9 ms·
"The big question land value taxes help answer is: How can a government raise funds without distorting choices and possibly leaving people worse off? If you tax
by giantg2 5y ago
"The big question land value taxes help answer is: How can a government raise funds without distorting choices and possibly leaving people worse off? If you tax income, it provides a disincentive to work. If you tax property, it provides a disincentive to improve the physical buildings on top of the land."
Of course it will distort choices and leave some people worse off. If the author can't see that, then they have a serious bias problem. The whole point of the land value tax is to tax land to encourage higher density and higher cost use. This is especially damaging to people who hold land that is developed around. If I have .75 acres with a single family home and 30 years later the area around me is developed, them I will be financially forced off of my land because I could theoretically put an apartment building on it. We already see standard property tax forcing the elderly out of their homes in many areas.
Please, show me how an appropriately set income tax disincentivizes work. I'm guessing they can't and are equally uneducated on that subject. Income tax would only provide a disincentive to work if the alternative (assistance programs) is more attractive. Which doesn't seem to be the case. The people at that lowest level of income aren't paying (or gets refunded) income tax. Most of the tax at that level on income is for programs like social security and Medicare.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- trgn 5y ago>If I have .75 acres with a single family home and 30 years later the area around me is developed I think this is exactly the framework. The idea is that that person right now is benefitting from increased community wealth (which would be realized in actual moneys upon sale of their property), and hence, should be taxed more. Maybe there are some sophisticated ways to strike a balance, to avoid the situation you are describing. For example, people could pay less tax, but then they (or their estate) cannot pocket the capital gain upon sale of their property. In any case, I think a land tax is much more equitable, because it punishes landholding, rather than punishes improving land. It's the poor use of land right now that I believe is the main driver of poor affordability of housing.
- giantg2 5y ago"(which would be realized in actual moneys upon sale of their property), and hence, should be taxed more." If it were taxed only when realized, that would make sense. "It's the poor use of land right now that I believe is the main driver of poor affordability of housing." It's the preference of a large number of people to live in a small area. You could fix this by capping the number of jobs so that increases in population would be forced to distribute more evenly through the country. This would also address issues like retrofitting existing infrastructure. Otherwise, prices/salaries will increase to make the scheme moot for the upper working class. That's basically how the mess got here in the first place, otherwise competition and property tax would have made a dent. It's all futile if you have FAANG paying absurd money with the capability and will to pay even more.
- trgn 5y ago> If it were taxed only when realized, that would make sense. The tax man does not like this. They like wealthy people to always pay something, each year. Hence, property taxes, so it can siphon off something at least. Also, why we have the alternative minimum tax schedule to prevent stock compensation to be used as a means to avoid taxes. The little old lady _is_ wealthy, a speculator effectively. She owns a valuable asset, the land her home sits on. The fact that she moved there 30 years ago, in your scenario, gives her an inherent claim to that asset. It's because of that same view we basically have Prop 13. Land value tax is a radical statement, in that people should not be able to profit from the value created by the community, of speculation basically. Your scenario highlights nicely how that causes friction with some of our innate sense of right and wrong. Deferring taxes to sale, may be a way to address this, but if history is a guide, it will instead create avenues for tax dodging.
- trgn 5y ago> You could fix this by capping the number of jobs so that increases in population would be forced to distribute more evenly through the country Interesting idea. But wondering how this would work in practice. The Federal government often does this when they distribute their own facilities across the country. Businesses already flock to places were cost of labor is low, but can only that in industries that require less specialization. > otherwise competition and property tax would have made a dent You said it. There is no competition, because housing supply is constrained (zoning), and property tax does not make a dent, because it favors speculation over improvements (further inhibiting competition).
- aperson_hello 5y agoGetting that 0.75 acres to turn over is exactly the point. Incentivizing them to leave (or better yet: subdivide and sell the land) is good for society. This policy only makes sense where zoning is also loosened enough to actually build on the land though...if zoning doesn't allow you to do anything with the land to make more money (building apartments, subdividing, etc.), this just becomes a tax on poor landowners.
