14 ms·
Firefox by default directs DoH queries to DNS servers that are operated by a "trusted partner". That's what I don't want - Firefox offering services. Once you
by Animats 5y ago
Firefox by default directs DoH queries to DNS servers that are operated by a "trusted partner".
That's what I don't want - Firefox offering services.
Once you have a centralized server, with a huge number of minor queries passing through it, the operators get uppity. They start thinking they have editorial authority. Someone will decide that the DNS server should censor something. Child porn is the usual excuse, and then, after a while, you can't see sites that mention Tienanmen Square or Ukraine any more.
I'm quite happy with Sonic's classic DNS server. It just answers DNS queries and forwards requests to the appropriate upstream DNS server as required.
- asimpletune 5y agoCan I ask what you would prefer? If FF adds an additional choice among the status quo, are you saying you would prefer the status quo minus the additional option of FF?
- ev1 5y agoSonic is a decent provider. This is rare. Most ISPs in the US will sell your queries, use it for marketing, inject fake NXDOMAIN ads, etc.
- zrm 5y agoSo choose a different one. You don't have to use your ISP's. The danger is in everyone using the same one, which is what you get if the browser vendors are choosing for everyone. Better yet, give the browsers a way to detect this (e.g. generate a random domain known not to exist and make sure it gives NXDOMAIN) and switch to the other DNS only if the normal one is broken.
- ev1 5y agoYou don't get this choice in most of the US.
- L3viathan 5y agoYou don't have the choice of DNS server in most of the US?
- josephcsible 5y agoNot without DoH. If you just try to set a custom server to use for insecure DNS, it's trivial for your ISP to rewrite all of your insecure DNS queries to go to itself instead.
- vasachi 5y agoIt is actually really easy to ignore user's selected DNS server. Basically ISP can just inject responses, given that DNS is unauthenticated. I don't know if US ISPs do that, but it can be done.
- ev1 5y agoI know that both T-Mobile and Comcast have both ignored user selected non-DoH DNS settings by force in the past, either by DPIing port 53 traffic or static routing major public DNS servers toward their own resolvers.
- gsich 5y agoSo, do they still do it? This fearmongering about DNS selling pops up in every DNS thread here.
- 542458 5y agoI don’t really understand this perspective. “Sure, I’m using vulnerable technology, but nobody has exploited me lately that I know of” isn’t a statement that would get positive reception in any other netsec discussion.
- autoexec 5y agoyeah... it's not fear mongering when it's a thing that actually happens. Some ISPs collect and sell your data. I mean, they even paid congress to make it okay for them to do it. They sure can't be expected to keep their word https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/01/t-mobile-sprint-and-att-still-selling-your-location-data-report-says/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/01/t-mobile-sprint-...
- contingencies 5y agoI live in China and (still) use Firefox in preference to Google. I agree they need to fire the management and focus on the code. The big pain with DNS is that it's one avenue of censorship but also a proxy for many wrong-headed network geographic assumptions through the lens of geoDNS. "Oh, you resolved from Europe, so you really want a European server! Let me help you out there..." The internet has far too many of these half-baked hacks layered now, it's getting to the point where to obtain a halfway trustworthy response you have to have a dynamic network of geographically distributed and temporally transient nodes seeking similar information and voting on the result. Geoscoping, echo-chamber personalization, household profiling, jurisdiction-second-guessing, ID verification as an outsourced service, political policy fandangling, globe splitting for artificial market segregation, walled-gardening, DRM...
- yrro 5y agoWhat is a practical alternative to multiple DNS views based on the client's geographical location, for the problems solved by them? A way to 'opt out' of response customization based on my location would be nice while troubleshooting. But then which zone is that going to give me? Probably the US one. :P
- contingencies 5y agoWhat is a practical alternative to multiple DNS views based on the client's geographical location, for the problems solved by them? DNS was originally intended to be a domain name resolution service with fixed records. Yet, IIRC even in the very early days (1983) it allowed multiple records. So providing a list of potential endpoints to the client to empower them was fully supported since approximately day 1. Apparently, instead of developing smart clients that use this (very efficiently provided) information to make reasonable actor-centric decisions, we have developed dumb clients and instead of selecting the best possible endpoint from a set it will just select either a random response or the first response most of the time. GeoDNS further degrades this already bad situation to purposefully provide limited, expiring and non-cacheable responses to individual clients thus locking in the failure. There are application-level peer selection implementations for various protocols, for example gentoo had a mirrorselect tool which is awesome and torrents will generally prefer fast peers. It would not be that hard to make a smart resolver that did AS-level resolution and cached previously observed bandwidth to make intelligent prioritization decisions without the need to actually actively probe the network. This could even be done at the OS level, transparent to applications. [RFC882] https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc882.txt https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc882.txt [RFC883] https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc883.txt https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc883.txt
- hiq 5y agoThis is configurable though (it's only a default), and is still better than the status quo in a lot of areas. Either you care enough to change it, or you stick to the default. Default (ISP) plain DNS is worse.
- mort96 5y agoIt's not though? You still have to trust your ISP, but now you need to trust some random company Mozilla has picked _in addition_ to your ISP.
- kemotep 5y agoThe random company in this case is Cloudflare and NextDNS. And using DoH you cut out your ISP from the equation (at least for your browser traffic). You can also setup a custom DoH provider (that can also be configured on the system level, not just the browser) so neither Cloudflare or your ISP gets your DNS queries.
