19 ms·
Nuclear power helped prevent ~2M deaths in the last 50 years
- pvaldes 5y agoGreat. Now lets talk about the ~7M of people that had received or still have to receive economical support and help to mitigate the effects of Chernobyl on their health and properties.
- jbirer 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disaster_casualties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disa...
- ch4s3 5y agoThere was 1 confirmed radiation death at Fukushima and more people died from the evacuation than the accident. The exposure to radiation in the exclusion zone was very low, probably too low to cause any excess cancer in the generally elderly population there.
- rob74 5y agoWell, there were no deaths because of the contamination in the contaminated area, because the contaminated area was evacuated. D'uh...
- ch4s3 5y agoPeople weren't evacuated immediately, which is the whole point. Your dismissiveness shows that you aren't very familiar with the particulars of the accident. There was a projection at the time that there would be a short term spike in thyroid cancer among that population, which hasn't materialized. In fact radiation levels are so low in the area that the wisdom of the evacuation is very much up for debate. Of people evacuated 98% were exposed to no more than a 5 mSv/yr dose. The current ambient dose rate is 3 mSv/yr in the area which is slightly less than you'd receive visiting Finland. Flying from NY to Fukushima would expose you to a 9 mSv/yr dose.
- formerly_proven 5y agoBy 2018 more than 3700 people have died in relation to the evacuation (there's a technical criterion for this, basically death materially brought on by the worsened living conditions or issues during evacuation). IIRC there are no increased cancer rates among the population. The majority of evacuated people have not returned to their homes. The social and mental health impact of the evacuation was and is massive.
- anon_123g987 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Addition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Addition
- mpweiher 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_T%C5%8Dhoku_earthquake_and_tsunami https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_T%C5%8Dhoku_earthquake_an...
- danbruc 5y agoWhat is the actual claim here? Nuclear power didn't prevent any deaths, after all everyone will eventually die for one reason or another. So it must be something like two million people would have died earlier without nuclear power, but by how much? Does it mean nuclear power saved the equivalent of two million average lifespans? Or would two million people more have died in coal mines?
- mytailorisrich 5y agoObviously when something is said to have "prevented deaths" this means early deaths from accidents/illness... Here, as is explained is the tweet, the claim is based on the reduction in air pollution.
- danbruc 5y agoWithout further details that is not really helpful. If everyone died one week earlier because of additional air pollution, would that mean nuclear power saved everyone's life? And it certainly makes a difference whether the average loss of lifetime is a week or ten years.
- arlort 5y agoA more interesting metric would maybe be years of life expectancy, but that's probably too much of a hassle to calculate for a metric which is relatively speaking useless
- pvaldes 5y ago> the claim is based on the reduction in air pollution. That has been heavily improved in the last years by a better car design, better materials, motor burning regulated by electronics and a much more strict regulation in vehicle emissions. Thus nuclear would be bragging here about other's merits. Using the same argument we could claim also that combustible fossils had saved millions of lives in the last years because cars now have much more plastic parts than before (reduced weight -> less mass to move -> less fuel spent to move it -> less air pollution).
- rob74 5y ago
- _vufv 5y agoNuclear weapons likely prevented >100M deaths in the last 50 years. Mutually Assured Destruction is the only reason we didn't have another hot world war since 1945. If there were no nuclear weapons now, you'd have a full scale NATO/Russia war today and a US/China war in a few months. Very ironically, Mahnattan Project heads should receive a few Nobel Peace prizes posthoumously.
- Synaesthesia 5y agoAfter WW2 Europe learned its lesson: another war would destroy the entire region, even with conventional arms. But nuclear weapons did not prevent this war. The manner which the weapons were used certainly precludes them from a peace prize IMO
- simonh 5y agoI don't understand how you can think that logic would work in Europe, but didn't work in the many parts of the world that went on to have full on wars WW2 style. Vietnam, Iran/Iraq, Many Arab/Israeli conflicts, etc, etc. What's special about Europe that would have made it immune? The answer is profuse nuclear weapons that made any direct conflict in Europe unthinkable for either side. Ukraine demonstrates clearly that when conventional war is thinkable, it only takes one side to feel they have the upper hand to make it happen. Nukes are the only reason Russian tanks aren't already dipping their treads in the sea along the coast of the Baltic States, or at least trying to.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoNuclear weapons aren't protecting baltic states, they are protecting Russia's imperial ambitions. It's army performanc is so abysmall european powers alone could steamroll all of it's offensibe force without US getting involved If the recent conflict has shown us anything, is that Russian military is overhyped, complacent and corrupt, and performs terribly in confrontation with much smaller, poorly eqipped, and also somehwat corrupt military.
