5 ms·
And the way to stop the trafficking is to make the industry legal, and regulated and the workers in it given protection (like pretty much any other worker - OHS
by chii 5y ago
And the way to stop the trafficking is to make the industry legal, and regulated and the workers in it given protection (like pretty much any other worker - OHSA style).
When you make a demand illegal, it doesn't stop that demand, but instead a black market and exploitation happens around it. Making it legal will stop the crimes, make it possible for the police to patrol and arrest people doing the wrong thing, and provide a way for those exploited to seek help without themselves being exposed to another type of danger.
- dylan604 5y ago"What these girls need is a union" --Officer Beatrice Russell, The Wire
- imchillyb 5y ago> And the way to stop the trafficking is to make the industry legal, and regulated and the workers in it given protection... @chii That's complete horseshit... Human trafficking isn't just applied to sex workers. Human trafficking happens with butlers, maids, housekeepers, drivers, gardeners, and other house-staff. Human trafficking is a demand problem not a supply problem. People demand slaves, so a slave market is born; period. Human trafficking is a: 'Humans Suck', problem. Can't stop human trafficking without curing the 'humans suck' thing. Doesn't matter the protections in place, they're there already. Doesn't matter about exposure to the issue, we all know it's happening. Doesn't matter the legal repercussions we enact, the penalties are on the books. Doesn't matter... Humans suck, and there are those who will pay a premium for a literal slave. Humans suck...
- prepend 5y agoNot all humans suck, obviously. I think the solution to demand problems is better options. Tiger poaching to sell their balls as boner pills went away with viagra. Viagra worked better than fake animal snake oils. Domestic robots will solve the human trafficking for domestic slaves as robots will be cheaper and better. I think there’s also social progress as neither I, nor anyone I know has human trafficked to get a butler or whatnot, but 100 years ago that probably wouldn’t have been true.
- dismantlethesun 5y agoI think automation can reduce the dependency on humans but it can't completely eliminate it. People don't use maids because they lack washing machines, microwaves, and food delivery services. The usage of maid service has to do with social customs than it does with actual necessity. > I think there’s also social progress Speaking about the US, there's a general aversion to employing people for personal service jobs. Tech workers making 300k can certainly afford a maid who makes 60k, but actively go out of their way to instead employ a variety of people through 'gig' work and 'apps' to do simple tasks. They simply don't want to be seen as employing a maid, but still get all the benefits of having one (via the errand running service).
- chii 5y agoThere's nothing wrong with employing a maid or any personal assistant services. The problem at hand is _only_ if those people are trafficked, and is not willingly being employed.
- thethethethe 5y agoNot so sure that making it legal alone will stop trafficking (not saying it shouldn't be legal though). People are trafficked to do legal work all the time, like in nail salons, laundromats, construction, canvasing, etc.
- dismantlethesun 5y agoI agree, but I'd like to get back to my original point which is that we should distinguish between human trafficking and normal immigration and outsourcing.
- david38 5y agoShow me the evidence? In Amsterdam, where this is a thing, a large percentage of the girls are actually trafficked. Of course they deny it, because to accuse a pimp means severe repercussions either for herself or family back home.
- otterley 5y agoI’m not sure the question is whether legality completely extinguishes a black market for the goods or services in question. After all, there’s still a black market for individual cigarettes (“loosies”) in poor neighborhoods, even though cigarettes remain legal. It’s a question of whether the situation is substantially and incrementally better in those places where the conduct is lawful than where it isn’t. So if there is less trafficking, I’d say that’s a net win.
- throwaway675309 5y agoI could accuse you of the same thing, if you're saying a large percentage of the girls a.k.a. a majority are trafficked yet they don't report it, how are you coming to that conclusion and getting that data in the first place? Show me your evidence.