6 ms·
Forgetting a Child in a Car Is a Horrifying Mistake. Is It a Crime? (2009)
- formerkrogemp 5y agoIt can be a crime. Neglect is not fun.
- jrwoodruff 5y agoCan be. But in the scenario described at the beginning of this article, what is the point of punishment here. Does this person need reformed? Can society dole out any more retribution/revenge/punishment than he's already experiencing? Willful neglect is awful, a crime, and should be punished. In some cases it's probably necessary for a court to determine if the neglect was willful or not. But I simply can't imagine the lifelong self-inflicted torment a parent would experience in a situation like the one described. Prison or death would be a respite I think.
- browningstreet 5y agoHumans are like the glitchiest consumer products. Bugs galore.
- maxwell 5y agoWhat object or entity has a higher feature-to-defect ratio than a human being?
- browningstreet 5y agoWe could think of it like that, but it seems like we're constantly surprised when humans can't run without crashing. Crashing is often non-recoverable, and not really built into the runbook. Some support teams do triage pretty well, but most... not so much. The tickets build up, and often just get flushed. Our monitoring infrastructure is built on the assumption of uptime. We ignore the technical debt.
- maxwell 5y agoIf uptime is the goal, individual humans are impressive compared to almost all human technology. The Centennial Light has now been running mostly continuously since 1901, while the oldest living human was born in 1904. The bulb hasn't burned out, but has been shut off briefly a few times, which seems comparable to one's heart stopping but being resuscitated. I'm not aware of any single "technology," in the broadest sense, operating for a longer continuous period of time.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andybak 5y agoI know we're not supposed to ask this on HN - but did you read the article? It's precisely examining the topic where most people's immediate response would be to want to punish the person who caused this - but in showing us the tragic human stories involved raises enough doubts to convince me it's an issue that needs a very careful weighing up. The only reason I wanted to know if you're engaging with the article rather than the headline is that you haven't acknowledged the issues raised by the writer - which struck me as odd in this context.
- formerkrogemp 5y agoOh, I'm sorry if I came across that way. I do agree that our first impulse should be to help rather than harm, and that reality is almost always rather complex. I meant that as a comment upon people calling child protective services and the worry of such an occurrence influencing people's behavior. Sometimes, reasonable behavior can be misconstrued and lead to criminal consequences. I didn't mean to dismiss the issue out of hand.
- bell-cot 5y agoNeglect is an ongoing pattern of behavior, by someone who is otherwise mentally competent. One-off screw-ups, no matter the outcome, are not "neglect". (Though very similar English words and phrases are often used to describe both a one-off screw-up and actual child neglect.)
- gameswithgo 5y agoWhen our kids were little it was something I worried about a lot because I can absolutely imagine myself doing it. I would never support punishing a parent further because of an accident. There but for random chance goes any of us. (or at least many)
- flyinglizard 5y agoWhen restrained, I give my kid my wallet or car keys (be careful with him locking himself with the fob).
- quietbritishjim 5y agoThe problem is, if you forget your them in the way that happened in the article, you would forget to give them the keys too. Or do you mean you give them the keys for the whole car journey? That's got to depend on the age of the kid surely?
- flyinglizard 5y agoThe entire journey. You don’t need to give them the keys really, just to toss them near their car seat.
- rootusrootus 5y agoI'd suggest just taking off your left shoe and tossing it in the back seat. Unless you drive a manual. Most people don't, sadly, so it's a workable solution.
- encryptluks2 5y agoI'm surprised smart cars haven't built in a feature yet to help prevent this.
- malsanton 5y agoI drove a rental recently that had a “check back seat” message and a chime when you turned off the car and it detected something in the back seat. I seemed to quickly learn to ignore the chime as it becomes the noise the car makes every time you turn it off. I would be surprised if they had any effect.
- SkyPuncher 5y agoThey do! My car has a "rear occupant alert" system. The problem seems to be that it struggles to differentiate between junk in the trunk and a living thing. Unfortunately, that makes it relatively useless since it's almost always beeping at us.
