12 ms·
Broadband cables to be routed through water pipes in new trial
- NickNameNick 5y agoI wonder how they'll deal with valves? If you need to close your water main, does it not close all the way? Does it cut the fiber? Both?
- qbasic_forever 5y agoProbably have to terminate the fiber before the valve, put a port in to get it out, jump the valve, and then start again in the pipe after it. However once you're inside the house and about to hit the main valve they'd probably just pull the fiber out and put in the box to turn it into a network connection.
- jacquesm 5y agoThat's exactly how they would have to do it, and it wouldn't just be the fiber but a pipe to contain the fiber.
- Teever 5y agoOh, good point. Maybe they plant to use the waste lines which shouldn't have valves on them past a certain point.
- gorgoiler 5y agoIn the UK these are called sluice valves, and they are very common in order to isolate parts of the network for maintenance. Well, they are probably called sluice valves in lots of other places, but the UK specific thing is the signage. Keep your eyes peeled for telltale SV signs (shown here alongside a fire hydrant indicator): https://c8.alamy.com/comp/DA5TFN/fire-hydrant-water-locator-signage-and-sluice-valve-indicators-on-DA5TFN.jpg https://c8.alamy.com/comp/DA5TFN/fire-hydrant-water-locator-...
- devoutsalsa 5y ago{{IPee_Address_Joke}}
- true_repairman 5y agoThe people of Penistone probably have some good ones.
- josephcsible 5y agoThis makes Google's 2007 April Fools' Day prank even more amusing in hindsight.
- achow 5y agoTiSP: A free in-home wireless broadband service that delivers online connectivity via users' plumbing systems. The Toilet Internet Service Provider (TiSP) project is a self-installed, ad-supported online service that will be offered entirely free to any consumer with a WiFi-capable PC and a toilet connected to a local municipal sewage system. https://archive.google.com/tisp/press.html https://archive.google.com/tisp/press.html
- yaur 5y ago
- dataflow 5y agoIs there no risk of the cables deteriorating/contaminating the water?
- hattmall 5y agoThey just run a conduit inside the water pipe, probably the same thing the pipe is made of, likely PVC.
- dataflow 5y agoThis seems like the only sensible answer here. Yeah, I hope so. Do you know how they might replace sections of the pipe in the future if they need to? Seems like it'd become quite an ordeal compared to normal pipe replacement. Not to mention the absurdity of people losing internet when a water pipe bursts!
- crgwbr 5y agoI’m sure the fiber optic cables are at least as safe as the plastic/wood/lead water pipes.
- jacquesm 5y agoThey'll be in another sleeve.
- 13of40 5y agoThe city replaced water mains near my house a couple of years ago that were made of asbestos impregnated concrete. I think the replacements were PVC, so I'm sure they could wrap the cable with something similar. The whole thing sounds kind of 1995, though.
- jagger27 5y agoWe've been putting cables underwater for over a century now. We can already do it in cold, and extremely deep seawater too. I think it'll be fine. I'd love to see this technique become widespread. It's so sad that even in the >1 million person city where I live there still neighbourhoods without fibre-to-the-premises in <current year>.
- FastMonkey 5y agoI guess the Yorkshire countryside is probably depopulating like many rural areas are, so they probably have extra capacity in the water lines. In London, decommissioned gas lines used to be sold to broadband companies to avoid digging up the streets. The difference here though might be that every waterline repair will probably lead to an internet outtage and vice versa. Since this is countryside and they probably wouldn't get the service otherwise, that's probably a trade off their happy to make.
- pmyteh 5y agoSouth Yorkshire's not that rural, compared to the wilder bits of North and East Yorkshire. Penistone and Barnsley are both in the Sheffield travel-to-work area so I doubt they're depopulating fast enough to decommission water mains.
- ck2 5y agoFirst few years no problem. Next few years they go to cheapest supplier in China who has trace toxic chemicals on the wrapper because they bypass the final wash process to save a few cents or their upstream supplier changes out the chemical mix to something cheaper. But you should be using Reverse Osmosis or distilled drinking water anyway given all that's going on with lack of regulation, review or enforcement.
- Dylan16807 5y agoTrace amounts that quickly wash out don't sound like they'd be a big problem. What are the supply considerations for pipes, anyway?
- mr_toad 5y agoSo their internet is going to be a series of tubes?
- larusso 5y agoInteresting. I remember a discussion from a few years ago where it was proposed to use water lines to get broadband cables into Berlin city houses. The issue was/is that it is really expensive to dig up the side of the house, make a hole and seal it up again. The proposal asked to use the main water pipe to run the cable through the wall. This proposal was put down because of fear to contaminate the water. I shared these negative feelings even today. But I wondered why they didn’t propose the sewage pipes? My guess was that the money saved in the process of getting the cable into the houses will be overshadowed by the running costs of maintaining this workaround. This is all from fuzzy memory from about 10 years ago. I’m not sure about all them details.
