12 ms·
Dear Mozilla: Fix Your Damn Browser
- ketralnis 15y agoThis seems a bit overblown for what amounts to a performance bug in a feature that few people even use (bookmarks).
- kemayo 15y agoIt's not just bookmarks. It's history and the location bar. He mentions that one of the things which triggers his crashes is using the back button, which is a feature that I think a reasonable number of people use. (I can't say that I've seen such issues myself... but it's been quite a while since I used Firefox under Linux.)
- Xurinos 15y agoBy chance, can you point me to a proof of that usability point? All I have is anecdotal evidence to the contrary, but I have long wondered.
- pjriot 15y agoDo people not use bookmarks? I have thousands of them. What are the alternatives that I'm missing out on? (big xmarks user too so sync is a must)
- AdamGibbins 15y agoI store all my bookmarks in http://pinboard.in http://pinboard.in, much better organisation, sorting, faster, cross-os, cross-browser.
- pjriot 15y agoLooks great, but I'm happy with what I have now so I'm not too pushed about spending money on a service. I'm also old enough to worry about trusting a site to hang around for 10 years with my data. (and by old enough, read: stuck in my ways enough) Must look into the migration effort though. And browser addon support. Its definitely a sweet looking service.
- AdamGibbins 15y agoIf you go for the premium service, a bargain $25 a month you get the ability to have it scrape and download every site you bookmark. So even if the site you bookmarked goes down, you retain the content. Pinboard also has good APIs so you can backup your data. No lock-in.
- pjriot 15y agoJeez, did not know that. I was thinking of writing something like that myself with version control for page updates just to be safe.
- pjriot 15y agoHoly crap, its $25 a year. That is a bargain.
- AdamGibbins 15y agoUrh, sorry - yes. s/month/year/ Total typo, sorry. Worth noting thats 25 minus your signup fee. So more likely $16 for your first year.
- smackfu 15y agoMost people use Google, or something like Facebook gets autocompleted.
- bilban 15y agoMost people?
- metageek 15y agoAnd the autocomplete relies on the Places system, which is what is hanging (or was, until a few weeks ago).
- pjriot 15y agoI'd say I do too, even for stuff I have bookmarked. In fact 80% of my bookmarks provide nothing other than peace of mind for a person with a terrible memory. :)
- gurraman 15y agoI haven't used the built-in bookmarks feature for years. I checked just now, and I have 10 bookmarks stored (all of them used for quick searching in FF). I still use the concept though, I just offload them to Delicious where they can be properly tagged and shared.
- yellowbkpk 15y agoI have roughly a dozen sites I go to. Most of them happen to have different first characters, so I type "f" and Chrome autocompletes http://fark.com/ http://fark.com/ and off I go. No bookmarks other than the shared history Google keeps for me.
- pjriot 15y agoI use them pretty heavily for reference/todo/toread type of stuff. And I have a terrible memory.
- dagw 15y agoMost (non-technical) people I know just use a combination of the browser history and Google.
- kemayo 15y agoI remember one of my co-workers telling me that Firefox was running great for him now that he'd upgraded from 4GB of RAM to 8GB. It finally wasn't slowly grinding to a halt any time he had more than a handful of tabs open for more than an hour or two. Seemed a bit like Stockholm Syndrome to me.
- jamesgeck0 15y agoHow long ago was this? There's been a number of memory usage improvements since 3.5. I had 40 tabs open for the better part of last week and didn't notice a performance hit; and I've only got 2Gb RAM.
- weaksauce 15y agoI have the latest version and my long running high count tab sessions slow down my system tremendously. OSX 8GB RAM.
- CWuestefeld 15y agoI have memory-hemorrhaging problems under various versions of Windows as well. I need to restart at least once a day (I typically have ~8 tabs in use). But the clincher that made me switch to Chrome a couple weeks ago was that every couple of hours it would decide of its own accord to tear off a tab into a new window, and then hang. This solved the memory leakage, but not in a useful way. I'm pretty sure that my problems are related to badly-behaving addins. But Firefox doesn't provide any good way to troubleshoot addins (compare to Chrome), and it seemed to me that the process to track down the culprit given that the problem is nondeterministic and takes a couple of hours to manifest would be more difficult than the switch to Chrome. That said, I'm having some compatibility problems with Chrome. Like, last night the CAPTCHA in the free annual credit report site wouldn't work.
- weaksauce 15y agoYeah. I had the same problem with chrome as well. Same setup. Maybe web browsers can't handle how I work with them at the moment. Maybe I'll go down the rabbit hole and try to fix some of the bugs myself.