- XCSme 5y agoTeslas do have a "dog mode". I don't think they should have a "child mode", as that would imply leaving your child alone in the care is fine. Not sure how easy it is to detect if you leave a child alone in the care, and for how long. What if you just go get something from the trunk, or if you forgot something in your home?
- DantesKite 5y agoI wonder how many people have used Tesla’s dog mode for their children.
- tlb 5y agoI turned it on once for my teenage daughter in a parking lot on a warm day and she was mightily offended. Teslas now have "camp mode" which also keeps the AC on.
- wongarsu 5y ago> What if you just go get something from the trunk, or if you forgot something in your home? To prevent the death of a child it would be sufficient to prevent the car from getting too hot. If you have a reliable way to detect the presence of a living being in the car, the car could just decide to activate the AC once a temperature threshold is met.
- sharkweek 5y agoUgh I remember reading this back when it published (think it won the Pulitzer that year) and now that I have kids I probably think about it every time I’m getting out of the car. “Are my kids back there?” Maybe that’s a good thing. I can’t even fathom the horror in that moment recognizing what has happened, when it really sets in before the brain kicks into trauma mode. Hard for me to imagine prison doing any good in these cases, but also understand the risk of neglect or even malice disguised as forgetfulness being unpunished. Tough one.
- happytoexplain 5y agoAgree - however: >malice disguised as forgetfulness being unpunished This is kind of a separate issue. If it was malice and proven in court, it will be punished. If it was malice but couldn't be proven in court, it won't be punished. That's true for anything. We can't entertain the thought of punishment "just in case" it was malice.
- listless 5y agoBeing drug through the court is a horrific and traumatic ordeal. Imagine facing that on top of losing your child and being responsible for it.
- TimPC 5y agoI think the risk of malice is extremely low. I have trouble imagining someone so selfish that they'd doom their child to this kind of horrible painful death because they were mad at them or wanted to get rid of them. Even if a parent is so horrible that they want to kill their child, few are so sinister as to do it in such a torturous way.
- rendall 5y ago> I think the risk of malice is extremely low. You could be right > I have trouble imagining someone so selfish... Alas, that's not an argument.
- ErikVandeWater 5y ago
- Drunk_Engineer 5y agoThe real crime is that "safety" regulators still require a child be kept in the back seat. It is an outdated regulation that makes no sense, unless your car is more than 10 years old.
- jxramos 5y agoWhat do the new cars offer exactly? I always understood it as to shield a child from the power of the airbags that are present in the front seat. Is there some mechanism that's changed for that seating with respect to air bag deployment?
- Drunk_Engineer 5y agoThere is a weight sensor built into the front passenger seat.
- bombcar 5y agoI assume it's because modern cars have weight sensors for the airbags, but they don't always work.
- a4isms 5y agoSome vehicles have a specific method of disabling the passenger seat air bag. Outside of the desire to place a baby seat there, some passengers may have a medical condition such that their risk of death is higher if the airbag deploys than if it doesn't. In most jurisdictions, it is still illegal to put a baby or very small child in the passenger seat. I can't speak for anyone else, but in my own case, I think the risk of forgetting to turn it off when a child is riding in the front seat is going to be much higher than the risk of forgetting my child in the rear seat. That's really the calculus: How is it that we think we could forget that our child is in the back seat, but remember to disengage the air bag every time we put their seat in the front?
- michaelmior 5y agoMy understanding is that the concern is that the passenger airbag can do serious damage to a child sitting in the front. You seem to be suggesting this is no longer the case. What has changed that now makes this safe?.
- aeharding 5y agoHow about analyzing the series of dangerous conditions that failed leading to a child dying in a car? For example, why have we built a car dependent society where you need to put a child in a car to do virtually anything? Blaming the last failure in a chain of failures -- the drunk driver, the tired parent, the 737 pilot --- prevents prevention. There Are No Accidents. https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/There-Are-No-Accidents/Jessie-Singer/9781982129668 https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/There-Are-No-Accident...
