8 ms·
What is the Eurodollar System? (2020) [pdf]
- ganzuul 5y agoWhen the price is the same in euros and dollars even though the exchange rate is wildly different, I call that a eurodollar and have done so for over a decade. IMO the use in the article isn't notable enough to scoop me.
- ericpauley 5y agoWould being a “fundamental building block of the financial market” [1] be enough? CME launched this futures market in 1981. [1] https://www.cmegroup.com/markets/interest-rates/stirs/eurodollar.html https://www.cmegroup.com/markets/interest-rates/stirs/eurodo...
- ganzuul 5y agoNo. Such things are irrelevant to people who are underpaid and live on rent. It's just a concern of an extremely privileged few who never care to interact with people like me. Perhaps the system is important. It can get by with a clunky name for how little use it sees. It's simply not part of my reality.
- hd4 5y agoStrongly recommend watching Eurodollar University, Emil and Jeff have some unique takes. https://youtube.com/c/EmilKalinowski https://youtube.com/c/EmilKalinowski
- bjelkeman-again 5y agoThis seems like a decent starting video from that: https://youtu.be/Nhyz4DUMht8 https://youtu.be/Nhyz4DUMht8
- bjelkeman-again 5y agoEven more relevant now in the context of the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
- codeflo 5y agoIf it weren't for the source, the cringy Matrix references and sensationalist writing would have made me dismiss this without much thought. The Wikipedia article on Eurodollars and some others make all of this sound a lot more mundane. So I'm confused. Does anyone know, or have a better source, whether there's actual cause for concern?
- hkon 5y agoRead the comments first as usual, and thought, hmm some references to Matrix can't be that bad. Color me surprised.
- tomc1985 5y agoIt's awfully patronizing for something coming from what I understand to be one of the larger Dutch banks. It reminds me of some of the internally-circulated bank employee training videos that I've had to watch for a past job, but none of them were this bad.
- mise_en_place 5y agoInterestingly, there is a Eurodollar future provided by CME. It is currently quoted at 96.765, meaning a deposit rate of 3.235%. Does that mean that the global market for dollars has already priced in Fed rate hikes?
- JackFr 5y agoYes, in a nutshell.
- lotaezenwa 5y agoYes, and this eurodollar futures price (and related options contracts) is used to derive, mathematically, the "percent chance of a rate hike" that you see around the fed meetings.
- epgui 5y agoI admit that this has piqued my curiosity, but my bs-meter is flashing yellow: this document is barely coherent.
- jrochkind1 5y agoI was wondering if it was just me being old thinking this sounded like it was written by a teenager on reddit. I kept looking at the hostname, is this really a legit financial organization hosting it?
- caminante 5y agoI can't disagree more. The first page alone defines what a eurodollar is(n't) in clear terms.
- epgui 5y agoI don’t have a problem with the definition. I’m not sure who or what you’re disagreeing with.
- caminante 5y agoYou said > this document is barely coherent. Then say > I don’t have a problem with the definition To a reasonable person, these two statements are not consistent. edit: I just get a feeling that you're relying on logical fallacy [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman
- tiku 5y agoEven tether/other usd stablecoins fall under this definition right? They all are stored elsewhere outside of the us, in part.
- lottin 5y agoThese are dollar derivatives—a financial instrument that is redeemable by USD at a fixed exchange rate, which is backed (theoretically) by reserves. Eurodollars are just USD deposits held outside the US.
- BlueTemplar 5y agoNot only deposits, but also debts ?
- lottin 5y agoNo, debts are a different type of asset. Eurodollars are currency, i.e. cash and bank deposits.
- cturner 5y agoA bank deposit is a debt, right?
- lottin 5y agoNo, it's a deposit which you can withdraw at any time. Although some people argue that a bank deposit is technically a loan—from a legal perspective they might be characterised as a loan in some jurisdictions, from an economic perspective a deposit is cash and not a loan.
