7 ms·
Tell HN: iOS Signal eats your disk space
Signal on iOS will not free up any disk space when you delete chats or media. You cannot see or clear usage in the app or in iOS settings. There’s a potential security problem where your data is not actually being deleted when you delete chats.
We are having no luck getting the Signal team to acknowledge the issue. The ticket was automatically closed despite activity.
https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-iOS/issues/4916
1. Be aware that a large portion of your storage space might be stolen by Signal.
2. Be aware that this might be a significant security flaw.
3. If anyone can get Signal to pay attention rather than closing repeated tickets as stale, that would be great.
- Strom 5y agoThat stale bot is quite the sight. It seems the Signal team has fully adopted the ostrich strategy for dealing with issues.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xerxes901 5y agoNothing infuriates me more than googling for a problem I’m having and finding a relevant issue that’s been closed by a bot as “stale”. I _get_ that I don’t have any right to free maintenance, but the stale bot paints some veneer of process around a maintainer thinking “issue looks hard, doesn’t affect me, so I don’t care”. I would just so much prefer them to be honest and just say that rather than passive-aggressively send me emails every 30 days warning that my issue is becoming stale or whatever.
- userbinator 5y agoI'd prefer they just leave them alone and open. This sort of "ADHD-driven development" that heavily biases towards novelty and ease over quality and stability is a real problem with a lot of software today.
- ______-_-______ 5y agoI thought stalebot was supposed to back down if people were commenting. But this time it added a "wontfix" tag right away, ignored the humans and closed the issue anyway. The scourge is getting worse.
- Avamander 5y agoIt's not even about expecting free development and fixes, it's about mutual respect. I respect that a developer doesn't have to fix an issue I report, but it's only fair that the time I spent on gathering information and reporting the issue is respected. It should be triaged, valid reports should be marked as such and if it's never gonna be dealt with then it should be closed. Not some kind of software development equivalent of stringing someone along as a side b***ch.
- samhw 5y ago> stringing someone along as a side b***ch Side blotch? Side bleach?
- proactivesvcs 5y agoOf the issues I've replied to, closed by the stale bot, they've been reopened.
- naoqj 5y agoAnd still you shouldn't have had to reply to those issues to keep them open.
- proactivesvcs 5y agoA small team with nearly 1000 open tickets needs a way to manage those issues which are genuinely stale.
- Avamander 5y agoIt's called triaging your tickets, not letting a bot roam free hoping to catch someone that didn't press a button at the right time. It's disrespectful to the reporters' time and effort to keep pestering them with an inane bot. It doesn't fix the issues reported. It just makes the bot owner feel good that they have fewer tickets open.
- proactivesvcs 5y agoI agree on most of your points but triaging requires resources - setting up a bot to quickly close stale issues is a poor stopgap but it seems they felt they had to do something.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jonas21 5y agoWhy not? It seems like a reasonable way to prioritize fixing issues that people actually care about.
- woodruffw 5y agoThis isn’t great in terms of storage waste, but I don’t think this is a “significant” security risk for the average user: most users should have both iOS FDE enabled and Signal’s own DB is encrypted (with a stored key, but accessing that key requires ACE, which is already a “game over” condition). If you want guaranteed deletion (modulo screenshots), you should probably use timed/self-destructing messages. That’s what they’re there for.
- nicoburns 5y agoFull access to be device isn’t a “game over” scenario if the content is no longer on the device at all. The lack of this deletion feature means that something like WhatsApp is much more secure against certain threat scenarios.
- outsb 5y agoSignal's insistence on doing the wrong thing for 99% of users (storing media blobs in SQLite) drives me crazy. Protect our metadata over the wire, fine, but there is almost no additional protective benefit whatsoever by storing the files inside SQLCipher when the user's fingers can be broken one-by-one until they unlock their phone. Meanwhile it causes issues just like this, not to mention broken integration with every audio/gallery/video app on the device.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- proactivesvcs 5y agoAccusing them of doing the "wrong thing for 99% of their users" is pretty hyperbolic. They've managed the feat of offering simple, easy E2EE for messages, audio and video calls for one-to-one and groups, without charging anyone a penny for it. Their protocol is so successful it's been adopted by others and is often considered a gold standard.
- jimkleiber 5y agoHaving used SQLCipher myself for an app I created, I've often thought about the tradeoffs between security and convenience. I struggle to see how the only benefit to using SQLCipher to encrypt the stored data is to try to protect against someone breaking someone's fingers and forcing someone to give up their password. Do you not think there are other, much less violent, ways for someone to read an unencrypted database on a phone?
- saurik 5y agoThe files on disk are already encrypted (or at least are encryptable: there is a flag the developer can technically turn off), remember, by iOS itself; this is an additional layer of what I'd think really amounts to nothing more than "obfuscation" added by the application (unless the app itself has to be separately unlocked each time you use it--to prevent this key from being stored on disk--which I don't think is true of Signal? or, if it is, is not how that user is clearly using it). The concept of SQLCipher makes the most sense as part of some (evil) defense-in-depth DRM scheme, with the goal of preventing the owner of the phone from getting access to data that is "for developer eyes only", which is how I swear I most often had seen it used. (It is also fine for encrypting data files in transit, or putting passwords on specific files; which, of course, fits perfectly with sqlite being used as an app-specific file format, but that definitely isn't the case for here.)
- javajosh 5y agoThey should not have closed the bug, but you have an opportunity to put on your hacker hat and take control of your device storage! Do you know how to attach a debugger to an iOS process? If necessary, could you fork the client, modify and install it locally? Do you know how to find out which files are taking up all the space, and delete them, from inside the process? (It's actually one reason I prefer Android because although I'm not an Android dev, I want (need?) to be able to do all of these things on my own devices.)