- deleted 5y ago
- dham 5y agoI think it's the main tragedy of the human race is not staying with nuclear and going all in. Unfortunately the fad of being afraid of nuclear will probably be the downfall of the human race. We would have had energy solved by the 80's. Almost sickening to think about.
- simonh 5y agoI don't know, early reactor designs were pretty unsafe and I'm not sure a lot more of them would have been better. Sometimes taking time to mature a technology, even one that's hugely beneficial in the long term, works better than just piling in quickly and risking finding that you invested in a developmental dead end. Having said that now nuclear does seem to be a mature technology with significant benefits.
- ganzuul 5y agoThe airborne reactor was our ticket to the future but it didn't produce plutonium.
- twofornone 5y ago>I don't know, early reactor designs were pretty unsafe and I'm not sure a lot more of them would have been better There have been what, 5 events in the last 50 years that released a significant amount of radiation, only one catastrophic meltdown (Chernobyl), out of thousands of plants running continuously for decades? Seems pretty safe to me...
- simonh 5y agoI agree the impact of and response to accidents is often exaggerated out of proportion. Except for Chernobyl. That one was a monster. However if you take the long term impact and costs of those accidents and add them to the cost of nuclear power overall, it's not a pretty picture. I would not have supported significantly more nuclear 40 years ago, some but not massive. I do support it now though. We've learned a lot.
- jbullock35 5y agoThe linked tweet doesn't provide a citation or context for the "helped prevent ~2M deaths" claim. But there is work in this area which suggests that "~2M lives saved" in the last 50 years underestimates the benefits of nuclear power by a lot. One commenter here writes > What is the actual claim here? Nuclear power didn't prevent any deaths, after all everyone will eventually die for one reason or another. So it must be something like two million people would have died earlier without nuclear power, but by how much? That's a better way to think about the problem: not "lives saved," but life-years saved. Calculations of life-years saved are necessarily sketchy, but there is at least one promising preliminary effort [1]. See especially page 22. [1] https://storage.googleapis.com/production-sitebuilder-v1-0-1/741/319741/PkwWoHa4/d3b0f38f46d248d3ae8f35e9a4e70994?fileName=Chernobyl_20211201.pdf https://storage.googleapis.com/production-sitebuilder-v1-0-1...
- johnnyb9 5y agoThe study is from NASA: https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es3051197?source=cen& https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es3051197?source=cen&
- ouid 5y agoThe idea that people are simultaneously intelligent enough to understand the somewhat nuanced argument that nuclear power is safe, but also so stupid that "2 million lives saved" makes more sense to them than just a number of QALYs is, I think, an abject failure of science journalism. If you explain everything like everyone is 5, you reap what you sow.
- danbruc 5y agoFor those unfamiliar with the unit, QALY is quality-adjusted life year. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality-adjusted_life_year https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality-adjusted_life_year
- anonporridge 5y agoLife-years saved is a step in the right direction, but still the wrong metric to focus on in my opinion. Healthy life-years is a much better metric to optimize. If we get people living to 200, but 120 of those years are in a miserable and extremely debilitated state, I consider that a failure compared to average life span of 100, where only 5 years are in an extremely debilitated state. i.e. getting 95 good healthy years + 5 bad ones >>> 80 healthy years and 120 bad ones. I suppose you can make an argument that extending your miserable years can help a person survive long enough to eventually take advantage of body and mind rejuvenation tech, so there is some point where absolute maximization of life-years might make sense.