- jroseattle 15y agoAs a dev, FF was my go-to utility browser due to Firebug. Google released Chrome, and I found myself using FF rarely. I rebuilt a laptop recently. After loading it up with software, it was a good 3 weeks before I even noticed that I didn't have FF installed.
- vectorpush 15y agoI've had a similar experience. I've really come to appreciate Chrome's built in developer tools and have pretty much left Firebug in the dust.
- redthrowaway 15y agoI'm in the opposite boat. I find firebug easier to use for the limited use cases I encounter (mostly scraping html id tags) than Chrome's dev tools. That said, I still far prefer Chrome as a browser.
- crikli 15y agoHere here! I've completely given up on Firefox on my MBP (3.06 Core2, 8GB, 480GB SSD). Between the egregious javascript memory leak and constantly increasing resource utilization it's just unusable. And my fans are running full tilt within 60 seconds of starting it.
- alphadogg 15y agoMy FF, fully updated, works fine. I use Bookmarks extensively. What seems to occasionally crash it are things out of Mozilla's current control: poorly written extensions or Adobe Flash hangs. Never even heard of needing to vaccuum the sqlite dbs. FF is a fine browser. So, basically we have one anecdote for and one against, and neither is enough to pass judgement on a full and popular browser like FF.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoWhat happened to Firefox focusing on Linux responsiveness? They even acknowledged it as an issue and promised to work on it, but I've yet to see that occur at all.
- smoyer 15y agoI feel the same pain ... I've switched away from Firefox now and only use it when I'm compatibility testing my applications/sites.
- bigohms 15y agoI dropped FF b/c of the memory leak. As a test, on a spare mac I wrote a script that launched FF and Chrome simultaneously and visited 10 websites I frequent. They both had similar clean profiles. After roughly two days of continuous refresh/load cycles, Chrome's memory was at 148MB, FF was 988MB.
- jamesgeck0 15y agoWhat version of Firefox? As of 7, memory usage is almost as good as Opera for me.
- jbk 15y agoI am a bit in the same situation as the author, using Firefox since before it was called Firefox, on all platforms and advocating it very widely. But, it is hard to go on advocating it. True, they fixed many issues on JS speed and memory with the latest releases (after denying the issues for a loooong time). However, the slowness of the SQlite backend is quite annoying, as mentioned on the article. The SSL management is beyond ridiculous, especially when the whole model of Certificate Authorities is broken, as the news showed us. The breakage of extensions at each update is abnormal. The Linux integration is abysmal... And yet, at each release, it seems the focuses on UI changes are the more important... IE9 is now decent, Chrome is really good and Opera too. All most of my developers friends have moved to Chrome...
- gcp 15y agoAnd yet, at each release, it seems the focuses on UI changes are the more important... I've seen almost no UI changes in Firefox 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9. All the change-logs were basically backend optimizations.
- burgerbrain 15y ago"I've seen almost no UI changes in Firefox 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9." So.. in the past 2 weeks? Seriously, that absurd numbering scheme needs to stop too.
- Joakal 15y agoChrome's doing it too. Just ignore the versioning.
- bzbarsky 15y agoIn the last 6 months. As you knew perfectly well, of course....
- burgerbrain 15y agoNo, actually I didn't know that. I no longer use firefox, and their scheme honestly makes no sense to me. I am convinced they only adopted it so that Mozilla supporters can shoot down any criticism from people who abandoned it more than a few weeks ago by saying "well your criticism is hardly relevant, we're several version numbers past what you were using now!" Notice several examples of this tactic in this very discussion... But anyway, are they bumping the version number every 1.2 months then? Is that supposed to be obvious? PS: I would also like to add that "There hasn't been a major UI change in 6 months" is anything but a strong refutation of the original assertion that Mozilla changes up the UI too much. This is another example of redefining "major release" to silence valid criticism.
- u48998 15y agoCross-browser bookmarks compatibility is the one reason I'm having hard time giving up on Firefox, otherwise, Chrome is certainly faster and better overall. The other issue is that bookmarks are not easily portable on cloud (don't talk to me about delicious or xmarks - I prefer to keep my bookmarks to myself). What if I use Chrome most of the time at home but can't if I'm using library or work computer? There are issues which are still unresolved in the browser world.
- masterleep 15y agoThis longstanding bug has been found and fixed in the past few weeks. There’s a workaround as well (use the Places Maintenance addon to properly index your Places database). https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=686025 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=686025
- metageek 15y agoI thought I hadn't seen Firefox hang in a while.
