19 ms·
Crypto, the Left and Technofeudalism
- kkfx 5y agoIMVHO the issue is more on the mere understanding what money is. I suggest rediscover a small scene from a Colombian movie (witch is nothing really interesting IMO beside that small sketch): El Concursante, here the relevant part: https://youtu.be/WpGhcDg7IJ4 https://youtu.be/WpGhcDg7IJ4 that's the more clear and simple compact explanation of the nature of money. In short: a currency is a symbol, a unit of measure, a cohort of people accept in place of something tangible. It reason is that we can exchange goods one counter another in the classic barter BUT sometimes two party have something to exchange that mach sometimes no, the general symbolic unit of measure solve that issue. Having understood that we can comprehend that actual issue is not the banking systems with a central bank but the fact that such bank is private and do not generate unit of measure for the public according to current public needs, they loan them treating money as the substrate of anything instead of the inverse. Understood that we comprehend that the solution is not finding new unit of measure of some kind but made central banks public and private banking without any seigniorage or power in the central bank. Cryptos are surely the ideas Big of IT have to ingest banking sector under their control, and banking sector understand that well, see for instance https://voxeu.org/content/banking-disrupted-financial-intermediation-era-transformational-technology https://voxeu.org/content/banking-disrupted-financial-interm... and https://voxeu.org/article/digitalisation-and-future-banking https://voxeu.org/article/digitalisation-and-future-banking they are even worst for the public because with physical cash limits are artificial, with cryptos the need of iron and connection are practical.
- draw_down 5y agoMore NFT chunder
- toraway1234 5y ago
- rvz 5y ago> That last move, the digital yuan, constitutes a revolution: when fully-fledged, it will equip every resident in China, but also anyone from around the world who wants to trade with China, with a digital wallet – a basic digital bank account. In one move, therefore, the commercial banks will have been ‘dis-intermediated’; or, in plain English, they will have lost their monopoly over the payments system. This is genuinely a radical break from finance as we have known it. And, yes, it is one that we should emulate in Europe and in the United States – which is, of course, why Wall Street and the rest of the West’s financiers will do their best to stop it, preferring to blow up the world rather than allow themselves to be… dis-intermediated. So is that why Stellar is still being used for a CBDC trial in Ukraine then? [0][1] Or even a Bhutan CBDC [2] using XRPL being trialed as well? Perhaps that is where we are going then. It also doesn't surprise me at all that Bitcoin has been a total failure in being useful for any of its original purpose and Ethereum has propagated and accelerated scam tokens with 'DeFi', ICOs and JPEG NFTs so quickly that it has become unusably expensive to almost everyone except millionaires spending $1k to send $100k hence the layer-2 contraptions that it needs to 'scale' up. [0] https://cryptobriefing.com/ukraine-cbdc-is-progressing-during-wartime-stellar-ceo/ https://cryptobriefing.com/ukraine-cbdc-is-progressing-durin... [1] https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ukraine-electronic-hryvnia-pilot-launched-by-tascombank-and-bitt-on-stellar-301443773.html https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ukraine-electronic-... [2] https://ripple.com/insights/bhutan-advances-financial-inclusion-and-sustainability-with-ripples-cbdc-solution/ https://ripple.com/insights/bhutan-advances-financial-inclus...
- Helitioo 5y agoNot sure what his problem is, a bank account is cheap, has great features etc. And hedge fonds can play there game anywhere. The same thing with the argument from people that the normal suppressed people can get money through it. Dictators / evil actors can use the same system and still have the high ground.
- tosh 5y agoaside: Varoufakis used to be economist-in-residence at Valve > Beginning in March 2012, Varoufakis became economist-in-residence at video game publisher, Valve. He researched exchange rates within the virtual economy on the Steam digital delivery platform, specifically looking at exchange rates and trade deficits. In June 2012, he began a blog about his research at Valve. In February 2013 his function at Valve was to work on a game for predicting trends in gaming. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yanis_Varoufakis#Academic_career https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yanis_Varoufakis#Academic_care...
