4 ms·
> “The teeth are authentic, there is no possible doubt. Our study proves that Hitler died in 1945," Philippe Charlier, lead author of the study in the European
by paxys 5y ago
> “The teeth are authentic, there is no possible doubt. Our study proves that Hitler died in 1945," Philippe Charlier, lead author of the study in the European Journal of Internal Medicine, tells AFP. “We can stop all the conspiracy theories about Hitler. He did not flee to Argentina in a submarine, he is not in a hidden base in Antarctica or on the dark side of the moon.”
It's pretty naive to think that a study like this one will do anything to shut up conspiracy theorists. You verified the dental records? Well teeth on the body could be easily altered. How are you sure of the records in the first place? Hospitals didn't have good record keeping in the early 1900s, so chances are you don't have the original data. Oh and why should we trust this "expert"? He's probably working with the establishment.
And so on and so forth..
- happytoexplain 5y agoThe word "naive" gets thrown around a lot when dealing with apparent expectations about apparent human irrationality. I find it's usually uncalled for. In this case, saying "We can stop all the conspiracy theories" does not mean that he thinks they will stop.
- bananamerica 5y agoConspiracy theorists are usually impervious to evidence. They'll simply adjust their stories.
- oh_sigh 5y agoThe fact that the records are so well known would also mean someone could create a fake set, using teeth and materials scavenged from the time
- braziljunge 5y agoAlternatively, one could assume a false record for dentistry matching to someone else. At a nation-state level, this would certainly be a reasonable level of “attack.” Could come either from German or Soviet assets, both having possible motive. One wonders how the Bin Laden disposal will play in the future. Perhaps similarly...
- TeeMassive 5y agoWhy Hitler escaping a "conspiracy theory"? A leader of a losing country fleeing for his life is not a far fetched hypothesis, especially given how the US actively recruited Nazis through Operation Paperclip and Operation Gladio for scientific and non-scientific purposes. I understand and agree that this study seems to put this question to rest (I would like to read the actual study tho) but just using the label "conspiracy theory" is simply intellectual laziness and doesn't advance the conversation.
- krapp 5y agoIt's a conspiracy theory because it's a theory about a conspiracy.
- pessimizer 5y ago"Conspiracy theory" is a pejorative directed at theories about conspiracies that implies irrationality or mental illness.
- krapp 5y agoDo you believe that's because there are established links between mental illness and belief in conspiracy theories, and many such conspiracies are irrational, or because it's all a campaign by the CIA to discredit truth-seekers who threaten the establishment order?
- Someone 5y ago> Why Hitler escaping a "conspiracy theory"? No, but claiming Russia and/or the USA lie about his death is. They likely had the the opportunity and the means to do that, but what would be their motive?
- sofixa 5y agoBecause the proof was overwhelmingly pointing at the other direction. It ranges from his defeatism earlier on, multiple eyewitness accounts from his last days, including his refusals to evacuate (including people begging him to join them in running away), the official Soviet accounts, etc. And around zero proof that anything else happened and he somehow miraculously escaped from the surrounded Berlin. So it's a baseless conspiracy. Now, what happened to the Gestapo Heinrich Muller is a mystery and warrants a conspiracy theory. Highly skilled man, ideologically flexible, didn't tell anybody he'd rather die, and no body has been linked to be his. He's probably in a mass grave in Berlin, but it's at least plausible he might have escaped.
- hatware 5y ago> do anything to shut up conspiracy theorists Maybe it's worth contemplating what the conspiracy _truly_ is? Why keep pushing out 'proof' when it's just to convince some fringe minority?
- laurent123456 5y agoConspiracy theorists believe in things like the Mandela Effect and the existence of alternative realities. With this, you can give them all the proofs you want and they can simply claim that history has been altered.
- shiftpgdn 5y agoJust because you believe in one theory that doesn't adhere to the mainstream "theory" of history does not make you a complete crackpot that believes all conspiracy theories. Come on.
- vlunkr 5y agoI would argue that believing in one conspiracy theory makes you much more susceptible to others, because they all require a flawed type of logic. Conspiracy theorists overlook large bodies of evidence and laser-focus on tiny contradictions and rely on their own intuition over research or listening to other experts.
- shiftpgdn 5y ago15 years ago believing in the NSA fiber taps made you an insane conspiracy theorist. Save your judgement for something else.
- kurthr 5y agoPerhaps you could argue that in the 90s, but no it was already the opposite of a conspiracy theory by 2000. The idea that not a single element of the tens of thousands (many TLAs) dedicated to US national security and monitoring was doing fiber taps (in SF or elsewhere) would imply that not a single one who had means (they were known to be doing it in other countries) motive (because they wanted metadata if nothing else) and opportunity (National security letters were a thing even then) would do their jobs. I mean... maybe at Home Depot, but not in the Federal Government where you take an oath to the constitution! Snowden changed a few people's minds, but not the elite.
