5 ms·

C Is Still Everywhere

36 points by pausmfib 4y ago

webmobdev 4y ago
I am doing some research for a personal project and wanted to integrate a tiny and fast http server. Most of the good and suitable open source code are built with C. You want small + fast, C, C++ and Pascal is still the way to go.
dmitrygr 4y ago
In other news: screwdrivers still everywhere. Anyone waiting for the death of C is delusional. It’s the best (often the only) tool for many jobs and will always underpin most of the world’s operating systems and low levels of user space. A few counter examples don’t invalidate this point.
- karmakaze 4y ago
  Perhaps this is better stated as "Standard/slot screws/drivers are everywhere." There are places where newer interfaces are more appropriate.
- pipeline_peak 4y ago
  I really hate to be right here, but Rust is picking up traction and has passionately growing fan base…..
- pornel 4y ago
  Major C projects that took 20+ years to develop won't be all replaced in a couple of years, but that doesn't mean the replacement hasn't started. C was the best/only option for almost a half of a century, so it has built a lot of momentum and legacy, but the niches where it's the best/only tool continue to shrink. C is unusual that it doesn't have a single 1:1 replacement, and few C projects are being directly rewritten in something else. Instead, C is getting sidelined, and not growing into new areas where the software is moving. Many other languages are now an obvious choice for things that used to be C's domain. I remember in the early 90s desktop apps were primarily in C (assembly and Pascal second), but nowadays apps can be written in a variety of languages, including scripting ones, or even entirely displaced by webapps. For early web services, if Perl was too slow, C was the second choice. Now C has been pushed to lower-level plumbing, and even that started being eroded by golang and Rust. Even games that used to be strictly C/C++ territory have moved to C++ engine + scripting (with the proportion of scripting growing). Unity games use C# (e.g. I was shocked that BeatSaber, a low-latency VR game, is in C#). I've been similarly waiting for the demise of x86. x86 used to be the best/only option for a very long time, and is still having a momentum in desktops, but a whole new, larger mobile computing world has sprung without it.
wcerfgba 4y ago
The most difficult thing I find about C is the (apparent) lack of libraries and packages. With other languages I know where to go to find libraries for anything I need, but I never know where to look with C. As a result I never really use it. A boilerplate project with testing, common libs for data structures, and pointers to useful resources like extra libs, would be really cool. :) That said if I had to do something nowadays that I would use C for, I'd probably just pick up Rust.
- melissalobos 4y ago
  > The most difficult thing I find about C is the (apparent) lack of libraries and packages I really am not sure if this is a joke or not, but almost every major library has a C interface. Almost all packages in your distro if you use linux have development versions that ship libraries that usually are linkable by C. In fact the wealth of libraries usable from C is usually noted as its main strength. What exactly are you missing, and have you tried googling? The GNU organization and similar all produce libraries(like https://www.gnu.org/software/gsl/ https://www.gnu.org/software/gsl/) that are mostly usable from C.
  - lumost 4y ago
    Coming from a different language, the idea that the OS provides your libraries is a radical departure. Generally a modern developer working in any other language will look to github along with the languages package repository for libraries. Anecdotally the types of libraries shippable with the OS represent a specific category of application which doesn't encompass many developers needs. (Although on the other side, github does not provide usable drivers for most operating systems... your mileage may very).
    - melissalobos 4y ago
      Even so, github does have a ton of very very popular C libraries(like https://github.com/nothings/stb https://github.com/nothings/stb). I was bringing up the OS provided ones since they claimed not to be able to find any. My main point is that it is patently absurd to claim that they could not find C libraries. Further: https://github.com/oz123/awesome-c https://github.com/oz123/awesome-c as another example of the many many C libraries you could find.

36 points by pausmfib 4y ago

I am doing some research for a personal project and wanted to integrate a tiny and fast http server. Most of the good and suitable open source code are built with C. You want small + fast, C, C++ and Pascal is still the way to go.

dmitrygr 4y ago

In other news: screwdrivers still everywhere. Anyone waiting for the death of C is delusional. It’s the best (often the only) tool for many jobs and will always underpin most of the world’s operating systems and low levels of user space. A few counter examples don’t invalidate this point.

karmakaze 4y ago
Perhaps this is better stated as "Standard/slot screws/drivers are everywhere." There are places where newer interfaces are more appropriate.
pipeline_peak 4y ago
I really hate to be right here, but Rust is picking up traction and has passionately growing fan base…..
pornel 4y ago
Major C projects that took 20+ years to develop won't be all replaced in a couple of years, but that doesn't mean the replacement hasn't started. C was the best/only option for almost a half of a century, so it has built a lot of momentum and legacy, but the niches where it's the best/only tool continue to shrink. C is unusual that it doesn't have a single 1:1 replacement, and few C projects are being directly rewritten in something else. Instead, C is getting sidelined, and not growing into new areas where the software is moving. Many other languages are now an obvious choice for things that used to be C's domain. I remember in the early 90s desktop apps were primarily in C (assembly and Pascal second), but nowadays apps can be written in a variety of languages, including scripting ones, or even entirely displaced by webapps. For early web services, if Perl was too slow, C was the second choice. Now C has been pushed to lower-level plumbing, and even that started being eroded by golang and Rust. Even games that used to be strictly C/C++ territory have moved to C++ engine + scripting (with the proportion of scripting growing). Unity games use C# (e.g. I was shocked that BeatSaber, a low-latency VR game, is in C#). I've been similarly waiting for the demise of x86. x86 used to be the best/only option for a very long time, and is still having a momentum in desktops, but a whole new, larger mobile computing world has sprung without it.

wcerfgba 4y ago

The most difficult thing I find about C is the (apparent) lack of libraries and packages. With other languages I know where to go to find libraries for anything I need, but I never know where to look with C. As a result I never really use it. A boilerplate project with testing, common libs for data structures, and pointers to useful resources like extra libs, would be really cool. :) That said if I had to do something nowadays that I would use C for, I'd probably just pick up Rust.

melissalobos 4y ago
> The most difficult thing I find about C is the (apparent) lack of libraries and packages I really am not sure if this is a joke or not, but almost every major library has a C interface. Almost all packages in your distro if you use linux have development versions that ship libraries that usually are linkable by C. In fact the wealth of libraries usable from C is usually noted as its main strength. What exactly are you missing, and have you tried googling? The GNU organization and similar all produce libraries(like https://www.gnu.org/software/gsl/ https://www.gnu.org/software/gsl/) that are mostly usable from C.
- lumost 4y ago
  Coming from a different language, the idea that the OS provides your libraries is a radical departure. Generally a modern developer working in any other language will look to github along with the languages package repository for libraries. Anecdotally the types of libraries shippable with the OS represent a specific category of application which doesn't encompass many developers needs. (Although on the other side, github does not provide usable drivers for most operating systems... your mileage may very).
  - melissalobos 4y ago
    Even so, github does have a ton of very very popular C libraries(like https://github.com/nothings/stb https://github.com/nothings/stb). I was bringing up the OS provided ones since they claimed not to be able to find any. My main point is that it is patently absurd to claim that they could not find C libraries. Further: https://github.com/oz123/awesome-c https://github.com/oz123/awesome-c as another example of the many many C libraries you could find.