8 ms·
Anatomy of the Presidential Motorcade (2016)
- cstross 5y agoMultiple USAF heavy transports are required to facilitate a single presidential visit, and those flights come at a steep cost. This seems a peculiarly American way to go about things ... specifically, it's not actually about protection or transport at all: it's about signalling imperial primacy through conspicuous misuse of resources. I live in Edinburgh, capital of Scotland, about a mile away from a royal palace that is sometimes occupied by actual royals. (Typically Princess Anne; sometimes Charles, William, or the Queen when she's in town to open a session of the Scottish Parliament.) And as I live on a main road they sometimes drive past my front door. A royal motorcade scaled for the heir to the throne and his wife, or the queen's sister, or a similar level of VIP, consists of: two SUVs (typically Range Rovers) and 2-4 motorcycles. One SUV for the VIPs (presumably armoured), one for additional security/backup, and the bikes leap-frog the SUVs to stop traffic at intersections so the SUVs don't need to slow down. The SUVs are notable for not having number plates (that's normally illegal in the UK). And for special appearances the VIP carrier is sometimes replaced with a classic limousine -- I've seen Daimlers and Rolls-Royces used (older, pre-BMW-ownership ones). The queen isn't a common visitor these days (she's 95, doesn't travel much during the pandemic) but used to rate something not much larger: add another couple of Range Rovers to the convoy and that's about it. What they don't do is shut down an entire city and have military helicopters and transports flying around the place, signaling what's going on. The emphasis seems to be on being discreet and agile, and able to avoid any possible threats notified by intelligence. If you've got a convoy involving a hundred people you can't simply pick another route. Now, obviously the rules are a bit different for the leader of the global imperial hegemon: projecting an image of invulnerability and overwhelming might goes with the territory. And a formal parade like a Presidential Inauguration or a state visit calls for laying on the pomp, ceremony, and escort size (a UK example might be the Trooping of the Colours, or the state opening of Parliament and the monarch's speech). But if the objective of the presidential motorcade is to safely deliver POTUS to a speaking engagement then safely extract him afterwards, with elbow-room for close protection duty, then 95% of this motorcade arrangement is a very expensive waste of people and equipment: it's signalling that the subject of the motorcade is important, not actually accomplishing anything tangible.
- jacquesm 5y agoThat project of 'overwhelming might' looked pretty silly when they got the beast stuck a while ago. Also, pretty wild to see your comment downvoted, someone must feel upset that you aren't giving 'proper respect' or something to that effect. Have an upvote.
- eatonphil 5y ago> That project of 'overwhelming might' looked pretty silly when they got the beast stuck a while ago. I hadn't heard of this before. Video for the curious: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yo5zH0Il8B0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yo5zH0Il8B0.
- jacquesm 5y agoI would love to hear the radio traffic around that incident, as well as to read the post mortem.
- eatbitseveryday 5y ago> Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- eatonphil 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/leaders https://news.ycombinator.com/leaders
- eatbitseveryday 5y agoWhat’s your point?
- jacquesm 5y agoIt normally does, but in this case it's funny. I'll petition Dan to tell me off. Better?
- t3rabytes 5y agoInteresting timing on this post, I got stuck on the highway in Greensboro NC behind a police blockade on Thursday for what I can only assume was the presidential motorcade making its way from downtown back to the airport!
- sandworm101 5y agoOr it was a training event. There are more fake convoys out there than real ones, and yes they will block traffic during practice events.
- kappuchino 5y agoWeird ... some link (for me: "basic layout") directs to an eyewear site?! I'm confused.
- martyvis 5y agoI was only commenting to my wife on how things are so much different here in Australia. Thankfully we have nothing of the threat model here (which primarily is the almost unfettered access to high powered firearms they have in the USA). Our Prime Minister was travelling in the state of Tasmania last week and I'd wager the security detail consisted of one or two standard state police motorcycles, one or two standard patrol cars, the PMs limo ( a pretty standard luxury sedan) and maybe a few unmarked cars like this one that had an awful accident. (I actually think maybe 10 years ago I passed the PMs car on a freeway and it was barely noticeable) https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-14/prime-minister-election-security-car-crash-tasmania/100992714 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-14/prime-minister-electi...
- sandworm101 5y agoIt isnt the guns. Canada has basically all the same guns and the Canadian PM doesnt travel with an army. It is about information. The US president's every movement is announced publicly days or weeks in advance. His advance team openly secures routes ahead of his convoy. They are effectively daring someone to try something. Cananda does it differently. Thier PM's exact moves are not announced to the world the week before. And when he goes somewhere he doesnt bring an army, rather he uses mostly local police who know the terrain. Thats the benifit of having a national police force (RCMP). The american secret service isnt integrated with the hundreds of different police agencies in the US. They dont trust them. So they bring thier own army every time, to face down all the potential troublemakers who know exactly where the president is going to be standing almost to the minute.
