21 ms·
It is immoral to use candidate answers in your product, assuming you don’t hire them. If you do hire them then I guess it becomes fine, but otherwise definitel
by dijit 5y ago
It is immoral to use candidate answers in your product, assuming you don’t hire them.
If you do hire them then I guess it becomes fine, but otherwise definitely immoral.
The problem is that we’re fleshy meatbags and easily influenced. It’s possible we internalise answers to interview questions and then “spontaneously” come up with them later, without _knowingly_ stealing the idea.
This happens sometimes in comedy, and the comedian apologises. You can usually tell the difference in comedy between plagiarism and accidental theft because the joke is delivered much differently but has the same core. It would be harder with interview answers.
- biztos 5y ago> If you do hire them then I guess it becomes fine Not that anything will stop companies from doing this, and not that I think it ever really happens, but for it to be morally OK I think you’d have to both get their permission and compensate them fairly. Before I work for you, my ideas are mine even if I write them on your whiteboard.
- dijit 5y agoSure, but if I ask you an interview question and your answer is good enough that I want to use it: you'll probably be the one implementing the solution. Why would I trust the answer more than the person?
- pbhjpbhj 5y ago>Why would I trust the answer more than the person? // Why wouldn't you? The truth of statements is not a function of the people making them (though of course that can often be a strong indicator of truth).
- pdpi 5y agoIf you’re hiring, and your candidate produces a solution to a real problem, and your interviewers actually want to use their solution, that person is getting an offer unless they were absolutely obnoxious and terrible to work with. Failure to do so is just bad recruitment. Or, put differently: if I’m the candidate and they end up “stealing” my solution, that’s a small price to pay to avoid working in what is likely a terrible environment.
- foobiekr 5y agoThat assumes the interviewer is ethical. In my experience, most people in SW do not have a strong cultural basis for ethical behavior of this sort.