3 ms·
My hypothesis, unencumbered with any evidence, is that modern society and parents have gotten very good at shielding small children from adversity and failure o
by WalterBright 5y ago
My hypothesis, unencumbered with any evidence, is that modern society and parents have gotten very good at shielding small children from adversity and failure of any sort.
Hence, the children do not acquire any ability to deal with adversity and failure.
When they get older, parents can no longer control their environment such that they do not experience failure. By then the failures are more serious and the kids have no coping skills.
- goat_whisperer 5y ago
- ausbah 5y agoamazing how people can be so bold as to share their uninformed opinion even when they acknowledge it's uninformed
- WalterBright 5y agoThe search for explanations always starts with a hypothesis. I find it funny you call me out for being honest.
- garbagetime 5y agoHow is it bold to discuss stuff in the discussion section of a website?
- adamredwoods 5y agoThe knee-jerk reaction is to blame the parents.
- RosanaAnaDana 5y agoAnother hypothesis not bothering with evidence, is that due to increased media, mass media, and internet media exposure, we lack a 'quasi-local' version of what success can look like in a meaningful way. The internet and mass media have 'de-smallified' our world, in that we're in constant exposure to those who have made it. They tell us their secrets, how they made it, and when it doesn't work for us, we get blame ourselves and take our failures as personal. There is an extreme selection bias for success in what we see in the world. Failure, in that same sense, is hidden. Kids don't see it except on rare occasions where it can be spun positively. Kids aren't exposed to the real grinding failures of just trying to get by. So we have two very different distributions forming childhood mental frameworks about what success looks like. Likewise, exposure is more and more purely digital. There's no grounding in any of this, or acknowledgement that most of why anything happens is due to circumstance and random chance. Youth get put in a situation where success is effectively (based on their abilities and view of success) impossible.
- peppustimbus 5y ago
- adamredwoods 5y agoWhy then must failure or adversity be learned at the childhood or "small child" age? If the end result is to obtain coping skills, what exactly are these skills? Are they only obtainable during childhood? Are there examples of adults who lack coping skills yet had "unshielded" lives?
- WalterBright 5y agoToddlerhood teaches us all kinds of things, like closing a door with your fingers wrapped around the door hurts. We learn an awful lot about how to not hurt ourselves by hurting ourselves. Our muscles get stronger by stressing them to failure. Is there any inherent reason the mind does not respond the same way? Me, I walked to kindergarten both ways, about a 3/4 mile walk, by myself. These days, it would be considered child neglect. I was one of those "free range" kids, as were all the others. I received one of the last chemistry sets that contained a bunsen burner, copper sulphate, and experiments with hydrochloric acid. I grew up just before the "everyone is a winner" movement. In high school, my preoccupation was shredding tires on my Mustang. At about that time, the cops finally shut down the high school drags in downtown Phoenix, just before I was able to participate. What a drag :-/ I got an Eagle scout with zero involvement of my parents. I had my own business for spending money. I got into fist fights with other boys. I build a flame thrower out of a lawnmower. My mom despaired as the driveway was black with tire marks. It was a good time to be a boy. And in no way was I different from the other boys. We'd shred their tires, too. During my entire K-12 time, the only two deaths in the entire schools were two boys who got smacked by running into traffic. No suicides. I feel kinda sorry for later generations with their helicopter parents.
- adamredwoods 5y ago>> Toddlerhood teaches us all kinds of things, like closing a door with your fingers wrapped around the door hurts. We learn an awful lot about how to not hurt ourselves by hurting ourselves. This is immediate feedback loop. >> Me, I walked to kindergarten both ways... You've lead a great life and had great opportunities, I'm so happy for you, but this type of self-righteousness is completely insensitive in this serious and complex issue. >> I feel kinda sorry for later generations with their helicopter parents. This is an insensitive thing to say.