- giantg2 5y ago"Getting that 0.75 acres to turn over is exactly the point. Incentivizing them to leave (or better yet: subdivide and sell the land) is good for society." I doubt the affected person feels it's good. Quite frankly, the land value tax ideas seem absurd to me. It's just another redistribution scheme - work hard, retire, get forced off your land via tax. It seems it's the government's and everyone else's desire to just drain people until they have nothing. Make other's lives harder to make your own easier, seems to be the motto of today. It feels like mob rule to me.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIt's not solely a redistribution scheme. It's based on the fundamental principle that the government is the ultimate owner of all land, and private individuals are simply renters. If you accept this to be true and good, then it makes perfect sense. If you are the type that wants to be non dependent on the government, it is deeply grating.
- giantg2 5y ago"If you accept this to be true and good oh, then it makes perfect sense." One can accept that the government owns the land while simultaneously believing that the government can abuse that power, just like a bad landlord can.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI don't disagree, But I do think the idea that the government, not individuals, is the ultimate owner of the land is a fundamental assumption of LVT. Not all people believe this.
- xboxnolifes 5y ago> If I have .75 acres with a single family home and 30 years later the area around me is developed, them I will be financially forced off of my land because I could theoretically put an apartment building on it. We already see standard property tax forcing the elderly out of their homes in many areas. This is one of my current issues with land value tax: pricing out existing residents. One mitigation I think that would help would be only adjusting the LVT of a plot on sale / ownership transfer. It would likely need a bit more nuance than that, as it doesn't quite work with company owned land (doesn't really switch owners like a sfh owner dying). The land will eventually get more efficient use, but there isn't the recurring threat of being priced out of your home.
- rnk 5y agoI guess it's not universal that they don't reduce tax rates for people that are unable to pay, retired elderly? In the Seattle area that's a thing. I want people to be able to pass on their businesses to their kids. But in the US we have this fantasy of inheritance taxes wiping out farm owners. It really only affects giant farms, 11 million is the federal threshold. I don't think society will be bettered by creating evermore trust fund babies. I'm generally in favor of making it hard to pass on wealth that is so high your offspring's families never have to work. I think one of the major challenges of the US in the future is the accumulation of wealth in smaller group of people over time, and the vast amount of income difference between the masses in the US.
- drewcoo 5y ago> show me how an appropriately set income tax disincentivizes work This can only lead to no appropriately set Scotsmen.
- RC_ITR 5y ago>We already see standard property tax forcing the elderly out of their homes in many areas. This was exactly the narrative that led to Prop 13, and what it has led to is the most inflated property market in the entire world because there is nearly no carrying costs for a first (LA), second (Palm Springs), third (Atherton), or fourth (Tahoe) home! Sure, a random subset of boomers can die in their empty 6 bedroom houses now, but countless people are moving to places like Texas where land value/property taxes have keep real estate prices relatively low (due to huge carrying costs). I love CA, but the income vs. wealth/property tax split is what will kill it (at least in its current form).
- rnk 5y agoProposition 13 needs to end. An obvious reason is that property can be owned by a corporation or LLC somehow and you can sell that to someone, effectively selling the house and avoid the proposition 13 tax reset. Proposition 13 has become just yet another way for wealthy people to avoid paying their fair share of taxes.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Proposition 13 has become just yet another way for wealthy people to avoid paying their fair share of taxes. “Has become” implies that was ever not that.
- rnk 5y agoThe thing I was getting at is in other states, maybe all states, they calculate the estimated value and you pay property taxes for land based on that. But with california's special prop 13 system, you don't have to pay more as a property increases in value. Thus the tremendous value of these systems that transfer ownership but avoid that 'tax re-value'. In other places, you can't avoid paying higher taxes as places increase in value, generally.
- jjav 5y ago> nearly no carrying costs for a first (LA), second (Palm Springs), third (Atherton), or fourth (Tahoe) home! You're still paying property tax on all those homes, and that propery tax goes up 2% every year. So "nearly no carrying costs" is not true.
- diebeforei485 5y ago> We already see standard property tax forcing the elderly out of their homes in many areas. It's reasonable to offer options to low-income retirees, for example allowing them to defer property tax payments until death. Texas does this, it works alright. Note that a single family dewlling on .75 acres likely costs the government a lot of money to provide services (plumbing, sewer, electric etc) and is likely already a net debtor to the city/county. This style of development is why American (and Canadian) cities are going broke.
- giantg2 5y agoI think that depends. Many places have private companies providing those services. The hookup costs are usually high. Then they make money on the bills too. It can be 50+ years before it needs to be replaced and another large fee charged. Also, many places could have well and septic, so that's all private costs. Off grid solar is also being a (small) option, where allowed.
