7 ms·
How far down the "flew 8,000 miles to get there, climbed over the barbed wire fence, licked both his thumbs, and pressed them against the shiny parts labeled 'D
by bell-cot 5y ago
How far down the "flew 8,000 miles to get there, climbed over the barbed wire fence, licked both his thumbs, and pressed them against the shiny parts labeled 'DANGER! 25,000 VOLTS!'..." rabbit-hole-of-stupid should one have to go, before it's 100% okay for me to stop caring whether or not his sentence was just?
- adfhdfhdryheryh 5y agoThis might qualify as high treason, as defined in the Constitution rather as used as an insult. The U.S. and North Korea are still technically at war, and this act was definitely aiding the North Korean government.
- SllX 5y agoI’m not sure we really are. The perpetual warfare in the absence of a treaty doesn’t really seem to hold water in a world where South Korea has opened factories in North Korea or the PRC and ROC openly trade. That said, even if it does qualify, that doesn’t seem to be the charge pursued by the Prosecutors so moot.
- victor9000 5y agoI'm not sure about the exact threshold, but in this case we have definitely crossed it.
- mywittyname 5y agoFive years seems pretty mild when you consider the chief purpose of sanctions is to provide an alternative to war as a means of settling disputes. And this man is willfully undermining the ability of his country to levy sanctions. Surely actively undermining the security of ones country is a serious offense.
- rbanffy 5y ago> as a means of settling disputes As a means of forcing someone to unwillingly settle a dispute in your favor that is. I have no sympathy for North Korea, but sanctions are not an alternative to war. Sanctions are an alternative to bullets.
- jacquesm 5y ago> Sanctions are an alternative to bullets. I'm going to have to disagree there. Sanctions once enacted are definitely an alternative to war, after all, bullets all by themselves don't constitute an act but sanctions are an act.
- axlee 5y ago> As a means of forcing someone to unwillingly settle a dispute in your favor that is. what kind of strange take it is? What do you think war is ?
- user3939382 5y agoSomeone recently explained their view, that sanctions are akin to siege warfare in days of old. Whether you agree with that analogy or not, there is an underlying valid point that not all warfare requires physical violence. We use the term cyber warfare as another example.
- chaosite 5y agoCyber-warfare is in most instances comparable to sabotage as used in warfare. I can see the point you're making about sanctions being similar to siege warfare. The main difference being that sieges separate you from your own forces and allies in a way that sanctions don't.
- zardo 5y agoThey are more like blockades, they just use diplomacy and legal systems instead of parking ships with big guns outside the harbor. And I suppose the difference between a siege and a blockade is pretty much whether or not you fire those big guns into the city.
- anikan_vader 5y agoI mean, they're really more like trade embargoes, which have existed for hundreds of years. Thomas Jefferson reacted to the Chesapeake affair, for example, by cutting off all international US trade. In retrospect, probably a pretty ineffective foreign policy choice, since it tanked the US economy and didn't particularly hurt the Brits, who were happy that France could no longer trade with the US. (This occurred during the background of the Napoleonic wars and the Royal Navy impressing US sailors).
- Consultant32452 5y agoSanctions aren't an alternative to war. We like to imagine dropping bombs on someone is less polite than starving them to death, but it's just an illusion.
- olalonde 5y ago> Surely actively undermining the security of ones country is a serious offense. The information he shared in North Korea is widely available online. Perhaps unethical but I wouldn't qualify it as a serious offense.
- vsareto 5y ago"Man involved in community that regularly gets away with illegal shit surprised when he goes to jail for illegal shit" I'm definitely not defending him, but I can see why he'd feel confident not getting caught
- javajosh 5y agoIt sucks but the world seems to punish people who are honest (like this guy) and help people who lie (like everyone who did what this guy did and lied about it). In the same vein, police get away with brutal abuse because they know what lies to tell to justify it ("I felt afraid for my life", etc). But the police would not get away with it if they told the truth, ("They showed me disrespect and I knew I wasn't going to get caught so I beat and arrested them on trumped up charges.")
- afarrell 5y agoIt similarly sucks that our justice system punishes the clumsy criminals and lets the really skillfully sneaky ones go unpunished. Nobody has yet faced charges for robbing the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoThat's why I find the fact that real murder and attempted murder have different sentences to be a grave injustice. Criminals should not receive a discount on their sentence because they happened to be a bad shot or because the good trauma surgeon was on duty that night.
- homonculus1 5y agoUnfair as it may seem, it's better that the legal system limit itself to actual occurrences and not extrapolate to hypotheticals
- djsdlkfjgdkjg 5y agoRight? Anyone can see this case have too much evidence. you don't need two brain cells to see that either A) guy was a dumbdumb and nothing he said could have been better than leaning it on tiktok with a dance on top; or B) he knows the stuff and would never say something as dumb as this. ...My guess is that they didn't even had to fabricate this. Having access to all digital data from someone for years, they could probably find that conversation on my grandma's facebook memes if they wanted to frame her instead.
- sneak 5y agoHe was imprisoned for teaching. You have to construct quite a mental abstraction for that to be a legitimate criminal offense.
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y agoI partially agree but there was clear intent in theory but in practice the action was deeply unethical. Wouldn’t you go to jail if you taught someone how to plan a murder, with the knowledge they clearly planned on using that information?
- novok 5y agoHe was teaching them how to manipulate distributed database entries that they have the explicit permission to use via their own private keys. If that is anywhere near equivalent to murder then I have a bridge to sell you. Next up teaching north korea how to farm better and how to dodge sanctions importing fertilizer is bad, because then their people wont starve as much and therefore can do more evil in the world via more energetic soldiers.
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y agoHelping the North Korean government do anything is assisting a government happy to let their populous die while resisting sanctions. I don’t think I compared it to murder from an immediate seriousness perspective, but I’m sure the impact of Bitcoin on NK would cost more than one life’s worth of quality of life (improving the bottom line, helping the country resist sanctions for longer, etc).
- sneak 5y agoTeaching a human being something is not the same thing as helping a government do something.
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y ago
- mulmen 5y agoThe bottom. We should all care about justice.