3 ms·
Fought Experiment: Lets say law enforcement was given the task to examine the affairs of 100, randomly selected, poor/medium income households and 100, randoml
by belter 5y ago
Fought Experiment:
Lets say law enforcement was given the task to examine the affairs of 100, randomly selected, poor/medium income households and 100, randomly selected, very wealthy households.
Statistically, where would they find the most amount of criminal activity?
Has any similar research been done, and would you care to share the data?
- Etherlord87 5y agoI'm surprised by the reactions to your comment, because the first thing I thought was "obviously the very wealthy households, because of drugs present".
- belter 5y agoAnd your analysis is corroborated by waste sewage analysis around areas like Wall Street :-)
- Thorentis 5y agoThese types of statistics are politically inconvinient and will never be reported on.
- belter 5y agoBut the data is out there and Data Scientists are not of the shy type...
- HPsquared 5y agoWhat data?
- belter 5y agoNumber of convicted criminals Age of criminal Sex Income Type of crime Residence area Profession
- PeterisP 5y agoOne consideration is that this type of data can't possibly answer the grandparents question, because we know that the rate of prosecution and conviction is rather unequal, so for any subpopulation "number of convicted criminals" can not be expected to be proportional to "number of crimes", if one of two groups has more convictions it does not imply that it actually has done more crime.
- HideousKojima 5y agoFortunately we have other sources of data such as the National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS). The NCVS asks victims of crimes for details about the perpetrators (amongst many other things). The data aren't perfectly comparable due to how the studies are performed, the way things are categorized, etc., but the NCVS largely corroborates the FBI crime reports. Namely, that Blacks and Hispanics commit a hugely disproportionate amount of crime compared to Whites and Asians. https://bjs.ojp.gov/library/publications/race-and-ethnicity-violent-crime-offenders-and-arrestees-2018 https://bjs.ojp.gov/library/publications/race-and-ethnicity-...
- tclancy 5y agoThis is a trick question and I fear that you know it. All manner of petty laws exist effectively just to harass poor people.
- simiones 5y agoWhat do you mean by "find the most amount of criminal activity"? Is this about criminal activity that can be easily found? Is it about criminal activity that happens in the household? Would tax evasion qualify as criminal activity? How about minor building code violations? Labor law violations?
- belter 5y agoAnything the law considers criminal activity. From stealing a car to setting up a secret Cayman Islands Trust fund to avoid taxes.
- banannaise 5y ago"The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges." Using the law as a measure of objectivity is nonsense. The law is in many cases written by rich people for the purpose of policing poor people.
- simiones 5y agoWell, then I'd bet that rich people commit many times more offenses, but that medium-to-low income people would have many times more offenses that can actually be found by searching their homes, or even proven at all.
- cmsonger 5y agoAssuming for a second that the question was asked with legitimate intent: That's the line of reasoning that gets a lot of innocent people treated very very badly based on their socioeconomic status, color of their skin, religion, you name it. Think of it this way: In 1,000,000 people of race blue, the crime rate is 0.01%. So of those million people: 10 are criminals. In 1,000,000 people of race purple, the crime rate is 0.03%. So 30 are criminals. All kinds of horrible sounding statistics here: purple people are 3x more likely to be criminal. Purple people neighborhoods have 3x more crime. Purple people 3x more likely to be murderer, drug user, etc. All of that misleads about the situation: for the most part both purple and blue people are law abiding and any given person you talk to is likely not a criminal. Now there is a second order problem. (The one that the article is referencing). The truth is that among blue and purple the rate of criminals is much higher. Pretend it's +0.3 for each. So 0.04 and 0.06. But the enforcement of laws at each point in the system are subject to discretion of the enforcer. Does the cop pull you over? Does the cop let you off? Does the prosecutor indict? Does the system give you bail? Because of focus on "where would they find the most amount of criminal activity?" we are now creating a self fulfilling prophecy where laws are selectively more greatly enforced against purple.
- belter 5y agoOf course the question was asked with legitimate intent. And because of the issues you raised, that is the reason why the FBI should have in this case knocked that door.
- h2odragon 5y agoHow do you count "criminal activity"? Shoplifiting isn't as big a score as kidnapping and eating a neighbor. How long must someone be a habitual shoplifter to bring their score up to the level of someone cannibalized one person?
- musingsole 5y agoYour thought experiment has a core problem: what is or isn't crime is already a political discussion -- even before mentioning the perpetrators. The wealthy don't commit crimes; they dictate the laws. For your thought experiment, you would have to have an universal definition of what's legal. While that may be hard to come by, I have it on good authority that one of it's most strident claims is: "Retaining more wealth than 80% of citizens is a capital offense."
- goodpoint 5y agoThat's some very loaded phrasing. What are you implying here?
- marcosdumay 5y agoHum... If you are sending the police to arrest people, you better have some odds very close to 100% that they are criminals. If the police is just investigating, they shouldn't have any kind of violent behavior.
- belter 5y agoShould be "Thought Experiment"...can't edit. Bloody mobile auto-complete...