7 ms·
What we need is more enforcement of existing labor laws. A 40-hour work week with teeth. No "unpaid overtime". No "time shaving". Out of hours phone calls count
by Animats 5y ago
What we need is more enforcement of existing labor laws. A 40-hour work week with teeth. No "unpaid overtime". No "time shaving". Out of hours phone calls count as work time, with a minimum time for a call. (3 hours in the movie industry).
- marricks 5y agoWe need a slew of things to change but not much will with the current power imbalances. Courts still won't/aren't going to hold companies accountable when million dollar lawyers and well priced bribes can save their assess. Arguing about which band aid is best feels a bit like a distraction.
- thot_experiment 5y agoYes, I mean we should also have a 32 hour work week but the laws surrounding it need teeth for sure. We should hold executives/managers criminally liable with the potential for jail time for repeat offenses. It's absolutely fucking absurd that shoplifting, especially when performed by disadvantaged folks carries harsher penalties than systematic wage theft. It's upside down clown world out there, abusing your position of power is FAR worse than stealing to eat or even fund a drug habit.
- pc86 5y agoAre you saying the punishment for shoplifting should be less if you're disadvantaged compared to if you're not?
- thot_experiment 5y agoNo, I'm saying the reality is that the punishment often IS harsher if you're from a disadvantaged group. I think the punishments should be harsher for wage theft than shoplifting because the former is abusing a position of power, which I believe to be more corrosive to the fabric of society. Though I also believe punishments should be proportional to your means, see for example speeding tickets in Finland. You shouldn't be able to afford to ignore the rules.
- lores 5y agoNot to mention that stealing $100 from 100 workers is objectively a worse crime than stealing $100 from a shop owner, and yet the former is not even punished. Talk about regulatory capture, eh?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mschuster91 5y agoFor what it's worth, that was the legal situation in Germany until 1975 [1]. A shame in my opinion that even small-scale theft under extraordinary circumstances got handled as a full blown crime since then. [1] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mundraub https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mundraub
- jslaby 5y agoYes
- ALittleLight 5y agoIn the current regime it seems like crimes are punished less if you are advantaged. The current system seems like a worse arrangement to me because it adds disadvantage to disadvantage.
- aaomidi 5y agoActually, yes. Punishment doesn't fix the need to shoplift. Maybe if we stop trying to solve everything with cops we'd actually make some social progress?
- syshum 5y agoI did not think shoplifting was punished at all in California.
- Animats 5y agoAn interesting thing about white collar crime - jail time is a real deterrent. It doesn't take that much jail time.[1] Routinely sending managers to jail for 30 days for time-shaving would stop that practice rapidly. [1] https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/how-stop-white-collar-crime https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/how-stop-white-collar-...
- farseer 5y agoThis! 40 hours workweek with mandatory overtime pay (usually double per hour) with a minimum duration. Reducing the workweek below that would be considered unnecessary government intervention and is liable to be bad for business and workers. No one wants a pay cut that goes with it.
- t0mas88 5y agoThe proposal isn't a paycut right? As written employees keep the same pay but work 32 hours instead of 40.
- pc86 5y agoOne, there are a lot of businesses that operate on margins well under 20%. Some percentage of these would absolutely go out of business if you somehow mandated 80% of the current hours for 100% of the current pay. Now you can argue they should go out of business anyway, and maybe you're right, but it's still the government passing a law to intentionally put a lot of people out of business and make a lot of people lose their jobs. Two, FTA "the proposed bill would require these employers to compensate employees who work in excess of 32 hours per week at 1 ½ times the employee’s regular rate of pay" - it's unclear to me how this impacts exempt vs. non-exempt workers. If you're salaried in California and you work 50 hours a week it's not like you get paid any more. Those are 10 hours of unpaid overtime. This doesn't seem to change that concept. If they're only talking about hourly workers, then it's a pay cut no matter what. In the "Disadvantages" section of the article it further implies that these changes would mostly impact hourly/non-exempt workers. Three, why the differentiation between <=500 and >500 workers? If I'm an hourly worker someplace with ~490ish employees who works 40h/wk I'm going to have to worry about my hours being cut because of hiring I have nothing to do with. If I'm consistently getting overtime for a larger employer at ~40 hours a week, I'm going to receive a pay cut if they downsize and that work is no longer considered overtime. Four, and perhaps most importantly, this is never getting signed into law. It's a publicity/donor stunt by some politicians and nothing more.
- thomascgalvin 5y ago
- artificialLimbs 5y agoWhat I’d like to see is less government power, which means they stay out of my life, which means more freedom and less coercion, which means I can negotiate my life as I see fit like a grown up who is responsible for himself.
- hinkley 5y agoAnd you’ll create a power vacuum that business will gleefully dive into and give you less freedom, more coercion, and less ability to negotiate your life as you see fit. If you don’t remember why unions and OSHA exist then you are doomed to repeat it. Captains industry have no problems oiling their machines with human blood.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoExactly how much are you willing to be coerced to put food on the table? Because that's what we are really looking at here: Employers having power to coerce you into lifestyles and coerce you into things just so that you can put food on the table. Laws protecting employees (most of us!) are there because employers didn't simply treat people well, and people had little choice if they wanted to eat. And I'll point out that you might be a grown up, but you live in a society. Simply taking care of yourself isn't enough, not only because other people are obviously doing things that benefit you greatly. You know, like treat patients in emergency rooms and uphold wiring standards so your air conditioner doesn't burn your house down, and even if it does the fire department puts the fire out without even forcing you to sell it for cheap or show proof of fire insurance. You couldn't help where you were born, nor did you have a choice in your own primary education, nor whether or not your parents were rich or poor. You might be responsible for yourself now, but you don't fully take care of yourself, your starting level got chosen by others, and you are at the mercy of the actions of others, which can greatly affect your day to day life.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThe government is the single most coercive entity making me work more to put food on the table. I work approximately 30% of my time to pay for services I don't want provided and mostly don't use. If you want to talk about coercion, my employer gives me money for my services and I have the ability to walk away at any time. My government takes my money, and if I resist, they will put me in jail or kill me if I resist. I am indeed at the mercy of the actions of others, but I am by far most helpless against the government.
- jeffbee 5y agoReal enforcement with teeth would help a lot with several issues. One of the biggest is that construction projects in California drag on and on because an inspector will show up at a non-union job site to stop work and survey the labor to make sure they are getting paid and have fair working conditions. By "frequently" I mean weekly or more. This has massive productivity impacts, but they have to keep doing it because wage theft is endemic. If wage theft convictions came with decades-long prison sentences, this would stop. Unfortunately the public does not have an appetite for punishing white-collar crime, they only want long prison sentences for homeless guys who steal shampoo.