- f0e4c2f7 5y agoHe was also the finance minister of Greece. You may or may not agree with his ideas or not but I think you'd be hard pressed to find someone with more nuanced takes on politics, tech, and crypto. Unusual combo. Interesting person.
- arinlen 5y ago> You may or may not agree with his ideas or not but I think you'd be hard pressed to find someone with more nuanced takes on politics, tech, and crypto. His very short and tumultuous tenure as the finance minister of Greece's Coalition of the Radical Left government (SYRIZA) was also between less-than-stellar and totally catastrophic, which culminated with being fired from his position. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Cabinet_of_Alexis_Tsipras https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Cabinet_of_Alexis_Tsipra... Appeals to authority aside, in this case "nuanced" doesn't exactly refer to insightfulness. It doesn't surprise me that he's pivoting to crypto, as his short-lived political career was saturated with self-promotion schemes.
- turtledove 5y ago> I fail to see how one can genuinely cherish freedom and tolerate capitalism. Quote of the article, imo. The framing of these questions is interesting in their bias, but the answers do a great job navigating them.
- pDiddlyDoRight 5y agoWhen he said the words "liberal techno-communism" in seriousness, as something NFTs could help? He lost me. I sincerely doubt he's talking about a moneyless, classless, stateless society - what Communism is. After all, there's (crypto)currencies and private (as opposed to personal) ownership rights. Sprinkle in some representative Democratic State that can build structures to isolate itself from the will of the people? And that's Liberalism, the thing Communists rebel against, critiquing to this day. Platonically-Synthesizing these two opposites would prove challenging without undermining the premise of one or both halves. While such a "Left" exists in more authoritarian contexts of international relations? They serve as examples of the failure of the previous "synthesis". Down here in the neighborhoods where life happens? Leftist action is often about showing each other that we're all we need. Why pay for a plow to scrape the apartment building's lot when we can do it? Why submit to draconian rent hikes from Slumlords when we can form a Tenant's Union? Why let people go hungry when we can throw in on a professional kitchen and the food we need to held our neighbors? There's plenty of work to do, even when there's no money. So damn the cash, full speed ahead! We have a better world to build. State be damned. Needless Social hierarchy be damned. Just do the things your neighbors need. And never act alone. Learn from Rojava. Learn from the Zapatistas. Learn from Cospaia. We don't need some magical thinking about how the Masters' Tools will dismantle the Masters' palace in the hands of some "great man". That same great man who, inevitably seeks - or is forced by necessity - to rise to dictatorship to keep the State together and potentially in line. And somehow, this whole State apparatus is supposed to wither away on its own? When it is our crutch against "external threats" and the State's own internal corruption? Color me skeptical.
- buddha420 5y agoYou can use NFT's as decentralized permission tokens for access to decentralized databases. Abstract all the world's resources and how they're converted between each other into one big linked excel table. Everyone wants to know how resources are moving around, but nobody can be trusted to host "the diagram of everything". Different parts of the excel table correspond to different resources in different places, and have notions of data sovereignty over their resources in the table, with areas of joined access between separate entities along boundaries where they exchange resources. Obviously you'd use something like soulbound NFT's, so its harder for people to sell off write permissions. But you could use all sorts of Sybil protection techniques. It seems like one possible starting point for a decentralized communism.
- lettergram 5y agoImagine when they can limit the trade of crypto to people who have certain ideas. Or limit the percentage of your wealth you can spend on certain items (games, movies, ... food). Many experts, including in this article, are describing that future. It’s why crypto and what not are a highly risky long-terms solution. If it can be abused, it will by a political actor at some point.
- hotpotamus 5y agoI've heard a landlord justify rent increases because the tenants were just going to spend the money on tattoos anyway. Seems like the present.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoThat’s the whole idea behind tax cuts and increasing income share for rich people and stagnating wages for everybody else. Only rich people can use money in a productive way. Giving it to the rest is just wasted.