- kfarr 5y agoBingo. The fact that performing routine errands such as food shopping requires a multi ton machine accompanying each human indicates the contributing failures here started long before the specific incidents. Another good book on the topic is Normal Accidents by Charles Perrow.
- trgn 5y agoSad this is getting downvoted hard. Probably because it feels gauche to bring this up in context of this article. Sort of every time a child accidentally gets shot, you cannot bring up the fetishization of guns as the underlying condition. Anyway, you have my upvote. The accidental killing of children with our cars (which forgetting them in the backseat is only a minuscule portion of) is purely 100% because the public realm we've built is unaccessible without cars. Revealing too that the majority of "fixes" to this problem are additional technological layers (cars with cooling mechanisms! occupant alert system! mnemotechnic devices! better code enforcement!), rather than supporting the removal of misapplied technology in the first place.
- hosh 5y agoI’m a parent of a toddler. Reading this article hit me hard. I could not stop imagining this happening to my child. Stories like this used to be tragic, but now it feels personally tragic. At the same time, I agree with this. I’ve been thinking a lot about the structural ills of modernity for years. So while others have mentioned this might be gauche, I think these are exactly what we should be discussing as a society. It isn’t just building a society where we are so car dependent. We have also lost the social net of extended families, village and communities. Where were the grandparents and extended families that could watch a kid so that they don’t have to go to daycare? Why are we so driven for material success that we overwork and juggle the care of children with other things? When that toddler turns to a teen, how has our world of “share this” and “retweets” that changed our sense of truths affect that teen? Gen-Z are already struggling to make sense of this.
- DantesKite 5y agoIt almost seems this is common enough that eventually cars sill have a feature to prevent heat death. I think of Tesla’s dog mode but for humans. Caveats: • Not saying parents have no responsibility • Not saying auto makers have sole responsibility • I understand the “slippery slope” argument that this will lead to parents leaving their children on cars • This is just an extrapolation into the far future, like 100 years or so, when we have metals far stronger than steel protecting your car door and sentient robots.
- reaperducer 5y agoIf you listen to the police scanner in towns with casinos (or even just video poker machines in convenience stores), you'll quickly learn that people lock their kids in cars all the time so they can get in a few minutes of "gaming," which too often turns into many many hours with the child locked in the car alone. And yes, often they die. I worry that if "dog mode" as it is becomes widespread, it will give the negligent parents an excuse and means to feed their addictions. I'd be happier if dog mode automatically called 911 after xx minutes of a living creature being left in the car.
- frenchy 5y agoTrying to play devil's advocate, I thought "What about if someone ends up homeless, sleeping in their car, and dog mode calls the cops on them?" Maybe that would actually be a good thing, if we also provided them with actual housing.
- a4isms 5y agoEvery safety feature is a slippery slope to sloppy drivers making mistakes. You can make the same arguments about disc brakes, anti-lock brakes, systems that mitigate crossing the center line or running off the road, systems that attempt to bring the car to a stop when a cyclist, pedestrian, or large animal steps in front of the car... Volvo once had a "pedestrian air bag" that deployed on the front hood if the car detected what appeared to be a pedestrian being struck. Maybe that was a slippery slope to reenacting "Death Race 2000!" I kid, of course. All safety systems lull people into some false sense of security. The question is not whether that happens, but whether the overall result is more or less safety. In general, we are statistically safer with these systems, even if some people become complacent.
- Johnny555 5y agoThere are lots of mnemonics people use to remember that their kid is in the back, like putting their briefcase/backpack next to the child, clipping the keyless entry keys to the car seat, running a bright cord from the carseat to the front, etc. But most of the times these accidents happen, it's due to a change of routine - father taking the kid to daycare instead of mom, an emergency phone call on the way to work causing distraction, etc. It's times when people skip the routine, and make a mistake. So in the end, criminal punishment ends up punishing people for being human.