- diebeforei485 5y agoMost suburbs were built around 50 years ago, and the bills are coming due.
- missedthecue 5y agoMost suburban/exurban SFH in most regions of the US have their own wells, septic, and plumbing. They're not on city water.
- loeg 5y agoMost suburban SFH is on well water and septic? I really doubt that. Exurban maybe, rural sure.
- bombcar 5y agoYeah, suburbs are developed and on city water. Only in suburbs of rural areas do you find developments where everyone's on septic - the minimum here is 5 acres if you have a septic system, so every development with lots smaller than that is at least on shared septic (at what point shared septic becomes a sewer system is up for debate). Amusingly enough I knew a guy who lived in a suburb of a major CA city, but since his house had been built when it was rural, he was unknowingly on a septic system even though everyone else on his block was on city sewer.
- powerslacker 5y agoIncome tax definitely disincentives work. Source: my life. In the current economic situation I could easily take on another 40/hour a week job. If I do that I only get to keep just over half of the additional pay my extra job would supply. It's not worth my time to work for half my 'hourly rate'. So now there's an extra job vacancy.
- rdtwo 5y agoWhich is normally a good thing. Because we need more people employed as opposed to one person with 2x income
- CapricornNoble 5y ago>>>Because we need more people employed as opposed to one person with 2x income To me that just suggests we have a massive over-supply of labor. Whether labor is employed or not, it comes with a non-zero resource maintenance cost, which exacerbates things like climate risk, etc. Setting tax policies in such a way to maximize the number of meatbags assembling widgets strikes me as directing us towards an erroneous local maximum. Feeding fewer mouths, but doubling the resource allocations to each would be preferred.
- rdtwo 5y agoHow are you going to cull all those extra months?
- giantg2 5y agoIs it really the tax though? It sounds like you have enough money where the utility of extra money is reduced and you would rather do other things with your time. Can you honestly say that you would work 80 hr per week even at full rate? Now let's also consider that your first 40 your job would be full rate too, also providing less incentive for more needing more money.
- Hammershaft 5y ago> Of course it will distort choices and leave some people worse off. If the author can't see that, then they have a serious bias problem. The whole point of the land value tax is to tax land to encourage higher density and higher cost use. Under our current system we subsidize low value land uses by subsidizing the crap out of infrastructure to expansions of suburban areas zoned for single family homes. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Nw6qyyrTeI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Nw6qyyrTeI The only revenue positive portion of nearly any modern american city/town are the few sparse walkable mixed use neighbourhoods and the dense urban core. Policies like a land value tax that push for higher value land uses are necessary to stave off the oncoming wave of municipal bankruptcies America faces. > Income tax would only provide a disincentive to work if the alternative (assistance programs) is more attractive. You are thinking in absolute terms and not on the margins. If the marginal income tax beyond a threshold jumps by %10, then even discounting the increasingly marginal value of each additional dollar earned I will value the return on work less when I hit that tax threshold.
- giantg2 5y ago"The only revenue positive portion of nearly any modern american city/town is the dense urban core." Even then most places rely on state and federal grants to make ends meet. Do you have have any examples of cities actually net positive without outside funds? "You are thinking in absolute terms and not on the margins." I think my position still stands. The claim was that people would not work because income is taxed. What you describe is reduction in work incentive when you hit the next bracket. I'm saying that in order to not work you would have to value the support systems more than making any income. And of course, most people are no where near the level income that they don't want to make more. We're pretty talking about the 1% ($600k), or maybe the top 5% ($240k). So not particularly useful for designing policy for the other 95-99%. In fact, it could be beneficial for those high earners to drop out and allow new people to take their place.
- Hammershaft 5y ago> Even then most places rely on state and federal grants to make ends meet. Do you have have any examples of cities actually net positive without outside funds? Did you watch the video? It's short and demonstrates incredibly well through data the problems with our model of urban development. > I think my position still stands. The claim was that people would not work because income is taxed. What you describe is reduction in work incentive when you hit the next bracket. I'm saying that in order to not work you would have to value the support systems more than making any income. On the margins, income taxes lower the incentive to work more hours.