- daltontf 15y agoThe new rapid release development cycle has bit Mozilla in the rear. For example, FF 7.0.1 on Vista needs to be run as Administrator. I didn't find this out until it just stopped working on my wife's laptop.
- gcp 15y agoUh, no, of course it doesn't. Something is seriously fubar on your side.
- sp332 15y agoThe automatic updates have to ask for admin rights, is that what you are seeing? You can deny admin rights and it will run fine (without updating). And they know it's not optimal, they're fixing that in the next version.
- fletchowns 15y agoAt least with Firefox you don't have to deal with things like this: http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=41467 http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=41467 When Firefox dropped http:// http:// at least they gave you the ability to turn it back on!
- Permit 15y agoI'm impressed by the passion with which people want http:// http:// back in their URLs. Perhaps it's tangential to the original thread, but why's it such a big deal?
- gwern 15y agoIt gets in my way doing copy-paste. I don't entirely understand it - it seems to have something to do with whether Firefox is busy or not - but it's easy for a copied URL to simply not have the prefix, which breaks subsequent use pretty frequently (eg. 'google.com' is not a useful Markdown link while 'http://google.com http://google.com is).
- muuh-gnu 15y ago> but why's it such a big deal? Because people copy&paste URLs all the time, and without the http:// http:// they dont work where pasted. Not having http:// http:// when youre copy-pasting feels like a part of your URL is missing. What I dont know is for whom they are hiding http:// http://? I'd guess there are 2 types of users, those who need the URL, then they need it complete, including the http:// http://, and those who dont need the URL to be visible at all (except maybe the domain name), like they dont need the current path in Explorer. But who exactly needs half an URL which is then only magically completed upon C&P-ing? And those who allegedly dont need http:// http://, why do they need the part after the TLD? From their POV, the arguments part is even more useless than http:// http://.
- wazoox 15y agoI see lots of unfair complaining here. I'm still running FF even on machines with 1GB of RAM, and I actually had troubles with memory leaks on Mac, that were mostly related to some extensions.
- acabal 15y agoI'm excited for Ubuntu 11.10 if only because it means I can flatten and reinstall, thus relieving me of Firefox's performance woes for another few months. It's really crazy the amount of memory it uses and the slowdowns that happen when you keep it open for more than a few hours.
- mahyarm 15y agoChrome hang's too, especially when I have 12 engadget tabs open on engadget. Firefox not so much then I have those same 12 tabs. This is on OSX.
- kijin 15y agoYep, same problem. Firefox hangs whenever I try to do anything "intensive" with Places, such as selectively deleting stuff from the history or reorganizing a large number of bookmarks. It's gotten much better than before, though. Weird thing is, Firefox is still faster than Chrome on my computer (Win7x64). I don't know what's wrong with my computer, but Chrome is noticeably slower than Firefox in day-to-day use. This only happens on this particular computer. Chrome is indeed faster in every other computer I've tried. Very strange.
- zobzu 15y agodrink more G cool aid. ff is also faster here. but also on my other comps, except for the osx ones where chrome is better.
- sciurus 15y agoIn Mozilla's defense, they've handled Places-related issues well in the past. http://shaver.off.net/diary/2008/05/25/fsyncers-and-curveballs/ http://shaver.off.net/diary/2008/05/25/fsyncers-and-curvebal...
- dsrikanth 15y agoI share the same feeling. It is becoming a pain. If I keep it open for few hours, it inevitably crashes and needs a restart. I started using firefox few years back only because it won't crash and is stable. Not anymore I guess!
- re_todd 15y agoYeah, I have to restart it at least once a day. In addition to "Clear Recent History", how about a "Clear Older History", where I can delete everything older than a month or a week? That would clean out probably more than 95% of the cruft possibly speeding things up. I'm sure there's a way to do this, but how about an easy way for the average user?
- azakai 15y ago> Firefox, on Linux at least, is busted. It’s busted so bad that it’s painful to use. And it’s been this way ever since Firefox 3 launched — three years ago. This is an odd statement, considering that many Firefox devs run Linux. I'm running Firefox on Linux right now, and it works great. I guess the author of the article is hitting a specific bug. It isn't a general issue that affects all users of Firefox on Linux.
