15 ms·
Apple unveils the best photos from the Shot on iPhone Macro Challenge
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoThe trick to getting the best out of camera phones is to shore up their weaknesses with external devices. Cell phone cameras are multiple stops slower than "real" cameras (i.e. they take in 1/4 to 1/8th as much light). So you add light to the scene to shore up that weakness. Most of these pictures were probably lit very carefully with high quality lights, or else were taken in bright daylight, and the phone was probably held in a high quality tripod. It is also likely that hundreds of dollars worth of software was used to edit each of these images. It's pretty cool that you can get such nice results from a phone. But you'd probably have an easier time of it on a five year old aps-c camera with a macro lens, to say nothing of modern 35mm cameras. These images are somewhat analogous to the videos of fake hamburgers that fast food companies use to sell their product. That is, the physical conditions where this picture was taken did exist. It's not totally CG. But the images are designed to make you think that you can get results that practically are out of reach for most of the people looking at the photos. Still knowing that can also allow you to make better cell phone pictures by taking into account those weaknesses when you're taking pictures. There are valuable techniques to learn from these images, aside from the fact that they are all high quality art.
- thr0wawayf00 5y ago> But you'd probably have an easier time of it on a five year old aps-c camera with a macro lens, to say nothing of modern cameras. That's probably true but as a casual hobbyist, it's so much easier to justify spending $1k on a phone and a few hundred on apps than getting buying a legit macro camera setup, especially used camera equipment. I was frustrated by the macro limitations of the iPhone 13 pro and started perusing for macro camera setups and totally balked at the prices. It made more sense to hold out for another major camera spec bump in the next generation of phones (which is rumored).
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoI don't know what your budget is, but it is not that expensive to get into a "real" macro setup, at least compared to the cost of a new phone. Try this on for size: https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1485795-REG/7artisans_photoelectric_a112_e_60mm_f_2_8_sony.html/overview?ap=y&ap=y&smp=y&smp=y&lsft=BI%3A6879&gclid=CjwKCAjw6dmSBhBkEiwA_W-EoM-ytlELC2I4lQRMxezReBjaYMQCMSNfnklScX2lfTYI-Q7q8U9YwBoCiXEQAvD_BwE https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1485795-REG/7artisans... https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_nkw=a6100&_sacat=0&rt=nc&LH_Sold=1&LH_Complete=1 https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_nkw=a6100&_sacat=... https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1059024-REG/manfrotto_mkcompactlt_bk_compact_light_tripod_black.html/?ap=y&ap=y&smp=y&smp=y&lsft=BI%3A6879&gclid=CjwKCAjw6dmSBhBkEiwA_W-EoB6KJfIuwmKiGca3q0bFPyBBQtAn2JPAaSir_0jC0aV-GaxNkGuz_BoCpUkQAvD_BwE https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1059024-REG/manfrotto... https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1459178-REG/viltrox_vl_200t_vl200t_professional_photography_led.html/?ap=y&ap=y&smp=y&smp=y&lsft=BI%3A514&gclid=CjwKCAjw6dmSBhBkEiwA_W-EoLw78oON0RvTKsxR-O66NJUegbvSRUCukXoZmS5Yqz18_VZl6rbCNxoC_RYQAvD_BwE https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1459178-REG/viltrox_v... These items come out to a total of about $1,000 and will vastly outperform any iPhone. Note that I am not recommending this particular setup as I am not a macro photographer, I just wanted to demonstrate what's possible. I'm also not saying you're wrong to wait for a better cell phone camera. Your preferences are your own and there is nothing wrong with them. Just trying to provide some information.
- dr_zoidberg 5y agoCompact cameras (under $500) usually have great macro lenses too, though you miss the flexibility of being able to change the lens. I've owned for quite a while a Micro Four Thirds camera from Olympus and that's a very good spot to be a hobbyist: not too expensive, but can do "pro things" like changing lenses, shoots raw, has a horseshoe socket, etc. Of course, the quality is not the same as a full frame camera, but then again, I'm not a pro :)
- nl 5y agoThe A6100 (linked above) isn't a full-frame camera either. It uses a APS-C sensor (dimensions of 23.5 x 15.6 mm). The Micro Four Thirds sensor is 17.3 mm × 13.0 mm Full Frame is 24 mm x 36 mm.
- barrell 5y agoI got the canon 100L macro lens last spring for my 6D mark II (after drooling over it for literally 10 years), and ended up getting the iPhone 13 Pro when it came out. So I'm a macro noob with no other equipment. Can confirm, everything out of my dslr + macro lens comes out perfect. It's ridiculous how hard it is to take a bad picture with those. Fluorescent lights, cloudy days, handheld, they're all perfect. That being said I've definitely used and shared more images from my iPhone macro mode. There have been a bunch of misfires, lighting is hard, sharpness is not there across the board - but it definitely scratches that itch and I find myself using my macro lens less. Although after writing this I fully expect to run around my house for an hour next time the sun is out to take some macro shots with the macro lens :D TL;DR - even as a pixel peeper the convenience of having macro on the phone puts dust on my dslr macro lens.
