4 ms·
> Really, I can't see a compelling reason to be in the cloud for the majority of mid-level workloads like ours. I work on a very small team. We have a few deve
by lolinder 5y ago
> Really, I can't see a compelling reason to be in the cloud for the majority of mid-level workloads like ours.
I work on a very small team. We have a few developers who double as ops. None of us are or want to be sysadmins.
For our case, Amazon's ECS is a massive time and money saver. I spent a week or two a few years ago getting all of our services containerized. Since then we have not had a single full production outage (they were distressingly common before), and our sysadmin work has consisted exclusively of changing versions in Dockerfiles from time to time.
Yes, most of the problems we had before could have been solved my a competent sysadmin, but that's precisely the point—hiring a good sysadmin is way more expensive for us than paying a bit extra to Amazon and just telling them "please run these containers with this config."
- TrickardRixx 5y agoVery similar experience here. I work on a two person "DevOps" team. Without AWS ECS we would have to have a much higher headcount. I get to spend most of my time solving real problems for the engineers on the product team rather than sysadmin work.
- dijit 5y agoWhat are “real problems” for the engineers or product team?
- TrickardRixx 5y agoThings like automating manual workflows, building small infrastructure debugging tools, or providing infrastructure consultation to an engineer trying to decouple two parts of a legacy code base.
- kissgyorgy 5y ago> None of us are or want to be sysadmins. It's such a huge misconception that by using a cloud provider you can avoid having "sysadmins" or don't need that kind of skills. You still need those, no matter which cloud and which service you use.
- exfascist 5y agoIn fact, if you're using Linux on your workstation you'll use the same skills locally as you do on the VPS/bare metal (depending on your scale.) Arguably "cloud" services need more sysadmin skills, not less.
- lolinder 5y agoIt's far easier to maintain my own Linux workstation than an internet-facing server used daily by customers.
- exfascist 5y agoAbsolutely but most of the knowledge translates, it's the procedures that differ.
- lolinder 5y agoIt's those different procedures that I'm trying to avoid. It's not that I couldn't do those things or learn to do them, it's that my time is best spent building and improving our applications, not keeping servers running, secured, and up to date. At some point we hope to get to the scale where it makes sense to pay a human to do that, but at this point the additional cost incurred by an ECS instance over an equivalent server is negligible.
- ChasingEchoes 5y agoThats a very big if. I have yet to work with a $corp that uses Linux for workstations. Overwhelming majority uses Windows. Some use macOS. The ocasional developer that uses linux will usually be in a VM, or if IT policies allow, WSL. So yeah, running cloud services doesnt require sysadmin skills, unless you assume copy pasting from oficial documention "sysadmin skills".
- xedrac 5y agoThat's funny... every team I've been on in the last 10 years has used Linux workstations almost exclusively, with a few Macs here and there.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- joncrane 5y ago"Infrastructure is cheaper than developers(sysadmins)" all over again.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ctvo 5y agoManaged container services (like Amazon ECS) are a sweet spot for me across complexity, cost, and performance. Mid size companies gain much of the modern development workflow (reproducibility, infrastructure as cattle, managed cloud, etc.) using one of these services without the need to go full blown Kubernetes. It's lower level than functions as a service, but much cheaper, more performant, matches local developer setups more closely (allowing for local development vs. trying to debug AWS Lambda or Cloudflare FaaS using an approximation of how the platform would work).
- jamesfinlayson 5y agoVery much agree - due to a coworker leaving recently, I'm looking after two systems. They're both running on ECS and using Aurora Serverless. My company takes security very seriously so if these two systems were running on bare-metal I'd probably be spending one day a week patching servers rather than trying to implement new functionality across two products.
- eric4smith 5y agoI can bet our team is smaller than yours. And yet… Sysadmin tasks take up maybe 2 hours a month. Your theory is right though if no one on your team knows how to setup servers. In your case the cloud makes sense.
- holografix 5y agoTo the peeps running ECS? Why not just straight up AKS or GKE? Have you compared ECS to Cloud Run on GCP?
- lolinder 5y agoIn my case, mostly because it was easier to get buy-in from the rest of the team on ECS than Kubernetes.