- 1123581321 5y agoNo, it does make a difference to have more information and especially more incisive and clear facts that are easy to present. I haven't had many arguments about Hitler's death, but I've pulled people away from the moon landing conspiracy theory, and a bunch of others. My success rate got much better once I was able to walk them through the Apollo 11 mirror and the detection of it from earth. It's not perfect, but it makes a difference having a single clear piece of information you can offer them, especially one they hadn't considered before. Consider different types of conspiracy theorists: 1. Ones who copy something they vaguely heard. New information is a relief to them. They don't like being on the outside. Even if you are only temporarily their new source of authority, convincing them of the truth is a win and you can build from there. Also, you can usually find someone they regard as an authority who can present the information. 2. Ones who want to have inside/obscure knowledge of something. Telling them a fact most people don't know is exciting. They may switch to the truth just to have one up over their fellow theorists. They may become your best research partner. 3. Ones who have put in work to adopt conspiracy theories but are genuinely confused about the story. These can be won over with an abundance of factual information and analysis. So not only do you mention the dental records, you show them the whole paper, review the other pieces of evidence, etc. They take time but the effort genuinely pays off, likely for life. 4. Ones who think anyone but their unhealthy brain or true cult leader is trying to deceive them. You probably can't win here. But they're far from most common and you generally know if you have one of these on your hands.
- kurthr 5y agoYeah, once you can point them to something they could test themselves it becomes a bit more real. Flat earthers I'm not so sure about. There are so many things just by looking at the horizon or up in the sky that make it absurd. I've taken to simply stating that I don't believe that they really believe in a Flat Earth. They're just faking it... prove me wrong.
- robonerd 5y agoThe best way to cure most flat earthers of their apparent affliction is to introduce them to even more obnoxious methods of trolling people. Trolly irreverence to rational conversation is the big draw of flat eartherism. Play chess with pigeons and they'll shit on the board, just to see you wince.
- legitster 5y agoThe interesting thing here is there was a conspiracy! At the direction of Stalin, the Soviet Union knew that they had Hitler's remains but intentionally sowed the idea of his escape. And we're not entirely sure why. So it's a wrong conspiracy theory that has been debunked, but because of a real conspiracy theory that we have evidence for.
- superdug 5y agoSays right in the bottom of the article that Stalin wanted to seed the idea that the West was keeping Hitler alive for nefarious Western reasons.
- qiskit 5y ago> And so on and so forth.. Or we could just take the word of the KGB/FSB who has lied about everything. The same people who say we can't trust anything from putin because he is/was a kgb/fsb agent are the same ones saying we should trust their version of events absolutely. Katyn massacre was rife with conspiracies too because the official narrative was a lie. The official narrative was that in 1970?, the kgb dug up their bodies, burnt them, ground them up into fine powder and dump them in a river so that nobody should visit their burial site. Were there many people in the soviet union/east germany looking to visit hitler's grave to pay homage? Of course not. Does that kgb narrative make any sense to you? Also, it's hard for me to believe that the kgb didn't keep some dna material. After all, by 1970, dna was old news.
- efficax 5y agoDNA was old news sure but using it to identify individuals was only theoretical and hardly widespread knowledge, it wouldn't be practical until the late 80s/early 90s...
- qiskit 5y agoSure. But police departments started keeping dna evidence in the 70s/80s in anticipation of advances in technology. It's how the golden state killer was eventually caught. If police departments were capable of such forward thinking, it's hard for me to believe the kgb wasn't. If the russians did get hitler's body, then they most likely still have it or dna material. Also, aren't they worried that fsb headquarters or their archives will attract fascists wanting to pay homage to hitler?
- AlbertCory 5y agoMaybe before you throw shade on the KGB (well-deserved in general, imho) you should examine the provenance of the official story. It does not depend solely on KGB / FSB [1]. In fact, it doesn't depend on them at all. Rather, Hugh Trevor-Roper interviewed many, many people, without them knowing what the other people said. He carefully cross-checked their testimony, and since then no serious person has disputed what he established. Unfortunately in the 1970s he damaged his credibility by "authenticating" the Hitler diaries, which were fake. That doesn't change what he did in 1945-46. [1] https://war-documentary.info/the-last-days-of-hitler/ https://war-documentary.info/the-last-days-of-hitler/
- pyuser583 5y agoWhen the Soviets took Berlin, they grabbed the dental assistants who worked on Adolf and Eva Hitler. They were able to come construct the dental work done on Adolf. Eva had a rubber bridge put it. That was much more helpful in identifying the bodies than any of the actual work on teeth. Adolf had X-rays taken of his teeth. I’m not sure if they survived the war, my off the shelf books focus on Eva, as her bridge was the “aha!” But Soviet intelligence spent great effort trying to hunt down the dental records of the Hitler and Goebbels families.
- belter 5y agoEverybody knowns he lives in San Diego and works at a Subway. He is normally in a bad mood, but the sauce is great. https://www.google.com/maps/place/San+Diego,+CA,+USA/@32.676505,-117.157559,527m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m5!3m4!1s0x80d9530fad921e4b:0xd3a21fdfd15df79!8m2!3d32.715738!4d-117.1610838?hl=en https://www.google.com/maps/place/San+Diego,+CA,+USA/@32.676...
- belter 5y agoCan't resist copying here one of the Google Customer reviews ( this one posted 2 weeks ago): "bad customer service, some guy in a mustache told me to follow him and he shipped me to poland? im confused"
- _abox 5y agoLooking at the reviews this has been a running joke for a while. Wonder what started it? Was the location featured in one of those "hunting Hitler" documentaries or something?
- zahrc 5y agoIf you look at the building from above, looks like a swastika. Took me a while to get it
- GekkePrutser 5y agohaha lol now I see! urban planner was sleeping lol
- ravenstine 5y agoOr we can possibly be wrong for any number of reasons. It's not like we haven't before taught millions of people complete nonsense on the basis of some dug up teeth. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nebraska_Man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nebraska_Man Plus I don't see how it would be a "conspiracy theory" to be skeptical of Hitler's alleged teeth. It might truly be a kooky, unfounded falsehood, but just being totally wrong shouldn't be labeled a conspiracy theory.