- aphyr 15y agoSure, the impact of any specific bug is limited--but the gestalt of Firefox is of a development process that values press and feature creep over performance and correctness. I haven't looked back since switching to Chrome. FF ignored obvious bugs for years. X pixmap freeing? Open since 2004. [1] I waited for six years, having to restart my browser every few hours, because it would leak over 2 GB from having a network graphs page open. Startup time? Last time I opened it, six months ago, FF took over 10 seconds to start, cold. Chromium snaps open in under a quarter second. Then there's developer friendliness. Writing extensions is a complete mess, especially compared to Chrome. Configuration structure is haphazard at best. Profile corruption is a thing. I don't understand how a multi-million dollar foundation can tolerate this kind of experience. Don't get me started on the rendering bugs. :-/ [1] https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=259672 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=259672
- azakai 15y ago> Sure, the impact of any specific bug is limited--but the gestalt of Firefox is of a development process that values press and feature creep over performance and correctness. I'm not sure if you are just trolling or not. Assuming not, then since Firefox's development is done in the open, I assume you have some evidence for this - meeting notes or such that show that? Or some other evidence? The evidence to the contrary seems overwhelming. Firefox's main focus in 4.0 was on performance, see arewefastyet.com for JS, and the major rewrite of the graphics system (Layers) that lets it use things like Direct2D on Windows as just two examples. And as a consequence of those huge efforts, Firefox just won Toms Hardware's speed test, beating Chrome, Opera, IE and Safari, http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/firefox-7-web-browser,3037-17.html http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/firefox-7-web-browser,30... Edit: Looks like I'm being downvoted. Please tell me hacker news isn't deteriorating into reddit, where opposing opinions are downvoted by reflex...
- gabyar 15y agoI was going to say that Firefox's lack of innovation and quality in the last couple of years, as compared to Chrome, could be due to lack of funding. But it turns out their revenue is well over $100 million annually, which should be enough to fix bugs. http://goo.gl/g5Upc http://goo.gl/g5Upc Still a good browser, but there's no question they've lost quite a bit of mojo.
- Finster 15y agoSounds like he needs to fix Linux. Good Luck!
- thaumaturgy 15y agoNow that AdBlock Plus is fully functional in Chrome/Chromium, we've been moving all of our clients -- a few hundred individuals and businesses -- off of Firefox. So far, everybody's been a lot happier with that. Firefox is terrible. It's embarrassing. And, I've completely lost interest in arguing over it anymore. The responses from Mozilla, Asa especially, have either been, "We don't think that's a problem", or sometimes, "go piss up a rope". Other people constantly chime in and say, "But I don't have that problem!", as if that somehow makes it better for the many many people who do have problems with Firefox. Fortunately, this isn't quite Netscape versus Internet Explorer all over again; this time, we have a well-supported third option, too.
- bad_user 15y agoFirefox is terrible. It's embarrassing. I do have Firefox occasionally choking, which annoys me as hell, but I'm on Firefox 8. I do get frustrated, but criticizing a software package that you get for freaking free, especially one that you ow so much to, with such a harsh tone really is unwarranted. And it really is free in a not-for-profit way. The Awesome bar that the article mentions really saves you from making useless round-trips to Google / being exposed to Google Ads, even if this hurts Mozilla's revenues; on the other hand Chrome's primary reason for being is Google's control on the web, ensuring that Google's search remains the default, which is one reason the Awesome bar will never make it into Chrome. Also, AdBlock Plus in Chrome has known bugs and limitations because of Chrome, because while Firefox is a platform, Chrome is a product that treats its users like idiots.
- pnathan 15y agoFirefox after 3 ran like a crippled dog. I switched to Phoenix, because it was a relief from the bloat of Netscape 6. It's been a long time since then, and running a modern Firefox tends to seem like Netscape 6 bloat. So I use Chrome. I am agnostic about my browsers. I like speed, speed, speed.
- asadotzler 15y agoJason, we’ve been working on this. There were some big performance improvements in Firefox 6 and 7 and we’ve got a big hang fix that’s just about to hit in Firefox 8. Can you grab an Aurora or Beta build and see if things are better?
- frossie 15y agoI suffer quite a lot from Firefox performance issues since I need to run two instances on one machine, and Firefox 7 fixed ALL my hanging/swapping issues. Great job on that and I definitely urge everybody to upgrade. While I'm here I'll add my usual "Dump Firefox? You can pry Tree Style Tab out of my cold dead hands" comment. That said, I have also experienced the "we are not doing it cause we don't like it no matter how insanely useful it is to corporate users" attitude, eg. the perennial refusal to add overstrike: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=38415 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=38415
- ximeng 15y agoIt seems unlikely that Chrome will get tree style tabs any time soon, despite some popular interest: http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=99332&can=1&q=%22side%20tabs%22&colspec=ID%20Stars%20Pri%20Area%20Feature%20Type%20Status%20Summary%20Modified%20Owner%20Mstone%20OS http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=99332&... "If I stop using the dev version, and switch to beta or (shudder) released, and turn off updating, will that give me the tabs back, or is it too late?"