- cavisne 5y agoSadly this is an ideas that has failed many times in the past, and often run by companies that are outright scams. Over half the cost in wiring a house with fiber is between the curb and the house.
- hattmall 5y agoThis would just be for the backhaul lines. Not going into the house. They could even do 5g micro sites to get it into the home.
- Thlom 5y agoMy town was “fiberized” twice. First by the local power company around 15 years ago. They laid the cable in the streets and then each house had to get their cable from the street and to the house wall (or they could pay a good chunk of money to have the power company do it). A couple of years ago the power company made a huge mistake when they changed TV-solution provider. The new TV-box was so shitty that the old provider started a new fiber company and gave every resident a deal they could not say no to so now most houses have two fiber cables into their house. Anyway, my point was that you can outsource the curb-to-house stretch to the home owners.
- jeltz 5y agoAnd this is why my city only owns the fibers under the streets and lets private companies rent them to provide TV and Internet. That means all building owners can deicide whuch ISP to use snd if one starts sucking they can switch.
- hanniabu 5y agoI bet they won't use food safe cables
- jacquesm 5y agoThey would have to use approved outer tubing inside which optical cable can be blown just like you would otherwise. If you don't do it that way I don't see how you will get the required mechanical stability.
- refurb 5y agoSo you'll need to open up a water line in order to fix/repair the fiber?
- rkangel 5y agoIn practice, fibres don't just break randomly, they break because someone digs them up or the duct they're in collapses or similar. If any of those happens, the water line is going to be broken and need digging up in exactly the same way as if there was no fibre there. And in fact the water line might protect the fibre under some circumstances.
- refurb 5y agoFair point. And I guess depending how it’s installed it may not be that hard to pull new fiber through without actually digging anything up, just from access at two ends.
- rkangel 5y agoI assume that's the point of the system - there are some long stretches of pipe at any place that pipe does anything there'll be some form of access point. So you get to the access point push fibre through to the next point (which could be a half a mile away in rural areas) and then do whatever termination you need. Repeat until broadband.
- Synaesthesia 5y agoIn South Africa, when fiver was released, you were required to dig a trench for the cables, which resulted in all the sidewalks in the whole city being dug up, sometimes even three times (There were several providers), which got me thinking, can’t these fiver cables simple be aerial?
- verst 5y agoIn my neighborhood in Seattle all the Fiber cables hang on utility poles. Is that what you mean by aerial?
- krasin 5y agoMy fiber line (Mountain View, CA, US) is aerial and uses the same poles as electricity. Strong winds cause tree branches to break, which in turn often cut wires. So, they might, but it's less robust than underground, which results in more maintenance and more operational costs to the internet provider.
- FastMonkey 5y agoThe power company where I live installs more ducts than they need when they dig a trench. So they'll install say 10 ducts in the trench when they only need one or two. They rent out the extras to telecoms.
- Jaruzel 5y agoAdding a UK take here: In my area in the South East of England, we have overhead power (and POTS) on poles down the streets. Recently Openreach have been stringing fibre alongside the existing cables. Virgin Media (the other provider) just dug trenches in the pavements about 20 years ago. Added bonus of having overhead power lines? Your lights flicker when it's windy...
- danpalmer 5y agoFYI the "new" here is this specific trial, not the use of water/sewer pipes for fibre, which has been happening for about 15 years now. i3 is an infrastructure company that do this. They trialled a sewer-based fibre network in Bournemouth where I grew up back in ~2010, although it never quite got past the trial stage due to contract issues. They've done similar trials in South Africa, Australia, US, and elsewhere. Not sure if any have rolled out to full scale usage but it's been long enough that I'd expect some have.
- gareth_untether 5y agoAnother commenter has said i3 isa scam company. Taking money to do trials that will never work.
- jacquesm 5y agoA technique that is in trial for 15 years is a failure or a scam. There is a company that has been working on tidal energy for more than two decades now, they are always trialing stuff, it costs millions and it has so far produced less power than you'd need for a lightbulb. And yet they keep getting away with it. This may well be such a scheme, after all, how many complications can there be before you've seen the bulk of them and you can decide to roll out at scale and for which situations the tech is suitable (and for which it isn't).
- aaron695 5y ago
- throwaway892238 5y agoI was just thinking the other day, how can I ingest more microplastics quicker?
- goda90 5y agoI hope you're not drinking out of sewer pipes.
- HellsMaddy 5y agoDrinking tea steeped from those fancy pyramidal teabags is a great way.
- rkangel 5y agoI assume you mean the Teapigs style things? Do they leech microplastics into tea?
- HellsMaddy 5y agohttps://www.cbc.ca/news/science/tea-bags-plastic-study-mcgill-1.5295662 https://www.cbc.ca/news/science/tea-bags-plastic-study-mcgil... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21070351 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21070351 From that thread: > Some of these fancy bags (e.g. from tea pigs) are made from polylactic acid. This is derived from corn starch and used in temporary medical implants (it degrades to lactic acid) so hopefully it's safe. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21072973 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21072973
- mountainriver 5y agoExactly, no thanks, please don’t put leaching substances into the water. I’m sure they say they tested it till someone goes cheap. Think about your kids ingesting that water.
