5 ms·
We made an explicit decision to not lie to our kids about Santa Claus or anything else. It was a good call.
by pfdietz 5y ago
We made an explicit decision to not lie to our kids about Santa Claus or anything else. It was a good call.
- admiralpumpkin 5y agoWe have told our child that a "Santa" is someone who gives without any expectations, sometimes secretly or anonymously. We empowered them to be a Santa if they want to be one.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat sounds like a great approach!
- asiachick 5y agoMom? Are you planning a surprise party for me for my birthday? I think telling my kids things for their enjoyment is ok. I don't believe me or my siblings were hurt by our parents given us the santa myth and I also feel it was an important life lesson to discover santa didn't exist.
- toast0 5y ago> Mom? Are you planning a surprise party for me for my birthday? How would you feel if you did have a suprise party? / No, but would you like me too? / No, but would that be ok for a future birthday? What do you think I would tell you if you asked me that and I was planning a surprise party? Or if I wasn't? You don't have to answer all their questions. Personally, I'd say, no, I don't like surprise parties, so I'm not going to plan one for someone, but for the sake of argument, I'll pretend I might.
- Aeolun 5y ago“If I told you it wouldn’t be a surprise any more, would it?”
- felipelemos 5y agoYou are not actually answering him, because you know that if you are planning a surprise party and you just answered yes, you would have ruined the party. The truth is that not every lie is a problem.
- polishdude20 5y agoAlso, think about how it adds to the work of the parents. Before your child, you probably never tried to lie as an adult and didn't need to remember your lies. All of a sudden, you've got a kid and now you start to lie to them and need to keep spinning these webs of lies to support previous lies. Must be exhausting.
- pengaru 5y ago> Before your child, you probably never tried to lie as an adult and didn't need to remember your lies. Where are these adults who never tried to lie?
- Danieru 5y agoPerhaps a better word is "conspire"? As in to perpetuate a conspiracy. It requires much more planning and care than a one off lie.
- polishdude20 5y agoI mean more like, you don't constantly lie to people. But yeah, like the commenter below says "conspire".
- tempestn 5y agoIt really isn't if you just treat it as a fun fantasy and don't work too hard to conceal the truth. Kids are happy to believe and have fun with it, and then when they're ready to know the truth, it's fairly obvious. For example, don't try to come up with explanations for inconsistencies or impossibilities, but just ask the kid what they think. Eventually it'll be like, "Well, obviously Santa can't actually come to all the houses, so I think the other Santas help him." "I know you and Mom put our presents under our tree, but I think Santa gives them to you." Etc. They basically explicitly tell you how much Santa they want to believe at any given point. Once they directly ask you if Santa is real, you can ask them if they really want you to answer. (The first time mine quickly said, "No, I know he's real!" and then dropped it for a year. :D ) But if they persist, you can tell them a nice version of the truth, like that the idea of Santa is definitely real, because why else would kids get presents from Santa every year. As they guessed, you help out by actually getting the presents and putting them under the tree, but it's because of this great spirit of giving that so many people feel around Christmas that we have this tradition.
- dudul 5y agoHow do you know it was a good call?
- dham 5y agoYea, I'd be pissed if my parents never did Santa, because frankly it was a very fond time in my childhood and once you learn Santa isn't real you never get that time back. So we do Santa with our son and daughter and there was never a discussion not to do it.
- dudul 5y agoSome parents tend to see children as mini-adults. Myths and legends may sound silly to us, but they are important for children's development.
- pfdietz 5y agoBecause we have an excellent relationship with our children, and they never expressed any regret for us having done that. You think children like discovering they've been lied to?
- gnicholas 5y agoHow do you keep your kid from telling all the other kids that Santa isn't real? Little kids can't keep secrets, let alone big ones!
- alar44 5y agoNot my kids, not my problem.
- speedgoose 5y agoThey may yell the truth about Santa but many kids will prefer to believe their parents and other adults.
- toast0 5y agoSame way you keep your kid from telling all the other kids that god isn't real. If you don't make a big deal about Santa, it won't be a big deal to them, and when they ask about him, you can say 'some people believe Santa is a nice guy that's totally not creepy and somehow delivers presents to all the children' or whatever. And you may likely have already had similar conversations about religion and how it's respectful to let people believe what they want about things like that. Of course, if you push Santa hard, and they're a fact oriented kid, when they find out the facts, it's going to be a big deal, and they're going to want to tell their friends about it. You won't know if they're fact oriented before you decide to push Santa though.
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoHow do you keep your kid from yelling "fire!" when there isn't one?
- pfdietz 5y agoWe told them that some other parents were telling their kids this Santa Claus story, and that while we didn't want to do that, it wasn't meant in a bad way, and so please don't spoil things for the other children.