4 ms·
"It's their fault, they only showed 5 warning banners. A 6th one would have totally stopped me from doing this." If a "type your repository name to confirm" bo
by paxys 5y ago
"It's their fault, they only showed 5 warning banners. A 6th one would have totally stopped me from doing this."
If a "type your repository name to confirm" box still doesn't make you double check that you picked the right repository, what else can they even do?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kemitche 5y agoThere's more nuance there: > I didn’t realize at the moment there’s an inconsistency in the naming of this special repo containing profile READMEs and that it differs for users and organizations: name/name vs. name/.github. It's not unreasonable for the author to have taken the action they did given what they were trying to do. The inconsistent UX for User vs Organization READMEs is a major factor in how the error happened. And given the number of single-repo orgs where the org's main product repo name == the org's name, well, it's not as surprising I'd say.
- farmerstan 5y agoI came in to say precisely this. It’s easy to point fingers after the fact but probably the person wouldn’t have checked regardless of the message in the dialog box. “They warned me but because I didn’t read the dialog box because it was too boring!
- sbarre 5y agoif you RTFA he did actually read the dialog box (which is where he found out that it would delete the stars) he just didn't notice the 1 line in a 30+ line generic modal. He accepts responsibility for what he did, but points out the very real opportunity to improve the UI/UX of a very destructive operation with real contextual data about what is about to be destroyed.
- pharrington 5y agoYou can only confirm the dialog box by typing in that line you're saying he didn't notice.
- Brian_K_White 5y agoReads article and somehow misses it's entire thoroughly examined point, chides author for not paying attention.
- pharrington 5y agoIf I understood the blog post correctly, the author wants the "You will PERMANENTLY lose: All stars and watchers from the repository" to be changed to "[...] X stars and Y watchers..." Which I agree would be a better UI.
- cycomanic 5y agoLike so often we can easily judge this by how willing we would be to accept the same behaviour in real life and I'm pretty certain that most would not accept an UI where you could e.g. just give away your house by writing the wrong adress into some form.
- farmerstan 5y agoI did RTFA. I do not accept the excuse that he didn’t read it properly. He skimmed it because he thought it was the same box but it wasn’t. He even admits that it contained the exact information that he was looking for. I don’t see any way he can complain.
- sbarre 5y agoOk then. I hope others are less judgmental of you than you are of them next you make a mistake in life.
- 5y ago
- burnished 5y agoYeah, I also found that tone sort of jarring, but they do bring up a good point; the warning banner and inputs should be contextual and having to input the number of things affected would be a UI improvement. And I can understand why they would write this in anger/frustration.
- mattcwilson 5y agoI’m curious which statements from the article carried that tone?
- burnished 5y agoI think in the "But theres a confirmation box, right?" and if I had to quote a portion I'd quote >>"To paraphrase, the box tells you “You’re about to demolish a house. If there are any people inside, they will all die”. But it doesn’t include anything specific to break you out of your auto-pilot mode if you’ve confused the address and think you’re looking at an empty house." >>"The dialog should be more contextual and, paraphrasing again, it should say “You’re about to kill 55,000 people.” That would’ve certainly made me pause." Theres something about the juxtaposition that makes it feel like it should have been obvious. I think its because in those examples you would blame whoever didn't put whatever guard rail was necessary to prevent those outcomes. My suspicion is that it wasn't the authors intent and they were probably just upset, but thats an opinion I formed after reading the rest.
- mattcwilson 5y agoThank you for quoting. I see where you’re coming from - the comparison to killing people is pretty hyperbolic. Do you agree that, hyperbolic metaphors aside, the UI improvement suggestion is a good one?
- burnished 5y agogo back and re-read the comment you originally replied to
- googlryas 5y agoNote the repository names here are "httpie/httpie" and "httpie/.github". I don't use github(but I do use git), but the difference between the two is not exactly clear to me. They could show you the number of stars, follows, commits, creation date, the number of files, all sorts of things. Also, note that github themselves accidentally set one of their repos to private, but restored it to a previous state through backups. If the move is so boneheaded, why did github make it themselves? A better question might be why, after making the mistake(which was big enough for the CEO to tweet about), and restoring from backups, they didn't just fix the glitch and prevent this sort of behavior.
- hnlmorg 5y agoI’ve never liked those “type this string to confirm” dialogs. It doesn’t actually tell me what I’m confirming aside from the name of it (and names are easy to get muddled up if you’re tired or rushing through something). What’s more, dialogs like that encourage people to copy/paste those often long strings, which completely sidesteps the diligence they’re trying to encourage. Whether you agree with the tone of that article or not, the UI suggestions made are sensible. Showing the contents of the repo you’re about to change is a lot more useful than asking someone to type the name of it.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> If a "type your repository name to confirm" box still doesn't make you double check that you picked the right repository, what else can they even do? It makes you type user/repo, which is different in a serious way. It's easy for the difference between ".github" and "httpie" to set off alarm bells. But the difference between "httpie/.github" and "httpie/httpie" can slip through. > "It's their fault, they only showed 5 warning banners. A 6th one would have totally stopped me from doing this." The request is for the warning to say how much will be deleted, not to add another step.
- Brian_K_White 5y agoThe article spent significant space describing exactly what, and why.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ccheney 5y agoAlso seems a bit suspect that they had a "perfect UI/UX example" to show how they would have handled these dialogs. Is this whole thing an advertisement for HTTPie?
- pharrington 5y agoAs much as I dislike the general tone of the blogpost (as well as specifics like expecting special treatment (ie restoring a backup) in exchange for money when 1) Github doesn't offer that as a standalone service and 2) that wasn't already in their contract), I don't see how the example UI is anything but a straight improvement.