4 ms·
How does a “flat lining” of wages of cause family stability to go down? And how do you explain high levels of family stability in countries that are much poorer
by rayiner 5y ago
How does a “flat lining” of wages of cause family stability to go down? And how do you explain high levels of family stability in countries that are much poorer?
- nightvoomer 5y agoCommunity.
- rayiner 5y agoThe “community” in those countries enforces exactly the norms the author talks about.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- danans 5y ago> And how do you explain high levels of family stability in countries that are much poorer? Less individual freedom, greater direct economic dependency on others in your group, and also the threat of ostracization, excommunication, and destitution if you go against its rules. Basically, there are extremely high cost/stakes associated with going it on your own. But on the other side there are also good things that come from greater direct interdependency, like perhaps less individual alienation and a greater sense of shared purpose, and access to community resources when you follow the prescribed rules.
- jacobolus 5y agoIn some places people have centuries of social-structure adaptation to deal with the stress of being systematically oppressed (by local elites, colonial overlords, ...). E.g. money gets shielded by community institutions (such as local religious organizations) that are harder for elites to steal from than individual peasants, and then those act as a kind of social safety net in hard times. Extended families/clans build social bonds through e.g. marriage and baptism, and help each-other. Often there are severe social problems in rural peasant societies: alcoholism, domestic violence, seasonal migrant labor keeping people away from home much of the year, corruption, ..., but people have also learned to be tough vs. some kinds of outside threats. But large waves in the world economy (or a large natural disaster or the like) also can overwhelm those defenses.
- danans 5y agoI think we agree that many pro-social structures exist in poor and socially rigid societies. However these come at the expense of many liberties (i.e. religious) that are held as important in the more developed world. It's not clear that loss of such personal liberties would be an improvement in developed societies, even if it reduced the nominal divorce rate.
- zozbot234 5y agoLiberties have always come paired with obligations to one's surrounding community, so there would be nothing new in this. We have a name for pure liberty or "liberation" shorn of any checks or obligations towards others: we call it licence, and every increase in licence is ultimately a step towards bondage and tyranny.
- danans 5y agoThose obligations are strong and operational in many places where religion isn't the center of civic life. There is nothing wrong with religion as a framework for teaching people about their social obligations, but it's hardly the only way to achieve that.
- rayiner 5y agoI agree there is a trade off, but let’s explore this a bit further. Who decides how much they value religious liberty compared to lower divorce rates? Decisions about these trade offs tend to be imposed from the top, by the elites. 2/3s of Americans still disagree with the Supreme Court ruling banning school prayer. When there is a trade off, who should get to make the decisions about where to strike the balance?
- danans 5y ago> Who decides how much they value religious liberty compared to lower divorce rates? > When there is a trade off, who should get to make the decisions about where to strike the balance? Of course the Supreme Court when concerning anything involving the government making an establishment of any religion. The US isn't Saudi Arabia. As much as it's any American's right to practice the religion of their choosing, it's not in any religion's right to deny any individual - even in their religion - their individual liberties, or to impose their religion upon a person of another or no religion.
- philistine 5y agoI think you're trying to think that stable families become less stable if their waged stagnate. They don't. What happens is that in aggregate, with stagnating wages, there are less stable (middle-class) families in society. For so-called poorer countries, they are differently structured. It's tough to compare their family units with our rich nations.
- rayiner 5y ago> For so-called poorer countries, they are differently structured. It's tough to compare their family units with our rich nations. But that’s exactly the point! Prior to the 1960s revolution in social norms, families in poor countries weren’t structured all that differently than ones in the US. I’m no Reaganite, but the fact is that the stuff the old “family values” conservatives said is pretty much the same thing my Asian immigrant parents told me growing up. Meanwhile, the data shows that Asian Americans who grow up in the bottom 20% have a 25% chance of ending up in the top 20% as adults. For white kids it’s just 11%. That’s a really big coincidence to hand wave away.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- philistine 5y agoAsian-Americans are not this rose-tinted perfect example of family values breeding success. https://www.vox.com/identities/22530103/asians-americans-wealth-income-gap-crazy-rich-model-minority https://www.vox.com/identities/22530103/asians-americans-wea... The crazy successful asian immigrants are mostly those who came recently, and who are bluntly the best and brightest of Asia coming to America for a better life due to US policy attracting the very best. Just like the above conversation, you only think of one slice of data to arrive at your conclusion.
- nradov 5y agoThe issue isn't with the absolute level of wages but with increasing income inequality (Gini coefficient) and the resulting loss of social status for young men on the lower end of that scale.
- purplerabbit 5y agoCorrect. The hierarchy is getting steeper and harder to climb. Men who don’t feel connected to a clear path of ascension become desperate and often either dangerous or losers. It’ll be interesting to see what happens to the increasing number of men who feel they have “fallen off the path”. Could be scary
- DeathArrow 5y ago>It’ll be interesting to see what happens to the increasing number of men who feel they have “fallen off the path”. Could be scary They will probably seek revenge against the social norms and classes which alienated them. History tends to repeat itself.