- dylan604 5y agoAll Macro photography requires extra light, it's not just anything to do specific to cell phones. That's why there are so many flash rigs designed for this. Also, the iPhone 13 camera has ridiculously fast lenses[0]: Pro 12MP camera system: Telephoto, Wide, and Ultra Wide cameras Telephoto: ƒ/2.8 aperture Wide: ƒ/1.5 aperture Ultra Wide: ƒ/1.8 aperture and 120° field of view If you search for lenses for "real" cameras with those apertures and focal lengths, you'll find 4 digit price tags for each one. Sounds like you need some more research into macrophotography [0]https://www.apple.com/iphone-13-pro/specs/ https://www.apple.com/iphone-13-pro/specs/
- kuschku 5y ago> If you search for lenses for "real" cameras with those apertures and focal lengths, you'll find 4 digit price tags for each one. The aperture is relative to the diameter of the first lens element. So you can’t just compare these values directly.
- _ph_ 5y agoSure you can. The f-stop is the ratio of focal length to aperture diameter. A aperture of f/4 means, the aperture is one fourth of the focal length. At the same f-stop, you get the same light density on the sensor surface. The catch is: a phone has a much smaller sensor, so at the same f-stop, across the whole sensor less light is gathered and consequently, you have a weaker signal.
- skylanh 5y agoWait until you start looking at transmission values... f-stop doesn't mean much other than the maximum that the aperture for that lens can open. It doesn't indicate lens or element quality, or aberrations. There's a reason that pixel peeping, gear games, and reviewers are so prevalent in high end photography. As a simple extension to this, most of my lenses work better a few stops before maximum f-stop. So, yes, but no.
- 5y ago
- duxup 5y agoUnderstanding the strengths and weaknesses of your equipment is pretty much the secret to ... everything, including knowing the internal software results you get ;) When photography was a bigger hobby for me I had an old digital camera that had a great lens, but tiny sensor and could be slow exposure wise. It did have a great set of built in color modes that I had trouble emulating in software ( and didn't want to spend time on that a great deal ) so I kept around and got a cheap-o mono pod and blamo it's slow nature was less of an issue. Folks with fancy new equipment seemed to struggle emulating what I got with relative ease. Now I probably couldn't emulate what they did in many situations, but I didn't try either, I knew what that equipment could do and it worked. The world of photography is a funky world of pixel peepers, TRUE---ish advice, and folks throwing tons of money at equipment and software and hours of editing and ... just sticking with some specific equipment for a while / learning it's nature can save you A LOT of time and money.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoGreat advice. It would be fun to see a behind-the-scenes of how some of these photos were taken > But you'd probably have an easier time of it on a five year old aps-c camera with a macro lens, to say nothing of modern 35mm cameras. The iPhone camera really is fantastic for what it is (economies of scale are an amazing thing) but you're not wrong. Doing this sort of photography work on an iPhone is more about the challenge than the capabilities. One of the interesting things about photography is that so many capable cameras and lenses have been produced over the past couple decades that you can stop by eBay and pick up some truly capable gear for relatively cheap if you do your research. It's tempting to get pulled into the world of modern full-frame cameras and the latest glass, but the truth is that an older mirrorless camera combined with some known-good old glass will produce amazing photos.
- formerly_proven 5y agoThis is even true for digital gear. At base ISO, cameras like a D7100/7200 have as good image quality as it gets for that class, and you can pick those up for cheap. Even fairly high-end, high-resolution full-frame cameras can be had for less than 500 quid (e.g. D800) and those still have outstanding image quality; there really wasn't a whole lot of major improvements in image quality in the last ten years when you control the light (i.e. don't need high ISO). Things get expensive if you want... ... best low-noise performance (needs sensor from the last ~five years, older stuff usually has color shifts and other issues which are not easy to fix) ... video ... mirrorless ... fast AF (especially if you also want mirrorless) ... all of the above
- kuschku 5y agoNot even necessarily – the Sony a6300 retails around 300 bucks used, which gives you 4K30 or 2K120 video at 8bit. It’s an APS-C mirrorless with fast AF, and its low-noise performance is (although a few years out of date) excellent for its price. And in real-life circumstances it’s better than a Google Pixel.
- ghostly_s 5y agoMost of the photos Apple highlights in this campaign are also shot with very expensive external lenses.
- Bud 5y agoFalse. Not a single one of them used any external lens at all, according to the page itself. This may be true for the campaign as a whole, but it's not true for the page under discussion in this thread.