- jacquesm 5y ago> all the potential troublemakers Some of which may be part of those local police forces.
- toast0 5y agoEven dead presidents get a substantial motorcade. They drove Reagan past where I was working a noon to midnight shift (on Wilshire Blvd), and all sorts of motorcycle police came and shut down cross traffic at the intersections so he didn't need to wait in traffic.
- mc32 5y agoWhy not use a couple of motorcycles and two MRAPs, one main and one replacement in the even the main suffers an incident?
- bombcar 5y agoBecause half the whole point is to put on a show for everyone.
- jacquesm 5y agoHere is a picture of the Dutch Minister President and his motorcade: https://www.ad.nl/den-haag/alleen-rutte-fietst-nog-naar-zijn-werk-de-haagse-autostraten-zijn-weer-vol~a09bbf33/ https://www.ad.nl/den-haag/alleen-rutte-fietst-nog-naar-zijn... Unfortunately even he had to have personal protection during the last couple of years for a period because of threats against him with respect to an attack or an attempt to kidnap him.
- leobg 5y agoCool dude. Makes me want to emigrate to NL.
- belter 5y agoThe picture just says 1000 words but not in the way meant. This just shows the power is somewhere else ;-)
- belter 5y ago
- jacquesm 5y ago> could also be considered upsetting It could be but not by anybody with a normal sense of proportion. > As if somewhat cooler than Presidents or Prime Ministers who have large security motorcades Intent matters. All I wanted to show is the contrast between the leader of one first world country and another. Obviously Obama or Biden are bigger targets and therefore need more security. > Just because he uses a bicycle for 400 meters as a photo op, between two Hague government offices while being discretely followed by the security services. You are inserting your own facts here. He actually does bike from home normally, as have many Dutch presidents before him. The main reason is that the Hague where our seat of government is is actually much faster to traverse by bike and if he were to upset the city twice or more daily with motorcades it would ding his popularity considerably, besides that even the right wing in NL has some sense of environmental responsibility. > The truth is that if you are the prime minister of a small country, a country that in the last major war surrendered in 3 hours, the Netherlands security is outsourced to NATO, or in other words, you are 100% dependent on US Military Power. That's a revolting little bit of writing. NL surrendered after being overrun by the Germans, which took 5 days, not three hours, and they just had a very large city bombed to rubble and were promised 'more of the same'. It made good sense from a lives saved perspective with the note that at that time it wasn't yet apparent what kind of atrocities would follow. > If you are small economy, that could not survive without being integrated in the European Union, so means you have small voting power as portion of all the votes of all other 27 countries. So you will have to follow the decisions of the other countries. NL is small, but it actually isn't all that small an economy. It's the 7th largest in absolute sense and the 6th largest per capita. And it isn't nearly the 7th or 6th country by size. > And finally if you are a prime minister who does not have a majority, so you are at the head of the government only because you agreed with the politics of every small coalition party, so that you could stay prime minister. So you are implementing the policies of somebody else. Coalition governments are a fact of life here and I consider that to be a very good thing. Those 'policies of somebody else' require give and take rather than 'might makes right' where one administration continuously tries to undo what the previous one established. > In other words, the reason why the US President has such a complex motorcade is because he has real economical, military and political power and upsets a lot of equally powerful parties. So he has the threats commensurate to his real power. That is undoubtedly true, but that does not warrant your ridiculous response. > The fact the US President goes on a big motorcade is what allows the Dutch prime minister to promenade himself on a bike ;-) And that just isn't correct. Really, your comment is in pretty bad taste.
- ilamont 5y agoThe protective detail of the Secret Service are masters of what they do, and they know how to optimize their capabilities against a potential enemy's weaknesses and strengths. My respect for SS capabilities declined greatly earlier this month after it was revealed 4 highly trained agents including one on the First Lady’s detail were accepting bribes from bogus DHS agents with high powered weaponry who are likely foreign agents. A postal inspector figured it out, not the SS. If SS can’t discern an obvious threat and ethical violation, how good are they at the other tasks they are supposedly masters of? Another question: why do they have anything to do with investigating counterfeit currency? That particular responsibility should be reassigned to another agency at Treasury or FBI so Secret Service can concentrate on their core mission of protecting the president.
- eatonphil 5y ago> Another question: why do they have anything to do with investigating counterfeit currency? That particular responsibility should be reassigned to another agency at Treasury or FBI so Secret Service can concentrate on their core mission of protecting the president. The Secret Service is under the Treasury. Its original core task was counterfeit currency. Only after McKinley was assassinated (20 years after Garfield was assassinated (15 years after Lincoln was assassinated)) I think was it expanded to also include protecting the president.