- Xeoncross 5y agoThis reminds me of firing the employee that accidentally causes an outage or data loss. Sure, the person could have been malicious, but the majority (all?) of the stories I've been involved with are normal people trying to do their best. Their mistake is burned into their mind. They feel like they let everyone down. Of anyone, it seems they are now the least likely to ever be careless again.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoRecently, I was asked if I was going to fire an employee who made a mistake that cost the company $600,000. No, I replied, I just spent $600,000 training him. Why would I want somebody to hire his experience? Thomas J. Watson
- 1970-01-01 5y agoAwful title. Yes, it is a crime, and the law varies by state: https://www.kidsandcars.org/resources/state-laws/ https://www.kidsandcars.org/resources/state-laws/
- rootusrootus 5y agoIt is illegal in some states to intentionally leave a young child in the car. That is not what the criminality discussion is about.
- 1970-01-01 5y agoSo it's just about Nevada and Texas? These are the only states where unintentionally leaving a child in the vehicle is allowed.
- rootusrootus 5y agoYou're saying they actually have a law on the books saying it's okay to do it accidentally? Why would someone write a law to say an accident is an accident?
- 1970-01-01 5y ago>You're saying they actually have a law on the books saying it's okay to do it accidentally? Don't take my word, here they are: Nevada: A parent, legal guardian or other person responsible for a child who is 7 years of age or younger shall not knowingly and intentionally leave that child in a motor vehicle if: Texas: A person commits an offense if he intentionally or knowingly leaves a child in a motor vehicle for longer than five minutes
- yohannparis 5y agoThis is, in my opinion, a product of personal vehicle dependant society. I am lucky enough to not dependend on a car for my everyday activity, and only using my car a couple of times a week. I can totally understand people being in the habit of getting in and out of their vehicle without checking the rear seat. Any child death is a tragedy, and a loss for the whole community.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> This is, in my opinion, a product of personal vehicle dependant society. Because no children would ever die in an accident involving public transportation? We could just call it an accident and not try to dig too deeply into societal problems to explain it. A little perspective: 3.6M babies/year are born in the US every year. 15-20 accidents like this occur each year. Tragic, yes, but it's not even remotely close to a trend that needs some underlying explanation.
- frenchy 5y ago> Because no children would ever die in an accident involving public transportation? I apologise for an appeal to "common sense" since I really don't have any data, but it seems sort of obvious that it would be safer for two reasons: 1. There's almost always other people there, so someone is likely to warn you that you abandoned your kid. 2. Your kid is there with you, so it's not like you have to remember them. You're trying to make the argument that "a few kids being locked in cars every year isn't that significant in the larger picture". That's a different argument than "the reason kids are locked in cars is because people are driving in cars".
- rootusrootus 5y agoI'm saying that it's a stretch to assume that kids dying in personal transportation is a problem that would be effectively solved by moving away from personal transportation, unless you don't care about actual deaths and only that they happened in personal transportation. The death rate is low enough that it makes any such claims suspicious.
- rootusrootus 5y agoIf I were going through that stage of parenting again, I'd do the shoe thing -- take off one of your shoes, toss it in the back seat. Hard to ignore that you're walking away from the car with only one shoe on. On topic: No, not a crime. Not negligence unless you're taking some abnormal risk that makes it more likely to happen. It is an accident.
- bell-cot 5y agoNo. American society has developed a moral panic/obsession with policing/persecuting parents (especially mothers) in certain ways. While pretty much ignoring systematic dangers to children such as lead (in paint, water, etc.), and the crushing financial penalties (from the medical bills for childbirth right through college expenses) for having them. At what point should I tell my [great-]granddaughters that I'll pay for them to get their tubes tied at age 18, and that is (sadly) the least-bad deal available in the U.S.?
- bryanlarsen 5y agoI once locked my daughter in the car. She was never alone or in any distress, I just somehow accidentally locked the door getting out of the car while the keys were on the front seat and my daughter was in the backseat. I tried to open the back door to get her out and was confused about why it wouldn't open until I figured out what had happened. A passerby called security who called a locksmith and the police. Both arrived quickly, the cop deciding that my daughter was in no danger so there was no need to break the window unless the locksmith couldn't get in. Sure enough, he was in quickly. He refused to take any money for the call. That panicked feeling was indescribable, and such a small shadow of what the people in the article must have felt and continue to feel.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoFirst day I’ve moved to a new place I’ve locked my kids in house. Luckily there was trampoline by the balcony so I could climb within a minute. But the sinking feeling is immense.