- ghostly_s 5y agoI see no claims on this page that no external equipment was used, and it's known that professional lens rigs have been used in these "Shot on iPhone" campaigns in the past. https://petapixel.com/2017/06/30/truth-shot-iphone-style-ads/ https://petapixel.com/2017/06/30/truth-shot-iphone-style-ads...
- galaktus 5y agoWhy would you make such false claims?
- ghostly_s 5y agoBecause it's true? https://petapixel.com/2017/06/30/truth-shot-iphone-style-ads/ https://petapixel.com/2017/06/30/truth-shot-iphone-style-ads...
- camillomiller 5y agoThis is false FUD.
- dietrichepp 5y agoI disagree that bigger cameras are better for macrophotography. I say this because of the physics of how light works in macrophotography, which matches my experience doing macrophotography with larger cameras (6x7cm and 4x5"). The long story short is that reducing the aperture has two effects on image sharpness. Smaller apertures increase the depth of field, bringing more of your scene into focus. Smaller apertures also introduce diffusion, which makes the whole image softer. This tradeoff means that there is a medium aperture which makes your image as sharp as possible. Photographing people with a 35mm camera, the aperture which maximizes sharpness is often achieved with apertures somewhere around ƒ/5.6 or ƒ/8. It is advantageous to use a 35mm camera because the larger sensor size can reveal more detail and capture more light. 35mm also gives you access to larger apertures and those nice, blurry backgrounds. In macrophotography, large cameras just aren’t as advantageous. The small apertures that you typically use will produce soft images, and the soft images can be captured well enough on a small sensor. Small cameras give you very blurry backgrounds to begin with, so you wouldn’t choose a large camera to blur the background. Additionally, small cameras require less lens movement, proportional to their size, to focus at the short distances required for macrophotography. I do some macrophotography with my RZ67. Mostly pictures of flowers. It’s fun, but I know that it would be much more convenient to use a smaller camera, and I wouldn’t be sacrificing image quality. One of the big reasons I use the RZ67 is because it uses a bellows to focus, and the bellows is long enough that you can focus very close. However, there’s a lower limit to the size of the subjects I can comfortably photograph, and if I were serious about macrophotography, I would use a smaller camera. Summary: Large cameras are better at taking pictures of large things, small cameras are better at taking pictures of small things.
- petepete 5y agoThis lines up with what Don Don Komarechka says on the subject. His images are fantastic and he shoots micro 4/3. https://www.donkom.ca https://www.donkom.ca
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoI appreciate your perspective, but most folks who are at the top of the macrophotography game use 35mm cameras and macro lenses. It's not actually the case that smaller sensors are net beneficial for taking macro photographs, otherwise we'd see a different trend. Even if these folks were just looking for the "real camera" ergonomics, they'd be using m43, but few of them do. (Perhaps you get some advantage of more depth of field, but 35mm camera lenses can be stopped down to achieve the same effect, when it is desired.) There are exceptions, as my sibling comment points out, but if you go to a list of the top macro photographers and check each one out, 90+% of them will be using 35mm cameras.
- mrbonehead 5y ago
- Karawebnetwork 5y ago> It's pretty cool that you can get such nice results from a phone. But you'd probably have an easier time of it on a five year old aps-c camera with a macro lens, to say nothing of modern 35mm cameras. Sure, but how often do you have them on your person in time to take candid photos? I am in a lot of entomology and myrmecology online groups and people are able to take clear photos of insects that look like professional macro photos using their phones. Before that, only a handful of pro/powerusers were able to share this kind of quality. When asked what camera he used, one popular youtuber (I cannot remember the exact context) explained that while expensive cameras are better on paper he often relies on his iPhone + a cheap ring light clipped on it. Animals often act in interesting ways when you are not ready for it. The ease of using the device that is in your pocket often outweight the potential increase in quality that would come from setting up a studio level setup. The best picture is the one you are able to take.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoWell, I often have a "real" camera on my person, because I like cameras. It definitely gets me better results than when I use my phone camera. That's just my taste. I'm certainly not saying your average joe would be best-served by going out and buying a GFX-100S. I'm not sure what YouTuber you're referring to, but most popular photography YouTubers mostly use real cameras still. Occasionally they'll do a gimmick video where they use a phone, but it's the exception, not the rule.
- Karawebnetwork 5y agoFor sure, if I am on a trip I'll have my reflex big bulky camera around my neck. But day to day, commuting to work, at a friend's, etc., all I have is my phone.
- subhro 5y ago> Sure, but how often do you have them on your person in time to take candid photos? Totally bad argument in justifying phone cameras. If you are having the expectation of getting photos of similar quality as shown on the page, my question is, how often do you have a high quality ring light on your person along with a stable tripod?
