8 ms·
Big Myths Employers Are Using to Force “Return to Office”
- snarf21 5y agoI really wish this debate would move to be more about preference rather than right/wrong. Everyone works better in certain situations. We aren't robots. There are enough companies giving everyone a choice that everyone should just be happy and stop dunking on everyone else.
- lucumo 5y agoI would also like to see more discussion of which activities and situations are better handled in person and which are better WFH. I think there's a lot of nuance there that could really improve the debate and work situations. E.g. - training a junior developer vs. turning a senior "debug commando" loose, - collaborating on an architecture vs. deep thinking about an algorithm, - screen sharing vs. whiteboard doodling, - dealing with an underperformer vs. getting out of the way of an overperformer, - when to check in with a home worker vs. when to let an office worker focus, - etc. There's just so many people completely focused on One Right Answer to the question. Even if it's a different One Right Answer for different people. As an engineer I'm interested in the trade-offs in every choice, but the discussion is so polluted that you can't really trust anyone to treat the subject with intellectual honesty.
- snarf21 5y agoAgreed. People today seem so focused on other people being "wrong" and no one is interested in this kind of thoughtful discourse.
- aaronbrethorst 5y agoThis seems to be a thinly disguised bit of content marketing for the author's consulting practice.
- vmception 5y ago"Thought leadership"
- the_only_law 5y agoThis is probably the number 1 modern internet phenomenon I absolutely hate. Blogspam articles trying to sell me something have destroyed search engines I swear.
- jobs_throwaway 5y ago>MYTH # 2: The office promotes connections I just find this bit entirely unconvincing. I don't have data to back up my claim, but IME 1 in-person interaction is worth ~5-10 'virtual coffee' type interactions via Donut or one of the similar apps. Maybe others feel differently, but I haven't found any substitute for live, in-person get togethers for connecting with colleagues on a personal level.
- lordnacho 5y agoOTOH it's also possible to have conversations of a whole other nature online. The pace is different, and the urgency is different. You can have hours long discussions about interesting stuff with someone you've never even met. For instance I talk to a professor in my field about stuff, and it's not that easy to find someone to just do that. Similarly I've had a lot of slow but insightful conversations with teammates about various technical issues, or personal issues.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoNot all of us seem to connect with colleagues on a personal level, and prefer to instead optimize for what’s necessary to get our work done. These are not friends; they are workers who share a common compensation provider.
- BaseballPhysics 5y ago...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- BlargMcLarg 5y agoSo is being so extremely judgmental without even considering things from GP's perspective. They are trying to keep things in harmony while focusing on output. It might not leave the work environment socially positive, but they aren't actively trying to make the place worse socially, either. That doesn't sound a bad deal considering some of us are very selective with relationships and frankly, selecting companies for colleagues would be a ridiculously long and potentially fruitless endeavor. Meanwhile, what you do get is someone who is a large net positive on other fronts.
- colinmhayes 5y ago> Go look at Buffer, Zapier, Automattic, GitLab, and more, who are Remote First companies with thriving cultures. I really don't think pointing to a couple companies that are remote and have decent culture invalidates the point that offices foster collaboration and culture sharing. No, it's not impossible to do those things in a remote environment, but it is absolutely much harder. It's not that hard to understand some companies aren't willing to put in the work required to build strong collaborative cultures remotely.
- p0wn 5y agoWhy is it much harder? I disagree. In office I usually only ever talk to people I directly work with. And, as an engineer, not very often. Every time I'd go in an office I'd just be sitting in front of a computer. If they had lunches then we'd all chat but it was all just bullshitting. I don't see how remote makes it harder to collaborate or 'culture share'. Culture sharing seems something woke people like to do a bit too much these days anyways. Rather stay home and keep my opinions to myself.
- postingposts 5y agoBecause it filters out the people who do all of category B (bullshitting, talking, having meetings) who normally spend their time taking away from category A (I am paid to do a task which I will do, and then be paid)
- diob 5y agoIronically I think those are the same companies that aren't willing to put in the work required to build strong collaborative cultures _onsite_.
- noahtallen 5y ago(I work at one of the listed companies, and these views are my own.) Honestly, on-site just wouldn’t work well with the existing company culture at all. My current team has members in at least 7 countries in North America and Europe. Some teams are more time-zone collocated, but many are not. The culture is built so that async communication — and in particular, publicly searchable written communication — is the default for nearly everything. So having a big time zone split isn’t a problem when you’re used to communicating via long-form written communication. Obviously, on-site is hugely different. If I went on-site, I would not be working with my specific team. I’m not even sure how the company could possibly reorganize to make that happen at all. It’s not like new hires in X geographic region are placed in Y division. So the best that could be done on-site is you get to make social connections. Can’t really have an on-site collaborative culture if none of your teammates live in the same city. And you can’t change that after the fact either, because people live in so many different places! And as a side note, having frequently worked in OSS projects, communication and work is very distributed anyways. So it’s important to be habitually in tune with that style of communication and work to be effective in a large OSS project with maintainers spread the world. So I would argue that even trying to have an on-site collaborative culture doesn’t make any sense if your company is truly globally distributed.