- Synaesthesia 5y agoNuclear power has a lot of connections to the nuclear arms industry, and as such is highly secretive. Many nuclear reactors were in fact to make bomb fissile material, with power generation as a side effect. The disposal problem is often covered in a veil of secrecy, eg when it pertains to weapons. This is why debating these issues, which I've looked at my whole life, can be troublesome. We just don't have all the facts! https://cnduk.org/resources/links-nuclear-power-nuclear-weapons/ https://cnduk.org/resources/links-nuclear-power-nuclear-weap...
- ch4s3 5y agoThe VAST majority of reactors ever built were not built to generate fissile material for weapons, and the VAST majority of nuclear weapons were built using centrifuge facilities which are cheaper to build and simpler in some respects to operate. Reactors have in fact been used to dispose of material from weapons. Civilian disposal plans in the west are all a matter of public record and there have been reams of paper generated about the topic. Yes, the weapons part is to some extent secretive, but the UNODA oversees disarmament so there is some multinational transparency.
- pydry 5y agoKeeping a nuclear industry around is still a good way to keep a lid on nuclear arsenal costs. There are supply chain efficiencies, a pipeline of necessary skills, etc. It's just a ridiculously expensive way to generate green energy. When Iran builds nuclear reactors for "100% peaceful non military purposes" suddenly the western media can see through the ruse and understands all this.
- ch4s3 5y ago> Keeping a nuclear industry around is still a good way to keep a lid on nuclear arsenal costs. No it isn't. We aren't really building new weapons, we're just maintaining the ones we have. There shouldn't be any unique supply chain overlap. There's also transparently budget under DOD in the US for maintaining the nuclear arsenal. The CBO publishes the numbers, $643 billion over the next 10 years [1]. As for the skills, the military just trains people. A large number of civilian operators were trained by the military, not the other way around. Iran is building centrifuges which it claims are for medical isotopes and later some reactors or scientific purposes. They've allowed in inspectors at various points and the western press generally, but cautiously accepts this as the truth. The problem is that they have the ability to enrich further to bomb grade material. The whole original deal was about getting them to give up enrichment and accept material at enrichment level sufficient for energy and medicine from France. That fell apart and they are enriching material again themselves. > It's just a ridiculously expensive way to generate green energy. If coal were regulated like nuclear energy it would be far more expensive due to fuel costs. If you had to dispose of lithium such that it couldn't leak for more than 10k years batteries would be far more expensive. If we didn't changes the regulations every few years and appoint anti-nuclear activists to run the NRC, it would be much cheaper. But yes, nuclear is expensive. It's also incredibly safe, 0 carbon, and produces no air pollution. It also provides base load energy which other 0 carbon sources can't do yet. You're just spreading FUD. [1] https://www.cbo.gov/publication/57240#:~:text=If%20carried%20out%2C%20the%20plans,billion%20a%20year%2C%20CBO%20estimates https://www.cbo.gov/publication/57240#:~:text=If%20carried%2....
- cinntaile 5y agoAs others have pointed out, what does this even mean? What kind of metric is this? What was it compared against? Where is the data? It doesn't exactly instill confidence that the director general of the International Atomic Energy Agency makes claims like these, this is marketing fluff.
- syngrog66 5y agowonder how many millions died from cancer from radiation from all the nuclear/atomic weapon tests, and the 2 major nuclear power plant disasters (that we know of) curious if its still a numerical net win or a lose when you take that side into account
- NovemberWhiskey 5y agoWhy would you bundle nuclear weapons tests together with civil applications?
