3 ms·
It was striking to: - read the OpenAI paper - notice there was a lot of words in the harm section - notice the mitigations boiled down to "limit access" (a m
by refulgentis 5y ago
It was striking to:
- read the OpenAI paper
- notice there was a lot of words in the harm section
- notice the mitigations boiled down to "limit access" (a marketing strategy) & "put rando colors in a very easy place to crop out", have them note how easy it was to crop, yet they still went with that strategy
- notice no one in actual AI art community has received an invite, but random SV hoi polloi and OpenAI employees have
I had been worried about the moneyed class taking all the work we had done in the open source community informing their approach (check citations on the Dalle paper), privatize it via applying it to a large dataset they built, and not share _any_ of their data or models because "harm reduction" that amounted to marketing x not risking their ability to monetize.
It was shocking to see DallE 2 get announced and take that exact approach.
We'll keep working, LAIONs 5B dataset starts approaching the #s cited in Meta's and OpenAI's papers.
- cscurmudgeon 5y ago> - notice no one in actual AI art community has received an invite, but random SV hoi polloi and OpenAI employees have Same with GPT-3. Requested an invite. Never received one. I have written survey articles comparing different methods. So thta was probably a red flag for them.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoThank you for putting this into words, "SV hoi polloi" ! perfect I'm pretty tweaked at how copyright is used here: Google gets to scan every book in the world, build derivative models off it, but when we want to see the source data we get "page ommitted from this limited preview" OpenAI CLIP scrapes all of google images, but isn't allowed to show us the source material in its training set, since that would constitute copyright infringement Why do the robots have the rights to the world's information while humans are left to the derivative output as the internet is flooded with auto-encoded content? I'm going to start my own internet, no bots allowed. In the future, privacy is tantamount, if you let a bot see your work you're bound to be plagiarized in a thousand variations.