- kitsunesoba 5y agoSignal seems increasingly like a Tesla in the chat space, where certain parts of the product are excellent (E2E encryption and battery/drivetrain, respectively) but everything else sits between mediocre and bad, and the bad parts are rarely acknowledged or improved upon. Disappointing.
- woodruffw 5y agoThe chief distinction being that Signal is a nonprofit foundation with a revenue measured in millions of dollars[1], while Tesla's market cap is over $1T. There are comparatively few excuses Tesla can make that can simultaneously justify that kind of speculative valuation. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signal_Foundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signal_Foundation
- shukantpal 5y agoTesla does not need to justify it's valuation. That's set by shareholders.
- woodruffw 5y agoI think you misread my comment. I'm not asking for Tesla's justification; I'm expressing my own view that the market's valuation of Tesla is excessive. You're welcome to disagree, but the underlying point remains: Tesla is fundamentally not resource-constrained in the way Signal is.
- mikece 5y agoSignal is a nice entry into encrypted chat. The fast signup makes it easy for me to recommend it. I prefer to use Wire, Threema, or Element but concede that too few people really care about private chat. This issue of Signal gobbling up storage space is an issue, possibly enough to gift licenses for Threema to the people with whom I chat the most.
- lmns 5y agoThreema's protocol doesn't even implement forward secrecy. From a security standpoint Threema is closer to iMessage than to Signal or other Signal-protocol-based messengers.
- Silhouette 5y agoI really wish there were better secure communications apps. Signal is good for encrypting messages/calls, which is the main feature I happen to care about personally. It's awful for keeping important communications safe, though, because it's deliberately tied to a single device that is highly likely to be broken or lost. There is still no sensible way for users to even export their Signal message history to another safe place as a backup, for whatever their personal definition of "safe" happens to be.
- rvz 5y agoWire, and Threema seem to be much better than Signal.
- stereoradonc 5y agoTelegram, too. I know its not the favourite of this community here, but it offers everything else that these clients can't even imagine.
- proactivesvcs 5y ago1. It's not stolen. It's used. It may not be used efficiently (or, if you're correct, used sensibly at all) but it's not stolen. 2. If deleted data not being purged from your iOS device is a "significant security flaw" then you shouldn't be using a device from Apple or Google; your threat model is way beyond the two big players. 3. Hyperbolic comments[1] don't help issues being re-opened. Helpful comments, preferably with steps to reproduce, and a polite note that the issue is still current, will get the issue re-opened in my experience. Getting on your high horse and making silly claims would get you put to the bottom of the pile if it were my job. [1] https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-iOS/issues/4916#issuecomment-1084723087 https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-iOS/issues/4916#issuecom...
- ribs 5y agoEh, sometimes going hyperbolic does the trick, but yeah, it’s not the most beneficial tactic, overall
- gruez 5y ago>Eh, sometimes going hyperbolic does the trick When has it ever worked?
- nh2 5y agoIt's not a hyperbolic comment. The Signal stale bot is bad and frustrates anybody contributing. * I've reported NullPointerExceptions with stack traces, stale bot comes to close. * I've reported Signal fatally corrupting its DB and losing all its data [1], stale bot comes to close. Few things are more frustrating than investing your free time, and then finding an automated system pitted against you. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26841134 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26841134, https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/issues/11160#issuecomment-1022315870 https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/issues/11160#iss...
- danuker 5y agoThe most prominent red flag about Signal is that, for all its purported commitment to "developing open source privacy technology", a real, working open-source app is not on F-Droid. https://forum.f-droid.org/t/we-can-include-signal-in-f-droid/7373 https://forum.f-droid.org/t/we-can-include-signal-in-f-droid...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- reayn 5y agoIt also eats up disk space on macOS (and I assume every other desktop considering the client is the same), I've had to reinstall it multiple times now just to save almost a dozen gigabytes of space... I'm not even an active signal user, I only have a few friends on there, I can only imagine what it's like for someone who uses signal as their only chat app, it must get crazy. Disappearing messages (4 weeks etc.) help mitigate the problem a little bit from what I've noticed but it's nowhere near a complete solution.
- proactivesvcs 5y agoThis is a real pain on desktop. I've taken to try to remember to delete files I've sent/received straight away if I don't need them.
- adastra22 5y agoAre you guys sending HD movies around or something? How is a chat app using dozens of gigabytes for message logs?
- reayn 5y agoI semi-frequently send audio files to one of the aforementioned friends of mine, and that’s about it. Everything else is just images (which signal compresses to oblivion btw) and stickers. The fact that there’s no way to view individual files that have been sent to/from me (+ their sizes) and remove them—like there is for messages.app in macOS—makes troubleshooting even harder here. I will admit though that I haven’t looked too far into the problem but it’s seems to be an issue that just about every signal user I know deals with.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- speedgoose 5y agoThese bots that close issues automatically because of lack of activity are so frustrating. It doesn’t take much time for a human to do the same and you don’t lack respect to your users. What are the benefits? A virtually smaller list of issues? It’s not because they are closed that they don’t exist.
- fhaldridge7 5y agonot sure if you already read this, but there was a discussion about these bots here a while ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28998374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28998374
- millerm 5y agoI don’t see this behavior on either my iPad or iPhone. They both are using about 12 MB of document storage space. I’ve been using Signal for years. My chats all expire in 1 hour, perhaps that feature delete’s correctly. Note: Twitter, on the other hand, is using over a gigabyte of local storage for some strange reason. Signal is open source, maybe somebody can go in and fix it if there is a problem. I suppose if someone’s extremely paranoid they could just simply delete the app and reinstall. Though Signal does do some strange replication of data I have never understood, because I’ve installed it on a laptop and saw it pull down a bunch of chat history that I thought I had deleted, but still couldn’t see in the app.