7 ms·
AMD's 8-core cpu for desktops arrives
- ck2 15y agoIt's kinda sad to see AMD slipping behind even with their best effort. I was a huge fan for years and this i3 I am using now is my first Intel cpu since the 80386. I was thinking maybe it's just that the OS and software is not parallel enough yet but the benchmarks show that's not the only issue.
- felipemnoa 15y agoCould you elaborate a bit more as to why AMD is slipping?
- ck2 15y agoThey put a bunch of effort into this cpu but in several cases it's actually slower than their older 6-core. They have a whole new approach coming but that will take at least a year to appear. Lately all AMD seems to be doing is helping keep Intel prices lower (I got this 4ghz i3 with motherboard for $100 after rebate, which is incredible compared to Intel pricing in the past).
- inconditus 15y agoThe equivalent price Intel chip gives more bang for the buck and improved lower power usage. See the performance section of the article.
- wmf 15y agoIt looks like Bulldozer is a "speed racer" design that was intended to run at 4-5 GHz. It's hard to tell the cause from the outside, but either due to 32 nm fab problems or design problems they're shipping it at 3.6 GHz. Given the fates of NetBurst and POWER6, I cannot imagine why AMD chose such a design. Another way to look at it is that the market will bear ~$1,000 pricing for Intel's flagship processors but <$300 for AMD's. That's sad. (I remember paying $700 for the first Athlon FX.)
- Symmetry 15y agoI've heard that the main problem is that they don't really have the expertise and manpower anymore to do a full custom design, but are using a more ASIC style process - influenced by the ATI folks. Also, this is an all-new architecture and so you'd expect that it would be unpolished and untuned. Intel hasn't done anything as drastic as what AMD has done here since the introduction of the Pentium Pro. Well, there was the Atom but Bobcat (also an all new design) is able to beat that the same way that Intel is beating AMD at the high end. In theory, this will let AMD mix and match components easily, and quickly synthesize new designs with the right mix of Bulldozer cores, Bobcat cores, GPU cores, memeory controllers, etc to meet market demand. I haven't seen any evidence that this is actually happening, though, or that its worth the price. By contrast, Intel has huge design teams that can afford to hand tune a range of designs to changing circumstances. Its also true that though GF has a more tolerant set of design rules in its 32nm process, it pays for it in lower overall performance compared to Intel's process at the same node. I'm not sure the high frequency design was a kiss of death. In terms of pipelining it doesn't seem any more aggressive than the Power7, which has been very successful. The Power7 benefits from 4-way SMT, though, and that probably helps hide the cache latency that is hurting Bulldozer so much. EDIT: See example here: http://realworldtech.com/forums/index.cfm?action=detail&id=123141&threadid=123055&roomid=2 http://realworldtech.com/forums/index.cfm?action=detail&...
- joel4039 15y agoAMD has lost their edge. They used to compete with low priced processors that were pretty much matched, within a few percent, with Intel's offerings. With their newest flagship Bulldozer processors retailing at 279.00 you can save yourself $60.00 and go with the a Intel i5-2500k and have nearly the same performance. The AMDs may do well in highly multithreaded scenarios, but their single core performance isn't stellar.
- yuhong 15y agoYea, they compensate by having twice the cores with each pair sharing a floating-point units, which works differently than Intel's HT used in Sandy Bridge. Basically which will be better depends on the workload.
- simpsond 15y agoThey are not totally slipping, but they are slipping in the high end desktop realm. They have not been able to compete with Intel, in terms of high end desktop performance, since the Core 2 arrived. Their first quad core was a train wreck... and the much anticipated (by me at least) Bulldozer seems to be at the level of Intel's year old Sandy Bridge.
- evandena 15y agoThe benchmarks are pretty disappointing.
- alperakgun 15y ago"The great revolution that AMD has been talking about... an eight-core desktop processor", is it really a revolution? an 8-core smartphone would be next..
- pjscott 15y agoLet's be more precise about what they've done. It's a processor designed for high single-core performance -- much higher than smartphone processors -- with good power-efficiency, on a much smaller die than would ordinarily be required for that. And 8-core smartphone processor is very different from an 8-core desktop/server processor, and much simpler.
- latch 15y agoAre you saying bulldozer is "designed for high single-core performance"? Because that's exactly where it's failing to deliver, and what will continue to lead to market share.
- pjscott 15y agoIt delivers very high single-core performance compared to smartphone processors, which was the subject under discussion. How it stacks up against other desktop/server processors is important within that market, but a distinguishing feature of desktop and server processors is that they all have high single-core performance.
- pnathan 15y agoParallax Propellor has 8 cores, a dev kit was $100, last I looked.
- pjscott 15y agoIt's very cool -- when I was working with microcontrollers, I would have loved to have eight independent cores -- but it's definitely meant more for embedded work, like industrial robotics, than for smartphones.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Deutscher 15y ago* Bulldozer's single-threaded performance is worse than that of its predecessor Thuban (2008). * It is barely competitive with the Intel 2500k, a chip about 2/3rd its size, less than half its transistor count and 100W more efficient (system-level) at load. I may be missing a thing or two, but the fact that this is all AMD has to show after 4 years of research and a 32nm process is just astounding.
- osivertsson 15y agoHas anybody seen any benchmarks of this CPU in Linux? I'm wondering how it would fare in a build server...