- jbellis 15y agoAnother satisfied Tree Style Tabs user here. After the AwesomeBar, that's the number two thing keeping me on FireFox. Especially now that version 7 cut its memory footprint in half.
- windsurfer 15y agoArch Linux here, Firefox 7.0.1. No hanging, no Flash problems, 15+ tabs is a-okay, and extensions work great. I'm happy!
- 15y ago
- ck2 15y agoI've also been using firefox since 1.0 and had such problems through 3.6 But 7.0 is the best version yet for me and radically faster on startup and operation (and I use a ton of extensions). It just took a weekend to get 7.0 to behave like 3.x and then I was happy.
- codexon 15y agoI noticed this problem in Windows along with huge memory leaks. I've switched to Firefox Nightly and this lag seems to have gone away. As a bonus, the browser feels as fast as Chrome and it takes several weeks more usage before needing a restart due to slowness.
- BadassFractal 15y agoI'd kill for multi-row tab support in Chrome (TabMixPlus in Firefox or by default part of the browser in Opera). It's the only thing that keeps me from switching 100% from FF.
- cookiecaper 15y agoI used Chromium on Linux for 2+ years and switched back to Firefox during the 4.0 beta cycle. I'm much happier with Firefox's extensibility and interface and I haven't had any major issues since going back. The main reason I used Chrome was because it was so much faster in terms of WebGL and JS execution, but now that Firefox is regularly improving and competitive, I am much happier with the experience.
- rorrr 15y agoI had to switch to FF 7 (clean install, no addons) for one full day yesterday, and it feels so much slower than Chrome. I used to be a huge FF advocate, until Chrome arrived. At first I stayed on FF and tried Chrome a couple of times. It lacked AdBlock back then, so I didn't switch immediately. There's no way I'm going back to FF now.
- johnconroy 15y agoOn my Win7 install FireFox is incredibly slow to start up and somewhat prone to crash (its FF7)... to my mind it's usable, but far inferior to Chrome, to which I switched about 3 months ago. Just as I type this I realise that MAYBE I've got a few dead extensions in my FF (and have far more extensions installed ). Still though: Chrome all the way for me... except for some reason it won't play a couple old flash games I like
- tytso 15y agoThe fundamental problem with Mozilla is that it is trying to do database queries in its UI loop, and it wants every single piece of state safely on disk after every single click. This results in a huge amount of disk space to get written to disk as you visit every single click. Now I don't know about you, but if my computer crashes, do I really care if everything up to the last click is safely on disk? I wouldn't care at all if the last 10 or 15 minutes of browser history; I don't care if the link colors are a little off due to a some history getting lost on a system crash. Compounding this is the fact that SQLlite was never intended to be a high performance database. It was designed for portability, and ease of setup. Which is fine, but it means that SQLlite uses many more I/O's and issues many more fsync()'s than would be strictly necessary. (In fact, Oracle doesn't issue a single fsync operation on a transaction commit; it uses direct I/O instead.) So even if Firefox manages to get rid of all of the various problems that cause its UI thread to block, this fundamental design mistake will cause them to do excess I/O's, which burns battery and burns SSD write cycles. They would be much better off if they kept all of their state in memory, and 10-15 minutes, updated the on-disk database in a completely asynchronous fashion. And if that means losing some history on a crash, is the fact that a user has visited one web site, but not another, really that important?
- capnrefsmmat 15y ago> The fundamental problem with Mozilla is that it is trying to do database queries in its UI loop, and it wants every single piece of state safely on disk after every single click No, this is not true. Since Firefox 3.5 they have avoided this entirely: https://autonome.wordpress.com/2009/05/05/front-end-performance-in-firefox-35-and-beyond/ https://autonome.wordpress.com/2009/05/05/front-end-performa... This approach has been largely replaced with asynchronous queries off-the-main-thread, since the temporary tables were actually a performance problem: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=552023 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=552023 So they've already done what you've suggested. It turned out to cause problems, and was replaced. AFAIK, there's basically no database queries in the Mozilla UI loop.
- tytso 15y agoThey are using asynchronous queries still, and the problem is that they aren't always asynchronous if there are any long-running queries happening in the background. That's the reason for the hang per the most recent bug. If temp tables were causing problem, then there's something seriously wrong with SQLlite's in-memory temporary tables (or how they are being used). By definition they shouldn't be blocking...