- foldr 5y ago> (i.e. they take in 1/4 to 1/8th as much light) Not sure if this is true for macro. For a given angle of view, the amount of light collected is determined by the absolute diameter of the aperture (as opposed to the f number). It’s rarely practical to use a very wide aperture for macro photography on a DSLR for depth of field reasons. People do all sorts of unnecessarily complex calculations with crop factors, but in this scenario all you have to think about is the diameter of the aperture in mm. The phone has an aperture of perhaps around 3-4mm. You’re unlikely to use a wider aperture than that shooting macro on APS-C or full frame.
- balls187 5y agomy Iphone 13 Pro has very (very) impressive low light performance.
- galaktus 5y ago> Most of these pictures were probably lit very carefully with high quality lights, or else were taken in bright daylight, and the phone was probably held in a high quality tripod. It is also likely that hundreds of dollars worth of software was used to edit each of these images. Like they do with "professional" cameras as well.
- camillomiller 5y agoActually way less than with pro cameras
- jacobolus 5y ago> “Most of these pictures were probably lit very carefully with high quality lights, or else were taken in bright daylight [...] hundreds of dollars worth of software was used to edit [...] analogous to the videos of fake hamburgers” You don’t have to speculate. Most of the photographers directly tell you how these were set up: > love going on early morning walks with my iPhone 13 Pro. The ‘golden hour’ brings the best out of nature > I’ve used a spot studio light on the lily with a dark background. > This one instance was during the sliver of golden hour when the sun is shining directly into my window, illuminating all of the tiny cells in each leaf. > I used two items that I found in my kitchen fridge: a strawberry and a can of soda. I placed a clear vase on my kitchen counter, poured the soda into the vase, and used a piece of black paper as the background. I then dropped the strawberry in the vase of soda and waited. Slowly, bubbles began to form on the surface of the strawberry, and its texture was completely transformed. > This image was taken along the edge of Riverside Park in Manhattan while on a morning walk with our puppy this winter. > This tiny, shimmering liquid jewel is delicately nestled at the base of a leaf after a tropical storm, almost imperceptible to the human eye. > The photo was taken when my 3-year-old son discovered the blossom of the tulip at home. I then appreciated the flower with my son and took out my iPhone, trying to capture the moment when the sun kissed the flower, which created a perfect shadow at the petals. As I moved my iPhone closer to the flower, it automatically turned on macro mode, It is entirely possible for someone on a tight budget to make their own studio-like lighting, and there are good photo editing tools available for free. Saying «don’t bother to be inspired by these lovely smartphone photos because some professionals spend thousands of dollars on lighting and Photoshop» is lazy cynical negativity in the extreme. And «people who win photography contests are typically more careful tool users than an average person with no experience» is hardly a deep insight.
- bee_rider 5y agoI am a little suspicious of some of these, though. For example in the last one, it seems a bit weird that his son discovered a tulip, and it just happened to be directly in front of a perfectly black background (?). I suspect some of the stories have been tweaked to play up the convenience of having the phone handy. But they are still very nice shots!
- 5y ago
- gnicholas 5y ago> the phone was probably held in a high quality tripod Why is a high-quality tripod needed? You can just set the camera to be on a timer so that it's not shaking (from you touching the shutter button) when it captures the photo. I think it's also possible to use an Apple Watch to trigger the shutter. > It is also likely that hundreds of dollars worth of software was used to edit each of these images. Do photo contests typically allow entrants to heavily edit photos?
- rococode 5y agoI'm no expert but I think these shots often use slower shutter speeds, for example 0.5s instead of 0.01s. This increases the amount of light, but any movement that happens while the shutter is open will cause blur. Movement causes blur at fast shutter speeds too, but it's less noticeable because obviously you can move much less in 0.01s than you can in 0.5s.
- gnicholas 5y agoI get that, but even a cheap tripod (I use a Joby) will hold a phone still for .5 seconds, won't it? You can put the phone on a 10 second delay, so any movement generated by you touching the shutter button would have dissipated by the time the photo is taken.
- infinityio 5y ago> Do photo contests typically allow entrants to heavily edit photos? To my knowledge - yes
- mym1990 5y ago"Do photo contests typically allow entrants to heavily edit photos?" This is going to depend on the genre of the contest, but for most contest types outside of the journalistic realm editing style will very much be a part of the process. You will typically submit the final print and no one will know what the original picture was. There are some contests out there with some pretty outrageous editing though!
- HidyBush 5y ago>Cell phone cameras are multiple stops slower than "real" cameras (i.e. they take in 1/4 to 1/8th as much light). this is not true. the iPhone camera's sensor receives the same density of light from its f/1.8 lens than any old traditional camera using an f/1.8 lens. this means the stops are identical. of course the total amount of light that passes through the iPhone's lens is much smaller than a normal camera's, but that has no bearing on the photo's exposure. the real difference rests in the signal to noise ratio, which is determined by pixel density, and that's why smartphone photos are incredibly noisy.
