4 ms·
Also, Chernobyl was due to a completely incompetent plant manager. They intentionally disabled many fail safes in order to get the plant into a vulnerable stat
by hedora 5y ago
Also, Chernobyl was due to a completely incompetent plant manager. They intentionally disabled many fail safes in order to get the plant into a vulnerable state.
- freemint 5y agoI've yet to see an insurance that would insure against human incompetence.
- kelnos 5y agoI think human error is one of the kinds of error it's really hard to work around. You are always going to have people who make mistakes or even intentionally cut corners or do unsafe things, depending on the circumstances. Would I expect a German plant to be run in a safer manner in the 2020s than a Soviet Ukrainian plant in the 1980s? Sure, absolutely. Both because of the design of the plants, and because of the different safety cultures. But I don't think we can just hand-wave a disaster away and claim that it only happened because of X or Y or Z, without being certain X, Y, and Z have been eliminated. And I don't think we can say that with certainty.
- dzikimarian 5y agoChernobyl was no error per se. It was conscious decision with political background, possible, because entire system of values in USSR was upside down. In normal country there would be no reason to do any of that.
- nl 5y agoAnd Germany has never had any odd political issues?
- dzikimarian 5y agoThis type of issues? No. I assume you mean nazis, but while it's hard to find words to describe their crimes, they had pretty robust approach to engineering. On the east side from the other hand ideology always beat logic. Also, if we're going to assume, that everything we build will be foundation for the next Hitler, then there's hardly point in doing anything.
- nl 5y agoThe point is that corrupt political outcomes occur anywhere. And Nazi Germany had exactly the same issues you identified in Soviet Union: a reluctance to tell authority bad news.
- dzikimarian 5y agoOf course it was present, like in any authoritarian system. But you can see that the scale of fuckups for these two is nowhere near of each other. Modern evidence is Ukrainian war, which Russians believed, can win in 48 hours.
- nl 5y agoI'm not sure what side of the argument you are on. My point is that authoritarian regimes are possible anywhere; they lead to information being surpressed; and this could be dangerous in the case of nuclear reactors. The example of Russia seems an excellent example of the same pattern.
- dzikimarian 5y agoNot sure if I have to pick a side. Usually there's some truth at both ends. :-) My point is, that chance of USSR-like regime in western Europe are pretty low, and being afraid to do anything, because it might be used by this hypothetical regime will probably cause more harm than good. For eg. right now we're feeding Russia with money, which is guaranteed to be bad for us in the long run. I assume we are doing that, because it will be easier to find single scapegoat for nuclear plant failure, than for years of bad foreign politics.
- nl 5y ago> that chance of USSR-like regime in western Europe are pretty low Why? Surely if Brexit or Berlusconi or Le Pen or Orban or Erdogan shows us anything it shows how democratic outcomes are unpredictable, especially over the 50 year plus timeframe of a Nuclear Plant.
- croes 5y agoAnd how can we avoid incompetence in the future?
- barry-cotter 5y agoDon’t have the politicians in charge tell people to over ride multiple safety procedures. Actually pay attention to safety in some fashion.
- mikeyouse 5y agoOh good - we just need to change human nature and fix endemic political corruption. Good thing none of that exists near the US nuclear industry. https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML2204/ML22040A111.pdf https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML2204/ML22040A111.pdf https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ohio_nuclear_bribery_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ohio_nuclear_bribery_scandal https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/flynn-backed-plan-transfer-nuclear-tech-saudis-may-have-broken-n973021 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/flynn-backed-plan-...
- Ma8ee 5y agoSo as long as we make sure that only competent and sane people get elected to political posts, we are safe. That will make me sleep well at nights.
- dzikimarian 5y agoIf you're assuming that political situation will come anywhere near this known from communist block, then random nuclear plant failure is probably pretty low on the list of the issues they caused. Much more people died due to simply saying something against propaganda than as a result of Chernobyl. I know that politicians suck, but if we do everything assuming that next Stalin and Lenin are inevitable, then even knfie production starts to look suspicious.
- Ma8ee 5y agoFor each Stalin, we get quite a few Trump.
- godelski 5y agoIt's important to note that Chernobyl and Fukushima have quite different (multiple!) causal factors leading to their meltdowns. Chernobyl was mostly do to highly secretive nature of nuclear (with information actively being suppressed by the Soviet Union), lack of safety equipment, poor staffing, poor response time, and a lack of knowledge of physics (xenon spiking). People mostly chalk it up to incompetence, but saying that's all that happened is naive. A lot of this isn't as surprising since the tech was very new at the time and the cultural warfare going on. Fukushima was a combination of cheaping out on safety concerns and a lack of scientific understanding that such a large earthquake could happen in the region (remember, that was the largest in recorded history for the area. Tsunami records indicating similar sizes are hard to differentiate fact from fiction). We've also learned a lot about fault dymanics since then (e.g. that Cascadia can have a massive quake too). Germany on the other hand is geologically stable and there's not many environmental concerns like tsunamis, earthquakes, or tornadoes. So we just have to hope we've learned some safety things in the last 50 years.
- sam_lowry_ 5y ago2 people died in Chernobyl at explosion time, 28 in the coming months, 30 in the coming years. None died in Fukushima. As far as people's lives are concerned, the death toll of the war in Ukraine is already two orders of magnitude higher. Economic costs are incomparable too.
- funcDropShadow 5y agoTell that to the families of the "exterminators" in Chernobyl. Tell them that it had nothing to do with radiation from Chernobyl that most of them died by cancer years after the accident.
- natmaka 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl:_Consequences_of_the_Catastrophe_for_People_and_the_Environment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl:_Consequences_of_the...
- 5y ago
- imtringued 5y agoThe Fukushima plant was older than the Chernobyl plant, maybe we should just shut them down and build new ones to save us the cost of another nuclear exclusion zone?