- mort96 5y agoCloudflare and NextDNS absolutely counts as "some random company" in this context. I have no reason to trust random American companies more than my local ISP. I don't trust the USA more than I trust my own country.
- hvis 5y ago> I have no reason to trust random American companies more than my local ISP. I don't trust the USA more than I trust my own country. You know you are quite fortunate to be able to say so. Firefox is a project with global impact. A lot of people around the world can benefit from DoH.
- adalu 5y agoEven people in Germany who want to read the other side of the war story, like I did yesterday to read RT(.com) vs the Tagesschau propaganda. Since my ISP, O2, has removed rt.com entries and other russian propaganda outlets (I acknowledge the "west" also has propaganda outlets like Reuters etc) I was looking for ways to still read rt.com news. I looked into Firefox' preferences and searched for "DNS" and saw DNS over HTTP and I could pick Cloudflare, NextDNS (never heard of) or custom. I picked Cloudflare and read rt.com thus getting the other side of the whole bs propaganda mess. The German Grundgesetz (constitution) says "eine Zensur findet nicht statt" (censorship does not occur/there will be no censorship) yet, there is censorship. I was sceptical about DOH in general (why do we need this?) but now I see why this can be a good thing and great as well that Firefox supports it so easily.
- candiodari 5y agoAs opposed by your "trusted" partner ie. your internet provider? Ignoring that these are the organisations that keep getting hacked, they also outright try to monetize your DNS queries whichever way they can (even falsifying real sites). And that's ignoring the obnoxious government interference ISPs tend to implement through DNS. From piratebay to youtube blocks. You have to trust someone with DNS. And Firefox's trusted partner is better than the current status quo.
- jeltz 5y agoHow is it an advantage to have to trust both your ISP and Clouldflare?
- candiodari 5y agoYou don't have to trust your ISP with DNS-over-HTTPS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNS_over_HTTPS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNS_over_HTTPS This is actually considered "a disadvantage" by wikipedia, because of course it means captive portals don't work.
- madeofpalk 5y ago> Once you have a centralized server, with a huge number of minor queries passing through it, the operators get uppity. This is currently the case, no? DNS is already, as far as the user concerned, a centralised service where any slippery-slope censoring can (and im sure does) already happen.
- masklinn 5y agoDns block at the isp level is already widely used for piracy, and non isp DNS are getting sued over not doing it: https://deepdotwebs.com/quad9-must-block-dns-queries-to-a-piracy-site-in-germany https://deepdotwebs.com/quad9-must-block-dns-queries-to-a-pi...
- eli 5y agoHow is this different from offering a default search engine provided by a "trusted partner"?
- raptor99 5y agoExactly, and how is it different from offering a default installed browser in an OS by a "trusted partner"?
- johnklos 5y agoSimple: when you use the default search in a browser, you immediately see who is providing search results. If you have a problem with Google, for instance, you see that it's Google and you go and change it. Mozilla decided to turn on DoH by default, without asking, without prompting, without any indication whatsoever. Even if you configure a canary domain, that doesn't disable the DoH preference - it just temporarily turns it off. Organizations making unilateral decisions about sharing my private information with an untrusted, for-profit company that has a history of abuse and social irresponsibility is a very bad thing, not a good one.
- zagrebian 5y ago> Child porn is the usual excuse, and then, after a while, you can't see sites that mention Tienanmen Square or Ukraine any more. Has this ever happened?
- CWuestefeld 5y agoAt the application level, it's happening right now all over social media sites. The risk is too great that our delicate minds, unable to separate fact from fiction, will ingest something deviating from the approved narrative.
- adalu 5y agoYes and it's happening right now with the US and Canadian "no encryption" campaign
- zagrebian 5y ago> US and Canadian "no encryption" campaign What is that?
- alexambarch 5y agoI believe they are talking about the EARN IT act: https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/3538/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/353...
- Jwarder 5y agoDidn't the UK run into a problem a decade-ish ago where the group compiling the list of porn sites to block by default included the websites for their rival political parties? I just tried searching for references, but I can't find anything with details. I can't speak with certainty and it sounds like it was just a grunt being a jerk, but still a risk with these types of restrictions.
- vageli 5y agoI'm not sure about weilding it for political power, but I did find this https://www.independent.co.uk/tech/o2-changes-porn-filter-after-charity-sites-blocked-9023209.html https://www.independent.co.uk/tech/o2-changes-porn-filter-af...
- ComodoHacker 5y ago>That's what I don't want - Firefox offering services. That's what I actually want from Mozilla — offering (but not forcing) privacy-enhancing services, preferably for free.
- abracadaniel 5y agoThe traffic already flows through their browser. If they wanted to filter content, they could do it now at render time. There’s nothing stopping a browser from doing content analysis before it chooses to display it to you. The fact that they haven’t, is a pretty good sign.
- darkhorn 5y ago> Once you have a centralized server DNS is not centralized. You can enter whatever DNS server you want. The problem with plain text DNS is that in countries like Turkey over half million domains are blocked in DNS level. Even if you enter your custom DNS, Turkish ISPs MITM the queries and respond with are IP adrress that says that the domain is blocked. DoH prevents such attacks. For this reason once again huge thanks to Mozilla who fights against opressing regimes.