- quickthrower2 5y agoOwnership of land is damaging to those who don’t. Not owning land is a tax to be paid to those who do. There is no perfect solution but incentivising people to sell their tennis court filled country castle pad so that 1k people have somewhere to live (and knock on effect would be fewer homeless people) sounds like a balanced compromise.
- sfblah 5y agoIncome taxes in California + US Federal are high enough that I don't really think it's worth it to try to get my income above, say, $500k a year. So, for me, income taxes absolutely disincentivize work. I actually had a second job for a while and quit it because of this.
- rnk 5y agoReally? Who doesn't want more money? Also, you're not necessarily working that much harder to make a million instead of 500k. Thousands of people who read headline news are making 500k a year in the software industry. The year I made a million dollars, a lot of it in stock from a fang company, I wasn't working twice as hard as the years I made 500k.
- sfblah 5y agoI hear you, but when half of that gets taxed away, it makes a difference. In my case, I've found I get a much better WLB at $500k.
- woah 5y agoProperty tax already means that your tax will go up. Your scenario seems like scaremongering
- yes_really 5y ago> Please, show me how an appropriately set income tax disincentivizes work. I'm guessing they can't and are equally uneducated on that subject. Income tax would only provide a disincentive to work if the alternative (assistance programs) is more attractive. Which doesn't seem to be the case. It's almost tautological that taxing income disincentivizes work. Of course, it does not mean that a 30% income tax will disincentivizes work so much as to completely stop it (the "optimal" point in the Laffer curve is around the 30% point), but it is obvious that on the margin people will start dedicating less to work if their returns are lowered due to taxes.
- schoen 5y ago> Please, show me how an appropriately set income tax disincentivizes work. The most relevant phenomenon is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deadweight_loss#Deadweight_loss_of_taxation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deadweight_loss#Deadweight_los... What might be confusing is that relatively few people are incentivized by an income tax to do no work at all, but many people may be incentivized to do less paid work than they otherwise would. (In fact, under idealizing assumptions which don't quite apply in all cases, you would expect every person facing an income tax to do at least very slightly less paid work than without the tax.)
- typ 5y agoThe effect of income taxes is not simply to disincentivize work like one would imagine. Top talents who are able to afford the cost choose their tax residence due to income tax. Even in the US, it would influence people's career decisions about where to live/work. Businesses also take the taxes into account when choosing countries/states to invest or build facilities.
- c1ccccc1 5y agoObviously we shouldn't just "turn on" a LVT for land that previously didn't have the tax until now. The idea would be that whenever the government is selling land to private individuals / corporations, instead of setting a property tax of a few % on the land, it sets a land value tax of about 70%. That means that less revenue is made from the immediate sale, but the land will bring in additional revenue over time. So most land would continue to use the original system, while a slowly increasing amount would be "LVT" tagged when it passes through the government's hands. To avoid the "being forced out" situation you describe, there would be a few options: 1. Live in a rural area that is very unlikely to be developed. 2. Make sure to buy a piece of land that is "original system" tagged instead of "LVT" tagged. 3. Buy "property tax increase" insurance. If your land's value goes up, the insurance pays the difference, and you don't notice the cost change. If those 3 options don't turn out to be sufficient, then probably there's some hacky provision that could be tacked on, like LVT doesn't go up for individuals until they sell their land, or something along those lines. But of course that should only apply to people who are actually living in their own homes, not to landlords. Anyway, the question is, why go to all this trouble? Why have an LVT at all? The answer is the following: No one created the land. When you're renting from a landlord, some of your rent is for the building, and all the effort the landlord puts into maintaining it. It makes sense that the landlord should be paid for that. Under the current system, though, some of your rent is for the land. That makes a lot less sense. Why pay the landlord for the land, even though the landlord didn't create the land? Imagine some travellers find an oasis in the desert surrounding a fresh water spring. They (for some reason) decide to settle there, and need to decide how to split up the daily 10 000 gallons of water that the spring produces. I think that probably the travellers would decide to split the water evenly: 100 travellers means that each gets 100 gallons per day. It would be weird if they decided that some of them should be considered "waterlords" and get 2000 gallons per day, and the rest should get 0, and would have to pay the waterlords for their daily water. Splitting the water evenly wouldn't be communism or anything. If Alice uses her share of the water to grow food, she wouldn't be obliged to share that food with anyone else, since she's the one who laboured to produce it. Everyone still gets to keep or sell whatever they produce, but the spring gushes whether anyone works or not, so the water gets split evenly. Objection: Maybe some settlers will specialize in farming, and some won't. Obviously the farmers will need to use more water, so shouldn't they get a higher fraction of the water? Answer: Yes, the farmers will use more water, but they can get it by trading the food they produce with their neighbours in exchange for water to put on their crops. The farmers would essentially be selling their ability to convert water into crops. Objection: Wouldn't it be an equally good system if instead of trading in water people could trade shares in fractions of the water produced? So 10 000 shares are split equally among all the initial settlers, and each share is worth 1 gallon per day. Answer: This has a few issues. The main one is that as new people are born and grow up, they would get an equal fraction of the water to everyone else in the "divide up the daily water production" scheme, but they would get nothing in the "divide up the shares" scheme, since all the shares would have been distributed already.