- fleitz 15y agoHow many build servers are actually constrained by CPU and not IO? If your build times are in excess of a few minutes it's probably better to distribute the build across many machines rather than trying to build one server to rule them all. As for benchmarks there are extensive reviews online of the bulldozer branded as "Opteron". http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=amd_bulldozer_linux&num=2 http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=amd_b...
- unsigner 15y agoIn my experience (game development, hundreds of thousands of LOCs of C++), compiling is purely CPU limited if your HDD isn't utterly braindead (e.g. at or above normal desktop 7200 rpm levels).
- ajross 15y agoBuilds are almost always CPU bound. If you're looking at a large C++ project, overwhelmingly so.
- nossid 15y agoNot a Linux test, but Anandtech built Chromium with VS which should ballpark it. It performed worse than the Phenom II X6 at that. http://www.anandtech.com/show/4955/the-bulldozer-review-amd-fx8150-tested/7 http://www.anandtech.com/show/4955/the-bulldozer-review-amd-...
- caf 15y agoAs an integer-heavy workload, it should do pretty well - provided that your projects are parallel-buildable (eg. make -j works).
- caf 15y agoThis article claims a 20% improvement over the Core i5 2500k compiling the Linux kernel: http://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/AMD-faehrt-den-Bulldozer-Achtkerner-FX-8150-vor-1359488.html http://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/AMD-faehrt-den-Bulldo... (auf Deutsch)
- thepointyhat 15y agoDoes anyone really need this for a desktop machine other than to wave their dick? I think IO is much more of an issue these days and most heavy compute tasks are probably better done on a graphics card. I'm sitting here in front of a lowly and cheap i3 desktop which handles some quite amazingly heavy tasks with no problems at all.
- steve8918 15y agoAm I the only one that would prefer cooler, quieter CPUs rather than 8-way monstrosities with big fans and creating lots of heat? I have 2 systems running in my room, a 2-core desktop, and a 2 CPU quad-core system that I run virtualization on. This system replaced about 4 other towers that I had running, each doing various things like running web server, dns, etc, but basically just sitting idle and sucking up electricity. I want to upgrade to a newer desktop, but I really don't want this thing to generate more heat, use more electricity and have a loud fan. Before, I wanted to upgrade my video card but couldn't find a reasonable graphics card that didn't have a fan.
- rdtsc 15y agoHmm, maybe instead of 2 system you can now have one 8 core system that runs virtualization and your desktop? Now you have one power supply, less fans, ... There is nothing inherently loud or power consuming about 8-way monstrosities. Do you remember Pentium IV or even Alpha (One of those things could heat up a room plenty well in the winter).
- ori_b 15y agoUnfortunately, you can't hide the loud, hot running monstrosity that you use for the heavy work under a staircase in the basement if you use it as a desktop.
- ori_b 15y agoUnfortunately, you can't hide the loud, hot running monstrosity that you use for the heavy work under a staircase in the basement if you use it as a desktop.
- pjscott 15y agoBulldozer is aimed more at servers; for your needs, AMD has the "Fusion" line of processors: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMD_Fusion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMD_Fusion That said, the Bulldozer chips have relatively power-efficient cores, and it will shut off power to cores that you aren't using. If your system isn't particularly loaded, there's no reason for it to burn enormous amounts of electricity.
- rkalla 15y agoXBit did a good calling out what AMD is doing here that is different (and in its infancy, disappointing with traditional benchmarks). AMD has decided to step back from the brink of maximum-speed per core, to maximum-cores-per-chip. If you look at the Anand benchmarks: http://www.anandtech.com/show/4955/the-bulldozer-review-amd-fx8150-tested/7 http://www.anandtech.com/show/4955/the-bulldozer-review-amd-... you'll see in very multi-threaded applications (like compression or encoding) the AMD CPU actually keeps pace with the 2600k; in other applications where it is more important to have faster single threads of execution, the Intel 2600k pulls ahead by a drastic amount though. These are the early days, but if AMD gets this down to 22nm next year and puts 16 cores on a desktop PC -- each core may be only running at 4Ghz, but in a scientific computing or server environment where you have 16, 4Ghz cores as opposed to 4, 6Ghz cores on some equivalent Intel can make a big difference. The new Bulldozer platform looks to be a strategic company gamble on all fronts (more cores, less speed per core) that could win AMD big in the server space (which is exploding) and in scientific computing environments. I'm not saying the numbers aren't disappointing, I was hoping to see some big ones in there to. I'm only pointing out that this isn't quite apples to apples, and when it is (e.g. straight multithreaded benchmarking) the comparisons look OK. All that said, I'm sure Intel has something waiting in the wings (e.g. 2800k) to shit all over this party and beyond that we have tri-gate IvyBridge CPUs next year that will hopefully bring a much-needed* leap to CPU performance. * "needed" as defined by "my impatient ass likes fast things.
- watmough 15y agoWhat kind of leap? The jump to an i52400 has been enormous for me. It's hard to imagine another similar one over the core 2 duo I was on before. Do you think AMD are going to be ready for memristor based memory?
- pdubs 15y agoI think you'd be right if AMD could halve their power consumption to at the very least match Intel.
- rkalla 15y agoNo doubt they have some tightening to do, but they are always a generation behind Intel when it comes to fab; when they get the new architecture onto 22nm I think things should even out, but then Intel will be jumping to something much smaller at that point in a tick-tock cycle anyway. Cat and mouse.