4 ms·
Why isn't it illegal to disrupt a market by undercutting the competition in a long-term structural way? What makes it worse is that money is pumped into it lik
by amelius 5y ago
Why isn't it illegal to disrupt a market by undercutting the competition in a long-term structural way?
What makes it worse is that money is pumped into it like a ponzi scheme (first investors cash, last investors are left with the bubble), which should be illegal in itself.
- willio58 5y agoHow would you go about enforcing the alternative? Force companies to charge the same as the their competitors? And how would you evaluate if the undercut is sustainable or not?
- DoughnutHole 5y agoThis legislation already exists. Predatory underpricing has been a known problem for century, and is already built into antitrust laws. The thing is that it's not generally illegal in its own right - it just forms a component of a potential antitrust case case which could result in the breakup of a company in conjunction with other anti-competitive or monopolistic behaviour. But the precedent is there. A company destroying its competition by operating at a loss and surviving entirely by virtue of external capital injection surely falls at the very least under the spirit if not the letter of antitrust laws.
- Ekaros 5y agoShow the numbers. Your incentive programs can't be more than your profits in a single market. That is the price you charge must be higher than the price it takes to pay for what you provide. Some things could be ignored in calculation like capital investments, operating cost and development costs.
- gruez 5y agoAccording to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumping_(pricing_policy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumping_(pricing_policy), it only seems to be banned if you're doing it as a country. >What makes it worse is that money is pumped into it like a ponzi scheme (first investors cash, last investors are left with the bubble), which should be illegal in itself. IANAL, but part of what makes a ponzi scheme illegal is that there's deception involved (ie. you're taking money for investors and saying that you'll use it to invest in the business, but really you're paying out yourself/other investors). There's nothing illegal about starting a crappy business, paying yourself and/or others (either through salaries or selling your shares), as long you're transparent about it and go through the proper channels (eg. board approval).
- amelius 5y ago> IANAL, but part of what makes a ponzi scheme illegal is that there's deception involved (ie. you're taking money for investors and saying that you'll use it to invest in the business, but really you're paying out yourself/other investors). You're taking investor money, and inflate the bubble. And you prevent the bubble from popping by using the investor money to subsidize rides. Part of the deception is that the true price of a ride is higher in reality.
- gruez 5y ago>You're taking investor money, and inflate the bubble. What counts as "inflating the bubble"? Are you just referring to share prices going up? Taking investor money and spending it on advertising arguably counts as "inflating the bubble" as well. Should that be banned as well? >And you prevent the bubble from popping by using the investor money to subsidize rides. Part of the deception is that the true price of a ride is higher in reality. It seems plausible that consumers were deceived about "the truce price of a ride", but it seems hard to believe that uber investors didn't know.
- kortilla 5y ago> Why isn't it illegal to disrupt a market by undercutting the competition in a long-term structural way? Because you can actually do what the competitor does for cheaper. It sounds like you’re arguing against companies being more efficient than others, which is strange. If you’re saying companies shouldn’t be able to operate at a loss while competitors don’t, you’re arguing against companies that invest in improvements as well, which is also strange. How would you structure the law in a way that allows better companies who invest in more efficient systems to win?
- nullc 5y agoIt's perfectly possible to back out the expenses that go into future improvements and ask if a company is selling a product at a loss. I haven't looked at the data lately, but not that long ago except in a few of the most established markets uber was paying drivers more than they were charging customers. This should be a violation of dumping laws-- but the laws are not enforced against large and highly aggressive entities.