10 ms·
DOS Nostalgia: On using a modern DOS workstation
- bombcar 5y agoI think if I went down this path I’d have to build a tower case - more control over the various devices and more of that 90s feel.
- udp 5y agoI too love using old hardware for “real work”. My current writing workflow is Office 97 on Windows 95 (Pentium II) -> SMB share on a Raspberry Pi -> upload .doc to google drive from my iMac. It’s pretty nice for distraction-free typing, and I still find Word 97 easier to use than any modern word processor. And the appeal of playing with my old computer makes me more likely to want to write. :-) The Win 95 machine is on a private network for which the Pi is the router, so the SMB share is available without connecting win 95 to the internet.
- akselmo 5y agoNice! Dont you have a problem occasionally wanting to play some Doom on the side? :'D
- foobarian 5y agoWhy limit yourself to old hardware too. I was just thinking about how blazing fast Win 3.1 would run on a modern i9 machine. None of that pesky memory protection or preemptive scheduling getting in the way of getting real work done :-)
- udp 5y agoDriver support might be an issue - and it might run TOO fast!
- dTal 5y agoSingle threaded only though! So you leave a huge amount of that i9 performance on the table.
- Kwpolska 5y agoOld software can be too old for your new hardware. Windows 95 won’t boot on machines faster than 2.1 GHz without an unofficial patch [0]. Old Windows versions support only one CPU core, in 32-bit mode, without using many “fast” instructions. And on the RAM front, Windows 9x tends to get unstable if you have too much of it (512 MB is typically considered the limit). [0] https://msfn.org/board/topic/141402-windows-95-21ghz-cpu-limit-broken/ https://msfn.org/board/topic/141402-windows-95-21ghz-cpu-lim...
- LukeShu 5y agoI'd managed to get Windows 1.01 to boot on my (at the time brand-new) 2009 3GHz quad-core AMD64 CPU with I think 8GB of RAM. I don't remember which DOS version I was running it on. I'm not sure I knew how much RAM it saw. And it was surely only using 1 core, of course in 16bit mode.
- anotherhue 5y agoI recently dusted off my mid-90s CRT and with a HDMI/VGA adapter have been using it on my main system. Call it nostalgia, refresh rate, phosphor hypnosis, whatever, but it feels simpler and quieter and less intimidating than a 32" 4K. Maybe the glass curve conveys a sense of the system being enclosed, as opposed to all around us as today.
- thom 5y agoIt's possible to go very far down this rabbit hole, and end up browsing Sony GDM-FW900s from 2003 for thousands of dollars.
- anotherhue 5y agoWhich is why I dusted off the old one :) -- can't justify 3k in any sensible universe!
- skocznymroczny 5y agoUnlike most people, I found CRT more pleasing to use than LCDs. When LCDs started to become mainstream, they were making me dizzy after short use. After using the same screen for a longer period of time, I can somewhat get used to it, but I still feel queasy after more than few hours of use. But switching to another LCD still takes me some time to adjust to make it even usable.
- LukeShu 5y agoLots of people find CRTs more pleasing to use than LCDs, because of better contrast ratios and lower latencies. But--fascinating--I've not heard of LCDs making people dizzy, do you have any idea what it is about the LCD that makes you dizzy?
- skocznymroczny 5y agoLCDs are actually infamous for making people dizzy, with the whole PWM thing. That's why many screens are advertised as "flicker-free". I am not an expert on the technical side of things but google "LCD displays PWM dizzy" and you'll get plenty of links. Commonly PWM is used for brightness management, so the screen might be flicker-free at high brightness (the blinding one like they use in computer stores), and suddenly it starts to flicker when you turn it down.
- flatiron 5y agoHave you tried abiword for word processing? Why don’t you have the pi upload to google drive? Have the smb mount point to a rclone mount that’s google drive. Skip a hop :)
- udp 5y agoThat’s a really nice idea. Maybe I could do the same with Dropbox. A good project for the Easter weekend - thank you! I haven’t tried abiword as I didn’t use it “back in the day”, but I might give it a go. I’m also using AppleWorks on my iMac G3 with an identical setup. The G3 is nice because it’s fanless and therefore almost silent, though it has a bit of CRT whine nowadays.