- Ekaros 5y agoEver seen how old iron and steel pipes look inside parts of the world? You are not going to pull cable through those deposits nicely... Or even be allowed to risk it...
- L_226 5y agoYup, I have. I have also seen cured in place pipeliner [0], and I have even been inside a 100+ year old 1.8m oviform pipe that has been lined! [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cured-in-place_pipe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cured-in-place_pipe
- qalmakka 5y agoWhy can't they just do like many other parts of the world and lay fiber alongside underground power cables? Fiber and electric cables mix up well because they don't interfere with each other.
- atdrummond 5y agoI would be cautious here - the persons involved with much of the prominent sewer/fibre corporations in the UK are extremely untrustworthy. Bournemouth's experience here a decade ago is instructive (https://www.zdnet.com/home-and-office/networking/bournemouths-sewer-based-fibre-plan-scrapped/ https://www.zdnet.com/home-and-office/networking/bournemouth...). I personally lead the effort to see a Fibre-to-the-home (FTTH) network deployed in my hometown of Quincy, Illinois. While this was eventually successfully implemented (with no thanks to any external firms, all done locally by our rural county telco coop) we had a false start (https://www.govtech.com/archive/quincy-running-fiber-through-sewers.html https://www.govtech.com/archive/quincy-running-fiber-through...) thanks to i3, the same chuckleheads who scammed Bournemouth through their Fibrecity effort. I likewise ended up with egg on my face, as the public figurehead for Quincy's fibre campaign (https://khqa.com/news/local/bringing-google-high-speed-internet-to-quincy https://khqa.com/news/local/bringing-google-high-speed-inter...), but my only concern was the wasted time and money, and loss of public trust, for our community and its efforts. I would simply recommend all involved be highly cautious; not because any of the underlying technology here is untrustworthy (although I'm skeptical of the technique for many reasons, most of which were well outlined by Jacquesm above) but rather because the underlying firms have their history rooted in nearly two decades of unfulfilled promises and wasted taxpayer funds.
- pleb_nz 5y agoI wonder how much chemicals will make it into the drinking water that we won't know are dangerous for 30 years.
- jacquesm 5y agoYou can trial this all you want it will never be deployed at scale. No water company is going to risk leaching of substances into their carefully laid and coated pipes, water systems are large, complex mechanical systems with parts from very different eras and using these as conduit for anything other than liquids is not nearly as easy as it might seem, there are all kinds of mechanical components in the flow that you have little visibility on (various different kinds of valves including ball valves that you could for this purpose rename 'shears'), baffles, joints, pumps etc. In short: this is an idea that should be discarded before you spend money on the trials because in practice it won't work, and that's before you get into the interruptions every time you want to open up a line for a cable upgrade, the problems involved in fixing anything inside a conduit carrying water under pressure, the inability to enter and exit the conduit at random spots and the various obstacles (seams, older welded joints, socks) that you'll encounter that will make inserting a continuous run of a cable through a water system already in place that wasn't designed very explicitly for that purpose.
- ricardobeat 5y agoI assume they chose this specific 17km stretch specifically for it's technical feasibility (otherwise why would they mention a particular location for the trial). The fiber doesn't need to go all the way via the water network, just enough to reduce construction costs. My first thought was "eh, more plastic leeching crap into the water", but then I remembered that all modern water pipes are already plastic.. too late for that. Most importantly, I was under the impression city-wide water pipes are rarely pressurized, the water 'runs' through it with a substantial air gap - that means entry/exit points are easy, and nothing actually needs to be in contact with the water. Is that not the case?
- DubiousPusher 5y ago> all modern water pipes are already plastic.. too late for that. This is not correct. While PEX pipe has become popular, a lot of homes are still built with copper plumbing. And lots of municipal water infrastructure contains a lot of metal.
- 5y ago
- olivermarks 5y agoI can see this theoretically working in sewers rather than fresh water but that would have a Terry Gilam 'Brazil' vibe to it... https://youtu.be/teufz17PqoY https://youtu.be/teufz17PqoY
- michalxnet 5y agoI would stay sceptical, way to many things can go wrong and british plumbing is an art of it self. I think this the sewer is more suitable approach. One company in Czech republic manage to pull it off after more then decade of research. Article in czech, but there is a lot of pictures to get the idea. https://www.lupa.cz/galerie/pilotni-projekt-unikatni-instalace-optickeho-kabelu-v-kanalizaci/#0 https://www.lupa.cz/galerie/pilotni-projekt-unikatni-instala...
- EricE 5y agoYeah, no thanks. Water is an awesome solvent and long term effects of these things are always worse than expected.