- timjahn 15y agoCouldn't agree more. For the past year+, Firefox has been getting noticeably slower and slower, to the point that I would cringe when clicking that little fox planet and thinking of what I could do in the next 3 minutes while Firefox opened. A few months ago, I finally switched to Chrome 100% and very rarely use the bloated software that is now Firefox. I used to recommend Firefox as THE browser. Now I recommend people uninstall it.
- dendory 15y agoI have a few issues with the current Firefox, but I use it as my full time browser and I never see a crash.. I'm not sure it's fair to criticize Mozilla itself and not some other piece of the ecosystem like plugins or extensions.
- jerhewet 15y ago> totally kills the value of the Awesome Bar I disable the (air quote) Awesome (end air quote) Bar every time I do a fresh install of Firefox. I hate this damned feature with a passion (thank you, but I already know how to type, so get the hell out of my way!), and if the product doesn't have a switch to turn this damned feature off I'll find a competing product that does. Note that so many people loathed this feature that Mozilla added an option to turn the damned thing off. And yes, I always do my Google searches by launching a bookmark that has their damned look-ahead feature disabled as well.
- hoverkraft 15y agoIt's endearing that for each comment presenting a criticism of some aspect of Firefox, there's at least one reply from somebody saying, "But /I/ don't have that problem" (see thaumaturgy's top-ranked post). So great. You don't run into problem x or problem y. But a LOT of people do. And when I sit down at somebody's computer, and they use Firefox, and they have more than a couple tabs open, it's slow. Inconceivably slow. Especially in light of how snappy Chrome manages to be with a big stack of tabs open. And then on a modern computer, a nice shiny new computer, things are pausing erratically, and there's lag, and it's slow, and it feels like 2005. I can hear you leaping to Firefox's defense now: "Sure, but that was only true until 5.323, when they fixed the 'FF is slow as shit' bug!" Or, "yes, but that has never happened to /me/, and I run Firefox on a Pentium I that I spilled a bunch of grape juice on and kick every day." Congrats, you're either an anomaly, incredibly fortunate, or you limit your number of tabs, restart Firefox regularly, and clear out your history daily. All things that I can assure you, ordinary, non-technical people NEVER DO. Chrome managed to make a browser that doesn't become unbearably slow under normal usage patterns. Firefox, for all its moral superiority (and I gladly concede that point), has never managed to do that.
- azakai 15y agoThe fact is, different people experience different things. Many people report that Firefox holds up better with many tabs open than Chrome. Perhaps since Chrome has one process per tab, which ends up straining some OSes. And many people report the opposite. It probably depends a lot on the OS, the specific tabs, their number, what addons they have, etc. There are definitely a variety of bugs that some Firefox users hit, and those users get a frustrating experience. I don't think anyone is denying that. But there are also plenty of users that are clearly very happy. And there are users of other browsers that also hit bugs - for example I recently noticed that Opera was churning my HD for no reason. Never seen that on any browser until then. I had to stop using Opera because of it.
- mmphosis 15y agoI don't use tabs in any browser, never have, never will. Open preferences, and turn off tabs -- easy. I don't see the need for tabs when the OS provides it's own tabs for all the windows I have regardless of whether it's a web page or not. Tabs within tabs, no thanks.
- sova 15y agoThe version of Firefox that is my favorite is actually pre-firefox. Phoenix was an amazing browser -- it was lightweight, incredibly fast, and the UI was simple and _very_ customizable. Phoenix, in my opinion, is the original idea and message behind Firefox: a fast and friendly alternative to bloated browsers. Over the years, Firefox has become HUGE. Why make a Firefox 7, 8, 9 etc. if it just keeps adding more things instead of cutting through the glut with the sword of speediness and optimization? Really, all I want a browser to do is pass the acid3 test and be up and running as quickly as possible. Cut everything else out. I think of Phoenix as like a pamphlet, Firebird (Firefox 1) as a novel, and current Firefox as an encyclopedia. Tucked somewhere within... on a select number of sheets in that amassed bramble of pages and thorns... in there is a browser we all know and love. "I saw the angel in the marble and carved until I set him free" ~ Michelangelo Firefox+Mozilla: please don't stop carving. We appreciate all you do, but it's time to get back to basics.
- mzarate06 15y ago"Firefox, on Linux at least, is busted. It’s busted so bad that it’s painful to use. And it’s been this way ever since Firefox 3 launched" I'm suprised I don't see posts like this more often, specifically about the Linux version. I've been on Ubuntu since 7.04, and Firefox has always felt like beta software, especially when running any Flash media. I get far less crashes on Chrome, so I've started moving away from Firefox and find the Chrome experience much more reliable.
