7 ms·
It’s also inaccurate to call this language “inclusive.” In reality, you’re excluding most Americans who aren’t among the handful of mostly affluent, white, coll
by rayiner 5y ago
It’s also inaccurate to call this language “inclusive.” In reality, you’re excluding most Americans who aren’t among the handful of mostly affluent, white, college educated people who talk like this. My Bangladeshi immigrant mom would have no idea what to do if a warning popped up telling her that she should use a different word than “mother.”
- raxxorraxor 5y agoIt isn't colleges that advertise this exclusively, it is also corporate consulting like McKinsey. Know them? Allegedly the Robin Hood of the poor and disenfranchised. The author of the article still sees it as a necessity. They cannot leave people talking like they want to.
- evocatus 5y agoHear hear. Latinx, Filipinx - how dare the whites invent terminology to refer to disadvantaged minorities, using incorrect grammatical constructions or letters not even in the language of the people you refer to. This is white cultural imperialism, full stop. Right or left, I don't care where it comes from - I know it when I smell it.
- rayiner 5y agoThis is an inherent feature of the emerging system where cultural norms flow top-down from college educated professionals (who are far whiter than the population as a whole). That’ll be true even on matters relating to minorities, because it’ll be college educated white people empowered to decide which non-white people get a platform.
- dijonman2 5y ago
- rayiner 5y agoProgressivism is a manifestation of cultural principles that are closely associated with, and disproportionately manifested among, people of white European descent. There are liberals in every country, but the emphasis on say and sexual self expression and self determination is pretty distinct to countries founded by white Europeans. It’s similar, in that regard, to small government conservatism. There are conservatives everywhere. But the particular antagonism to government authority is uniquely a product of certain white European cultures.
- rendall 5y ago> cultural norms flow top-down from college educated professionals It doesn't flow anywhere except to other college educated professionals. These people attempt to tell rural, or the working-class, or immigrants what to say and how to behave, who then turn around and do something else like elect Trump.
- tomp 5y agoThis has nothing to do with “white” and everything to do with regressive left. Here is Kamala Harris, an Indian-Black American, pushing “Latinx”: https://mobile.twitter.com/kamalaharris/status/1290733001320652801?lang=en https://mobile.twitter.com/kamalaharris/status/1290733001320...
- rayiner 5y agoYou can’t overlook the role that white progressives play in selectively amplifying minority voices. I can’t get on CNN to give the “Bangladeshi guy take” on rising crime by saying stuff most Bangladeshi people agree with. I have to provide a Bangladeshi perspective that is appealing to the white progressives that make the decisions at CNN. There’s a deep synergy here that exploits the fact that most Americans have limited insight into what minorities think, but generally want to be supportive. White progressives can amplify their apparent mandate by selectively platforming progressive minorities to speak on behalf of those groups. Those progressive minorities, meanwhile, can wield the outsize influence of progressive whites over the media and institutions against other members of their own group. That’s how “Latinx” happens. Progressive Latinos by themselves have no power to influence what the general public calls Latinos. But if they get Elizabeth Warren to say it, they can turn it from a “progressive Latino” issue into a “Latino” issue and lots of well meaning people will go along to be supportive of Latinos. Kamala Harris is a great example. She was polling in the single digits among Black people (https://www.politico.com/news/2019/12/04/kamala-harris-black-voters-2020-075651 https://www.politico.com/news/2019/12/04/kamala-harris-black...). And I’ll tell you that most desis are closer to Tulsi Gabbard than Harris. Including the Russia stuff—given India’s long-standing affinity with Russia. She’s not Vice President because she’s the one people in those groups would pick. She’s Vice President because of all the white Act Blue donors I know who are thrilled to have a Black-Indian Vice President who just happens to think the way they do.
- screye 5y agoDesi here, like Tulsi more than Kamala. I'd say Kamala is more disliked than the average white person too, because she panders so incompetently. I have not heard great things about Pramila Jayapal either.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rmbyrro 5y agoThese people remind me of crusaders a thousand years ago, fighting the "infidels" all over. In fact, the whole body of thought governing them reminds me too much of the Latin Church. I have no words to express how I detest the kind of thinking behind them.
- donkeybeer 5y agoHow many people have these people killed and how many wars have they started in the name of inclusivity?
- season2episode3 5y agoIt's hard to tell tone from text, but I'm going to assume you're not being facetious here... I'm pretty sure the answer is 0.
- rmbyrro 5y agoThey wage numerous wars, but the playing field is not full of swords and shields, but reputation destruction, intimidation, doxing, canceling, etc. The digital and public life is so important for many people today that, if you eliminate them there, it's like killing a good chunk of their lives. These people wage crusades against individual reputations and public/digital lives. Just because they think differently.
- shadowgovt 5y agoSo like killing except for all the "not killing." So not like killing at all. It is, however, a bit like building an orthodoxy. Which the group formerly in position to build orthodoxy is surprised to learn is an uncomfortable process.
- rmbyrro 5y agoMy reading is the only thing preventing a considerable portion of them from killing is law enforcement, and the fact that most societies has evolved past supporting violence. You have to observe that deadly violence was normalized in the past. It was even entertainment in Rome. Hence, the Colloseum. Externally, it's evolved, but internally the ideolog is quite similar. Some of the similarities are: - divides men and women - interferes and intends to control families - demonizes people that are useful to society and accumulate wealth
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dsco 5y agoWhy would you use the word filipinx when there’s already the gender neutral word Filipino? Also doesn’t filipinx exclude Filipinos outside of the American diaspora? Then what do you call Filipinos outside of that geographical area? See, you’re digging your own semantic hole with all this political correctness.