5 ms·
"The tests being done in conjunction with TSA are designed to evaluate how a system that has proven to be highly effective in providing safe travel in the airli
by woodruffw 5y ago
"The tests being done in conjunction with TSA are designed to evaluate how a system that has proven to be highly effective in providing safe travel in the airline industry will work most effectively in passenger rail operations."
Highly effective, indeed[1]. The US would probably be better off dropping the pretense and paying the 55,000 employees of the TSA to do nearly anything else instead. Even continuing to pay them their entire salaries while eliminating their jobs would save money in the form of increased airport efficiency.
[1]: https://www.vox.com/2016/5/17/11687014/tsa-against-airport-security https://www.vox.com/2016/5/17/11687014/tsa-against-airport-s...
- bliteben 5y agoI find it crazy that the US exported this whole system to the world, must be good business for the companies supplying the security theater though.
- crmd 5y agoIsrael was doing it before the US. Going through Ben Gurion airport is next-level unpleasant as a business traveler.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoIsrael was doing it for ~50yr before anyone else was.
- skeeter2020 5y agoYou could also argue that Israel has done a lot of it "right", at least compared to the rest of the world.
- adrian_b 5y agoI have been a frequent flyer with El Al (Israeli airline) both before 2001 and some years after that. I have not flied recently to Israel, so I do not know if their methods have changed, becoming more similar with what is typical for USA and Europe. The methods used by Israel and by USA (the USA methods being imitated by most other countries) for checking the flight passengers did not have any resemblance. After 2001, Israel did not make any change in their procedures, because there was no reason, their procedures were much better than what was invented then in USA. While USA has relied on spending much money on improved machines for scanning people and luggage and in harassing the passengers with things like taking off the shoes, Israel did not rely on machines, but on ancient low-tech methods, i.e. well-trained professionals who questioned the passengers. The main test that you had to pass to be allowed boarding were 2 separate discussions with 2 Israeli security agents, to whom you had to explain the purpose of your flight. The 2 agents asked mostly the same questions, but with various variations in content and order, so you had to tell convincingly the same story twice. From the point of view of the traveler, the disadvantage of the Israeli method was that it was slow, a lot of time was needed for the discussions with the agents. Nevertheless, I prefer that method, because it was much less stressful for me than having to do a lot of unpacking, then undressing, and then dressing, and then packing, while having to be very careful to not have something lost or stolen (I usually travel with a very large number of electronic devices, many of them small and easy to loose; I have also seen once how the laptop of another traveler was successfully stolen before entering the scanning machine, without anyone noticing how; I do not know whether the thief could have been identified later, from the security camera recordings). In many hundreds of flights with El Al, I was subjected to a body search only once, while on the airlines embracing the USA model, many travelers now do not remember any more the times when they did not have to pass through a body and personal luggage security check. The only one case when I had to pass through a body search was because I happened too be extremely tired and I wished that the discussions would pass faster, but of course, my noticeable haste had the opposite effect. The flight was late in the evening and all the day I had been extremely busy. I had literally run through the city the entire day, to complete various errands in time from the flight. After much effort, I had succeeded to reach the airport just in time, but I was exhausted and I just wanted to reach the airplane ASAP, to finally be able to rest. However, the security agents noticed that I seem to be in a hurry, and they thought that this is suspicious. Therefore I had to also pass through the body search, but like I have said, they did not do such searches on everyone, but only when they had grounds for suspicion.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoIt's really important we have that 3 in 70 chance the TSA catches someone trying to get a bomb onboard a plane! Airport security isn't about preventing loss of life. It's about keeping the passenger airline industry alive. Biden is famously pro-rail and I think this is just a way of killing off rail before he has a chance to fund a bunch of construction and equipment. Which is sad, because our federal highway system is crumbling in decay because we way, way overbuilt it. It's all moot. No matter how much security there is, no matter how badly intelligence services or political leaders fuck up (in the case of 9/11, it was political leadership. In the case of the Boston Marathon bombing, it was intelligence), they'll just shout that they need more surveillance, more security measures, more rules. Nobody will ever say "no, you intelligence people need to do your job properly."
- nullc 5y agoThe TSA works for Biden, this is an action of an executive branch office, and an action that requires a significant amount of budget. If Biden didn't want this to happen it would stop at a stroke of his pen. If this is a move to kill passenger rail, then it's Biden that is killing it. When I lived near Dulles airport I frequently used the train to travel up the north east as far as NY or Boston-- even though the train was often more expensive. The fact that I didn't have to deal with the TSA and their intrusive searches was a significant part of that. From the article it sounds like they're only currently planning to quietly invade your privacy in the background, which might not the rail killing effect you are concerned with. But if they did go full airport-tsa style handling of the trains then I wouldn't be shocked if it killed passenger rail: Not dealing with the TSA may not be a reason for most passengers, but it only has to be a reason for enough to bring it under a threshold of viability.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoIt seems unlikely that Biden wants to kill passenger rail. He's made a pretty big deal of using Amtrak between DC and Delaware to commute when he was in Congress. TSA has tried this before with Amtrak and it's possible that this decision is being made at a level lower than that of the president.