- sciurus 15y agoI have the opposite problem: flash will consistently fail to work on a page in Chromium but work fine in Firefox, even though they're using the same copy of libflashplayer.so.
- pythoning 15y agoDisable unnecessary extensions and plugins and Firefox 7 will be instantaneous and memory efficient. Right now on OS X Leopard I have Hacker News, Slashdot, CNBC and Huffington Post (yuck) open in FF 7.01 and FF is using 179 MB. When I had Firebug and the Stumbleupon tool bar enabled as well as some useless plugins that were enabled by default for media types I don't use, these same tabs were using 440 MB. Google controls my email, phone, SMS and search information, I will not give them browser level access even if they let you opt out of data collection. I like Firefox, it works great now and is rapidly improving. Mozilla's rapid release cycles should be applauded.
- Bo102010 15y agoMy sister complained to me about the "hanging" Firefox problem, and disabling stupid extensions fixed it right up. Firefox really needs to have a profile-cleaning mechanism. These problems people report must be very system-dependent. I've been running Firefox on my 2GB RAM Dell laptop I bought in 2007 for $600 without any issues.
- plasma 15y agoI use to be a fan of firefox, but switched to chrome because: 1) it became slow to open. FF use to open within a few seconds, it now opened in no less than 30 seconds. Strike 1. 1) I then noticed during the 30 seconds that ff was accessing my dish access was crazy. A bug report said it was "working as intended" because it was needing to derive encryption keys for ssl by reading my temp data files on disk. So 30 sec load time from hdd access at startup is working as intended? Strike 2. 3) ff updates brick extensions. They aren't usable after an update. Just annoying to experience each update. 3) I switched my mums pc to chrome after the resent few ff updates. Too much mental energy and effort to click next/yes to each update wizard step, to then see the plugins out of date too etc, just silly. She asks "whats this" each time ff asked about updates, after doing it a few times recently and teaching her it was ok to say yes to, I sill just replaced it with chrome that eliminated the support overhead for me. So I had switched to chrome and it opens fast. No crazy disk access. It doesn't pester me at all about updates, or break things due to new versions. It just works and gets out of my way.
- emp_ 15y agoThe problem with FF is that it came to beat something really bad, now they have to beat something really good and are kinda lost in the inversion of priorities.
- alanh 15y agoSince we’re on the topic of longstanding Firefox issues: Add support for `display: run-in` already. You are the ONLY browser not to support it. http://www.quirksmode.org/css/display.html http://www.quirksmode.org/css/display.html Last I brought this up, I was told: 1. that it wasn’t completely defined, and some edge cases can arise 2. that it 'wasn't necessary' as you could 'solve' the problem by adding more (wrapping) markup 3. that `run-in` was going to be dropped from CSS2.1. None of this is very valid. 1. So do what the other browsers do, and/or when you encounter a weird edge case, fall back to `display: block` (as suggested by the spec). 2. Adding more markup (A) because one browser is being pissy (B) goes against the fundamental philosophies of both CSS (A) and web standards (B). Clearly! 3. It’s only being dropped from the spec because they can finalize the spec if it is 100% implemented by 100% of the major browsers. So this is circular reasoning caused by your ten-year rolling decision to ignore `run-in`. Run-in is a very useful concept (I’m always tempted to use it on /about.html). Please, reconsider.
- bzbarsky 15y ago> So do what the other browsers do What other browsers do is completely insane (e.g. removing a block that a run-in has run into makes the run-in just disappear altogether in WebKit), so implementing it would be actively bad for the web. > It’s only being dropped from the spec because they can > finalize the spec if it is 100% implemented by 100% of > the major browsers. They can finalize the spec as long as every feature is implemented interoperably by _two_ browsers. There are three run-in implementations, and they're completely incompatible. The feature got dropped from the spec because the working group couldn't figure out any way to even define a restricted behavior subset that Presto, Trident, and WebKit implement the same way. So no, Gecko's lack of implemetation here didn't block the spec in any way. The fact that all three existing implementations are completely incompatible with each other and all horribly broken had a lot more to do with it.