- tome 5y ago> Please, show me how an appropriately set income tax disincentivizes work. Here's a proof that income tax disincentivizes work: Would you work an extra hour a week if it were paid at 1000x your normal rate? I confidently assert that you would. Would you work it for 100x your normal rate? Almost certainly. 10x? Probably. 0.5x? Probably not. 0.01? Almost certainly not! So, earning more or less than some threshold hourly amount incentivizes or disincentivizes that hour to be worked. This is exactly the effect of income taxation. Now, I sympathise with people who have worked hard, paid tax on income and bought property. They don't want to, in addition, be charged to own that property. I myself am in the same boat. But I also sympathise with people who have studied hard and learned skills. They don't want to, in addition, be charged to use those skills! The only argument I can see for income tax over property tax is "I expected the former but not the latter, so you've violated my expectations". I don't find that argument very convincing.
- dllthomas 5y agoThis only obviously holds locally. If we imagine a world where the only use for money was to bid in an auction for a single good against others subject to the same taxes (and without pre-existing savings), changing these rates shouldn't affect how much I want to work. I expect that our world does not sufficiently resemble that one for your conclusion to be wrong, but I think we don't get it for free.
- jjav 5y ago> The whole point of the land value tax is to tax land to encourage higher density and higher cost use. This is why I disagree so strongly with the idea. Do I want to live in a society where every square meter of land is forced to be used for the highest possible ROI? No, absolutely not. There is already far too much drive to maximize profit on everything. We need less of that, not more. Just a small sampling of land uses which are economically suboptimal: parks, playgrounds, bike trails, dog parks, community sport areas, nature conservation areas/greenbelts. And so many more. I want to live in a town which has a lot more of all of the above, not less. If the only thing that mattered was maximizing profit per square foot, it would be optimal to raze all the above and build them up with high-density housing towers.
- ItsMonkk 5y agoNot true. It's not each piece of land that you are optimizing, but the community as a whole. If you were to build up Central Park, yes, you could get more income for that space. Because people get less access to things that they want, everyone would move out to CT or NJ. Less tourists would come. The surrounding land would all drop, it would hurt NYC land values as a whole. In fact, with proper zoning in place that does not incentivize scarcity, one thing we would quickly find is that middle housing would finally be able to be built, and that middle housing would then lead to less skyscrapers in all but the biggest cities and central-most downtowns.
- jjav 5y ago> It's not each piece of land that you are optimizing, but the community as a whole. If you were to build up Central Park, yes, you could get more income for that space. Because people get less access to things that they want, everyone would move out to CT or NJ. Less tourists would come. The surrounding land would all drop, it would hurt NYC land values as a whole. How do you propose finding the optimal balance, and even tricker, to encode that into the tax code for computing LVT for each lot? Let's say paving over all of Central Park with highrise apartments makes NYC less attractive (I'll agree) and that leads to people moving out and housing prices collapsing (I'm not so sure about that, people might tolerate less nice living in exchange of economic opportunity of NYC). What if only 50% of the Central Park land area is built up? Or 64%? Where exactly is the sweet spot that will extract as much value as possible while still not driving too many people away? That's all going to be very speculative, there's no way to know exactly. And to encode the optimal answer into tax law? Seems impossible. Also when you say: > It's not each piece of land that you are optimizing, but the community as a whole. Every proponent of LVT I've heard, always says that every plot of land should be taxed based on its maximum economic potential. I had not heard arguments about trying to balance it over the community as a whole. And how do you encode that balancing goal into tax law?