4 ms·
Why not? I think the respectful solution is to show it as "you starred X, it's private now, you can unstar if you like" (make sure if the name changes privatel
by Dylan16807 5y ago
Why not?
I think the respectful solution is to show it as "you starred X, it's private now, you can unstar if you like" (make sure if the name changes privately then the new name isn't shown).
Such a solution is not only good in the case of mistakes like this, it also doesn't gaslight the person that starred a repo only for it to disappear from their list.
- munk-a 5y agoOr even make it so that those starrings that no longer have permissions to view the starred item just effectively don't exist because of data rules.
- Dylan16807 5y agoThat's bad because it lies to users and you can't remove the star when it's in that state.
- munk-a 5y agoBut if your star doesn't effectively exist why does that matter?
- Dylan16807 5y agoBecause if the star is merely hidden then the repo can come back later. If you don't want any association with that repo any more, it's bad that it can put itself back into your starred list.
- akerl_ 5y agoThis may be the most hilarious misuse of “gaslight” that I’ve ever seen. If I publish something and you save the link and then I decide “nah, I don’t want that to be published”, I haven’t gaslit you.
- Dylan16807 5y agoI think you misunderstood. If you remove the content, that's fine. If you make the link itself disappear from where I saved it, that's gaslighting.
- akerl_ 5y agoNeither one of these is gaslighting.
- nybble41 5y agoSure, to really count as "gaslighting" there has to be a deliberate attempt to make someone doubt their own sanity. I think we can rule out malicious intent in this case. However, when you save a link to something and then later come back to find the service acting like the link never even existed, as opposed to telling you that it was removed, that can feel pretty similar even if it's not intentional. A user's list of starred repos shouldn't be silently abridged just because one of the repos was removed or made private. A placeholder should be left indicating that the repo was once starred but is currently unavailable. This is something I always found annoying about Google Play Music also; when they removed a track from their service it would just silently disappear without a trace from your playlists, so unless you saved a copy of the list somewhere and compared them you might not even know to look for it elsewhere. You're just left vaguely wondering why that song never comes up in the shuffle any more. YT Music is a bit better about this—they generally leave a grayed-out placeholder. Sometimes the metadata is lacking but you can at least see where it was and know that a track was removed.
- calcifer 5y ago> it also doesn't gaslight the person that starred a repo only for it to disappear from their list. It's honestly hilarious how the definition of 'gaslight' has expanded so dramatically in the past few years that it now means 'anything that confuses me'. For future reference, here's what it actually means [1]: > Psychological manipulation of a person usually over an extended period of time that causes the victim to question the validity of their own thoughts, perception of reality, or memories and typically leads to confusion, loss of confidence and self-esteem, uncertainty of one's emotional or mental stability, and a dependency on the perpetrator Github did none of those things to you. [1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/gaslighting https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/gaslighting
- Dylan16807 5y agoRemoving something from my personal bookmark list, with no notification, does in fact lead me to question the validity of my own memories. That fits just fine with simpler definitions like "To mislead someone such that they doubt their own memory, perceptions, or sanity." It's an expansion from the original context but I don't think it's an unreasonable expansion.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jacobolus 5y agoThe origin of “gaslight” is a movie where a husband surreptitiously removes objects from the room, dims and brightens the lights, etc. and pretends the changes were just the wife’s imagination. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaslight_(1944_film)#Plot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaslight_(1944_film)#Plot Removing bookmarks from someone’s list without notification seems at least broadly comparable (in both cases, the victim is confused and might question their own memory, because the state of the world changed in an incongruous way), though it is the action of an emotionless machine with a programming bug rather than a malicious human.
- calcifer 5y ago> albeit the action of an emotionless machine with a programming bug rather than a malicious human Yes, if you remove a major part of the definition (intent) then it can fit whatever you want it to fit. Like Gino D'Acampo most famously said [1], if my grandmother had wheels, she would have been a bike. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-RfHC91Ewc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-RfHC91Ewc