4 ms·
USB-B ports (the square ones) were designed for peripherals, normal USB-A ports were for hosts. I believe that was so it was clear why you couldn’t plug your h
by MBCook 5y ago
USB-B ports (the square ones) were designed for peripherals, normal USB-A ports were for hosts.
I believe that was so it was clear why you couldn’t plug your hard drive into your printer and expect it to work. There were no B to B cables. Heck there were no A to A cables, right?
I think there were some other weird connectors designed to sort of handle the fact that some devices (phones) could act as either a host or peripheral.
All that said sticking with that connector makes a lot of sense. If you’re buying your first printer it’s unfortunate that you have to buy a cable. Better ton of people will be replacing a previous printer and already have that exact cable on hand. If they used USB-C those people would have to replace the cable.
ID copy? No idea.
- dylan604 5y ago> ID copy? No idea. What do you mean by no idea? Do you mean you have no idea what the reviewer's point was? Do you mean you still have no idea on what it's for even after I just described it?
- MBCook 5y agoI meant I had no idea what it would be useful for. Though another comment on this story made it clear for me. It’s probably for businesses that need to make copies of people’s ID cards or medical cards or such.
- whoopdedo 5y agoA-A cables do exist. I came across it with a USB 3.0 hard drive. But the version 3 micro-B connector was notoriously fragile, so this one had a sturdier A connector instead.
- actionfromafar 5y agoThose are not standard though, more like a "hack".
- masklinn 5y agoThey’re beyond non-standard, they’re explicitely against standard: A-A cables are actively hazardous, because the A side is the one which provides power, and USB hosts usually don’t expect to get powered through the cable (though I hope and expect over time they added protections for that as USB got misused). B-B cable (whether full, mini, or micro) is at least innocuous and inert.
- fmajid 5y agoAnd that's also the reason why C female to A male adapters are banned, otherwise you could attach them on both ends of a C-C cable to make an A-A cable.
- tjoff 5y agoThough they are often not just a cable. But a chip inside the cable, presumably acting as slave for both hosts - and I guess fully compliant in theory at least.
- masklinn 5y ago> and I guess fully compliant in theory at least. An A-A cable is necessarily non-compliant by definition.
- tjoff 5y agoWhy? In practice it would be equivalent to a device with two say micro-usb-ports. Unusual for sure, but necessarily non-compliant?
- masklinn 5y ago> Why? Because the official spec says so, and as described above USBx was originally a strictly host-device protocol, the A plug is at the host, and the B plug is at the device. An A-A cable is a host-host link, which from the USB standpoint doesn't make sense (pre type-C). In particular, the host is in charge of sending power, the device is supposed to be able to handle it. In particular if one of the hosts gets powered off, its 5V now gets powered (possibly without limitation) by the other, drawing way more than the 500mA specified by the spec, and damaging the cable if you're lucky (until that catches on fire and burns down your house) or the electronics (and killing your mobo). Think of it as creating a plug-plug extension cord and connecting two of your house's outlets together (don't do that). > In practice it would be equivalent to a device with two say micro-usb-ports. micro-USB has both A and B variants (likewise mini). What you're probably thinking of is a micro-B plug. And having a B-B cable is also not compliant though nobody does it because it's completely useless (because the device side is "passive", so nothing can happen). > Unusual for sure, but necessarily non-compliant? Yes necessarily non-compliant. [0] "Smart" devices like smartphones and tablets can be both device and host which created an issue, this was acknowledged and support was added with "On The Go" (OTG) and mixed-compatibility receptacles (so USB mini and micro have AB receptacles, aka female, which can thus accept either an A plug — acting as host — or a B plug — acting as device). OTG cables are still asymmetric, with an A side and a B side, and A-A cables are still illegal OTG. Type C replaces this with a fully symmetrical cable.
- watermelon0 5y agoMany USB switches come with A-A cables for connecting to computers. The only reason I could find is that B connectors are a bit higher, so they would need to use a larger case.
- 2000UltraDeluxe 5y agoThis. There are plenty of printers that can print straight from USB storage, and I wouldn't be surprised if there are scanners/multi-function devices that can scan to USB storage as well. Having two USB ports to plug those storage devices into would cause _a lot_ of support calls because some people would insist on using the wrong port. The same applies for record players able to record to USB storage, many external hard drives and other periopherals from the 2000's and early 2010's. Mini-USB was also quite common for smaller devices in those times. After 2012-ish, many seems to have switched to micro-USB and now we're gradually moving to USB-C. That being said, A-to-A cables do exist and some rare devices use them.