- camillomiller 5y agoThis
- twoWhlsGud 5y agoThat: https://www.dpreview.com/articles/2666934640/what-is-equivalence-and-why-should-i-care https://www.dpreview.com/articles/2666934640/what-is-equival...
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoYou mentioned that the stops are identical, but then you said that the phone photos are noisier at the same ISO. You didn't mention this, but there will also be a deeper focus plane. So they aren't identical -- at least under the sense of the word "identical" that's useful to me. You need to use a much slower shutter to get the same noise level. Or a much faster aperture at the same shutter speed. That difference is exactly what I'm talking about. You'll generally find that a cell phone photo has about the same noise once if you divide the ISO by the square of the relative crop factor (and set exposure accordingly). Coincidentally, you also need to use an aperture that's faster by the relative crop factor to get the same level of background blur.
- HidyBush 5y agoI never claimed taking photos on a minuscule sensor with a plastic lens is identical to doing so with a high end DSLR. Stops refer to exposure and noise and depth of field have no bearing on a photo's correct exposure. It seemed to me that parent was spreading a common misconception about how exposure works across different sensor sizes so I wanted to correct/clarify that. The whole topic of noise equivalency or depth of field equivalency is completely separate and I just mentioned it to make it clear what part of a camera influences which characteristic (light density for exposure, pixel density/pixel size for noise, sensor size for depth of field)
- camillomiller 5y agoDude, have you ever even used an iPhone 13 Pro? Believe me, the macros you take with this phones are stunning. And lighting and stabilization are a determining factor for macro even with cameras, actually even more so for cameras than phones. These pictures btw were not taken this way. The reason I know is because I talked to the Italian winner and Apple about exactly that. Check this one out: https://www.icloud.com/iclouddrive/0b1PRNfudllgp0q1LyuHrW1OQ#IMG_0452 https://www.icloud.com/iclouddrive/0b1PRNfudllgp0q1LyuHrW1OQ... Taken at dusk. No other lights.
- geoduck14 5y ago>F 1.8 1/83 sec 1.57 mm ISO 320 No flash For something taken at dusk, I'm surprised of the lack of sunset colors in the background. I would absolutely believe that shutter speed would produce that sharpness. And the depth of field looks like it would be aligned with a macro shot.
- camillomiller 5y agoThe sun had just set behind the clouds in Cabo Sao Vicente. The blue you see in the background is the Atlantic Ocean from the top of a high cliff.
- Spooky23 5y agoThe whole point of a contest is to push the boundaries. I get your point, but at the same time the quality of casual shots on an iPhone is better than any camera I’m gonna see. Hell, the iPhone 13 camera can take night shots better than what I can see in some cases.
- drexlspivey 5y agoPretty crazy that you can get this kind of shots with a mobile tbh. Until very recently you would require a DSLR with a bulky specialized lens. For reference this is what a typical macro lens looks like https://images.app.goo.gl/nf5keSiugxyb2pmA6 https://images.app.goo.gl/nf5keSiugxyb2pmA6
- shagie 5y agoThe issue is the working distance. You'll note that the photographer there is shooing with a lens that has a fairly long barrel. For the Nikkor 105mm macro lens - https://coinimaging.com/nikon_105vr.html https://coinimaging.com/nikon_105vr.html At 1:1, there's 15.3 cm between the front of the lens and the subject. But if you're shooting with a rather short lens (e.g. those in the camera of a phone) then the working distance is very close. This becomes important important when photographing insects (you'll note there are no photos of insects in that collection) Some other lenses and their working distances - https://www.kielia.de/photography/calculator/working-distance/ https://www.kielia.de/photography/calculator/working-distanc... The Olympus 30mm shooting as a macro lens has a working distance of 16mm (quite different than the 153mm of the Nikkor 105mm macro lens). The "getting close" also impacts the "how do you light it" and keeping the subject out of the shadow of the camera.
- Auracle 5y agoI would say most really good insect macro images are done with dead insects anyways, as they need to be stacked to get a decent depth of field. The “how to light it” is probably a bigger point. Even with a ~100mm lens, dealing with the lens’ shadow can be annoying.
- tomduncalf 5y agoThe macro capability is a really fun addition to the iPhone. It can be hard to get a good shot though, quite often focus is off – the best way I've found is to use the Halide app, then you can enable macro mode and "focus peaking", which will highlight the in-focus area with a colour. This means that a) you are definitely in macro mode all the time, and b) the focus is fixed and you adjust what is in focus by moving the phone around until the right bit is highlighted. I have also had good results with the default camera though, but it's harder to control. If you look at the photos close up they don't look amazingly sharp, and the "blur" around the edges looks a bit odd (not sure if this is just a macro lens thing or something iPhone specific), but regardless, it's a pretty awesome capability to have in your pocket at all times!
