6 ms·
It's a funny passage, but there is a reason governments pay farmers not to produce. They want surplus capacity. They prefer resiliency to efficiency when it com
by jfengel 5y ago
It's a funny passage, but there is a reason governments pay farmers not to produce. They want surplus capacity. They prefer resiliency to efficiency when it comes to food crops (including fodder). If something goes wrong, they want the ability to put additional fields into play quickly. You actually do have to maintain the machines that you aren't using.
Inefficiencies always look silly, and there will always be those looking to take advantage of them. Compare the vast amounts of fraud on the recent COVID policies. But they were more effective than just letting people die or go bankrupt, which would be even more disruptive.
Heller's book is funny and I don't want to ruin what is basically a good joke. But it's not as silly as it sounds at first.
- QuikAccount 5y agoI work in Agtech and this is not exactly true. At least not true in terms of big farms. They always work at capacity, in fact one of the reasons Covid hit agriculture supply chains so hard is that they had no extra capacity.
- modmans2nd 5y agoBig farms use crazy automated machines that almost (or do) drive themselves. Maximizing output allows them to set the market price because to generate so much compared to any other grower (like OPEC with oil).
- aeternum 5y agoYes, it sounds funny when written out but the character in Catch 22 is providing some useful utility in having those fields ready to grow if needed. Geopolitics can change quickly, the world's two largest wheat producers could go to war with each other. Starvation is bad, and unused fields may be a small price to pay to subvert it.
- giantg2 5y agoIs this true? We aren't seeing this even as we are facing a potential food crisis due to the war in Ukraine. SCOTUS seems to think it's about price control when looking at the Roscoe Filburn case.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aeternum 5y agoPrice controls have the same effect. By either reducing supply or setting a price floor you prop up the market-clearing price from the natural price which would be lower. This prevents those farms whose profitability depends on sale price being somewhere between the natural and artificial price from going bankrupt. Whether the government can actually leverage those unused acres when needed however remains to be seen. Government would need to act quickly enough to see a potential shortage coming, and give farmers the green-light to plant. Farmers without unused acres will likely lobby hard against this.
- _aavaa_ 5y agoSo in the end it still seems like the only realized effect is price control.
- vkou 5y agoWhen you don't have price controls for food, you get revolutions. Or civil wars. Just ask how our boy Mubarak is doing down in Egypt, or Assad in Syria. If you're a government minister that wants to die in bed, you need to do three things. 1. Subsidize food production and overproduction. 2. Limit food price increases. 3. Ignore people whining about the cost of #1 and #2, because they aren't the ones who will be swinging off lamp posts when the revolution comes - you are.
- imtringued 5y agoLimiting food price increases prevents farmers from making money. It would be more appropriate to introduce a subsidy for food production and pay for it by raising taxes on food and then making the fraction of the price that is below the price limit tax exempt. This way there is an incentive to stay under the price limit to minimize taxes but it is not mandatory. You can then pay the subsidy out as a food dividend so that everyone has equal access to the proceeds of "food price gouging".
- dredmorbius 5y agoOpen conflict between China and India would indeed be bad ;-) Russia and Ukraine rank 3rd and 7th, respectively, in the event that's what you were alluding to. Though as exporters their standing is higher. Based on 2019 FAOSTAT data. https://www.fao.org/faostat/en/#data/QC/ https://www.fao.org/faostat/en/#data/QC/ Via Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_wheat_production_statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_wheat_production...
- svachalek 5y agoPerhaps gp meant wheat exporters, Russia and Ukraine are 1st and 5th there.
- dredmorbius 5y agoYes, that's pretty obvious.
- AniseAbyss 5y ago
- lostlogin 5y agoGovernments do pay farmers not to farm, but having seen this in the uk, the land that is set aside was marginal anyway and so a subsidy is collected but the production barely changes. Then there is corn, where so much is produced that uses are engineered to try find ways to use it all.
- giantg2 5y ago"They want surplus capacity. They prefer resiliency to efficiency when it comes to food crops (including fodder). If something goes wrong, they want the ability to put additional fields into play quickly." Source? This is not the reason I'm aware of. I believe it's all about price control on the supply side, not capacity. Just look at that old SCOTUS ruling that forbid individuals from growing more more a specific amount a wheat. They used the interstate commerce clause to say that the secondary affects of growing your own wheat jeopardizes the wheat industry due to the inability to control prices. For example, there are current talks about a food crisis due to the war in Ukraine. Yet the USDA has not authorized the land enrolled in conservation programs to be utilized. Also, that land tends to be the lower producing land. Farmers get paid the same for the enrolled land, so they enroll the lower producing acres.
- aaron_m04 5y ago> I believe it's all about price control on the supply side, not capacity. That doesn't contradict GP's point. Keeping prices from dropping too low reduces incentives for farmers to exit the business, thereby maintaining high capacity for when it's needed.
- giantg2 5y ago"thereby maintaining high capacity for when it's needed." How so? We're talking about acres not farmers. Small farms can go under and larger farms will take over working the land. We saw that in the 80s. The land being conserved is generally lower capacity anyways (they aren't going enroll the high producing acres). So it might not contradict in theory, but the evidence from the current situation seems to support that the capacity is not valued and only the price control reason is. Is there any support for the idea that it's about having reserve capacity to utilize? Has it ever been utilized?
- modmans2nd 5y agoIf farmers can't profitably farm they sell the land off to other interests or go bankrupt. People are not choosing to go into farming....at all. thus a bankrupt farm will sit fallow, be bought by some golf course development, or be turned into a "nature preserve", reducing capacity. The dots are not hard to connect.
- supportlocal4h 5y agoPlease expound on your claim that you have to maintain machines you aren't using. Is there some requirement for how many working machines you have to possess to qualify for a subsidy? If so, is that requirement equally as absurd?
- cryptonector 5y agoThis is the first time I've ever heard this justification for what I always knew as price controls.
- SteveGerencser 5y agoIs there really such a thing as putting fields into play quickly when crops take a year to come in and can be lost in a single bad weather event?
- imtringued 5y agoThe government could have paid the farmer to do no till agriculture instead and mandate that he improve the quality of the land to specified criteria. >You actually do have to maintain the machines that you aren't using. Oh no! The dreaded capital depreciation on underutilized capital. Thank god we have created a money system that cannot represent this capital depreciation so we must utilize all capital at 100% (read we must grow the economy at the rate productivity grows).