- AlexandrB 5y agoI'm assuming this is a positive statement, not a normative one. I love how this undermines the basic functioning of the market via supply/demand. If demand is artificially restricted by taking money out of the pockets of consumers, how is "what to produce" decided? I think increasingly that decision is pseudo-centralized in VCs and other large investors who decide what businesses to fund.
- FredPret 5y agoLong term the system still works - if those VCs et al back bad ideas, they lose their money
- spaetzleesser 5y agoEven if the VCs lose money that money still mostly circulates among the wealthy and well connected.
- golemotron 5y agoIt's kind of amazing that, in the interview, everyone is an idiot except him.
- thematrixturtle 5y agoI'm genuinely not sure what you're trying to say by that, since that's not at all the vibe I get from Yanis. Or are you saying that since Yanis is deeply skeptical of crypto, this implies he thinks everybody in the space is "an idiot", and hence you think he's actually the idiot here?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dmitriid 5y ago> the idea that people must now play like robots to earn a living so as to be human in their spare time is, indeed, the apotheosis of misanthropy This quote is amazing, and describes most of crypto.
- pessimizer 5y agoVery much in the same spirit as yesterday's "Books Become Games" post: https://justinehsmith.substack.com/p/books-become-games https://justinehsmith.substack.com/p/books-become-games
- CryptoPunk 5y agoThe choice is not between some communist utopia that Varoufakis alludes to, and people grinding in virtual worlds to make a living. The choice is between a family in the Philippines facing severe hunger during the lockdown, and that family being able to sell virtual goods to wealthier people in the developed world, to put food on the table. More generally, allowing web users to assume genuine ownership - secured by provable scarcity and public key cryptography - over virtual goods, means the profit that the internet generates will not be monopolized by a few internet giants. Consider, the Ethereum Name Service airdrop rewarded over 100,000 accounts with its ENS tokens. This is a degree of diffusion in the distribution of ownership over critical protocols that was totally impossible before blockchain-based assets and networks.
- netsharc 5y ago> More generally, allowing web users to assume genuine ownership - secured by provable scarcity and public key cryptography - over virtual goods, means the profit that the internet generates will not be monopolized by a few internet giants. Arguably YouTube has enabled thousands of new entertainers, making many of them (but well, a small percentage of all) filthy rich and/or famous, by making entertainment products. Funnily, OnlyFans also fits in the category.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoYou don't own anything in YouTube. YouTube can always deplatform you.
- epolanski 5y agoMaybe slightly out of topic, but I'm incredibly impressed by the intelligence of this man, and how easily he can communicate on complex topics in such a simple language even a teenager without most of the context could grasp.
- 0des 5y agoIs it intelligence or is it also empathy?
- epolanski 5y agoEmotional intelligence?
- skc 5y agoHe is indeed brilliant, but simple language? I found myself opening a tab to a thesaurus multiple times reading this. :)
- dopidopHN 5y agoI speak a Roman language, Lot of your fancy words in English come from Roman roots. And we have the same effect with greek roots in our own language. Several times I rolled my eye at Yanis picks of words. “How greek of you sir.” I actually enjoy that.
- CryptoPunk 5y ago[flagged]
- breakfastduck 5y ago
- CryptoPunk 5y ago[flagged]
- breakfastduck 5y ago[flagged]
- CryptoPunk 5y ago
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> Tolerate the right of people to sell their labor for wages? Tolerate the right of people to offer wages for other people's labor? No, tolerate a system that works as hard as possible to ensure that selling one's labor for wages is the only option, rather than a right. Tolerate a system in which increases in productivity accrue benefits mostly to capital rather than society as a whole. Tolerate a system in which profit is preferentially distributed to the capital that partially enabled it rather than the labor that also enabled it. It's all very well to point to some historical societies in which a person was not even free to sell their own labor. But to insist that this is the yardstick by which we measure our own society is devastatingly narrow-minded.