- dylan604 5y agoFocusing for macro is definitely a painstaking process. That's why they invented equipment to help like focus rails[0]. At macro sizes, the focus ring on the lens is just not going to help get that final focus. Instead, the camera is physically moved closer/further from the subject to get final focus. With the super shallow depth of field, millimeters matter so these rails allow you to make very tiny adjustments. [0]https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1532833-REG/dot_line_dl_0328_dual_axis_macro_focusing.html https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1532833-REG/dot_line_...
- m463 5y agoI would imagine focus stacking would be a future enhancement, like HDR has stacked images for a long time
- dylan604 5y agoFocus stacking is a style. It doesn't necessarily make it better outright. Someone might not want the look of a wider depth of field. HDR is also a style, and at least they made it optional and not forced on every single image. Hopefully any focus stacking will be optional as well.
- xwdv 5y agoIs this the climax of smartphone macrophotography? How much better could it get from here, seems impossible with the given constraints.
- michelb 5y agoAlthough not a macro-related problem perse, these look great at the size they are taken, zooming in or enlarging them a little bit shows some of the flaws (overly processed, computational errors). These pictures have been made by people who have photography as a serious hobby and know what they are doing, hence the well-lit and positioned scenes. I have not been able to make a picture like these without a lot of effort. But it is possible. That said, it's a pretty incredible feature so far!
- jclardy 5y agoOn the leaf image: “The reason I like this so much is the obvious layering. The depth of field created with the iPhone here very clearly shows you what the focal point is, and represents a fantastic example of how good the software is at completely isolating the foreground, leaving the background blurry. A perfect example of computational depth of field.” — Peter McKinnon Is this correct? From what I've shot in macro on my DSLR, the blur is natural because the focus plane is so thin. I realize the phone has a much smaller sensor, but is the blur in macro mode computational? I thought that effect was only applied in portrait mode shots.
- dylan604 5y agoAt this point, I don't know how to apply any natural photography rules to camera phone results. There is so much processing going on that it is hard to even try to do things the "old" way. From the skin softening, to the pushing of the contrast/color balance/saturation, to the correcting of content replacing a person's face with a leaf type examples, etc, I really don't want to use the damn camera at all from a purist point of view.
- jitl 5y agoThe leaf was actually a leaf. https://twitter.com/mitchcohen/status/1476951534160257026?s=21&t=Y26LcIOuc4EdKofupaTuYg https://twitter.com/mitchcohen/status/1476951534160257026?s=... Using Halide or similar with RAW substantially improves your control.
- astrange 5y agoIt doesn't actually do any of those, people just hear "computational photography" and make up things in their heads. "Real digital cameras" also have computational photography a.k.a. sharpening, auto exposure and auto white balance.
- dylan604 5y ago"real digital cameras" have all of those features you mentioned as options. "real photographers" set up their camera with the settings they prefer and develop in post. i'm deliberately using quotes there as photo journalists have been forced to do certain things that would go against the norms as mandates have come down upon them. These mandates are meant to ensure claims about mainipulation in post has a little ground to stand on, but the people making those mandates don't understand what they are mandating with their PHB directives.
- thekoma 5y agoPeople seem to always be impressed with close-up images of plants.
- irae 5y agoHumans can learn a lot from observing the world around them. We do this a lot as kids. So maybe seeing up-close details we either can't see with the naked eye or never payed attention before can be interesting. At least to me, it feels to add completeness to my observation of what nature is capable of, and this enhances my conception of how much I was missing and it is now "complete" to me.
- whistlerbrk 5y agoAgree with this. My children are so close to the ground they can observe things I just walk by. They are constantly pointing out to me things they find beautiful in their tiny details. Admittedly I've trained them to be highly observant but they've outdone me in a short time.
- dotancohen 5y agoI hope that you like flowers. All but two of the photos are leaves or petals.