- changoplatanero 5y agoI tried to estimate how many deaths TSA is responsible for from traffic fatalities from their employees commuting to work, thinking that maybe more people died this way than lives were saved from prevented terror attacks. Turns out driving is really safe and not many fatalities are due to TSA employees commutes.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoThe article shows the number of people who died due to driving because driving increased when airline travel decreased due to the TSA.
- labster 5y agoBut how many people were saved from cancer deaths, because they weren’t exposed to more radiation in the upper atmosphere? Is that offset by breathing more ozone and PM2.5 on the roadway?
- vlovich123 5y agoNo. That's the same amount of radiation as eating an average banana gives you.
- dylan604 5y agoI've never understood the banana reference. Are they saying that there's so little radiation from a high altitude flight that it's the equivalent to a banana, or that a banana is an unusually high source of radiation?
- vlovich123 5y agoBananas are rich in potassium which can be radioactive. On average, bananas emit roughly similar amounts of radiation as high altitude flight. The intent is to demonstrate the silliness of the argument that flying poses some kind of radiation risk that elevates mortality - would you claim that eating a banana (even at population scale) meaningfully changes mortality? People hear radiation and lose rationality because of the fear mongering in the 50s and beyond.
- hparadiz 5y agoHaving to go through TSA makes it even harder for trains to compete with cars.
- LewisVerstappen 5y agoHey man, if this system can prevent just one train-hijacking then it will be worth it. /s
- sandworm101 5y agoIn defense of the TSA, "security theater" is a legitimate form of security. They may never catch any would-be hijackers, but how many didn't make an attempt because they knew that they wouldn't be able to reliably sneak a gun past security? Look into news reports from the 60s and 70s, before serious security at airports. Hijackings were almost normal. Today, hijackings are thankfully almost non-existent. You don't end speed traps just because nobody got caught speeding last year. I also appreciate the security theater because it makes airports a generally drug-free environment. I bet few here have ever spent much time on a bus. Not a short hop on a city bus, an overnight inter-state trip on a greyhound. I have a couple times and each time I would have PAID for a TSA-style check before boarding. It would weed out 99% of crazy/high people who make such journeys so miserable for everyone around them. A typical long trip by bus, without the TSA: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mwOYroU7bk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mwOYroU7bk
- arcticbull 5y agoAnyone whose goal is to sneak a weapon through TSA would do a quick google and learn that they fail to catch weapons and contraband snuck through their checkpoints in their own tests about 95% of the time [1]. [1] https://abcnews.go.com/US/exclusive-undercover-dhs-tests-find-widespread-security-failures/story?id=31434881 https://abcnews.go.com/US/exclusive-undercover-dhs-tests-fin...
- sandworm101 5y agoEveryone has seen those results, but have you looked into the nature of the devices they were using? These weren't handguns or swords. These were devices designed to mimic bombs, bombs built to best sneak past security checks.
- woodruffw 5y ago> These were devices designed to mimic bombs, bombs built to best sneak past security checks. If I was a terrorist looking to bring a bomb onto a plane, I would probably also build it to sneak past security checks. Isn't that the point?
- jancsika 5y ago> Even continuing to pay them their entire salaries while eliminating their jobs would save money in the form of increased airport efficiency. Like many pro-efficiency/anti-waste rants, yours ended up flying to close to the sun here. If you eliminate the TSA you also eliminate the entity doing the random screenings. And random screenings do provide some security which is difficult to game. Hell, random screenings even publicly signal their unpredictability by generating news stories about a famous presidential candidate being pulled out of the line for a random screening. That's the only bona fide security feature I know about the TSA-- I'm not a security expert, so there may be others.
- KerrAvon 5y agoNope, total bullshit. Two things have made the skies safer since 9/11: - reinforced cockpit doors - passengers now actively resist hijackers Everything else is security theater.
- dangerwill 5y ago100% correct
- woodruffw 5y agoI would love a concrete study demonstrating the benefits of random screenings. Absent that, I'm not convinced that they are either beneficial or random.
- djfobbz 5y agoIf you think that your government is keeping you safe, good luck to you!
- woodruffw 5y agoThe government keeps us safe in plenty of ways (food and drug regulations come to mind immediately). The TSA just happens to not be one of those ways.
- theknocker 5y ago