- Manuel_D 5y agoThe largest credible estimates for Chernobyl are in the hundreds or in the single-digit thousands. Estimates larger than that make significant methodological errors, like failing to account for better technologies for diagnosing certain types of cancer (especially thyroid cancer). For Fukushima, most estimates predict zero deaths due to radiation exposure besides the plant workers.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoIt rounds down to 0, counting Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
- HstryrsrBttn 5y ago
- almet 5y agoIt's frightening to see how the nuclear power debate is done nowadays. Yes, nuclear energy is generating less CO2 than some other forms of energy, but saying it's saving lives seems sketchy at best, and to be used as a "hammer argument". Because it's "saving lives", it's good. All energy producing less CO2 than the current mix is "saving lives" in a way. So yes, we should aim for less production of CO2. There is no question here. But I believe that in order to have a opinion on the matter we need to understand the whole picture. - *Waste* : we don't really know what to do with them. We pile them up and try to protect humans from them, but really we don't know what to do more than that. - *War risk* : if a plant is a military target, it might cause big trouble to the population around, and to the nature… - *Dismantling* : we still don't know how to dismantle a nuclear power plant and we don't know the energetic cost of doing so. Still, we have many nuclear plants that are coming to their end of lives, and we still don't know how to so properly. - *We don't have sufficient sources of uranium* : it seems that we lack some uranium in order to produce enough energy in a sustainable way. - Also, uranium extraction is complex geo-politically and seems to creates a geographic context keen to a war on resources, especially if we don't have enough. So, it might "save lives" wrt CO2 emissions, but that doesn't necessarily mean that it's a clean energy, nor that's the energy of the future, in my opinion.
- jopsen 5y agoI don't think it's lower CO2 emissions that saves lives. It's likely reduced air pollution. Gas power plants probably have similar properties. (Not that I would advocate for gas) In any case, most the problems around nuclear are lack of political will and economies of scale.
- Manuel_D 5y ago> Waste : we don't really know what to do with them. We pile them up and try to protect humans from them, but really we don't know what to do more than that. We know exactly what to do with it: bury it underground, in bedrock, like what Finland is doing [1]. For countries like the USA that don't reprocess nuclear waste, it represents a future source of fuel so burying it is wasteful. There's also an incredibly small amount of waste: all nuclear waste from electricity generation in the USA fits in a volume the footprint of a football field and 10 yards high [2]. > War risk : if a plant is a military target, it might cause big trouble to the population around, and to the nature… The risk posed by nuclear power plants in wartime is drastically lower than the actual war itself. The vulnerability of power plants are also overstated: reactors are essentially inside of bunkers, protected by meters of reinforced concrete. The Ukraine war has demonstrated the resilience of nuclear plants: none have been breached. > We don't have sufficient sources of uranium : it seems that we lack some uranium in order to produce enough energy in a sustainable way. Existing terrestrial reserves are more than enough for centuries, or longer with reprocessing. Uranium seawater extraction affords an effectively unlimited supply [3]. Nuclear power represents the only non-intermittent source of carbon-free energy besides geographically limited sources like geothermal or hydroelectric power. For that reason, it's going to be the backbone of most countries' decarbonization efforts unless a massive breakthrough in storage is made. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onkalo_spent_nuclear_fuel_repository https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onkalo_spent_nuclear_fuel_repo... 2. https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/5-fast-facts-about-spent-nuclear-fuel https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/5-fast-facts-about-spent-... 3. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2016/07/01/uranium-seawater-extraction-makes-nuclear-power-completely-renewable/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2016/07/01/uranium-s...
- ncmncm 5y agoIf nukes prevented that many deaths, imagine how many solar + wind will prevent. The point here is that each $10B spent on new generating capacity displaces some amount of coal generation. If you spend your $10B building nukes, it displaces A million tons / year of coal output, if you spend $10B building renewables, it instead displaces B million tons. And B is much larger than A, because a GW of solar + storage is much cheaper than a GW of nuke. The corollary is that each $ diverted from renewables to nukes is not just harmful, but brings climate disaster nearer. Best, of course, would be to stop diverting money to fossils, but all we can do about that is build out renewables + storage as fast as we can. Renewables will be running at 100% at all times, and each kWh produced displaces a kWh of fossil generation. Displaced fossil generation in most markets is methane gas, because methane gas is cheaper and therefore preferred. But! anywhere coal is being used at all, they will prefer to cut coal output because cutting coal saves more money than cutting gas. A particularly good example is Germany, where they cannot get enough natural gas to meet their needs, and are burning coal like nobody's business. Every last kWh of renewables + storage that can be put on the German grid, provided it is steady-enough output, displaces exactly that much coal. The cost of storage is plummeting even faster than of solar or wind ever did, so there is some short-term sense in delaying storage build-out until it is cheaper, so you can buy more of it. But in the big picture, building out storage at any price is much, much better than waiting.
