5 ms·
Today I asked a bank for a conventional mortgage and they said no
- dazc 5y agoWithout saying how much you asked for, this is a non-story.
- tosh 5y ago> $840K mortgage with 20% down for a $1.05M offer. House not appraised yet, but almost certainly above offer price since all comps from the realtor are $1.2M. https://twitter.com/dvassallo/status/1513685250655760384 https://twitter.com/dvassallo/status/1513685250655760384
- rsynnott 5y agoThat's over four times their demonstrable annual earnings (if your earnings are as inconsistent as this, a bank is not generally going to care very much about what you were earning two years ago). Totally unsurprising that they were turned down, surely? Also unclear whether this is earnings from a job or something else (the "adjusted gross income" would make me suspect at least partially something else). In a time of uncertainty, banks are going to be cautious, and some lenders realistically don't want to touch self-employed etc at all.
- SilasX 5y agoAlso answered: He paid himself out a salary that was a small fraction of those figures (but most of which was self-employment income): https://twitter.com/dvassallo/status/1513683918058262528 https://twitter.com/dvassallo/status/1513683918058262528 There was also a tweet saying how much of the last year was investment income, but I can't find that and Twitter actively makes that hard to search for.
- rsynnott 5y agoYeah, so he should be going to a specialist broker/lender, not a random bank.
- quantified 5y agoA small bank or S&L that services the loan after issuing is more likely to issue the mortgage. And it’s more likely to benefit the community compared to a big bank. Worked for me.
- parkingrift 5y agoBanks were lending seven times annual earnings as of 2021. I have not seen updated numbers, but four times earnings is likely on the lower end of the average loan to income ratio.
- rsynnott 5y agoWait, really? I didn't know it had gotten that bad again; those are subprime crisis sort of numbers.
- parkingrift 5y agoYes. However, it doesn't actually say much about affordability because interest rates drive such a large percentage of costs. A $285,000 mortgage (ignoring taxes+fees) would be $1,126/month at 2.5% APR but $1,618/month at 5.5%. If you use "conventional" lending standards a borrower with a household income of around $39k could qualify at 2.5%, but at 5.5% the income requirement would jump up to around $55k. The ratio drops from around 7.3 to 5.1. https://www.longtermtrends.net/home-price-median-annual-income-ratio/ https://www.longtermtrends.net/home-price-median-annual-inco...
- Dylan16807 5y agoIt says he didn't even get that far, because they treated his income as almost nothing.
- FireBeyond 5y agoIt doesn't say that - it says they found his income too inconsistent, year to year.
- Dylan16807 5y agoIt does say that. >> Few variables are missing here like the mortgage amount you are asking for and the upraised value of the house. > [numbers] But we didn't even get to that state with this lender. > They excluded all my business income because it’s too inconsistent. Quote: “Your business income is too inconsistent. Only usable income is capital gains $14,527 + $780 rental income.” Didn't get to house details, income was treated as $15k which is under the poverty line.
- netsharc 5y agoGotta love the e-mail with the 2 sentences pressed together without punctuation (there should've been a period before the "We are not..."). Have education standards fallen that low that someone who writes like that is allowed to be customer-facing?
- janandonly 5y agoWhat happened to saving for something, and then when you have the needed money, buying it out of pocket? I know I will never be able to buy a house. That is why I rent. But people being able to bid higher on houses (because they can and do get higher mortgages) drives prices up even more... so that is no solution.
- rsynnott 5y ago> What happened to saving for something, and then when you have the needed money, buying it out of pocket? For buying houses? There was never an era where that was a particularly normal thing to do; in most countries home ownership becoming common came about as a result of mortgages.
- dazc 5y agoIf the price of a house was directly related to its actual building cost, and considering how much deposit one needs nowadays, it isn't a bad idea.
- adastra22 5y agoCost of new house construction in the Bay Area is on the order of a million dollars. Still need a mortgage.
- theandrewbailey 5y agoBut before mortgages were common, people had to buy houses 100% upfront if they were to own them.
- sofixa 5y ago> I know I will never be able to buy a house. That is why I rent. It really depends on your local market, but for my specific case (France, Paris area), it's cheaper to buy if you stay there for ~5 years than to rent. I had some extra help from government programmes encouraging homeownership, town redevelopment and new constructions through lower taxes/cheaper loans, IIRC the generic advice for my area is ~6-7 years. Also it's technically not a mortgage because the place itself isn't collateral and it won't be immediately repossessed if I stop paying the bank, but that's just how things work here. Loan rates being what they are, there's very little incentive to save upfront for decades to be able to buy outright.
- refurb 5y agoNot enough info. But without knowing what his sources of income are, it's quite possible it's not a nice stable W2 income, but rather self-employment and/or some weird crypto returns, etc. Hilarious when the banks give out NINJA loans in 2006 and everyone complains about their crappy lending standards, then banks reject mortgage applications and the same folks are up in arms that they didn't just approve on the spot.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> Hilarious when the banks give out NINJA loans in 2006 and everyone complains about their crappy lending standards, then banks reject mortgage applications and the same folks are up in arms that they didn't just approve on the spot. I don't follow. What is humorous about saying loans should do verification and that this guy has enough income demonstrated over multiple years to qualify for a loan? There is no contradiction there.
