4 ms·
This thinking is very common amongst a certain class of parents. Trying talking to parents of children in private school. They are often hyper-competitive; co
by jgrahamc 15y ago
This thinking is very common amongst a certain class of parents. Trying talking to parents of children in private school. They are often hyper-competitive; constantly comparing their children against their classmates and forcing them from an early age (primary level) into extra classes to 'get ahead'.
This was once summarized for me by someone in Palo Alto as "it's either Harvard or the gutter".
- guard-of-terra 15y agoI understand that, but for me, summer holidays are sacred. You can cramp more useless things (think music school or painting) into the rest of the year, but don't you dare touch summer!
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>You can cramp more useless things (think music school or painting) into the rest of the year, but don't you dare touch summer! // I used to think that art was useless. Then I grew up and now I think that it's pretty essential to a fulfilled life. Not to material wealth but to personal enrichment. FWIW I'm rubbish at artistic realism and can barely hold a tune singing (I've no sense of rhythm either).
- guard-of-terra 15y agoParticipating in art by consuming or by producing? The latter has a pretty poor performance when done by kids. In the best case they go to music school/painting lessons and earn no skills and no satisfaction and no results; in worse case they show some promise and try to study art only to figure out that they can't live off art and they aren't that good anyway. I was in the first bucket.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoProducing. It's not the destination, it's the journey.
- guard-of-terra 15y agoFor some people, including myself, it's both unproductive and not much interesting.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoI'd really love to sit and talk with you about this but I don't feel it will be productive in this medium, thanks for your comments
- arethuza 15y agoDepends on the environment and the private school - for the school our son attends the only thing that people are "hyper-competitive" about is rugby! As someone who previously had almost no interest in team sports I have to admit that I've been rather impressed at "character building" aspects of a school that is very rugby focused - although I hate to think what it is like for kids who don't like this particular sport. [Edit: Oddly enough, at the age of 12 our son also announced one day that he'd like to go to Harvard, a pleasingly audacious goal for a 12 year old Scot.]
- DanBC 15y agoPeople in the UK will move house to get into the catchment area of a good (free) school. Not just secondary school (ages 11 to 16) but for primary schools too (ages 5 to 10). That's an investment of hundreds of thousands of pounds for something which (at primary school ages) doesn't appear to have much of an evidence base. I haven't heard anyone saying "It's Harvard or the gutter", but they're similar.
- impendia 15y agoThe housing phenomenon you describe is absolutely ubiquitous in the US as well.
- waqf 15y agoI'm intrigued that you didn't anglicise to "... Oxbridge or the gutter". Is Harvard now both as well known as and more prestigious than Oxbridge in the UK?
- DanBC 15y agoI'm just lazy, that's why I didn't anglicise. I would think that Harvard is as well known as Oxbridge. I'm not sure about the other Ivy League colleges.