5 ms·
"We uncovered all these riches just 10-15cm under the floor slabs. It was completely unexpected." They never did any scans? I remember being a kid and learning
by giantg2 5y ago
"We uncovered all these riches just 10-15cm under the floor slabs. It was completely unexpected."
They never did any scans? I remember being a kid and learning about how some old churches would entomb people directly under the floor (not catacombs).
- Swizec 5y ago> some old churches would entomb people I remember visiting the Westminster Abbey. It’s full of famous dead people. Marked floor tiles and all. Chaucer, Darwin, Newton, Dickens, lots of kings and queens all right under your feet.
- BurningFrog 5y agoCan you actually "walk on their graves"?
- bombcar 5y agoAt the ones in Italy I saw yes, you basically couldn't avoid it there were so many.
- justin66 5y agoIn Westminster Abbey, all except for the grave of the unknown warrior. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unknown_Warrior https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unknown_Warrior
- dghughes 5y agoThat was what irked many Canadians during the trucker tantrum. The nitwits intentionally walked and even pissed on the tomb of the Unknown Soldier in Ottawa.
- cylinder714 5y agoAs well as Stephen Hawking: https://www.westminster-abbey.org/abbey-news/ashes-of-stephen-hawking-buried-in-the-abbey https://www.westminster-abbey.org/abbey-news/ashes-of-stephe...
- lumost 5y agocounter point, wouldn't you have assumed that scans/surveys had been done? This is a famous church after all!
- jjulius 5y agoForgive my ignorance - genuinely curious if there might be a different way of thinking about this. 10-15cm underneath the floor seems so shallow that one would assume it would be picked up with such a scan. With that context, why shouldn't we assume a scan hadn't been performed?
- jjnoakes 5y agoI think the idea was that the people who would consider scanning recently might assume that someone scanned previously, based on the popularity of the site, and decide against it based on that. Though I'd think you'd be able to verify an assumption like that.
- jjulius 5y agoAh, of course - makes sense. Totally obvious in hindsight. Thank you!
- lumost 5y agoIt's pretty tough to verify such things. We don't make reliable records of the absence of something, and while someone at the church would probably know where the records of such a thing occurring were - it would take time to find that person. Not to mention its no ones job to verify assumptions on what things have/have not been done. Which is a good reminder that many things we don't know about are because no one has ever bothered to try, or failing that, they haven't tried hard enough.
- bombcar 5y agoIt may also be "less completely unexpected" or "unexpected for legal reasons". I, knowing nothing, would assume that beneath any old cathedral floor is found something. But admitting that may be a much longer process than "accidentally discovering" it when work begins.
- jl6 5y agoWhat type of scan could be used to detect things like this? Are these done regularly at historical sites?
- beowulfey 5y agoCurious about this as well. There may be something, but I can't think of any technology that can penetrate stone, other than X-ray, and you need a detector on the other side to see the image...
- bcraven 5y agoGPR (Ground Penetrating Radar) would work to detect cavities at least. Some high resolution seismic work also be an option, albeit harder to run.
- tonfa 5y agoSo not sure it would have worked in that case. The statues where basically used to fill the space (mixed up with other things) when the wall (Jubé) they were on was removed on the 17th century (iirc). There were some large (known) cavities around, which is the floor based heating system from the 19th century. The discoveries have been made below/around the heating system. (The other known pieces of the Jubé, now at the Louvre, had afaik been discovered when the heating system was installed in the 19th century, so not a surprise we found more of them when searching the same area)
- asdff 5y agoIt doesn't seem like the notre dame was the best curated cathedral based on my readings since the fire. The alarm system failed and was far from modern, actually very crude with the guard physically walking to where the fire was reported (which wasn't even where it was), vs it automatically calling the fire department and a specialized team directly and not some half asleep security guard on the night shift. The restoration team working on the roof at the time were all smoking cigarettes and investigators still haven't been able to rule out a mere cigarette causing the blaze. No sprinklers to speak of despite similar fires affecting similar buildings and causing similar billions in damage. No other preventative measures as far as i'm aware; other cathedrals have been covering their beams with fire retardant material. The state owns all the cathedrals but doesn't insure them, so restoration currently has been reliant on donors, and to me its still an open question if it will ever be completely restored as planned (since some donors have even backed out). The fact the building survived seems to be because firefighters guarded the towers and allowed the roof to burn itself out on top of the stone vault which contained it.
- hef19898 5y agoFire protection =|= curration. As far as insurance goes, we are talking about a state, slef insurance can work pretty well in those cases. The fire alarm system was acobbled together legacy system, no big surprise in a century old building. Thr number of cathedral fires, or similar fires in other hostorical buildings is negligible. In a sense Notre Dame served as a wake up call.
- asdff 5y agoIt seems the state has not self insured this building if donations are needed to see it rebuilt.
- DocTomoe 5y ago> Sprinklers, fire retardant material A cathedral is - among other things - a memorial to its builders. Changing the building is removing that function. Also, sprinklers may destroy more than they protect. > The state owns all the cathedrals but doesn't insure them, so restoration currently has been reliant on donors, This may be just me, but I find a rebuild-by-donations societally and spiritually a lot more meaningful than just some insurer and/or state handing over money. See also: Dresdner Frauenkirche [1]. It shows that society itself cares about the building, its history and cultural importance and spirituality. [1] https://www.frauenkirche-dresden.de/reconstruction https://www.frauenkirche-dresden.de/reconstruction
- hef19898 5y agoHindsight is always 20/20, isn't it? I like those surprises so, theybare fun to read and show just how much stuff is still out there to be discovered in front of our noses.
- djbebs 5y agoThis was the default method of burial in portugal up until the mid 1800s. There was actually a minor civil war as a result of the authorities stopping the practice.
- travisathougies 5y agoI'm not sure why it would be unexpected. Almost any Catholic cathedral of any import (even the new ones) bury people immediately underneath the floors. It's part of the planning of any church. It would have been even more common and less regulated in the times Notre Dame has seen.