5 ms·
The Huge Endeavor to Produce a Tiny Microchip
- simne 5y agoLovely pictures :)
- geenew 5y agoAny idea why the colour on the fab floor is an odd yellow hue? Is the standard colour spectrum for interior lighting not compatible with chipmaking? I'm imagining a situation akin to the darkroom requirements for processing photographs.
- sibrahim 5y agoMy understanding is that was the original purpose, but probably unnecessary given that all the relevant process steps are encased in tools that are not exposed to the general clean room environment in operation (they have to maintain a higher grade of clean room internally). However, I suspect it's probably going to continue being propagated forward due to Copy Exactly which has historically meant that Intel documents and copies the smallest details in all their fabs just in case they are necessary. In the end, if it ain't broke...
- mrlonglong 5y agoIn short, they've cargo culted themselves. No wonder they've lost their place as makers of powerful processors.
- boondaburrah 5y agoWhy would you not want the additional protection if you have to pick a colour to make the room anyways?
- mrlonglong 5y agoCopying everything implies they do not have full understanding of what makes for a successful process.
- speed_spread 5y agoIt's possible that some level of unresolved empirical "magic" be involved in the process, which does not diminish the value of the end product. Why deprive yourself of hard learned lessons even if you don't understand it all?
- toss1 5y agoChesterton's Fence [0] should overrule fear of cargo culting, especially when the fence (or in this case color) was clearly put up by people who really knew what they were doing at the time. Unless there is a significant cost to it, and unless the benefit is understood, there is no reason that they should be faulted as ignorant cargo cultists simply for keeping it in place. [0] https://www.chesterton.org/taking-a-fence-down/ https://www.chesterton.org/taking-a-fence-down/
- sibrahim 5y agoRight. There's not a compelling reason to switch and there's more than a hint of CYA mixed in with Chesterton's Fence: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-06-09/how-intel-makes-a-chip https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-06-09/how-intel... > For decades, Intel’s cleanrooms have been lit like darkrooms, bathed in a deep, low yellow. “That’s an anachronism,” says Mark Bohr, a small, serious man who has spent his entire 38-year career making chips, and who’s now Intel’s top manufacturing scientist. “Nobody’s had the courage to change it.”
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoPhotoresist is UV sensitive.
- boondaburrah 5y agoAnything UV sensitive is usually done in a yellow room, so that's probably it. I know this is exactly the case for PCB manufacture and printing press plate making to lessen accidental exposure, so it's exactly like a red safelight in a darkroom.
- simne 5y agoThis remembers me, when many years ago I worked with old chemical photography - used special light to limit parasitic exposure of film and photopaper. Usually used dark red light, or yellow-green. And I lived in absolutely typical apartment, and used for photography ordinary bathroom, but switched off normal lights and used special lights, and apartments become looking like them from fantastic films. So, yes, my first education electronics and I've few times been at real fabs. At fabs there are two things which don't appear in typical homes - many devices emit ultraviolet and it is extremely powerful, so appear even through covers, or use open electric heaters, which emit red. Main lights I have seen there, where just ordinary fluorescent lamps, but I sure, on more modern fabs, used special lamps or color filters, to filter out part of spectrum which could cause unnecessary additional dose for photo-chemistry.
- kurthr 5y agoNot all lithography is Deep/Xtreme UV even in the newest fabs, because the equipment is so expensive and relatively slow. A lot of lithography is done the old way and is sensitive to UV from any lights. Box to box processing is almost complete, but there are times when a box may need to be opened or exposed to ambient light. So there are some pretty good reasons to not to increase uncontrolled UV light exposure.
- simne 5y agoAnd photoresist is not only UV sensitive, people have success on exposure it with just very powerful halogen lamps, which don't have much UV. So at fabs, usually, main light is not powerful, or have some color filters.
- xyzzy21 5y agoIt's because photoresist is sensitive to deep blue out to UV so you want to avoid that kind of light as wafers with photoresist applied but not-yet-exposed are running around in their robotic FOUPs through the facility. It's exactly analogous to red safe lights used for film print photography.
- MrBuddyCasino 5y ago
- vmception 5y agoDoes anybody know how NY Times decides to include or omit a comment section from articles? Seems random
- HonestOp001 5y agoMy theory: if it controversial, they leave it off. If it is a feel good story, put it on.
- knownjorbist 5y agoWell that's pretty easily disproven. I think it has to do with what kind of article it is.