- bombcar 5y agoGiven that currency has dead presidents on it you’d think it’d be a conflict of interest to have the Treasury protecting live ones.
- ricktdotorg 5y agoFYI Secret Service is no longer part of Treasury, has been part of DHS since March 1 2003.
- eatonphil 5y agoAh I forgot about that. Thanks.
- eatonphil 5y agoWhile reading on tangents I noticed this kind of funny collection of breaches the Secret Service didn't know about during the Obama years. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/long-list-breaches-scandals-secret-service-under-obama-n215751 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/long-list-breaches-scan...
- jacquesm 5y agoThat is a pretty chilling read, not quite funny, at least one of those had the potential to go pear shaped in a hurry.
- closeparen 5y agoI suppose there’s a whole essay about culture and masculinity to be written here, and someone probably has, but color me unsurprised that people who volunteered and were selected to travel the world as some of America’s most elite fighters would also get up to some drunken sexual adventures in their downtime.
- bannedbybros 5y ago
- AlbertCory 5y agoPersonal stories from the edge: I was at Google (GW3, down Charleston from the main buildings). The Turkish PM was visiting, and they had the intersection at Charleston & Rengstorff blocked off for him. OK, I don't know who ordered that. Another time, there were two black SUVs parked in the "expectant mothers" spaces, and a guy in a suit with an earpiece standing nearby doing nothing. I walked in between the SUVs, just to see what would happen (nothing). I don't know who was visiting, and I'm they wouldn't tell me.
- daenz 5y ago>This vehicle, along with others in the motorcade, may also provide laser warning (used by some anti-tank guided missiles) and radar warning for the convoy. If a threat is detected, such as one using a laser for designation and ranging, or if a threat radar were detected, IR smoke, chaff and targeted jamming could be deployed, disrupting such an attack. This suggests that if someone pointed a powerful laser at the vehicle, it would deploy countermeasures. I don't suggest anyone do that, but wouldn't we have seen something like this by now?
- ReactiveJelly 5y agoMaybe laser guidance for weapons uses some detectable carrier wave and not just an always-on laser? That way an enemy couldn't jam laser guidance easily with fake laser dots.
- zauguin 5y agoBut wouldn't any competent weapon developer then change this wave and emulate laser pointer as much as possible to avoid detection?
- bombcar 5y agoI assume that they don’t turn all countermeasure systems on all the time. Though I do think they should roll out with the minigun out just for funsies. https://www.military.com/video/specialties-and-personnel/president/presidents-gmc-armored-suv/660778749001 https://www.military.com/video/specialties-and-personnel/pre...
- daenz 5y agoThat's pretty cool. It's a shame that the gunner's back is exposed though. Some more engineering could probably fix that.
- hawthornio 5y agoSeems like security theater
- doodlebugging 5y agoI used to commute between DFW and Houston every week. I would time my departure so that I missed as much of the ordinary traffic along the way as possible so that I could drive above the speed limit without having to deal with the highway patrol and all the other local cops who would be out during normal peak traffic times. One time during the Bush administration I made it into Waco flying fast and took the loop out onto HWY6 which would take me south most of the way to Houston. At the time HWY6 was two lanes for most of the drive with part of it under construction for widening. It traveled through several small towns, speed traps all of them, and eventually merged with HWY 290 out of Austin near Hempstead, Texas. Anyway I was about to merge from the loop onto HWY6 and was coming up to speed, roughly 80-85 would've been normal cruising speed for me back then though the speed limit varied from 55-65 mph. I know, what an asshole. This was me. As I merged I could see a couple of SUVs coming up hard behind me so I made sure to get up to speed quickly and stay in the right hand lane (4 lanes thru this part of the drive). I was cruising pretty fast but was still passed by two black SUVs with US Gov't plates moving a bit faster than I was. I figured they had to be Secret Service or similar since they were coming from the Crawford direction where Bush had his ranch. They were cruising pretty fast and so I decided to glide in behind them and get a rolling speed check. I had to do 98-100 mph to stick with them. Doing some quick mental calculations I decided to just lay back behind them and match their speed as far as that would take me since they would obviously be able to fly thru all those speed traps with no issues. Onward we all went, two black SUVs and a blue VW flying along about a half mile behind at near 100 mph. We cruised thru those little towns without seeing a single cop and I followed those SUVs all the way until I let them go in traffic in NW Houston since I was near my destination. That drive cut enough time from my normal commute that I was able to sit and eat breakfast before showing up at my work site. If any of you are former Secret Service and remember being tailed by a blue VW across Texas one morning, thanks for the escort!