15 ms·
How do people learn to cook a poisonous plant safely? (2019)
- mjh2539 5y agoIn the past, put small diluted amounts on an animal's skin, then their tongue, then have the animal eat it, then when you're satisfied you do the same with a person.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ClosedPistachio 5y agoDo you think this is why, perhaps instinctively, dog owners share parts of their meals with their dog? Interesting hypothesis...
- samatman 5y agoThe more plausible hypothesis there is that dog food is quite the recent invention relative to our symbiosis with wolves.
- jamil7 5y agoJust speculating but I could imagine trained dogs used for hunting or guarding camps might have been too valuable to risk experimenting with food on?
- dmitriid_y 5y agoPre-history humans weren't scientists who would've separated this test out from the rest of their lives. You're thinking too literally. Pre-history humans would live close to their dogs. There likely wasn't a conscious "I'll give this to Fido, and if they're good in a bit, I'll eat the rest". Instead, a dog grabbed some scraps here or there, before or after the meal. If still hungry, the dog might wander around looking for more scraps and munch on what they find. Eventually, the food you know you can eat runs out during a hard winter or other crisis, but you see Fido munching on some things like he always does. Maybe you'll munch on those things too. Congratulations, you've acquired enough calories to make it to the next genetic lottery! Assuming the crisis is bad enough for you to experiment but not so bad for you to eat Fido, Fido survives until the next genetic lottery too! And so we have yet another co-evolutionary moment folded into our genomes.
- robbedpeter 5y agoIf anything, if you had a dog 100+ years ago, it's because it provided value to you, in the arena of herding, hunting, work, and protection. Survival value, not anything close to modern notions of pets. That means your dog was a valuable asset, keeping you and your family from starving. Royalty and rich people got food tasters, but only a dumb rat bastard would treat a dog like that. Plus, dogs have shorter intestines and more potent stomach acid, rendering safe many food sources humans cannot eat without getting sick. After seeing a dog chow down on a rotten carcass, you're not going to think of them for testing the edibility or safety of things. That's not to say dogs haven't died like that through history, but it's not a thing people would do deliberately. Food used to be hugely more scarce than it is now, and a large majority of humanity got by with very little. To use a dog for testing new food would have been foolish or cruel.
- lurquer 5y agoNo pets in 1920? Dog breeds specifically tailored for pets have been around for centuries. Go to an art gallery… you’ll find countless portraits of people from centuries past with their ‘lap dogs’, pet squirrels, pet cats, etc.
- throwra620 5y ago
- BurningFrog 5y agoIf they wait 10 minutes for the dogs reaction before eating themselves, sure.
- delecti 5y agoI think that's reversing cause and effect. The only reason wolves stuck around long enough for us to turn them into dogs is because we shared food with them. So we were doing it before they would have let us experiment on them.
- goda90 5y agoThe animal method would definitely not be flawless though. Trying to eat everything a ruminant eats is a path to not feeling great, or if you're checking if something can be safely eaten by your dog, you might miss out on some great food.
- hapiri 5y agoI think tastes can be adapted, and culture will defined what is "great" food. But to extend your point, I wonder what happens if they encounter something completely non-toxic to dog, but are toxic to human.
- martopix 5y agoIt's worth mentioning that Hans Rosling, the "young swedish doctor" mentioned, is famous for many other things, including founding MSF in Sweden, writing a book called Factfulness, being a co-founder of Gapminder, TED talks, cool dataviz, etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Rosling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Rosling
- photochemsyn 5y agoA large number of people apparently believe that the experimental method was something invented in Renaissance Europe. This has always seemed like ludicrous nonsense to me. Local peoples around the world have certainly conducted experiments for centuries if not millenia before then. For example, consider pottery, and the invention of glazes. It's generally thought that the invention of the ore -> metal process involved potters experimenting with different glazes and finding lumps of metal after the firing process was complete. With toxic plants, well, most peoples kept domesticated animals and would probably use them to test the toxicity of potential food sources. Feed it to the chickens, pigs, llamas, etc. and see what happens. Soak the potential food source in water, see what happens. Try adding other substances, like charcoal or clay, and see what happens. Why don't people recognize this? Simple - infantilization of native peoples as a justification for the ravages of European colonialism.
- choeger 5y agoThat's a very plausible theory you have there (except for the hit on European colonialism). But there's the question of why someone should sacrifice so many domesticated animals just to discover another food source (after all, they already had animals). Also, some of these steps are so off, that even reasonable experimentation wouldn't explain it. I mean, how would someone come up with the idea of mixing non-food with ash? There's probably some utility in this step (e.g., making color?) and only later it turned out to yield edible matter.
