7 ms·
So... cancel them? I get that people are angry, but such a central enforcement authority would be at least as abusable, if not more. You can't win here. If y
by ajross 5y ago
So... cancel them? I get that people are angry, but such a central enforcement authority would be at least as abusable, if not more.
You can't win here. If you trust someone else's software, you need to evaluate the author and establish a relationship. For decades in open source, we did this via formal organizations with charters and incorporations and foundations and boards and stuff (FSF, Red Hat, yada, yada). We can trust gcc or Linux because we have visibility into the reward structure that produced it beyond "what this developer did".
NPM's big failing is in short-circuiting that process and inviting a culture where any rando can push out a package that can be trivially slurped up and used by everyone, transitively. That's great for the rando developers, not so great for the consumers as it turns out.
But you don't fix it via mob justice. You fix it via organization.
- oefrha 5y agoIf you classify revoking a malware author’s developer certificate in a signed environment (e.g. Apple platforms) as cancelling, sure. Not to mention warnings from a checker which can be ignored are far weaker than revoked certificates.
- ajross 5y agoYour hyperbolic use of "malware" for what is clearly a prank is precisely why this is abusable. I buy that you feel strongly and think this developer should be punished for, essentially, making their views visible in their work. Now imagine the people who would want to punish you for your views. Think they won't find anything?
- oefrha 5y agoThis is as much a “prank” as “benign” adware that pops up an ad on your desktop every hour.
- ficklepickle 5y agoMaybe adware that pops a message that doesn't generate any revenue once after 15 seconds would be more accurate. But I suppose that depends on if a single non-commercial message counts as an ad.
- oefrha 5y agoAdware tend to be localized to your own computer instead of working its way into websites you build and pushing itself to all your users.
- oauea 5y agoPerhaps you should reflect why you are pushing adware to YOUR users then. Maybe you should vet YOUR work more carefully instead of pulling in hundreds of dependencies that YOU haven't bothered to vet.
- oefrha 5y agoYes, more visibility into which packages are published/controlled by malware authors helps with vetting (immediate pass instead of reading thousands of lines of code). Yet some people are terrified by that prospect. Really makes you wonder.
- oauea 5y ago"i dont even want to bother reading the code i ship to my users"
- vkou 5y agoPerhaps this is the year when we will collectively realize that cancellation is, in fact, an appropriate response to someone behaving in an anti-social manner.
- 0des 5y agoIs this satire?
- eyelidlessness 5y agoI can’t speak for GP, but ostracizing and shunning are pretty much the assumed enforcement mechanism—when they’re articulated—among people with libertarian principles when those principles are applied consistently. “Cancelling” is far more humane than incarceration or other forms of punishment, because you can emigrate elsewhere. It’s also far less likely to create implicit hierarchies if it’s commonplace.
- 0des 5y agoSo someone misplaces their idealism and your solution is canceling them until they must emigrate? Who are you people?
- eyelidlessness 5y agoI mean I’m not asking for anything to be done here at all, but I hope you’d agree that “someone misplaced their idealism” would be better served by a trip to another package registry than a trip to prison… right? Who are me people? I’m not that organized. I’m just observing that “cancelling” has a philosophical underpinning in even more theoretically libertarian thought than which I personally endorse. I think it’s worth the observation because the people who most object share similar philosophies. I do have a strong sense of freedom of association which makes me sympathetic to that idea. I also understand it’s not the end of the conversation. But I find the hypocrisy of ideological freedom contrasted with freedom to associate really galling.
- JohnHaugeland 5y agoI'm not sure why you're making the claim that writing out a list is somehow "mob justice." It's just documentation.
- awb 5y agoLists have been used as far more than documentation throughout history. Lists expand in scope and purpose and can be used for mob justice. How will your list safeguard against this? This is one of the more bizarre proposals I’ve seen entertained on HN. Where is the line? If I commit a political dissertation in the comments or README? If I change all my unit tests to use political phrases? If I name all my functions with political connotations? If I pass extra politically motivated data back with every response? And how long does your name stay on the list? Any way to get it removed faster? Any way that it gets extended? And this is in response to using free software? We already have mechanisms for dealing with poor OSS decisions: raise an issue, fork it, unstar it. Maybe we should focus on building up the better OSS projects than trying to create a blacklist of maintainers that don’t adhere to some standards they never agreed to, but we imposed on them.
- JohnHaugeland 5y agoCool story. Anyway, the list that they're discussing has actually existed for 30 years, and your hair pulling about what might happen hasn't. . "Where is the line?" Relatively easy for the rest of us to see. . "If I commit a political dissertation in the comments or README? If I change all my unit tests to use political phrases?" Nobody suggested this should be penalized. This is common. . "And how long does your name stay on the list?" Forever. When you commit a crime, that knowledge never disappears in any country. . "Any way to get it removed faster?" No. . "And this is in response to using free software?" No. . "We already have mechanisms for dealing with poor OSS decisions: raise an issue, fork it, unstar it." None of these address what happened in any way. . "Maybe we should focus on building up the better OSS projects" You go ahead. The rest of us will act without you. Your agreement is not required.
- awb 5y ago
- ComradePhil 5y agoWhat are you suggesting here? That npm Inc (basically Microsoft), Python Software Foundation, Ruby community, PHP community, Rust community, Go community raise funds to hire people to individually vet each and every change in each and every package? OK, let's do that because we have SO MANY excess jobless developers. /s OR we could use MUCH less resources and just make a sanction list.