- BlueTemplar 5y agoBut then how do you get the multiplicative effect described in the article without any debt ??
- j4yav 5y agoWhat is with all the Matrix references?
- throwaway13337 5y agoInteresting to see this topic posted here. I've gotten interested in eurodollars recently. Maybe it's one of those internet collective consciousness things? The big takeaway for me with the eurodollar deep dives is that the global monetary system creates money (mostly dollars) through loans. These loans are given by parties that are not able, officially, to print dollars but, at the same time, 'print' by loaning them - or rather the promise to pay, in dollars mostly, some sum that the loaner has fractionally. That is, they don't own as many dollars as they're loaning. It's just entries in a database. In this way, more dollars can enter the global monetary system than can be controlled by the US at all. This is kind of a revelation. It means that the special power that the US has in printing dollars is only special in that it can never default on the dollars because it can, in the end, print them for real. I've long thought that the US has had a major advantage in that they can 'tax' trade by requiring the world to hold these dollars that only they can print. They still have something special in their ability to never default on them but not in their ability to print them.
- boppo1 5y ago> not in their ability to print them Bond buying & yield curve intervention is pretty special. And catastrophic, IMO.
- kzrdude 5y agoDoesn't the same apply to domestic banks? Most units of any currency is created by commercial banks, not by the central bank.
- walterbell 5y agoThe scale is notable. > The results are as shown below as of end-2018: USD57 trillion, nearly three times the size of the US economy before it was hit by the COVID-19 virus. Even if this measure is not complete, it underlines the scale of the market.
- throwaway13337 5y agoYes. The banks are the ones that ultimately are creating money through giving out loans. The fed, as far as I understand, can only influence this indirectly. Interest rate setting is supposed to throttle the demand for loans. Lower interest rates, higher loan demand. Therefore, more money enters the economy. However, the other side of the equation is the banks' appetite for giving loans. There are times when banks (due to regulation or market risk they perceive) that they'll be more or less likely to make loans regardless of the demand side. The fed seems to be only controlling the demand and not the supply. They cannot force banks to make loans more willingly directly. Another aspect is the appetite for the sorts of loans banks want to give. There's an argument that too many loans are now given for speculation (housing, asset purchase) and not for things that grow the economic pie like small businesses. Small business are more risky for the banks than speculation so we end up in this sort of undead economy.
- nathias 5y agoDebt is very useful for financial formalization, it can translate actual existing trust/political relationships into monetary ones. It is feudalism distilled to its pure elements.
- walterbell 5y agoMatrix-analogy-free podcast from 2019, https://www.macrovoices.com/podcast-transcripts/548-jeff-snider-eurodollar-system-overview https://www.macrovoices.com/podcast-transcripts/548-jeff-sni... > You contend that there are massive amounts of US dollar money supply being created outside of the banking system and, therefore, outside of oversight and regulation by the Federal Reserve ... it wasn’t until 1964 that anyone in any kind of official capacity finally got around to investigating this thing, even though it was almost a decade old by then. The Bank for International Settlements finally published the first study on the subject of Eurodollars ... people like Milton Friedman and Paul Einzig, very highly respected people in finance that no one questions the credibility of, who are attesting that this was actually going on as long ago as the 1960s. Cambridge University, March 2022, https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/enterprise-and-society/article/abs/banking-and-eurodollars-in-italy-in-the-1950s/32A572F724877D45E2D924C4A7C28D3D https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/enterprise-and-socie... > This article challenges current interpretations of the rise of the Eurodollar market. It argues that rather than being the exclusive innovation of British banks, the Eurodollar market had also Italian origins ... resulting from the fact that nonresident foreign-currency deposits were not subject to reserve requirements ... The comparison facilitates an approximate estimation of the size of the Eurocurrency market in the late 1950s and, even more importantly, a recalibration of the view that the City of London was the dominant Eurodollar player from the outset.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- IAmEveryone 5y agoI was waiting for the paragraph "revealing" that it's George Soros or the Rothschilds pulling all the strings... The topic is ripe with (sometimes actively harmful) conspiracy theories already, it's neither funny nor enlightening to inject more of it.