- hoistbypetard 5y agoI remember reading this a few years before my son was born. It was a crushing read then, and is not less so now. Also, Gene Weingarten is a national treasure. His writing in general and this piece in particular make me want to be sure newspapers prosper enough that it's always someone's paying job to be a long-form journalist. Even if I frequently get my news other ways, that is an extremely valuable social function.
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoTrigger warning, the article uses very descriptive and disturbing language to describe the death of a child... not something I really wanted to read today. But as an engineer of machines that test automotive safety systems, including the LATCH restraints that anchored the carseats in which those children sat, and also the window motors that sealed them in, I wonder if there's more we could do here on a systemic level. We live in a society that uses a mode of transportation which has two characteristics: One, to be safe at speed, small children must be buckled in the back by adults known to be fallible, forgetful, imperfect humans, in such a way that the toddler cannot escape, and two, because the vehicle must be theft-proof and rain-proof, when parked in ordinary sunlight, it becomes a greenhouse which would kill a child in that seat. There are 1.4 billion vehicles in the world, it's only a matter of time before probability will cause these problems to align. Knowing that this is a thing that could happen - no, poor choice of language, WILL happen again - how could we build a better car that will avoid these issues? Many new cars have infrared temperature sensors for automatic climate control, why not run the fan to keep the internal temperature survivable for the first 24 hours it's locked? It's already a pain dealing with automotive requirements that wiring and circuits be capable of a -40 to 105 C temperature range. Why not relax these for the cabin, and include vents or louvers (or crack the sunroof automatically) to allow air exchange when parked? Cars also have microphones inside the cabin for hands-free phone use, could the mic pick up the distress of a child and sound the horn/alarm or open the windows? No, I don't want to encourage people to leave their kids in their cars, and I don't want anyone's battery to run dead, or their upholstery to get rained on, or their car to be cold in the snow, or a lowered window to result in thefts, or spurious alarms to annoy people...but those are all avoidable. On average, once per week, a kid dies in a hot car in the US. Villifying the adults isn't working, therefore, we should try something different. And no, making the climate controls smart today won't prevent the three dozen deaths we're likely to see in the next summer months, but eventually those safer cars will trickle down to parents.
- mymythisisthis 5y agoWhat if the car texts you a picture of what is in the back seat, if it detects any weight, after it is turned off?
- nsonha 5y agois there any tech product that could alarm you about forgetting a child or a pet in the car. I know that you should use your brain for that but just a precaution and out of curiosity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sulam 5y agoAs a father of two, this article is so damn horrible I don't have words for how it makes me feel. I don't know why it's on HN's top page again, but I remember the last time it was, and it was the same thing. I work in the consumer electronics space, so I have a reasonable sense of how hard this would be, but it seems like an air temperature monitor that is on/around your baby would be pretty easy to build and probably sell millions.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoI remember researching all sort of safety gadgets before our kid was born (and after reading a choking story from a friend). All of these gadgets suffer from false positives. Imagine heart rate disappearing three times a night and you’ll throw that product away after first night.
- sulam 5y agoHeart rate absolutely — I think temp is a lot more reliable. The only problem is if the thing is in sunlight.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoI wonder how many kids died in cars because we can't as a society trust parents run quick errands while leaving the kiddo alone in the house until they are like, 25 years old.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoInstead of complying car manufacturers, how about changing car seats? They have expiry of 10years anyway - some electronics would easily last that on tiny battery. Other thing I find weird about cars is how they don’t come with monoxide interlock. Heck some generators do now, why not cars?
- qwertyX99 5y agocheck out r/fuckcars, this is not-so-hidden costs of car-centric urban planning