- flatiron 5y agoGive abiword a try! It tried to clone office 97 as much as possible regarding user interface. Would get you off the windows 95 requirement and you could use Debian 32 bit. Debian would also work nicely on that g3. Bring both of them up to date! Rclone supports drop box. It’s more of a 15 minute rtfm task than an Easter weekend. If you are celebrating have a nice Easter.
- jmmv 5y agoDebian doesn’t work any more on PPC Macs, nor does any other Linux distro I’m afraid. At least I couldn’t find one when I was looking into this recently that was actively maintained. Of course you can go with an older version of Debian. Or you can give FreeBSD a spin. Still works nicely on those old machines, including the latest versions! (NetBSD and OpenBSD work too, but they are harder to install and their boot loader is pickier.)
- flatiron 5y agoYer right! I had no clue they retired Debian on 32 bit PPC! End of an era!
- 5y ago
- Decabytes 5y agoI had a pretty good time running an 8Gb rpi 4 running BSD with the Lumina D.E. I did the same experiment on a rpi 3 and found 1GB just a little too limiting for the type of work I was doing. 8Gb was definitely overkill for my workflow but I couldn't help myself when I was upgrading. I think some of the productivity gains definitely felt like a placebo though. Having a device that just had the github repo of the project I was working on, with a fresh OS install with no other distracting things installed, is not a unique experience to the rpi. In fact I could mimic this by just creating a "work" user on my current desktop. But it was at least an exercise
- nix23 5y agoI write my journals on VM370CE V1R1.1 (running on sdl-hercules) i love the editor and it's completely distraction free.
- forgotmypw17 5y agoI also think Word 97 is the pinnacle of word processing. I run it in a Windows Me Virtual Machine and post the texts to my blog using IE6 :)
- flatiron 5y agoHave you tried wine? I image that word 97 would run great in it.
- forgotmypw17 5y agoI love Wine, and use it regularly for other progs like Netscape, but W97 works better this way. Even emulated, it is more responsive and cleaner than GDocs and LibreO
- nonrandomstring 5y agoE-waste is a really big issue. Looking after old computers and giving them a genuine use is a good contribution to reducing pollution. I wrote about this recently [1][2]. DOSBox on top of a minimal nix install also works well as it emulates old video modes quite nicely. [1] https://cheapskatesguide.org/articles/techno-clutter-farnell.html https://cheapskatesguide.org/articles/techno-clutter-farnell... [2] https://cheapskatesguide.org/articles/uncharitable.html https://cheapskatesguide.org/articles/uncharitable.html
- bstar77 5y agoI like doing writing work (wordperfect) on my old machines (286-486 era). It's the one task that I find is actually better on these old machines. My Model-M keyboard is better for typing, there are less distractions and I prefer looking at a CRT when writing. It's also somewhat ceremonial booting up the machine and running WP, so that helps getting into he writing mindset. What makes this especially convenient is that I can save files direct to a CF card and interchange it with my modern machines. CF uses the same IDE interface as a vintage hard drive, so hooking up one of these solutions with old hardware is trivially easy.
- udp 5y agoI also use a Model M. they don’t make them like that any more! I use an IDE to SD card adapter rather than CF, as SD cards are super cheap and easy to image.
- bstar77 5y agoI prefer CF cards because there's no signal conversion needed while SD card adapters needs conversion electronics. I'm not sure if the SD card adapters are any less reliable, but I've stuck to buying Startech CF adapters and have not had any issues yet. Plus, I have about 30 CF cards on hand so it's nice to still have a use for them.
- nhecker 5y agoBut they /almost/ do! I use an '86 IBM M as my daily driver, but I've bought two keyboards from https://www.pckeyboard.com/page/category/UKBD https://www.pckeyboard.com/page/category/UKBD which still makes this style of keyboard. They're not nearly as broken-in as my M is of course, and the construction differs in a few insignificant (to me) ways, but the typing experience is identical. I'd recommend giving them a look if you're in the market.
- hans_castorp 5y agoAh! Wordperfect - best word processor on DOS by far.