- CryptoPunk 5y ago>>No, tolerate a system that works as hard as possible to ensure that selling one's labor for wages is the only option, rather than a right So you propose the government provide an alternative, by doing what I described, which is effectively to steal from the Ant to give to the Grasshopper, i.e. tax the more productive to provide resources to the less productive. And the absence of this non-consensual redistribution is what you and Varoufakis absurdly enough, find intolerant to those who value freedom. Marxism is deliberately obfuscated, to hide what it really advocates. >>Tolerate a system in which increases in productivity accrue benefits mostly to capital rather than society as a whole. Tolerate a system in which profit is preferentially distributed to the capital that partially enabled it rather than the labor that also enabled it. Increases in productivity accrue benefits to society at large right now. In the US, there was a small increase in capital's share of national income, but labor's share remains significant: https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/sources-of-real-wage-stagnation/ https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/sources-of-real-wage-stag... In those regions which witnessed significant productivity growth, wages increased substantially: https://www.csmonitor.com/World/2016/0207/Progress-in-the-global-war-on-poverty https://www.csmonitor.com/World/2016/0207/Progress-in-the-gl...
- ykevinator2 5y ago
- tphyahoo2 5y agoYanis: "The Gold Standard is, indeed, a great source of insight into how dangerously primitive Bitcoin maximalist thinking is. Suppose Bitcoin were to take over from fiat currencies. What would banks do? They would lend in Bitcoin, of course. This means that overdraft facilities would emerge allowing lenders to buy goods and services with Bitcoins that do not yet exist. What would governments do? At moments of stress, they would have to issue units of account linked to Bitcoin (as they did under the Gold Exchange Standard during the interwar period)." The reason governments could do this with gold is that gold is easy to counterfeit, hard to store securely, and expensive to transact with at a distance. So it makes sense to keep it all in a giant vault (a bank, or central bank) and trust the vaultkeeper to issue ious and transact in those. But bitcoin does not suffer from these defects. I don't think Yanis understands this. https://nassimtaleb.org/2016/09/intellectual-yet-idiot/ https://nassimtaleb.org/2016/09/intellectual-yet-idiot/
- chalst 5y agoSince you cite N N Taleb, you might be interested in his assessment of Bitcoin: > its current version, in spite of the hype, bitcoin failed to satisfy the notion of "currency without govern- ment" (it proved to not even be a currency at all), can be neither a short nor long term store of value (its expected value is no higher than 0), cannot operate as a reliable inflation hedge, and, worst of all, does not constitute, not even remotely, a safe haven for one’s investments, a shield against government tyranny, or a tail protection vehicle for catastrophic episodes. https://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/BTC-QF.pdf https://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/BTC-QF.pdf
- llamaimperative 5y agoNo, the reason governments can do this is because people trust their IOUs. That’s why they can do the same thing with or without any underlying asset with any characteristics. The characteristics of the underlying asset would probably modulate the degree of trust people can put in a government’s IOUs, but considering e.g. the extent of people’s trust in the US (with no underlying), I think it’s fair to say if Bitcoin became this currency, governments would have no problem issuing IOUs for it that people would trust.
- Fargoan 5y agoGovernments could issue currencies on a layer 2 that settles on the Bitcoin chain.
- hanniabu 5y agoBitcoin L2 is centralized b/c Bitcoin doesn't have base layer smart contracts (and no, simple scripts are not smart contracts)
- TimJRobinson 5y agoLightning is not centralized, but tends towards centralization because of routing issues. But they're all going to settle to Ethereum anyway. It's already more decentralized and secure than Bitcoin and can support any smart contracts they need.
- nullc 5y agoThis is just nonsense.
- atmosx 5y ago...and why would anyone do that?