- Proven 5y ago
- ed25519FUUU 5y agoI actually don’t care whether I’m more productive at home or in the office. I’m positive I’m more productive in the office but I won’t return either way. It makes no difference to me. My life is not about my employer extracting 100% of my productivity from me. I have a better quality of life working from home and I’m going to keep it.
- postingposts 5y agoNOOOOOOO… you HAVE to be a cog in the machine and not enjoy your own life because… because… NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO lol
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoGP made a really good point and perhaps you also had something interesting to share from your experience. However, the snark distracts from the discussion and adds noise to GPs comment thread. I mean this without sarcasm, the 'Guidelines' at the bottom of the page and in particular the 'In Comments' section are really on point and worthwhile to read.
- postingposts 5y agoI have read the guidelines. Could you tell me where it says “don’t make jokes”? The guidelines aren’t rules, they’re guidelines. Otherwise they would be called rules. You can’t break a guideline, to wit. I think you’re really overestimating how much my comment either adds or detracts from the conversation. But I can say it in a clearer way: I do not care one single iota about the investment companies have made in leasing buildings whatsoever. I do not care to be babysat at work and I leave places that choose such paths. I look down on people who want to have that either as an occupation or a career. I will be laughing the entire time the physical workplace burns because it’s comical. Have you ever read Candide by Voltaire?
- happytoexplain 5y agoYes, this is an unjustly ignored point. The nigh-100% focus on which one is more productive is a blaring signal of how sick work culture is. At times we seem to simply accept that employers/managers are the dictators, and employees are the subjects, rather than that both are equal humans.
- wgx 5y agoAnecdata: I’ve noticed that the voices in an organisation who are more keen for a return to the office tend to be the managers, directors, leadership sort of roles. I wonder if being in the office is just simply more enjoyable for those with power and influence, while individual contributors (trying to get their work done) find they like it more at home?
- beardedetim 5y agoMy experience matches yours and I've always thought it was due to trust. Leadership doesn't trust their team and have no idea if they're being productive or not. So they use "at desk not talking with head down" as a proxy.
- karpierz 5y agoThat's a pretty cynical take. Everyone is trying to get their work done, it's more of a question of whether remote work makes that easier or harder. - People whose productivity is based on regular social interaction will work faster face-to-face. - People whose productivity is based on long periods of focus will work faster remotely.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tapanjk 5y agoThe thing is, you have to produce results when you are remote. In an office, you can get by looking busy. I think the people who insist on going back to the office are the ones who are missing the stage on which they used to perform without actually doing real work.
- nunez 5y agoin functional orgs, looking busy will catch up to you eventually, remote or otherwise.
- teus 5y ago> I wonder if being in the office is just simply more enjoyable for those with power and influence, while individual contributors (trying to get their work done) find they like it more at home? Alternate take 1: If IC positions attract strongly introverted people, ICs as a cohort will naturally be less desirous of returning to the office than cohorts that require some ability to extrovert (such as management). Alternate take 2: ICs are responsible for their tasks/goals. Managers are responsible for the tasks/goals of their managed individuals as well as the health of the team. People aren't machines. Managing people is not as simple as checking if they're completing sprints on time. Are they overworked? Underworked? Happy? Depressed? Engaged? Disinterested? These sorts of assessments are important yet can be hard to determine remotely. If managing requires some amount of extroversion, and also the ability to not just measure that boxes have been checked but attest that boxes will continue to be checked in the future, it follows that managers likely are "more keen for a return to the office".
- Overtonwindow 5y agoI'm surprised security and confidentiality hasn't been more of an issue point. Especially for Apple.
- ryanbrunner 5y agoI feel like for many companies that was a problem that had to be solved a long time ago. It's pretty rare that you're not taking home a work laptop, or have work data on your phone or at least a company-provided phone already.
- LunaSea 5y agoIt's not going to get solved, simply ignored and pushed under the rug.
- ryanbrunner 5y agoOh for sure a lot of companies never bothered to solve it, but the problem existed prior to everyone working from home.
- onecommentman 5y agoI agree, but in the opposite sense you are probably meaning. If office buildings have been left vacant for many months, I would wonder what sort of sophisticated surveillance systems could have been installed, tested, and activated in the interim. Easier to compromise the physical security of one large complex than 10000 home offices. The last place I would trust from a security standpoint would be the meeting rooms of a major HQ at this point, until they have been sanitized one-by-one.