- photochemsyn 5y agoThe history of the potato is instructive. The wild varieties that the first South American human settlers discovered (dates vary but > 14,000 years ago probably) were toxic, but if eaten with a small amount of clay, were discovered to be edible. Andean peoples didn't stop there however: they began breeding less toxic varieties of potato (there are now ~ 4000 cultivars) which also was a process of experimentation and selection of optimal results over a long time period. Breeding of maize followed a similar experiment-and-select process. As far as why the architects of European colonialism wanted to deny that native peoples had such capabilites, well: > "In a secularizing world, infantilization quickly became a moral posture and a theological necessity. It allowed the main actors in slavery and colonialism to make peace with their own consciences, and the intelligentsia and the Church to produce a powerful mix of justifications for the new world order. It allowed glib talk of the historical necessity to care for the retrogressive, irrational, ignorant savages and the Christian responsibility to guide them towards a better future." https://newint.org/features/2007/10/01/roots/ https://newint.org/features/2007/10/01/roots/
- terryf 5y agoThe article explains well how the knowledge, once learned, is carried on. It's also a reasonable explanation for things that have an immediate feedback loop. Like fire - you start it and boom, you're not cold any more. Great, let's do that again! But it doesn't explain cassava, or some other foods (lots of mushrooms for example and some nuts) where you have to take n steps, during all of which it's still poisonous and that are completely non-obvious and after that there is a distinct change in the "is poisonous" property. It especially doesn't explain the "if improperly prepared, will maim you over a long period of time" types of things (cassava!) Of course there really isn't another option - someone somehow figured it out after all - but the search space is so large it feels like there should be something more to it.
- throwawayffffas 5y agoIt's probably applying and combining analogous processes. I.e Food A is toxic and we don't know how to treat it. Food B is toxic and we know it takes n-1 steps to make safe. Someone comes along and applies n-1 steps to Food A and its still toxic. Someone else comes along and applies n-1 and then an nth step and there's progress. But yeah, the article does not come near to examining the way cultures discover things nor in general nor in the case of the cassava.
- terryf 5y agoSure, that makes sense, but not for cassava! The article even says that the natives had no idea why they were getting sick! How did they connect the "can't use legs" to the cassava they ate? Again, I realize that it must have been the way you describe, but it's still amazing.
- throwawayffffas 5y agoIt's truly amazing, especially for cassava or say Hákarl[1]. > How did they connect the "can't use legs" to the cassava they ate? Keep in mind these people are in Africa cassava is native in South America. I am pretty sure people in south America will tell you that cassava is toxic if you don't do all the steps and not just "it's our culture". The it's our culture response might be the case in places where it was introduced and people were told you have to do x,y,z to eat it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H%C3%A1karl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H%C3%A1karl
- carapace 5y agoSome people are really friendly with plants, and the plants tell them how to do these things.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt is hard to understand this, but it appears well-attested by individuals who had no other way to learn what they demonstrate knowing. As described, the individual plant is not the friend, but rather the spirit of its species. I have no way to properly apprehend any of this.
- carapace 5y ago> As described, the individual plant is not the friend, but rather the spirit of its species. Aye. > I have no way to properly apprehend any of this. Sure you do! You're a living being too, eh? :) You've got all the hardware, you just need to learn the protocols. It's not that hard to learn, the hardest part is "letting your hair down" so to speak. Check out the recent scientific advances from Michael Levin's lab's work, e.g. "What Bodies Think About: Bioelectric Computation Outside the Nervous System" - NeurIPS 2018 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjD1aLm4Thg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjD1aLm4Thg https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18700328 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18700328 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18736698 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18736698 In a nutshell, whatever "thought" is, the biomolecular machinery that supports it is common to all cells (not just neurons.) In other words, all cellular life "thinks". Combine that insight with the "Law Of Regulatory Models" from Cybernetics, to wit: "every good regulator of a system must be (contain) a model of that system." and it seems to me that we have a solid basis to talk about "nature spirits", eh?
- ncmncm 5y agoI would have to do the work to get the results, which involves a commitment. So, I did not mean that nobody can properly apprehend it, just myself. Somebody who did do the work was Monica Gagliano, and wrote it up in "Thus Spoke the Plant". https://bookshop.org/books/thus-spoke-the-plant-a-remarkable-journey-of-groundbreaking-scientific-discoveries-and-personal-encounters-with-plants-9781623172435/9781623172435 https://bookshop.org/books/thus-spoke-the-plant-a-remarkable...