- TimJRobinson 5y agoBecause it's a credibly neutral financial layer that countries can use to transfer value and we can have a global financial system that no one controls. It's amazing how few people realize the massive wealth growth this would cause. The internet did this with free flow of information, blockchains can do it with the free flow of capital to wherever to makes most sense.
- codeflo 5y agoI've seen interviews with Varoufakis before, there are several on YouTube. I find him very hard two bear for two (unrelated?) reasons. First of all, I have the impression that he's incredibly vain. Maybe that's not entirely his fault, because parts of the left in Europe celebrate him like a rock star. But when he retells the story of how he negotiated with other leaders of the EU about the Greek debt crisis, the framing is always that he was the only wise person in a room full of idiots, and they wouldn't agree to the rational course of action because they were intimidated by his superior intelligence. This is of course just my observation, and I don't have a good source ready, so I'm curious if others have the same impression. Second, although he downplays it somewhat when asked directly, he is a full-on radical marxist. This includes the view that anytime someone makes any money anywhere whatsoever, that can only mean somebody else is being exploited. I don't know how marxists square their conviction that no trade is ever beneficial to both sides with the reality that nobody is held at gunpoint to make those trades, but here's an example quote from the interview: > So, when a recession hits, and the central bank decides to stimulate the economy, the central bank lowers the interest rate of the overdraft it grants commercial bankers – who then exploit this to profit from arbitrage (by lending the money on to customers at a higher interest rate). I find this incredibly disingenuous because as an economist, he knows better. Lending is a service that banks provide that many (arguably perhaps too many) people choose to make use of. And Varoufakis is fully aware of the difference between risk-free and risk-adjusted interest rates. But of course, "banks bad", that's what his audience wants to hear. I think there, he agrees with the crypto people to a much larger extend than he would admit. TL;DR: I think Varoufakis is overrated, although I somewhat agree with him on crypto.
- hkt 5y agoMarxist exploitation occurs in the labour relation - it isn't really about consumers. The thing he was referring to was the price mechanism, for which Marxists have entertained quite a few alternatives based on the use value, labour costs to produce (labour value) etc. Re CBDC, he's referring to current accounts. There is a big debate at the Bank of England about how to offer these accounts via intermediaries, the idea being that they will add value in some way. The idea of the bank offering basic (read: deliberately rubbish) accounts vs not offering then at all is a key part of that debate. Underwriting for loans is different, but it is a fair thing to say that most banks don't bother investing in SMEs or the real economy more broadly. The fact is, banks lend to virtually risk free borrowers in the form of mortgages - the risks being mitigated by persistent property price inflation. As such, why charge above the base rate? It doesn't seem as though he is advocating replacing the lending function of banks, though in the broad sense I'd guess he would prefer savings and loan cooperatives like building societies and credit unions.
- jesprenj 5y agoCrypto means cryptography!
- catlifeonmars 5y agoThank you! I always click on the HN articles with “crypto” in the title thinking I’m about to read about information manipulation using modular arithmetic and instead…
- tasuki 5y agoReally, you thought a post titled "Crypto, the Left and Technofeudalism" would be about information manipulation using modular arithmetic? It was an interesting interview, Yanis Varoufakis is quite thoughtful.
- catlifeonmars 5y agoOne can always hope…
- dundarious 5y agoAt this point it's a lost cause. Recently, I tried to search for details regarding a new release of the go x/crypto package, and unfortunately all the results were related to cryptocurrencies, etc. Somewhat similarly, I like to use quotation as the noun, and quote as the verb and never the noun, but it's a totally lost cause, not even worth mentally noting when others use quote as the noun, never mind "correcting" them. Measured by usage, the consensus has shifted.
- mchaver 5y agoLanguage changes whether we like it or not. Before cryptocurrencies, "crypto" meant cryptography, but with mainstream adoption of cryptocurrencies, the popular meaning of "crypto" has shifted to cryptocurrencies. If cryptocurrencies fall out of use maybe it will shift back.