- bilban 15y agoOh well, I've been using Firefox since it's pheonix, firebird days! I've never evangalised so hard about a piece of software, and every Linux and Apple user owe it a debt of gratitude, in as much that it was a good cross platform browser. Performance wise, some upgrades have been for the better some for the worst. But don't get too sentimental about past incarnations. I remember there being memory issues in the 2.x line. I saw the browser eating over a half gig of ram once - and I nearly fell off my chair. Those that have dozens of tabs open - I do think you need to ask yourself why? It just slows your computer down. I think we use them as replacement for bookmarks, which says something about the browser UI. I've only recently left 3.6 to try out TenFourFox on my power pc - which at first felt a million times better, but after my initial excitement, I noticed it's a bit of a cpu hog. Idling with Gmail open, it seems to be quite greedy. Which suggests to me that there is an inherent problem with the browser - imagine if I had a handful of web apps open. To say Firefox is broken is a bit strong. It would be better to say it has it's faults and could be faster. If it's DB is a bottleneck - could it be swapped for something else? I do however think the browser UI is in serious need of some love, and could do with some innovation. It's barely changed. For example tab management is dire.
- colanderman 15y ago> Those that have dozens of tabs open - I do think you need to ask yourself why? Spatial memory. If my tabs are not exactly where I left them last week, I utterly forget what I was doing. (I'm one of those people whose room looks like a mess but I can tell you where anything is -- so long as no-one's moved it.) If tabs are slowing things down, then the browser should "background" tabs that haven't been used in a while. (I'd say swap them to disk but the OS does this already!) Pause Javascript, Flash, etc.
- ootachi 15y ago"If tabs are slowing things down, then the browser should "background" tabs that haven't been used in a while. (I'd say swap them to disk but the OS does this already!) Pause Javascript, Flash, etc." This would massively break the web. Even throttling setTimeout() calls for tabs in the background caused breakage.
- Jach 15y agoWhy does there have to be one? I'm happy using both Firefox and Chrome, they each have their own workflows for me. I have a personal gmail account, and a work google apps gmail account, and recently Google decided you can only stay logged into one gmail account at a time per browser session. So if I want both open, I have my personal one in Firefox and my work email in Chrome. That in general leads to the use of using Firefox for personal browsing and Chrome for work-related browsing. In Firefox I have all my bookmarks and Stumble Upon, along with RSS feeds and about 400 tabs opened (not loaded with the Bartab Lite addon and organized in a tree with the TreeStyle Tabs addon). In Chrome I have work-related things open, like our issue list and email, so very few tabs, and I use it for quick googling (work or personal). I also have Firefox using websync so I can get at my tabs from school or other computers. Chrome's also nice for having a Private Browsing mode instantly launchable without closing your other non-private session. Firefox only crashes completely these days, sometimes, when java applets load. Chrome only crashes on pages.
- pshirishreddy 15y agoExactly my thoughts, I have given up on you firefox but even then I try to switch back to you to see if you fixed it, but then again you lost it. I am running it on 64bit Win 7 and I get browser hangs even when I open a new tab.. Fix it before I get too accustomed to other browsers :)
- dbbo 15y agoThe _only_ reason I have stuck with Firefox so long is that Vimperator and later Pentadactyl blow all Chromium vim-like addons out of the water. I have finally got so sick of paging issues and unresponsive scripts in Firefox (sometimes to the extent that even the Magic SysRq key could save me) that lately I've been using Chromium + vrome exclusively.
- SkyMarshal 15y agoSame. Also the Ant Video Downloader is great for getting indie music and remixes from Youtube (and then ripping the audio out of the Flash with Audacity or something). FF's plugin capabilities are unmatched, hopefully their new Continuous Integration/Deployment model will enable them to iterate quicker on the performance and other issues.
- nirbheek 15y agoDeleting your places.sqlite file is the easiest, but the worst way of defragmenting it. The easiest (if you're using btrfs) is to run: `btrfs filesystem defragment ~/.mozilla/firefox/*/places.sqlite` or use ioctl(fd, BTRFS_IOC_DEFRAG, NULL). As far as I know, this can only be done as root. I'm not sure if other filesystems have similar defrag hooks. So the correct approach is to make this facility accessible from unprivileged userspace.
- Havoc 15y agoI've had a hanging issue too. Fixed it by disabling MSE real-time protection (20 hangs per day -> 0). Somehow I don't see MSE causing the hangs on *nix though so perhaps a separate issue. Worth a try though for anyone battling.
- cluboholic 15y agowhats surprising is how well Internet Explorer turns out to be.. when IE10 final comes out I might actually switch to IE for a change. I turned my pc's screen this morning only to find out that the firefox session i had running from the previous day was consuming 2.5gb of memory.. with 3 tabs open.. whatever those tabs were doing all night .. that amount of memory can only be accounted to a memory leak a river can pass through. and yes i'm using the latest version thanks.