- moron4hire 5y agoI had a friend who was creating a cardboard miniature of a museum exhibit he was designing and he wanted to take photos of it "on the ground floor" to give a pre-visualization of what it would look like. So he pulled out his DSLR and was woefully disappointed that all his photos came out looking like photos of miniatures, even if he got really close in. I told him to switch to his smartphone. He'd be able to get in closer. The scale of the lens more closely matched the scale of the scene, so the relative angles between foreground and background objects would more closely match our expectations of being a full-sized scene. It came out great. Yes, we had to dump light on the thing to get the images to not be grainy. But the images had more of an "on the ground" feel. Because of that (and my own experiences with smartphone photography), I feel like these images all fail to use the hardware effectively to do something unique. Some others have talked about the differences in lenses and sensor sizes and all that, that makes high-quality smartphone photography so much harder than SLR photography. Yes, that is true, for the sorts of images that you would take with an SLR. But that's not the only kind of images you can take. The popularity of the SLR is both its biggest advantage and its biggest curse. It's advantageous because there are TONS of accessories and guides and examples, etc. ad nauseum. It's a curse because it sucks all the air out of the room in regards to other types of cameras. There are so many, many different types of cameras, and they all make unique shots that you really can't replicate with the other types of cameras. Few people have really explored what that means for smartphone cameras. It's clear that it would need to be used in ways that are unique to the device. Not just "it's the best camera you have with you, because your other camera is too heavy to always have on you." But stuff like, "because the lens is so tiny, we can squeeze shots out of tiny holes that would block a normal SLR". Stuff like, "this camera is a Star Trek tricorder connected to a global information network." I rarely ever see that.
- treerunner 5y agoI get the feeling that iOS runs photos through a neural net filter by default. It would be nice to know exactly what is behind any given shot, both my personal images and those of a collection/competition like this. Thus armed with knowledge, only then can we truly judge for ourselves.
- criddell 5y agoWhat difference would it make? The computation part of iPhone photography is an essential part of it.
- mmackh 5y agoI do wonder what the subjects in these photos would look like with different cameras and lens combinations. Everything about those shots scream great composition, but held back by the technical aspects: blurry and distorted.
- Saint_Genet 5y agoTechnically impressive but visually uninteresting just about sums it up.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- atultw 5y ago“A Drop of Freedom” reminds me of Apple's old flower wallpapers with the black background
- FollowingTheDao 5y ago
- Bud 5y agoIf you have ten axes to grind about stuff Apple did years ago to build its manufacturing capacity, that's cool and all, but it has zero place in this thread.
- FollowingTheDao 5y agoYears ago? Try last year! https://www.theinformation.com/articles/seven-apple-suppliers-accused-of-using-forced-labor-from-xinjiang https://www.theinformation.com/articles/seven-apple-supplier... And it's sick you think all they did is OK since they needed to "build its manufacturing capacity" and you forget it all the minute they show you a pretty photograph. And it is also sick that you think sharing the reality about Apple means "I have an axe to grind", and not that I am just a person who cares about humanity.
- Bud 5y agoYou're out of line. Think more carefully before referring to others as "sick". You haven't the slightest notion of what I "think" or what I have or have not "forgotten" or what I think is or is not "ok". I'll thank you to cease pretending otherwise. You clearly and obviously have an axe to grind, you have no objectivity whatsoever, and the stuff you're trying to inject into this thread simply has no place here. None at all.
- Kalanos 5y agothe resolution on these is terrible
- 58x14 5y agoIf I counted correctly, 8/10 of the selected submissions specifically mention the iPhone and the macro feature by name. Same with the comments on different submissions. Okay, okay, I know, it's Apple, this is a marketing campaign. I guess next time, I'm going to take a photo of the contents of my fridge, with the caption: "Every morning, when I check my new iPhone 14 Pro Max Plus, I'm filled with a sense of inspiration. The new Wake Up feature really gives me a boost of energy, even on cloudy days like when I took this photo of an avocado. The deep, dark green of the rind reminds me of the striking new Alpine Green color of my new iPhone 14 Pro Max Plus, and the texture couldn't be more vivid than shot by the new Macro+ Holographic Lens."
- hnlmorg 5y ago> If I counted correctly, 8/10 of the selected submissions specifically mention the iPhone and the macro feature by name. Same with the comments on different submissions The contest was only open to photos taken from an iPhone. This is mentioned in the heading, sub-heading and opening paragraph.
- smoldesu 5y ago"It's your first day of school Jimmy, show me that smile! You know it's going to come out great on the iPhone 16 Ultra Max, thanks to it's advanced computational photography and new Neural Merge technology! I can even switch it over to the new Pro Portrait mode for a better digital Bokeh on the bus." - A future excerpt from the Federighi household, probably
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- autoexec 5y agoI didn't even read the text. I just noticed that plants and water seem to be huge winners. The one that wasn't a plant or water was "sea glass" so... still water. Next time try flowers and water.
- some_random 5y agoIt is literally called the "Shot on iPhone Macro Challenge".
- yalogin 5y agoAll of them are extreme close up shots. I am guessing those are the ones that ended up being interesting may be?
- wonderbore 5y agoHalf of these are pretty unimpressive. The composition of “A drop of freedom” does not inspire me at all. The only focused area is a boring droplet in the middle and everything is blurry. Probably a million better ways to frame it. “The Final Bloom” is absolutely beautiful however.
- renewiltord 5y agoThe iPhone's macro photography is best for the fact that I can take pictures of labels and stuff for later. Something that was made for pretty stuff that nonetheless works quite well for my mundane use-case. I love technology like this.
