spanish is rusty.
- steve_adams_86 5y agoNorwegians also owned a lot of farms in Canada! I believe that’s winding down now because the farms causes extensive disease in local wild populations.
- thedailymail 5y agoSalmon also became a staple in the American diet during the Great Depression, mainly because it was so cheap compared to other sources of animal protein. As Marc Reisner wrote in Cadillac Desert: "People who came through the Depression didn’t just eat salmon, they survived on it, and they were sick of it; it was known as poverty steak, because it sold for ten cents a pound.”
- Tagbert 5y agoAs a child in the US in the 1960s we ate quite a lot of canned salmon. It was a cheap protein source.
- takurx 5y agoSalmon sushi also has been popular in Japan. Salmon sushi is not traditional Edomae sushi, but it put on fat as same as tuna and it's great taste. (It come from California roll, American sushi?) For fresh Norway salmon to Japan need Northern Sea route near Russia. I'm praying for peace.
- owly 5y agoIf you eat seafood, you should watch Seaspiracy. It uncovers the massive amount of lies flowing from the seafood industry. https://www.seaspiracy.org/ https://www.seaspiracy.org/
- JetAlone 5y agoWas "Conspirasea", taken?
- julianbuse 5y agoThis is brilliant.
- kim_bauer 5y ago
- kupopuffs 5y agoThis thread has a lot of vague assertions about popularity opposed by very confident, emotionally offended experts backed by anecdotal evidence. Love it
- bayesian_horse 5y agoNo, Norwegian salmon doesn't have parasites. Mainly because they treat them with a ton of chemicals in open sea pens. Hardly ideal...
- toredash 5y agoSource?
- bayesian_horse 5y agoI suggest you google the topic. It's too complicated to comprehensively answer with any one source. But it's indisputable that Norwegian aquaculture is quite heavy on pharmaceutics and that there are environmental issues, both with those chemicals and with the ectoparasites the fish still have. There are documentaries about it.
- toredash 5y agoLike this one: https://www.mattilsynet.no/language/english/fish_and_aquaculture/farmed_atlantic_salmon_and_rainbow_trout_are_safe_for_sushi_and_sashimi.31976 https://www.mattilsynet.no/language/english/fish_and_aquacul... Which states differently?
- bayesian_horse 5y agoIt does not. It asserts that Norwegian salmon as a food product does not pose a risk to consumers regarding parasites. It doesn't even talk about pharmaceutical use, chemical traces in the flesh or effects on the environment. I'm not saying that this salmon poses health risks to consumers. But the Norwegian aquaculture industry does use a lot of pharmaceuticals in the open sea water. And the high density contributes to a high propensity for ectoparasites. Both of these things pose an environmental hazard. (I'm a Veterinarian by the way...) https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0044848619322057 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S004484861... I most want to point out that Norwegian farmed salmon isn't as glorious as it was stated. I'd like to add that this is a predatory species and needs to be fed mostly fish protein to grow profitably. This in turn means the food for the farmed salmon is usually fished out of the sea, too. This is certainly not sustainable and will hopefully be replaced by insect protein (soy doesn't work). But it needs regulatory action, as it is more expensive than harming the ocean...
- meristohm 5y agoFor a rare treat I'll enjoy some salmon, either cooked-from-frozen or as sashimi (preferred, even over otoro). Once I learned more about tuna I see them now as wolves of the sea (rather than chickens) and generally avoid eating animals that are high on a food chain. Sardines, mackerel, and bivalves, along with sea greens of all sorts (wakame, nori, alaria, dulse, kelp, etc) are what I eat more often, in part inspired by Bren Smith's book Eat Like a Fish [0]. [0] https://www.worldcat.org/title/eat-like-a-fish/ https://www.worldcat.org/title/eat-like-a-fish/
- Py-o7 5y agoSardines, mackerel, oysters, mussels and sea vegetables... this sounds a lot like me, except I also eat salmon regularly. My understanding is tuna, especially the premium kinds like blue fin that show up in sushi, is loaded with mercury, PCBs and a lot of other bad news. The deleterious effect (of PCBs in this case) is already showing up in orcas that eat large prey like tuna https://phys.org/news/2018-09-pcb-pollution-threatens-killer-whales.html https://phys.org/news/2018-09-pcb-pollution-threatens-killer...