- refurb 5y agoYes there is, the guy's tweet showed his AGI per year - nothing more. No indication of source. Check his prior tweets - he wrote e-books, he mentioned how much his income fluctuates. Those are all red flags for typical mortgage lenders. He got rejected because banks cater to certain types of customers. If his income was all W2 statements and clearly 100% salary he'd be fine. But it's not. Hell, even trying to get a loan based on an AGI where 50% is a performance based bonus can be hard. That will be discounted heavily since there is no guarantee you'll make that much money next year.
- Dylan16807 5y agoIt's only a contradiction if you treat lending standards as a single measurement of strictness, one number that goes up and down. Claim A is that they're being too strict about type of income. Claim B was that they were being too loose about amount of income. It's rational to believe both claims at the same time.
- 5y ago
- chubbyFIREthrwy 5y agoThis tweet (from the reply thread) has the answer[1]: >[Mortgages are easy to get in the US] Only if you're employed. Most mortgage lenders here are middlemen who sell your mortgage to Fannie and Freddie, and they have pretty strict guidelines on what they'll buy. That is, most lenders don't actually use their own judgment about what counts as high risk or what is an appropriate interest rate to charge, but are simply planning to resell to Fannie/Freddie, and thus copy-paste their standards. This ... was a shock to me. I had always assumed "banks are happy to lend to anyone who doesn't need the money". Then I retired on crypto gains and tried to get a mortgage (mid-late 2020), where I saw the very same disconnect -- even with liquid assets more than twice enough to buy the place outright, it didn't matter. Nor did arbitrarily increasing the down payment. Anything above 50% down didn't affect the rate, and even then I'd pay above 5% interest, when conventionals were getting under 3%. To show you how absurd it is, the FatFIRE[3] people advocate getting around this by setting up a trust that pays your own assets right back to you.[2] Apparently, if the trust would live for 3 years, and you've already taken two months of this "income", Fannie considers that just as good as a super-reliable W2 income, and will treat it as conventional. Then, you dissolve it after buying and invest the money like you would have before. I ended up just paying cash for the place, which has its own advantages: you can beat out tenuously-financed offers with a lower bid, and you avoid some of the closing costs and mortgage expenses. It still would have been nice to lock in 30 years of 2.8% interest to apparently-clueless banks. Final note: This guy should be able to get a loan, since, even with the income fluctuations, it's consistently high, but yeah, it wouldn't be conventional with the absurdly low 30-year-fixed rates. [1] https://twitter.com/AzazelAyers/status/1513784320225206272 https://twitter.com/AzazelAyers/status/1513784320225206272 [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/fatFIRE/comments/ojs18l/obtaining_a_mortgage_using_a_grantor_trust/ https://www.reddit.com/r/fatFIRE/comments/ojs18l/obtaining_a... [3] FIRE = financially independent and retired early (Throwaway because of personal details.)
- refurb 5y agoNot really surprising, since as you put it, most mortgages are cookie cutting products that have a long checklist of qualifications. They are designed for W2 income earners and if you step off that well-worn path, they can't help you. Others can help you, but you won't be able to access the typical residential mortgage market.
- wdb 5y agoNothing new? Even getting a mortgage in 90s and early 2000s was difficult when self-employment. As an employee I am struggling to get a small mortgage (1/4) for a house abroad in my home country. Having more than half of the house price doesn't matter :(
- acomjean 5y agoIt’s kinda new. In the late 1990s after quitting my job I got a mortgage. They had all types (my favorite offer was one where you just paid back interest for 30 years and at the end owed the whole principal again). But back then as long as you put 20% down you were ok. Then we had a mortgage crisis where too many people were defaulting…
- atemerev 5y agoThis is to be expected. For mortgages, absolute amounts matter much less than long-term predictability (especially so in these times). A government employee with 65k salary has better chances for mortgage approval than a contractor bringing in 150k.
- Overtonwindow 5y agoThe 1099 vs W2 issue is a huge problem with mortgages. I used to have my own company, and I was paid 1099 for consulting. I’ve had the business for five years and it was profitable. however the Bank would not give me a conventional loan, so I changed things around and made myself my own W-2 employee. Started issuing myself paychecks and taking taxes out, and three months later I went back to another bank and they were happy to give me a 30 year fixed conventional.
- otterley 5y agoThis is why I always recommend working with a mortgage broker instead of directly applying with banks - especially if your source of payments is not a 9-to-5 salaried job. Not every bank wants or is set up to handle your business, and the broker’s job is to find the lenders who do. I’m sure the poster will be able to obtain a mortgage, just perhaps not by direct application to banks.
- bradgessler 5y agoHow is there not a company specializing in mortgages for people who don’t have 3 years of W2’s? Some of the situations I’m seeing in the threads below seem like no-brained, low risk loans that would be free money to a bank. If it’s a question of modeling risk, is it purely a function of banks not having the tools to model non-W2 earnings? The whole thing seems absurd, but there has to be a reason for it. Regulation? Past financial crisis? Fat and happy banks loaning to W2’s? Wealthier people not needing mortgages?