- pmoriarty 5y agoMany mystery foods were probably first tested on slaves and prisoners.
- wahern 5y agoOnly empires have slaves or prisoners. And prisoners weren't even a thing until very recently--past couple of centuries. Unless they were royalty, it made zero sense to expend resources imprisoning someone. Rather, you killed them (e.g. criminals), enslaved them (a broad category of practices), or let them go.
- ncmncm 5y agoExile was popular. And often crueler than execution. Romeo wasn't overreacting.
- wahern 5y agoEven the U.S. had exile, though it slowly faded away. By the 1970s it seems to have disappeared as a formal punishment, though people might sometimes get suspended sentences on the condition they leave the state. This happened to a family member of mine--given a suspended sentence (enough for prison, not jail) and admonished by the judge that if he ever returned to the state he'd have to do the time. (Said family member never did return. They weren't a resident there, anyhow, but a resident of an adjacent state.) Today it would be considered unconstitutional, which is a real shame as forcing someone to leave what might be an enabling environment (e.g. running with a bad crowd) is often the best remedy for all involved, particularly the person misbehaving.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt is still used for bad cops. Instead of being prosecuted, they are let go, and hired into the next jurisdiction over.
- yardie 5y agoEvery time I eat ackee[0] I wonder how this toxic fruit turned into something edible. If you eat it raw you might die and will be very sick. If you roast or boil it you still might die and still be very sick. No, intrepid reader, you have to boil it at least twice to remove the toxins. And I'm curious to find out who was curious enough to keep going after boiling the first time and failing. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blighia_sapida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blighia_sapida
- Carioca 5y agoEven more interesting than cassava is Maniçoba, a traditional dish of the Amazon made with cassava leaves, which are more toxic than the root and less nutritious. The leaves are boiled for a full week before adding other ingredients and serving. People from the region are absolutely loathe to skip any steps in the traditional preparations, even though it has been shown that the same result can be achieved with a few hours in a pressure cooker.
- ogma 5y ago
- nobodyandproud 5y agoWhy are they loathe? Is the margin for error in pressure cooking low? Is there the cost of making a mistake very high?
- Carioca 5y agoIt's very deeply embedded into their psyche as “this is the only way to do it, anything else will kill you.” And I'm not talking just about older or more rural people either, I know young hip professionals from Belém (pop 1.5m) who will not touch maniçoba made in anything different from the traditional way.
- beaconstudios 5y agoThat's probably a good way to avoid people poisoning themselves by "innovating" on a process that, though time-consuming, is very reliable.
- nobodyandproud 5y agoThat makes sense and I think the memory and message is optimal. The cultural memory of, “It’s death to take shortcuts” saves lives compared to a less complete message. Or one that is more complete, but is longer and harder to understand. Think of social media; or your average product manager. The whys and hows are best left to science; but science is a fragile institution with membership requirements. Whereas the culture will live on long after.
- mageofpanthera 5y agoIt's actually quite straightforward. Use the Eye to detect if a plant is [poisonous]. Process the plant until the [poison] is neutralized. For instance, Monk's hood is extremely [poisonous], Datura is mildly [poisonous], and Rose thorns are deceptively [poisonous]. With Rose thorns, the process is relatively straightforward. [Boil] the thorns and let the water cool and set. The [poison] settles on the top. Pour out the top until the residue becomes nutritiously [clear].
- culi 5y agoThe thing people don't understand about "poisonous" plants is there are very very few plants in the world that exist where a bite can just straight up kill you. And many others that are classified as "poisonous" are barely so. Spinach is so full of oxalates and some legumes we commonly are so high in saponins that there are other "wild" plants that we've classified as poisonous because of having similar amounts of oxalates or saponins Also poison usually has a taste. Obviously this varies widely by the specific phytochemistry, but anyone who's foraged enough can tell you that you can always tell when you've misidentified a plant or a plant has tasted "off". It's really unsurprising then that people are able to experiment in this way Lastly, I also wanted to point out that many of the compounds that make something poisonous can also give it medicinal uses. Like how chimpanzees will chew Vernonia amygdalina leaves to treat parasitic infections TL;DR: dosage, yo
- ncmncm 5y agoJust for the record, spotted water hemlock root smells and tastes delicious, but kills with greater agony than almost anything. It looks a little like wild carrot or queen anne's lace. There is no known safe dose.
- mageofpanthera 5y ago[1 microgram] should [hit it] ;)
- 5y ago