- drewcoo 5y agoI still haven't seen any articles about the money. If people are being herded back into offices there's likely money behind it. The owners of all of that office space are going to lose a lot if nobody goes back to the office. Are they paying to incentivize any of this "return to office" stuff? Likewise, if the business real estate market crashes, what are all the ripples? Are there people paying to prevent the crash because it would hit them indirectly?
- jksmith 5y agoThis is scaler talk about an issue that will require some vector solutions. Having consulted for several F500 corporations, I've seen first hand that they mostly suck, and a lot of this culture talk is driven by Bill Lumbergh not being able to do his cube circuit every day. The direction of decentralized work effort has let people step back from the trees to see the forest, and simply ask why a company thinks it's even worth their in-person time. This should even be a stockholder fundamental question if a chunk of company expenses goes to keeping lights turned on.
- nunez 5y agoI favor the proliferation of remote work environments, but I disagree with much of this article. Yes, maintaining a positive and welcoming work culture is intentional. However, human-to-human interaction is a big part of that. There's a big difference between having a few get-togethers per year and being able to ask someone (who might not be in your immediate circle) out to an actual coffee. Also, career growth is 100% about who you know. Knowing everyone is easy at small companies but is impossible at larger ones. Yes, you can ask your skip-level for an intro to someone outside of your immediate silo, but I'd argue that this is more difficult for people that aren't intrinsically-motivated to make that leap themselves. This is something else that is bolstered by closer proximity and person-to-person interactions. Everything else mentioned here varies from person to person, IMO. Offices can be very fun places to be, even if you have a thriving social life. For many, it is very difficult to make friends outside of your regular social interactions. Yes, there's Meetup, but (a) not even town has a thriving Meetup scene; you can almost bet on Meetup sucking in rural/suburban neighborhoods, and (b) it takes a real ability to go into an event knowing that you'll know no-one and that you'll do your best to leave knowing someone. I hosted large Meetup groups for many years, have gone to countless events and have interacted with probably thousands of people, and I still have a lot of trouble with this because I strongly prefer, and have always preferred, being by myself. Anyone that says "it's easy bro" is probably naturally good at this and doesn't comprehend that someone could struggle here. On the other hand, offices can be a means to an end for people with families who want to spend as much time with them as possible. For these people, perks and social outings aren't incentivizing. However, many people with families are CONSTANTLY distracted in ways that they wouldn't be in an office. Crying babies, toddlers being toddlers, pets, random noises, etc. are common enough to create a bingo card out of. I don't think this reduces "productivity" (which is in the eyes of the beholder), but these things definitely wouldn't happen in offices.
- taylodl 5y agoMy team meets in-person every other week for most of a work day. I have lunch with other colleagues on a semi-regular basis. I have long-going conversations on teams with several colleagues. Nobody in my circle of contacts which consists of roughly 200 people want to return to the office full-time - and I work at a Fortune 200 company with a big office tower downtown. They're fully onboard with this working model after seeing the productivity numbers. Maybe part of the difference is my company has dozens of field offices scattered across multiple states, so they're already used to a lot of their employees essentially being remote.
- taylodl 5y agoI should also point out we're using remote work as a means to hire also. We're hiring people from all over the country and allowing them to stay put. Some have chosen to move here so they can have some in-person time every now and then, others have decided to remain where they are. We've been doing this successfully for over two years now.
- davoneus 5y agoI don't care one way or another is someone works remotely or in the office. What I do care about is effective communication between co-workers. Unfortunately though, for remote workers, there is an enormous elephant in the room; namely non-verbal communications. Truth is that study after study (after study) has shown how large of a role non-verbal clues are in the human communications process (some show 90%). To my mind, argue all you want about video conferencing and chat apps, humanity is innately social, and when you cut out large chunks of that social engagement and replace it with remote-work, there will be enormous social and work environment impacts. Of course not all shared-location work environments are created equal, and too many in management are both lazy and power hungry. They (and their companies) want to blame anything but their own horrific employment practices and lazy, out-of-date policies. So it's not all a bad thing remote-work has become as big as it has. However, like all human activity pendulums, the remote-work vs in-presence work one WILL swing back. I expect many of us will get a great deal of enjoyment in seeing it when it does.
- bitcuration 5y agoBloomberg: Bosses Don't Follow Their Own Advice in Returning to the Office https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-04-19/bosses-don-t-follow-their-own-advice-in-returning-to-the-office https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-04-19/bosses-do... While 35% of non-executive employees are in the office five days a week, just 19% of executives can say the same, according to a survey by Future Forum, a research consortium backed by messaging channel Slack.