5 ms·
This is not similar to anything on that page, as it operates on temperatures of thousands of degrees. The comparison with steam engines is also quite bad, as th
by marcosdumay 5y ago
This is not similar to anything on that page, as it operates on temperatures of thousands of degrees. The comparison with steam engines is also quite bad, as the Carnot efficiency on that kind of temperature difference is way above 90%.
So, it's just an overrating research PR piece, like the ones people like to complain. This thing probably scales just fine, and may be quite useful. The entire problem is that science gets divulged on those insane PR pieces where it's compared to completely different things, or promise completely impossible results.
- abeppu 5y ago> the Carnot efficiency on that kind of temperature difference is way above 90%. This is definitely not my area, but is Carnot efficiency directly comparable to the efficiency numbers cited in the article? Or is the "work" in Carnot efficiency the mechanical work, prior to being converted to electricity?
- kragen 5y agoYes, it's directly comparable. You can interconvert mechanical work and electricity freely; electricity isn't like heat. Everyday machinery does it with 95% efficiency, but there's no fundamental limit.
- diarrhea 5y agoAt those temperatures, Carnot efficiency is between 80 and 90 percent. The comparison to steam engines is misleading, but there’s an important distinction. Steam or gas turbines would reach very high efficiencies at these temperatures too, but won’t because of material properties and limitations thereof. These limitations don’t seem to exist for this new technology. Hence, reaching very high efficiencies becomes possible. In theory… In practice, I don’t see how heat sources with temperatures that high are feasible or could stem from renewable sources. (something with the thermal battery? Wasn’t explained much in the article) In any case, in comparison to steam turbines, the technology presented here does absolutely nothing in terms of decarbonising the grid, as claimed. It’s just potentially more efficient. But what’s the source for the primary energy?
- intrepidhero 5y agoI think the (unstated) idea is to use an arc furnace, during peak solar/wind output to heat graphite and recover the energy later using their fancy new TPV cell. That's going to require some really good insulation, since your heat source is intermittent and your temperature difference is huge. My first thought was let's use it in fission (and later fusion) reactors.
- marcosdumay 5y agoIt's too hot for a fission reactor. Probably for fusion too, but that's not clear. I got the impression they would heat the graphite with concentrated solar power.
- MisterTea 5y agoThe problem is it only generates electricity when the input temperature is 1900-2400 C whereas uranium melts at 1132.2 C.
- klyrs 5y agoPassively slurping the heat off a critical puddle of molten uranium is the disruptive startup pitch I'd make to secretly record audience reactions.
- marcosdumay 5y agoWith unmoderated fast neutrons, and critical geometry your startup will be always exceptionally close to booming and taking over a huge flank of the market.
- MisterTea 5y agoYou can use this as an inspirational soundtrack for the presentation: https://sentientruin.bandcamp.com/album/wormboiler https://sentientruin.bandcamp.com/album/wormboiler
- the8472 5y ago