- dogman144 5y agoNot to be rude hopefully, but those all look like stock high quality desktop backgrounds or 1:1 copies of an iphone add. Images seem less about artistic meaning and more about coloring and related implications about an iphone.
- MaXtreeM 5y agoSlight OT: I am thinking about buying a camera. I have never had a good camera system nor I ever had a flagship phone (iPhone/Samsung/Pixel). I though a mirrorless with good lenses would be a good starting choice. I don't want to do professional photography, I just want to shoot holidays in nature and my upcoming baby. I did some internet research and was blown away when people compare photos from best phones to photos from mirrorless/DSLR cameras. My impression now after some research is that you can get better looking images from camera if you are willing to do some post-processing in Lightroom, etc. If you compare raw images then a lot of times people tend to say that the one taken on a phone looks better (I know it might not look more "real", just that people like it more). Would you agree that buying a camera is worth only if you are willing to do a lot of preparation and post processing but if not just buy a phone with all the advantages it brings? Is it even worth buying a camera in 2022 if you are targeting a price of about what top model iPhone costs? Let's leave pure love of photography aside for the sake of argument.
- stu2b50 5y agoIf it’s for holidays and kids, I’d say stick with a top of the line phone, then think about getting a discrete camera for edge cases (if you have that kind of money) The best camera is the one you have available. Kids are mobile and wild and often do memorable things at unexpected time. Whipping out your iPhone and taking a video or picture is easy and pretty much always capable. Phone cameras, with much processing magic, do produce pretty good pictures. And pretty good pictures beat non existent excellent pictures because you didn’t lug your camera around.
- matwood 5y agoIt depends. I've only bought more gear when I had an exact need. My first camera was a D40, and I used it for years until it simply stopped working. My next camera was a D7100 that added features I knew I wanted after using the D40 for years. I still use this camera. Recently I bought a Z5 because I wanted FF and to move to mirrorless. My lenses followed similar trajectories - want to take bird pictures, need a zoom. All the time I also mostly had the latest iPhone. The iPhone takes great pictures with little work in many (most?) situations. Is it worth buying a non-phone camera in 2022? I think if you really like taking pictures and are bumping into phone limitations, sure. But, if I started today, I would get a flagship phone first and grow from there.
- qq66 5y agoThe macro lens is the reason I bought the iPhone 13 Pro and the extreme sizem weight, and poor ergonomics of the phone are why I returned it. I'd buy an iPhone the dimensions of an iPhone Mini (but say, twice as thick) with the fancy cameras, LiDAR, etc.
- J_cst 5y agoClose up pictures of flowers and plants. Vivid colours. Extremely boring. That's it, saved you a click. You can thank me later no prob. j/k
- fleddr 5y agoI've been doing macro photography with the big gear for over a decade, very actively, in the range of 1:1 to 5:1 and anything in between. I've also been using the macro mode on the iPhone13 Pro on the side, so I'm in the position to judge and compare. The positive conclusion is that relatively speaking, when reasoning from a smartphone without any macro capabilities, it is a meaningful breakthrough. And this matters as for many people it's their only camera. If you enjoy current smartphone photography, macro is no gimmick, it's perhaps the style of photography that is most creative, fun, and full of untapped potential to get unique shots. When comparing to the big gear, this should be seen as a start at best. It drastically falls short in many ways. As a first example, the "Sea glass" photo. Which is wonderfully misleading. The photo is artistically attractive but technically crap. It lacks real sharpness and definition, there's the plastic-like noise reduction, and you'll see "trails" in parts of the image, a result of computational processing of multiple exposures. Whilst you might not care in this case because the artistic quality distracts you from those glitches, they are a real issue in many photos. Macro photography is defined by a lack of light. The mobile workarounds are extremely aggressive and create tons of glitches all the time. My second point is on the flowers. They are very large. And that's one of my conclusions, macro mode works pretty decently (for a phone) on decently sized subjects. It's closeup photography, not macro photography. To illustrate the difference in capability, the smallest flower is photographed is 3mm. I'm filling the frame with it and then still have 40-50MP of cropping space. And details are actual details, not some computed blur or guess. Still, for a lot of people closeup photography is a new capability. I'm just saying to not think it rivals macro photography. Finally, in macro photography subject isolation is important, clear details with a smooth and soft background. Macro mode does not do that, it fakes the blur and often gets it wrong. In particular it computes some kind of half-state: soft but still with details, which is optically impossible and looks crap. Don't let my words discourage you though. It a step up in mobile photography, good to have this capability in your pocket. Let it make you fall in love with the endless possibilities of closeup/macro photography, and some of you might take it beyond the phone.
- nappy 5y agoThis is cool, but I really don't understand what the point of macro photography is on a smartphone.