- jopsen 5y agoIn the meantime it's okay to take 2 minutes to celebrate that nuclear wasn't such a bad idea. We should just have doubled down on it 50 years ago. So much geopolitical trouble would have been avoided if bad actors in the middle east and Russia wasn't flushed with cash.
- cycomanic 5y agoSo who do you think is one of the largest providers of uranium in Europe? The arguments of Germany not being so dependent on Russia if they would have left their nuclear power plants running longer has been debunked several times. I believe this is largely nuclear power lobbyist taken advantage of the current situation. The EU is even more dependent on Uranium from Russia than gas. 20% of the natural Uranium and 26% of the enriched Uranium used in the EU comes from Russia and Kazastan [1] [1] https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/ukraine-krieg-eu-ist-auch-von-russischem-uran-abhaengig-a-d9575895-93da-4274-a5e5-167f4d9d2f0f https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/ukraine-krieg-eu-...
- hans1729 5y agoASK HN: does anyone familiar with the matter have access to robust predictive models wrt the impact on health of the expected problems with long-term storage of nuclear waste? For the german/french speaking part of the audience, ARTE recently uploaded an insightful documentation on the state of nuclear facilities in France (which I found very sobering, to say the least): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-gXrL4tPMoM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-gXrL4tPMoM -- while that is surely not ARTEs best piece and you get an idea of the redactions opinion through editorialization, it's definitely a recommended watch. The link points to the german version. Bottom lines: - nuclear power is not as transparent about the existing impact on the environment as one would think. for example, rivers even in the middle of europe are regularly contaminated with "negligible" contaminants, where what is defined as "negligible" is _not only intransparent, but not publicly known and censored in cases of information-requests, with the given reason being raison d'être of the state (!)_ - the storage-situation is not only not robust (not a single long term storage concept actually proved viable, globally), but much worse than I'd have anticipated [...] those are the points that immediately come to mind. My point here is: yes, great, we need to reduce the burden on the environment as much as possible, and _if_ nuclear is the way to go, then please, let's do that. But the unwillingness and lack of competence with regards to the long-term potentials for problems will bite us, and it will do so in more than one way, and I'm very concerned because of it. If the situation in central europe is as questionable as ARTE illuminates, I'm not sure I want to know how bad it is in regions with less political transparency. Hence the initial questions, primarily: who has access to such models?
- herschel113 5y agoAs always numbers as that are quite fuzzy. To estimate the risk, I like to look at physical modifications of our environment that _may_ prove dangerous, until we can prove their'e not. And if we look at the matter our earth and atmosphere is composed of, nuclear energy will likely do a much more distinct impact in the long term than any other man-made energy production efforts so far. While we are just causing turmoil in the carbon and mineral dust distribution of our planet, this is also done by animals and plants in the long term and by vulcans in the short term. But messing with the isotope and elemental composition is quite unique and happens far slower on a natural pace, and in other bodies like stars of course. So tl;dr: We modify our planet in a _maybe_ destructive way for hundred thousands of years to come, by nuclear power generation. We don't know for sure if and how risky it is, but on other things (think of terrorism) we are taking vast efforts to keep risk at pace. So we should do with the elemental and isotope composition of our environment - by nuclear power!
- jthrowsitaway 5y ago> And if we look at the matter our earth and atmosphere is composed of, nuclear energy will likely do a much more distinct impact in the long term than any other man-made energy production efforts so far. Citation is very much needed. Comparing nuclear energy with the dirty business of the fossil fuel chain is a no-brainer in my mind. Nuclear energy isn't perfect, but it's a lot more contained than fossil fuels.