- js2 5y agoQuora: How does the NYT determine which articles have comments? Bassey Etim, Community Manager for the New York Times: The vast majority of NYT comments are handled by a human moderator. This means that we have to make an editorial decision about which comment threads we will open for comments each day. Also, we adhere to a sort-of "slow moderation" theory, which posits that the best way to respect the commenting efforts of our readership is to ensure that their comments exist in an urbane, literate environment. (Definitely not an approach that is good for everyone, but it works fabulously for us, for reasons you can probably divine.) Our goal is to have every NYT comment thread offer tangible added value to each article for our readership. The costs to this approach are obvious -- it takes a long time, and many stories do not get comments. But NYT readers expect the highest-quality everything from us, so that's what we deliver. To answer the root of your question, these are our general criteria for opening a story for comment, generally in order of importance: - News value of the story - Projected reader interest in the story - Have we recently had comments on this issue? - Whether we can moderate the projected # of comments in a timely fashion. https://www.quora.com/How-does-the-NYT-determine-which-articles-have-comments https://www.quora.com/How-does-the-NYT-determine-which-artic... https://archive.ph/D6Oc8 https://archive.ph/D6Oc8 Why No Comments? It’s a Matter of Resources https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/27/reader-center/comments-moderation.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/27/reader-center/comments-mo... https://archive.ph/Deota https://archive.ph/Deota The Times Sharply Increases Articles Open for Comments, Using Google’s Technology https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/13/insider/have-a-comment-leave-a-comment.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/13/insider/have-a-comment-le... https://archive.ph/dZkUD https://archive.ph/dZkUD
- voxadam 5y agohttps://archive.ph/OpmdV https://archive.ph/OpmdV
- uhuhoo 5y agoThanks. Also, disabling 1st party js works in this case.
- rwmj 5y agoIf you want to find out how chips are actually made, this documentary filmed inside an Intel fab in 1978 is excellent: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Now_the_Chips_Are_Down https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Now_the_Chips_Are_Down You can find the full thing on iplayer (in the UK) or various video sites.
- andrewf 5y agoAlso "Indistinguishable from Magic: Manufacturing Modern Computer Chips" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NGFhc8R_uO4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NGFhc8R_uO4 is a presentation from a manufacturing engineer which goes into some nitty-gritty
- russellbeattie 5y agoSeconded. Such a well done presentation absolutely packed with info and lots of inside-baseball comments which were interesting as well. I'll never be within 10 miles of a fab, but still totally worthwhile knowledge to have.
- geenew 5y agoThis one from 1967 at Fairchild is also good: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z47Gv2cdFtA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z47Gv2cdFtA
- xyzzy21 5y agoNice article. Hopefully the complexity of fabs and their operations makes it obvious why chip shortages can easily take 3-5 years to address if creating new fab capacity is the problem. It also costs between $30B-$50B to create a new "mega/ultra/super fab" operating at volumes typical of TSMC, Intel, Samsung, etc. Even then, the small corner of a fab my business operates in isn't even mentioned in the article because it's far "too small" - all the businesses combined into our segment has total market revenue ranges in the $5B-$10B/year range. We are essential but small money-wise for most people to care. The other part of the story with water - some of the most advanced water purification and recycling development is happening in this realm as well. Another company product line unrelated to ours is able to detect 10-nanometer-sized contaminants in water at volume both to assure incoming water purity as well as outgoing. Much of the total volume of water is recycled. There are also surprising ways seemingly unrelated parts contribute. For example our product operates on clean-room floors but we put a ton of effort to reduce the floor footprint (we're 30% smaller than the de facto competitor). That directly reduces the amount of water consumed as a multiplier effect because it means you get more productive output per square foot of HVAC air processing capacity. That HVAC is primarily chilled water based. It also reduced energy consumption or increases productive output per unit kW. Whenever you have high capital investment, you get the most innovation in basic technologies required for the business and the most spin-offs as well. Whenever you have low investment, you get zero innovation.
- calrain 5y agoSo, hypothetically, if Taiwan's chip manufacturing facilities were lost due to a 'Special Operation', how bad would the world be? Are there enough chip fab facilities to cover basic requirements by businesses that don't directly build computers or smartphones? And how badly would computers / smartphones be hit? It feels like all our eggs are in one basket with Taiwan, or is that an incorrect assumption?
- kayson 5y agoIt would be disastrous. While TSMC does have a few foundries outside of Taiwan, the company accounts for about a third of total global semiconductor production. Maybe more if you consider just the most advanced process nodes. It's not that we'd lose their particular capacity, since Samsung is a fairly equal competitor, but the overall loss would be catastrophic. Everyone would be in a dire situation, but computers and smartphones would especially be hit hard because they are using the newest nodes. As an example, Apple's SoCs (at least the recent ones) all use TSMC 5nm and that production would just disappear. It's not correct that all our eggs are in one basket. There just aren't enough baskets to accommodate the loss of an entire one. Other players include SMIC, UMC, Global Foundries, and now Intel, but their capacity isn't significant enough to make up for the loss. This is why there is a push both to "second source" production, and to increase production capacity overall, especially in more politically stable geographies. The latter is a huge challenge because it requires a lot of capital and a lot of time.
- calrain 5y agoThanks for your answer! I do hope more fab's are set up around the world, it would be horrible to have to build fabs after just losing 1/3 of the worlds manufacturing capacity, especially as the new fab itself would consume so much semiconductor in its own right.
- koffiezet 5y agoThere's a reason the US has a symbolic military presence in Taiwan, most likely even on the Pratas island to train Taiwan defence troops there. It would be the first and obvious strategic target, and taking the otherwise uninhabited island without hitting the potentially present US military personnel would be hard - which should make China at least think twice about making a move against it.