10 ms·
Hopefully NASA watched this video, before making the contacts public instead of first examining the claims privately. "Spinlaunch: BUSTED!": https://youtu.be/9
by belter 5y ago
Hopefully NASA watched this video, before making the contacts
public instead of first examining the claims privately.
"Spinlaunch: BUSTED!": https://youtu.be/9ziGI0i9VbE https://youtu.be/9ziGI0i9VbE
- panick21_ 5y agoNever ever recommend Thunderfoot for anything. He is an embaracing.
- belter 5y agoYour argument would be stronger if you would address the technical challenges he commented on.
- panick21_ 5y agoI have years ago stopped watching his videos. He has long ago discredited himself and should not be promoted. He should improve his video making skill beyond 2003 and stop making insulting people a core part of his message. I have no interested in addressing his arguments, whatever they are on SpinLaunch. And I don't want to defend SpinLaunch anyway as it is terrible idea.
- belter 5y agoI think you are taking him too seriously and being maybe being a bit harsh. He is a mix of John Oliver and Johnathan Colbert with a bit of more precise shades of Veritasium. He is primarily producing entertainment, and there is no harm in that. But he does it with a correct scientific background and some humorist tones not everybody appreciates. It's not a purely scientific channel, sometimes he get's some things wrongs, mostly on his opinions about the economics of projects. The only thing I found too many, easily dismissing in this thread, is that when he makes one these busted videos he is also daring to make a statement and they are not random ramblings. For example his first video of SpinLaunch, if you ignore the tone is a much better analysis than the one from Scott Manley, even if Scott Manley is a much better source for anything else related to Space. Can you point me one of those egregious errors he made? Because I looked at this whole thread out of curiosity, and every single commentator criticizing him, did not provide a single concrete example. It's a new genre...Scientific Entertainment ( bit still scientific) Not sure everything in this short life of ours, needs to be taken so seriously:-)
- panick21_ 5y agoHis fans believe any video by him is the god given be all and and all statement on any topic. He employs a large number dishonest lines of arguments. Drawing large conclusions for limited unrepresentative data. Not actually fairly representing the things he is arguing about. What he does is build narratives to lead viewers to the conclusion he want them to reach. > Can you point me one of those egregious errors he made? Because I looked at this whole thread out of curiosity, and every single commentator criticizing him, did not provide a single concrete example. I have not one of his videos in a long time. I remember watching his videos on Falcon 0 and struck by him clearly have no understanding of the issues with his driving goal seeming to be to gather all possible evidence and building a 'Busted' narrative while ignoring any evidence that points into another direction. In general, looking at his videos he seems to have made a career out of calling Musk an idiot. To be fair their are a lot of low equally low quality channels that made a career out of calling Musk a genius but those are equally stupid. He even attacks some of those channels in his own videos, but its very telling that those are the kinds of channels he interacts with. Because that the level he is playing at. > It's a new genre...Scientific Entertainment ( bit still scientific) Not sure everything in this short life of ours, needs to be taken so seriously:-) You don't have to be serious but I very much get the vibe that he thinks he is very serious and his fans think he is very serious as well. A also think he is deeply unfunny and his videos are pure cringe to watch. Somehow he is a genius who knows everything about everything and yet his videos production quality is worse then a 8 year old on Instagram. His channel is the kind of channel that is designed around making online interactions worse for any topic, not better. This is the kind of video that I find actually helpful: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d43ckxS8gJY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d43ckxS8gJY
- Laremere 5y ago"Busted" videos like this are low quality armchair analysis aimed at giving giving the viewer a sense of intellectual superiority. Saying "this solution breaks the laws of physics" can be valid if analysis is done correctly, saying "this problem is hard, and they haven't already solved every single piece of it so their whole business is stupid" is not valid.
- belter 5y agoI agree with you that the video could be more detailed on some of the technical analysis. However it raises enough technical arguments, to justify any approach to SpinLaunch to be done in private and with a very skeptical attitude.
- JacobThreeThree 5y agoPresumably NASA, who's paying for test launches, did a more thorough analysis than a YouTuber.
- belter 5y agoOnly thing NASA seems to have contracted the company for is for a technology demonstrator, of throwing a small rocket at Mach 2. The article describes it like they are throwing satellites into orbit. In reality even the far fetched plan, is to throw a small rocket into high altitude to save money on the first stage. Then the rocket is what will put the satellite in orbit. I can't find a single reference to this agreement (yet) in any NASA official site. Not saying it's not real, just that I can't find an official NASA reference yet. It's not yet listed here under the current available ongoing agreements: "Current Space Act Agreements" https://www.nasa.gov/partnerships/about.html https://www.nasa.gov/partnerships/about.html
- attilaperez 5y agoTheranos had Walgreens, Nikola had GM...
- 5y ago
- gchadwick 5y agoWell I would hope NASA is doing their due diligence. Perhaps though there's a big push to invest in private space and they're not looking too closely at lower value/more speculative prospects.
- colechristensen 5y agoI can't tell if you're joking.
- raverbashing 5y agoAh of course it's thundrfoot. His phosphine "debunking" video was high on "hot takes" but low on actual intellectual honesty There are ways of criticizing and going about that don't involve patronizing and shallow dismissals
- blackholesRhot 5y agoFYI I'm a Spinlaunch invesetor. Just watched this video. His argument for why Spinlaunch won't work is basically: 1) in the video of their first test chamber (12m diameter) there's some dirt and rust, therefore they don't know anything about vacuums 2) in their first ever test fire of a projectile leaving their 33m chamber, the projectile is wobbling, therefore they don't know anything 3) in a mock up video they made of a future launch system the headquarters is close to the launcher, which might explode if there's a misfire, therefore they don't know anything 4) the founder has an uninspiring resume when you look online 'Add these up and there's no chance they'll succeed. What they've done isn't as impressive as 50+ year old gunships.' Give me a break. Their rate of progress is exceptional. They've already overcome so many challenges. These are weak arguments. Doesn't mean they'll be successful. But these arguments are weak. Some quick counter-arguments 1-) the 12m test chamber was a demo chamber. they were constantly spinning it up and letting people go inside. doing tours. stress testing new materials and arms. blowing stuff up. if anything the fact that it was so reliable even with the imperfections is a positive 2-) when someone is learning to throw a football there's tons of wobble. spinlaunch needs to figure out a perfect spiral. these videos were from their first couple attempts ever out of a chamber. what they're showing is very hard. this team has shown an ability to innovate and improve. those were images of their first few attempts to "throw the football" 3-) give the team some credit. these videos are designed for the general public. what they built already has an incredible amount of kinetic energy. they stress tested many tethers (past their limits) before going to this scale. when you're picking on things as small as "they're going to kill themselves by sitting right next to the system" you clearly don't have much left to nitpick 4-) jonathan is an absolute genius. just because he has a spartan online bio and unorthodox background doesn't mean he's not an absolute force of nature. thunderf00t is a very smart dude. but i'd bet anything that in a debate -- on basically any topic -- jonathan would absolutely decimate thunderf00t cheers to the builders
- sebzim4500 5y ago>thunderf00t is a very smart dude I just saw one of his videos on why Falcon 9 will never be economically viable so I would strongly disagree with this assessment.
- caconym_ 5y agoI really hope NASA is making better use of taxpayer dollars than paying their decision-makers to watch clickbait trash on Youtube. How any serious person could take this sort of thing seriously is beyond me.
- rozab 5y agoRichard Woolley springs to mind. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_van_der_Riet_Woolley#Views_on_the_practicality_of_space_flight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_van_der_Riet_Woolley#V...