- Jaruzel 5y agoA few months ago, I installed Windows 2000 onto an ancient ThinkPad T21. I then put Office 2000 on it. The intent was 'mono-focused' (I like that word) writing. The project stalled, as I was stuck looking for a good offline dictionary/thesaurus to put on it, as I knew I would need it, most out there are horrible or online only. I should resurrect the idea and blog about it really (directly from the aforementioned ThinkPad). I think there's mileage in a 'Writers Distro' for Linux, which only bundles a set of apps for Writing, and NO network drivers.
- anthk 5y agoTry WordNet, it requires tcl/tk, it may run under Windows 2000. https://wordnet.princeton.edu/download/current-version#win https://wordnet.princeton.edu/download/current-version#win
- Jaruzel 5y agoOh that's nice, cheers.
- goosedragons 5y agoHave you tried StarDict? I'd imagine 2.4.8 probably runs on 2000 since it dates from 2006. There's loads of compatible dictionaries you can install.
- btrettel 5y agoI use Artha on Linux, which uses the WordNet database. It's fast and convenient. My only issue is that I would prefer using a more up-to-date fork of the WordNet database as I don't think WordNet has been updated in a while. http://artha.sourceforge.net/wiki/index.php/Home http://artha.sourceforge.net/wiki/index.php/Home
- WorldMaker 5y agoIt was mentioned in a different article on HN the other day a Professor somewhere who still swore by an old CD of Microsoft Bookshelf [1]. That Professor believed that the American Heritage Dictionary, 3rd Edition included in Bookshelf remains one of the best dictionaries ever assembled. Bookshelf CDs also included Roget's Thesaurus. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Bookshelf https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Bookshelf
- 1970-01-01 5y agoI have about a dozen Pentium and 486 machines sitting in the attic. I wonder how long until they become valuable ($XXXX) artifacts.
- bombcar 5y agoGet one setup as a "blast from the past" machine and try to sell it. I bet there's people out there that would pay for a nostalgia pentium ready to roll, especially if you did all the work getting it to go.
- iguessthislldo 5y ago$XXXX specifically isn't likely for that era, at least anytime soon. If it's something rare or unique like the Thinkpad 701 with its butterfly keyboard, then it easily can go into hundreds. If they're normal machines in working order, then I wouldn't expect a ton, but many people want them for retro gaming or some other reason like the author does. Even a non-working machine has parts some people might want. I have a couple of working, but worse for wear machines with sentimental value that I've been trying keep an eye out for non-working counterparts to salvage and for spare parts. One of them is actually a Thinkpad 240 that's close to the 240x author got.
- Bostonian 5y agoTo avoid distractions it's simpler just to turn off Wi-Fi or to take your laptop somewhere where there is no Wi-Fi you can access. I got a lot of programming done at my kids' piano teacher's house.
- AshamedCaptain 5y agoIt's always kind of ironic to read complains about distractions on online blogs.
- aphroz 5y agoStrangely I have lived almost exactly the same thing as the author (I had to check it wasn't me). The difference was that I bought the C64. I spent an unreasonable time connecting it to the wifi and I still haven't figured out the best way to SSH to my desktop.
- phkahler 5y agoI need to run an old DOS program that communicates with a 9-bit serial protocol that need an ancient UART. This hardware is nearly unubtanium. I think a good DOS emulator could fake this with an external - say arduino - device on the wire. I emailed the dosbox crew about this but got no response. Any ideas?
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoHack QEmu to add an emulation for the UART. It's not as hard to add devices in there as you'd think.
- phkahler 5y agoSince it's for work I was hoping to pay someone to do it. Have to run it by management but I think 90% they'd go for it. Thanks for the tip, I'll check out qemu.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoFWIW I am not working right now (and for the next month or so, waiting on a job offer) and might be interested, depending on the specifics. ryan [dot] daum @ gmail.com
- phkahler 5y agopinged by email. I love Hacker News...
- smm11 5y agoOpenStep a lot of the time. Browsing via X, but yeah.
- pasc1878 5y agoHow. Openstep does not use X. It uses display postscript which will display on other machines like X11 does
- linguae 5y agoThere are third-party X servers for OPENSTEP; this (https://ftp.nice.ch/Attic/openStep/X11/ https://ftp.nice.ch/Attic/openStep/X11/) is one that I found after a minute of using Google.