- rektide 5y ago
- atmosx 5y ago> (Nb. We can already see how DAOs are being usurped by regressives and real estate moguls in the United States.) What is V. referring to?
- Proven 5y ago
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoI feel Yanis is speaking to a previous era which is now ending. He says money-printing and QE will continue? He says Tech will rule everything? That was believable a year ago. But today, we have for the first time seen enough inflation from all that QE for it to now be a mainstream political issue (and not just something ranted about on RT). We have central banks raising rates for the first time in decades. We have Tech stocks now doing far worse than they were just a year ago. And -- Yanis does touch on this -- we have also seen China systematically destroy its Tech industry in favor of more materially-productive enterprises. So -- maybe it's just a short-term hiccup, but -- my feeling is that the winds are now blowing differently. More towards fiscal policy and away from monetary (i.e., government spending), more towards industrial policy, and more towards old 20th century type enterprises. I could be wrong though.
- TimJRobinson 5y agoRay Dalios new book "Changing World Order" gives a good overview of how this crazy money printing / QE is the end game of a governments monetary policy before their demise. People think it can keep going forever before it collapses. Most people don't realize because the last time this happened was before our lifetimes.
- antifa 5y ago> we have also seen China systematically destroy its Tech industry in favor of more materially-productive enterprises. Could you elaborate more on China destroying it's tech industry? My understanding would suggest it's better phrased as the US is destroying it's tech industry by doubling-down on unproductive enterprises. Too much of our tech industry is focused on building walled gardens and inventing new ways to be a middle-man or nickel and dime people. China is actually taking a strong stance against the current wild west of getting children addicted to gambling with microtransactions.
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoI meant "Tech" with a capital T -- analogues of Facebook, Netflix, and so on -- not real physical competencies like being able to fab a chip or make a high-temperature jet turbine. So I think we're in agreement. For a reference, here's a Bloomberg article: https://archive.ph/dyhKM https://archive.ph/dyhKM
- emsign 5y agoLiving offline as much as possible as a declaration of independance. It's a better living anyway.
- blurbleblurble 5y agoI've always found it ironic that the Bitcoin maximalists are themselves advocating for the freedom to print money. A money system where currencies are printable by anyone and where they compete with each other on open markets looks a lot like a decentralized, libertarian version of MMT.
- TimJRobinson 5y ago> I've always found it ironic that the Bitcoin maximalists are themselves advocating for the freedom to print money. What are you talking about? Bitcoin Maximalism is about no one having the ability to control the money supply.
- blurbleblurble 5y agoLet me articulate cause I hear you in that the most hard core Bitcoin maximalists abhor all shitcoins and would probably be okay with a kind of mandate that Bitcoin and only Bitcoin be legally considered currency. My comment is more about people who say "MMT is bad, here is a list of cryptocurrencies that I consider to be real money." My point is that advocating for the collective freedom to print/burn digital money that competes with government issued money is very similar to MMT in a key way. In my mind MMT is basically the idea that making modifications to money supplies (including both inflating and deflating them) is an appropriate way of getting beneficial civic, geopolitical and socioeconomic change. But of course most MMT assumes centralized and coordinated changes and relies on a premise that the administrators of those changes are trustworthy. By advocating for the freedom of anybody to create a new currency for freedom of choice over what currencies they use, the situation that emerges is effectively a kind of decentralized MMT, where the entirety of the money supply is being modified collectively by peoples' choices, according to their needs and values. A lot of cryptocurrency people seem to have this imaginary ideal scenario where at some point everything will "switch over" to just a handful of the thousands of existing cryptocurrency/blockchain projects and all of the others will just magically die out... but as long as people advocate for the collective freedom to be able to create and use cryptocurrencies it's gonna effectively be a situation where every single project with a token is literally printing/burning/modifying money and stuff that acts like money, based on their needs and governance structures. And that includes Bitcoin miners. If Bitcoin can be called money they're printing money.