3 ms·
We should have a law that says that any product sold at a large scale should first be approved by a consumer organization. Let's stop producing junk that works
by amelius 5y ago
We should have a law that says that any product sold at a large scale should first be approved by a consumer organization. Let's stop producing junk that works against the consumer's interest.
- richardwhiuk 5y agoThat sounds eerily like censorship.
- amelius 5y agoI don't see the analogy. They can still publish the blueprints for the device, they just can't produce it at a mass scale. The market creates a natural power imbalance, and the market has shown that it can't act responsibly here. A better analogy is the power imbalance in the relation company-versus-employees, where you create a union to break the imbalance. Except now it is a "union" of consumers. Another analogy is democracy: let's not produce stuff that a few CEOs and shareholders want, but instead, let's produce stuff that the world wants. Also helps with resource/climate/environment problems.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> any product sold at a large scale should first be approved by a consumer organization You’ve created a government body gating market access. Surprise! Only the incumbents’ products get approved. Even if it doesn’t get corrupted, the wait times and specialist skills required to prepare the requisite documentation and answer questions properly will add a huge barrier to entry for new entrants.
- amelius 5y ago1. It only becomes active after (say) 10K-100K products are sold (threshold can depend on market/product type). 2. You can still go to court where a jury of consumers can look into the case. 3. Surprise, without government intervention the market doesn't function like it should (see this very article).