9 ms·
Yes, because when the American government controls Twitter, you can be certain all views will be respected and treated impartially...
by krapp 5y ago
Yes, because when the American government controls Twitter, you can be certain all views will be respected and treated impartially...
- sebow 5y agoNationalizing in the traditional sense is not the solution, indeed, but rather hold the platform up to the letter of the constitution. This right now is not exactly possible given that "twitter is a private company", therefore arguably if one puts it in the hands of the government, you have the double-edged sword of potentially being abused by the government, and on the other hand the solution i forementioned on holding it accountable given that it would become public under the law. However, just like with any other gov. institution, being held accountable is more often than not up to the people through their civic initiative and probably not something that the government will do out of interest. So in this regard in US it could work given the nature of the constitution, whereas in other countries Twitter would just become a propaganda machine (isn't it one already?).
- nradov 5y agoSupreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas suggested extending common carrier legislation to cover social media platforms. That would essentially prevent them from censoring any content legal in the US. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/techtank/2021/04/09/justice-thomas-sends-a-message-on-social-media-regulation/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/techtank/2021/04/09/justice-t...
- sebow 5y agoThanks for the link, I remember hearing about Clarence Thomas' take on this subject but I never took the time to study it. My personal opinion (before reading the material above) is that the "core issue" stands on the S230 "loop-hole" (I don't want to use the term 'abuse' given the negative connotation ... so far it[S230] has been a net good since it made the internet grow so much since 2007, but things have started to change with the rise of monopolistic corporations) giving companies both privileges with less responsibility than should necessary. At least in principle a Bill of Rights should exist, especially considering that places like Twitter are considered fairly often under the law (think court cases) 'public spaces'. Therefore in my mind if the public street is a place where i can speak freely, so should one be able to on Twitter/any other such deemed public space.
- missedthecue 5y agoWithout irony, you probably would have less censorship than should a private company own it. Is that a good thing? Not sure. Seems like spam would overtake it quickly.
- krapp 5y agoSure, until an American president decides to ban another country's account for disrespecting him, or use it for leverage in negotiations, or have the NSA bulk scan their citizens private messages for 'terrorist' communications, or have the algorithm bias other country's newsfeeds in favor of American propaganda. Twitter is a global platform and much of the world wouldn't trust the US as far as they could throw an American nuke (not withstanding how much they would also trust their own government.) The only reason Twitter works as well as it does now is that its primary concern, as a company, is profit, and not the national interests of one specific country.
- oceanplexian 5y agoThat ship long since sailed. Look at Russia, for example. They have basically been cut off from all forms of social media and the president didn’t even need to order them to do it (Even though the president has more or less total power over anything involving international trade). The social media companies did it voluntarily.
- krapp 5y agoI would still prefer it to be the choice of individuals and private platforms, which can be competed with and avoided, than a government. Even if I think blacklisting Russians at every opportunity is a terrible, unproductive and ultimately self-sabotaging move for Americans to make.
- stale2002 5y ago> Sure, until an American president decides to ban Well, that is what the court system, and the supreme court is for. The court system puts very strong restrictions on what the government is able to do, regarding speech. Sure, maybe a president would want to do something. And the courts, which have a very established history of protecting speech rights would stop them. A better solution, though, would be to make a new law that requires twitter to follow similar standards as the government has to follow, in the same way how we put strong restrictions on what telephone companies are allowed to do (So don't give me any objections about how such laws would be illegal, when we already have them! Use our phone laws as the model, to do something similar, if not exact the same).
- jdrc 5y agoDoes American government censor the press? Or mail?
- sbarre 5y agoDuring the Trump administration, their vindictive treatment of the press and the selective removal of access to the White House by outlets not toeing the line more or less amounted to quasi-censorship in practice.
- jdrc 5y agoSmall potatoes compared to the ugliness around the world
- onpensionsterm 5y agoIn living memory, through McCarthyism.
- zionic 5y ago>McCarthyism Isn’t that “ism” largely discredited? He was right, the government/institutions were full of communists. Today they’ve rebranded as socialists, but to my knowledge everything he fought against came to pass. Attaching the -ism label is just a thought-terminating cliche.