3 ms·
"The land tax amount needs to be high enough that the pain of the tax effectively forces owners to improve what's on the land" The author likely isn't aware of
by giantg2 5y ago
"The land tax amount needs to be high enough that the pain of the tax effectively forces owners to improve what's on the land"
The author likely isn't aware of that. If the author made that argument then it would undermine their argument about affecting people's choices minimally or not at all.
- pj_mukh 5y agoThe reform of zoning laws (atleast in California) is blocked by property owners sitting on low-tax properties. Raising the land value tax would be a surefire way to make the opposition disappear as property owners would have to scramble to make their land more productive.
- giantg2 5y agoOr they'll block land value tax just as they so zoning. But you seem to be agreeing with my point that it inherently is designed to affect choices (eg changing land usage to be more productive).
- pj_mukh 5y agoYes, LVT solves problems at multiple levels (removes barriers to zoning reforms and incentivizes more productive use of land). It’s also politically difficult to get passed. However, it seems if we were to try to turn the tide on just one policy, it would be LVT, as it solves a lot of other political problems downstream.
- ItsMonkk 5y agoThe carbon price and dividend shows a great example of how to correctly set incentives. You tax the carbon. That tax money is then put into an account. At the end of the year, every single individual is then given an equal share. The disincentives the use of carbon, while at the same time providing means that a majority of people actually get a net benefit. The land tax should be set so that the price of the house becomes just the price of the house - the cost of the materials and labor. The land value should drop to zero. You then take that money, maybe use some of it for some public goods, might use some of it to get rid of bad taxes like property, income and sales, then give the rest back just as with the carbon tax. The transition needs to be done with care(I heavily like giving everyone tax credits equal to the current value of their land, others like phasing in the tax over decades), but once we are in a land value tax environment everyone will be better off.
- giantg2 5y ago"The land tax should be set so that the price of the house becomes just the price of the house - the cost of the materials and labor." How is that even possible? The root cause of property values being high in specific areas is because demand is high. Without changing demand, I don't see how it can just be labor and materials, especially since the buyer will be paying land value tax as well (since it's not a condo, high rise apartments, etc).
- ItsMonkk 5y agoAn increase in the tax of the land reduces the purchase price of the land. It's the exact same thing in reverse with interest rates over time. As mortgage interest rates drop, the monthly payment is what people look at, so home prices go up.
- giantg2 5y agoI doubt that would actually occur. People with deep pockets could buy it up because they don't care about the tax. They'll just pass the cost on to renters anyways.
- ItsMonkk 5y agoThe reason that most taxes can be passed on is because as price is raised, the supply and demand curve is pushed and less is made. With land, there is a finite supply, none can be created, none can be destroyed, so land value taxes can not be passed on. As the land value will always be zero, there is little value in holding land that you are not using productively, so speculation will drop heavily.
- fennecfoxen 5y ago> With land, there is a finite supply You say all this as if there isn't any meaningful supply-and-demand to be had in the secondary market.
- 5y ago