- herschel113 5y ago> Comparing nuclear energy with the dirty business of the fossil fuel chain is a no-brainer in my mind. This may hold if, as most of those studies do, compare the almost-certain effects that are almost-now. They fail -like any study- on vague and long term effects. Eg. who will condense health effects of radiation spread by fighting in chernobyl ruins into a reasonable paper any time soon? So we cannot reliable know the impact of nuclear waste, that if not treated again, will be nuclear waste for 100.000 of years for some kinds of waste and this is for sure. For fossils, we in fact can not precisely know the if reducing CO2 emissions again, if climate effects will vane in time. But we have some expectations on the intertia this system has. Still not knowing precisely trigger effects that may start processes going thousands of years (melting ice etc.) And we can expect most dust and toxic effects to stop within years, if those operations are stopped. Nature will close the holes we digged in 10s of years. For windmills, solar panels and batteries we can be sure it's impact is not far away from it's dirty production, maintenance and recycling impact. Again, of course, one day may prove we're going to far and all wind has been stopped by windmills...
- deltaonefour 5y agoThis type of logic also justifies the nuclear bomb, as development of the nuclear bomb is an inevitable parallel to nuclear power. Not against nuclear power, but as unwise as it is to ignore data, it's also unwise to blindly trust it without addressing non-quantifiable aspects of it. No other power source can do what it did to Chernobyl. Are we really saying 4 or 5 Chernobyl level melt downs are ok every decade or so because the overall lives saved are greater? Hard to say, and also hard to say whether new technology can adequately reduce the risk of nuclear power. My stance is that although we must move forward with nuclear if fusion doesn't pan out, we should nevertheless proceed with the utmost caution. I feel the attitude for nuclear power on HN is a little too enthusiastic. Tons of people are all in because of some statistical metrics. Just keep in mind that numerical metrics are an accurate viewpoint, but they are just one angle out of multitudes of metrics, many of which cannot be quantified.
- Archelaos 5y agoSuch statements like "measure x prevented/caused n deaths" should generally be considered highly dubious unless applied to a very narrow context (such as a randomized double blind placebo control study, etc.). There is nothing that can really prevent death; everyone will die sooner or later. So speaking of "preventing/causing death" is an abbreviated way of speaking. It makes most sense when it is about "immediate death", but the longer it takes for a cause to develop its presumed effect, the less the effect can be solely attributed to this particular cause. It then makes no real sense to just count the numbers of deaths related to a particular cause, if it is only one of an actually unquantifiable number of contributory causes. But analysing the structure of the statement closer, it becomes even more dubious, because (after applying some small interpretative clarifications) it follows the basic structure: "measure x prevented n of d, because it has an effect e that is (indirectly!)[1] somehow correlated with d". To evaluate the extent to which such a claim could probably be valid would require a considerable amount of background information. Just presenting it as a statement without any substantial discussion is not enlighting at all, but just polarizes the audience: if the statement fits into someone's already established belief system it is readily accepted at truth, and if it contradicts someone's belief system it is instantly rejected. There is no chance to learn anything from it. [1] In the case of hypercapnia, CO2 can directly affect health, but I do not think that was the point of the statement.
- PolygonSheep 5y agoSince an argument about Chernobyl inevitably comes up when nuclear power is discussed I thought it would be interesting to ask: what would the coal/natural gas power equivalent of Chernobyl be? That is, an accident which caused significant death or ecological contamination. The closest I can think of for a "coal Chernobyl" would be something like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingston_Fossil_Plant_coal_fly_ash_slurry_spill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingston_Fossil_Plant_coal_fly...
- wdr1 5y agoIt baffles me how it's completely normal to avoid any mention of nuclear power when discussing climate change. Kurzgesagt just did a great video[1] on what we should be hopeful for addressing climate change, but again, absolutely zero mention of nuclear power. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LxgMdjyw8uw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LxgMdjyw8uw
- stjohnswarts 5y agoMe as well. I almost never hear nuclear advocates poo poo power from solar and wind, all are welcome, but coming from the other side they completely overlook the fact that nuclear power has been working fine for decades, is a 90% fix for climate change and yet they still lose their minds when you bring it up.
- slantaclaus 5y ago2 million is a very low ball estimate in my opinion. If it weren’t for nukes there would have been at least one more world war between WW2 and now.