- edulete123 5y ago[flagged]
- levzettelin 5y ago
- cturner 5y agoThis is not correct - "Consider what the logic of the Eurodollar system implies. Global financial markets and the global economy rely on the common standard of the USD for pricing, accounting, trading, and deal making. Imagine a world with a hundred different currencies – or even a dozen: it would be hugely problematic to manage, and would not allow anywhere near the level of integration we currently enjoy" 1. It is common to use USD because it is convenient, but it is not a standard. There is no structure that forces it. 2. The world does have dozens of liquid currencies already. Banks do offer rates on them. And banks do trade in them without the USD being in play. 3. It is simply not true that the current system of floating exchange rates would fail to function without the USD. The author moves on to talking about it being a privilege to be a reserve currency. It is not a privilege to be the reserve currency - countries generally go out of their way to avoid it happening - the Swiss central bank headed it off within the last ten years. Patrick Boyle's recent video /The Weaponization Of The Dollar/ touches on this in the last few minutes. I stopped reading here. The concept of Eurodollars (US-denominated debt outside the reach of US foreign policy) has been effectively obsolete in the developed world for decades. Any bank who has a balance sheet large enough to be involved in significant trading operations (e.g. operating as a top-level general clearing member at a clearing house, or acting as a prime broker for foreign exchange transfers) is also able to qualify for an account with the US central bank. This gives them access to cheap lending (free money). When you take on this membership, you sign up to align with aspects of US foreign policy. And not just for stuff you do that is denominated in USD - it applies to all your business globally. A recent example of this - Deutsche Bank got fined for money laundering done by Danske's Estonian Branch. Danske were operating on DB's balance sheet, which means that DB had failed to ensure that their balance sheet use aligned with US standards on money laundering, so DB got fined in the US even though they had no direct hand in the wrong-doing. It is these arrangements that allow the US to be so effective in launching sanctions against other countries. Consider how Trump decided to go after Iran even though European countries wanted to stick by the Obama-era deal, and how thorough those sanctions have been. Is it possible to have a top-tier western bank who choses not to have a relationship with the US central bank? Hypothetically, yes, but who would do such a thing? Such a bank would lose access to cheap lending in the world's largest economy and would lose economies of scale. It is not the USD that is powerful, it is the US. The US is a vast economy with a strong rule of law tradition. Common use of USD is a side-effect of that.
- Projectiboga 5y agoIssue with creating money "at interest" is the interest is never created. This has facilitated all sorts of exploitation over the last 4, 500 years. Slavery, large wars, exploitive business practices, resource extraction, fossil fuels are all encouraged by this need to grab more than is there.
- intrasight 5y ago“...Gold is gold everywhere, fungible and indifferent. But when a disk of gold is stamped by a coiner with certain pompous words and the picture of a King, it takes on added value -- seigneurage. It has that value only in that people believe that it does -- it is a shared phant'sy.” - Neal Stephenson, The Confusion Good discussion in Wired interview: https://www.wired.com/2004/04/clearing-up-the-confusion/ https://www.wired.com/2004/04/clearing-up-the-confusion/
- specproc 5y agoThey're called Eddies, choomba.
- mikaeluman 5y agoIndeed an interesting topic. The demand for dollars largely stem from the ability to use them. When doing international trade you want to be paid in a currency you know is fairly stable and exchangeable to other goods and services with relative ease. When sovereigns in developing countries issue bonds they tend to need to do it in USD to get any takers; else the risk of their inflating the value of their currency away is just to great. As US dominance decreases it's currency will face competition from e.g. the yuan. Ray Dalio writes about this in his "The Changing World Order".